Is The Story Of The Mom Who Agreed To Let The Internet Name Her Baby For $5,000 Fake? [UPDATED]

Everyone has had fun in the last couple weeks taking a cracks at the woman who agreed to let strangers on the internet name her baby in exchange for $5,000.

Belly Ballot, a Texas-based website that helps parents-to-be crowdsource names for their unborn children, hosted the controversial and silly contest that ended up getting national and even international attention. Last month the site announced that a woman named Natasha Hill was the lucky winner of $5,000 and an internet-approved name for her fetus that is still TBD. Initial reports on Hill (based mostly on a Facebook page that has since been taken down) reported that Hill was an engaged 26-year-old art teacher, a West Los Angeles resident and a UCSB alum. Belly Ballot's co-founder Lacey Moler told The Huffington Post that Hill was chosen from a pool of 80 applicants because of "her honesty and enthusiasm."

That statement from Moler seems ironic given that there is definitely something fishy about the winner of the contest.

Natasha Hill just happens to be a dead-ringer for Natasha Lloyd, an actress living in Los Angeles who is also a UCSB alum. On Lloyd's Facebook page (which was taken down in the last 24 hours) it says that she shares the same birthday as Hill. We don't know exactly what is going on, but we've reached out to both Natasha Lloyd and Belly Ballot for some sort of explanation. (And we'll update the post if and when they do.)

We don't have confirmation of what's going on, but we do have eyes. Here are some photos of Hill that have been circulating in media reports that are originally from her Facebook page (that has since been taken down):

()

And here are headshots of actress Natasha Lloyd from her IMDb page:

()

via IMDb
Hill told the Huffington Post that she had a boyfriend named Craig who didn't want his last name used. On her Facebook page, she said she was engaged:

But on Twitter, Lloyd makes cracks about how she's planning on impressing men on first dates:

Hill has given interviews to TODAY and the Huffington Post, but so far she hasn't given any on-camera interviews. The website's owners told KTLA that Hill was "too shy" to stand in front of cameras. (And, really, that might be the fishiest part of all.)

We're not sure if it's a prank that went too far or if Belly Ballot hired Lloyd to win some publicity or if there's another explanation entirely.

The contest was sponsored by the site's advertisers. Online voting for the name of Natasha Hill's baby is supposed to commence March 18th and continue through March 22nd.

UPDATE 3/4/13: Moler has admitted Lloyd was an actress hired to be the winner the contest. The owner of the Texas-based startup admitted Sunday that while she had said previously 80 moms had entered the contest, no one actually had, so she decided to hire Lloyd to play the "winning" mom, reports NBC. Once Lloyd, as "Natasha Hill," was announced the winner, Moler says actual expectant mothers applied to enter the already-closed contest.

NBC's Today Moms blog adds:

Moler also told the blog:

Lloyd confirmed she was an actress hired to play the mom, but would not comment further.

Related:
L.A. Mom Gives Up Naming Rights to Unborn Child for $5000 Cash Prize