Kamala Harris pledges to build 3 million affordable homes and apartments in her first term as president.
(
Larry Valenzuela
/
CalMatters, CatchLight Local
)
Topline:
Kamala Harris pledges to build 3 million affordable homes and apartments in her first term as president, but Gov. Newsom has fallen short on a similar campaign promise in California. What lessons can she learn?
What is she promising: The Democratic presidential nominee pledged in August to build 3 million additional affordable homes and rentals over the next four years to address “a serious housing shortage across America,"
Why does this sound familiar? The promise from Harris echoes Gov. Gavin Newsom’s platform during his first gubernatorial campaign in 2018, when he called for California to add 3.5 million housing units by 2025.
What lessons could Harris learn? Even with new policy priorities in place, high construction costs, onerous regulations, lack of public funding and community resistance remain major hurdles to supercharging homebuilding in California — offering lessons for a potential Harris administration.
Read on... for more on what Newsom has accomplished and fallen short on for housing.
For California political observers, the housing plan that Kamala Harris recently unveiled may have caused a twinge of familiarity.
As a central plank of her agenda to “lower costs for American families,” the Democratic presidential nominee pledged in August to build 3 million additional affordable homes and rentals over the next four years to address “a serious housing shortage across America” — echoing Gov. Gavin Newsom’s platform during his first gubernatorial campaign in 2018, when he called for California to add 3.5 million housing units by 2025.
Housing policy experts are enthusiastic about many of the ideas that Harris floated to promote production, which include creating a new tax incentive for developers who build starter homes for first-time homebuyers, expanding a tax incentive for affordable rental housing projects and establishing a $40 billion “innovation fund” to finance construction, as well as repurposing some federal land for housing and streamlining the permitting processes for projects.
Michael Lens, a professor of urban planning and public policy at UCLA, called it a wonk’s wish list: “This is all of the stuff we talk about at dorky academic conferences.”
But transforming the housing market from the top is difficult, as Newsom’s experience has demonstrated.
While California has increased production during his time in office — about 112,000 units were completed last year, according to the Department of Housing and Community Development, compared to about 70,000 in 2018 — it is still only building at a fifth of the rate necessary to meet his original target.
The governor has since acknowledged that 3.5 million units “was always a stretch goal” and scaled back. His office declined an interview request for this story.
Even with new policy priorities in place, high construction costs, onerous regulations, lack of public funding and community resistance remain major hurdles to supercharging homebuilding in California — offering lessons for a potential Harris administration.
“You’re going to be limited in your ability to change things on the ground,” said Ben Metcalf, a former state and federal housing official who is now managing director of the Terner Center for Housing Innovation at UC Berkeley. “Even when you are trying to move carrots and sticks, you find years later, what do you have to show?”
People moving from expensive cities to outlying areas for more affordable housing or moving into bigger homes during the coronavirus pandemic has driven up demand in new places, while even many recent pro-growth boom towns are becoming strained by the natural limits of expansion or a dimming taste for development.
“There is plenty of reason to think that it could get worse, in the sense that California is a bellwether,” Lens said.
Construction is constrained in California by pricey land, local zoning limits and fees, lengthy permitting processes and the threat of litigation, all of which drive up the cost of building and make it difficult for many projects to pencil out financially.
It’s unclear where the Harris campaign came up with its goal of 3 million housing units over the next four years — or how exactly it would measure success, given the emphasis on affordability. A campaign spokesperson did not respond to questions seeking a more detailed explanation, though he did clarify that this would be above current production.
That would require a President Harris to immediately boost construction nationwide by 50%, to levels not seen since before the housing market crashed during the 2008 financial crisis. The country built about 1.45 million new homes last year, according to the U.S. Census Bureau.
Gov. Gavin Newsom's first gubernatorial campaign in 2018 called for California to add 3.5 million housing units by 2025.
(
Miguel Gutierrez Jr.
/
CalMatters
)
The strategy carries some political risk. Newsom set an ambitious housing goal as a candidate for governor, which would have required California to build 500,000 new homes per year, and then faced criticism for falling short.
Metcalf noted that Harris’ plan for 3 million homes is more aggressive than the 2 million figure that President Joe Biden was campaigning on before he dropped out of the race this summer, but far below the Housing and Urban Development Act of 1968, which targeted the construction or rehabilitation of 26 million units over the next decade, including six million for low- and moderate-income families.
“The last time we saw an incoming president really putting a big, bold number on the board was that,” Metcalf said. “She wants to be able to campaign for a second term saying, ‘Hey, we did it.’”
Clear regulatory hurdles
California officials are undertaking a serious push to make it easier to build housing.
Over the past several years, they have passed major legislation:
Advocates projected these policies could unlock millions of new homes across the state, but the impact so far has been significantly more modest.
“That’s a precursor to making a lot of these things work,” Lens said. “We have to make housing more allowable in more places.”
New housing construction in Elk Grove on July 8, 2022.
(
Rahul Lal
/
CalMatters
)
A series of laws to encourage more “accessory dwelling units” has been a promising exception, according to Chris Elmendorf, a UC Davis law professor with an expertise in land use and housing law. Since California forced local governments to waive fees and affordability requirements and grant faster approval for backyard cottages and other secondary units, the state has seen a boom of ADU construction.
Elmendorf said Harris’ proposed tax incentive for starter homes — which is not an official category, but generally refers to more modest housing that provides a cheaper entry point into the market — could similarly provide a quick jolt to the housing supply.
“If the goal is to promote small, inexpensive, market-rate homes, that’s really different than what California has been doing,” Elmendorf said. “California has been able to pass a lot of laws, but it hasn’t been able to pass many laws that make housing economically feasible.”
Experts argue that California has not been able to maximize the effectiveness of its new pro-housing laws because it is prioritizing so many other goals — demands to use union labor, requirements for more deed-restricted affordable units to reduce gentrification, environmental considerations to discourage sprawl and climate risks — that it’s still too expensive to build here.
California has been able to pass a lot of laws, but it hasn’t been able to pass many laws that make housing economically feasible.
— Chris Elmendorf, Law professor at UC Davis
The high costs for workers, materials and local regulations have been compounded lately by elevated interest rates, which drive up the price tag to finance projects and may actually be reversing California’s progress on construction. Metcalf compared it to a straw breaking the camel’s back for the building industry.
“That’s something that we’ve made almost no progress on as a state,” he said. “Once you have the table set, if the costs are too high, then nothing gets built.”
It’s of particular concern for affordable housing developers, who rely heavily on public funding. Chione Lucina Muñoz Flegal, executive director of the affordable housing advocacy group Housing California, said that despite state laws that have made it easier to plan projects, developers continue to struggle to pull together enough money to get them over the finish line.
She is hopeful about a surge in financial support — through the tax incentives and innovation fund in Harris’ plan — that has been unavailable from state or local governments, which she said have not generally prioritized money for affordable housing because constituents do not understand the benefits.
“There’s a narrative challenge that we’re grappling with that often translates into a political challenge,” Flegal said. “That’s a way the federal government could be impactful in a way the state could never be.”
Use sticks as well as carrots
Though Newsom made clear his desire to boost housing production in California, not everyone has been on board with his approach.
Some cities, particularly wealthy or coastal suburbs, have vigorously fought to restrict additional development in their own communities, resisting a state mandate to plan for far more housing and suing to exempt themselves or overturn new laws that make it easier to build more densely. They contend these policies would destroy the character of their communities.
The construction project is funded by the No Place Like Home bond, which passed in 2018 to create affordable housing for homeless residents experiencing mental health issues.
(
Camille Cohen
/
CalMatters
)
But the federal government does not have the same legal authority that California has given itself to demand local communities build more housing, and there’s no guarantee that Congress would be willing to step in to play more of a role in what has traditionally been a local matter in most states.
“Plans don’t translate into outcomes if people don’t want to build housing,” Elmendorf said.
So to reach her goal of 3 million new homes, Harris would have to rely more on the proposed incentives, such as the tax breaks for starter homes and affordable rentals and the innovation fund, for voluntary compliance.
Experts believe she has a good political opportunity to actually get her plan passed. Congress will be under pressure next year to extend a series of tax cuts made under former President Donald Trump that are set to expire at the end of 2025, which could be used as a bargaining chip for Harris’ housing proposals.
The federal government also has the power of the purse on a scale well beyond California, which it could amplify through regulations — such as tying transportation dollars to building more housing — that make supporting development the more desirable option.
California has tried this type of regulatory incentive, encouraging local governments to remove obstacles to construction with grant money and creating a “pro-housing designation” for cities that adopt streamlined development policies, which gives them privileged access to state funds.
“Unfortunately, that pro-housing designation is not based on outcomes. So that’s a fundamental problem,” Elmendorf said. “That’s something Harris will have to figure out.”
A community college student looks through her class schedule for next semester on her laptop at a Panera Bread in Stockton on May 7, 2026.
(
Larry Valenzuela
/
CalMatters
)
Topline:
After CalMatters reported last week on the heavy course loads of some part-time faculty, California’s community college chancellor is reviewing whether online professors are providing a quality education to students.
Why now: CalMatters found that some professors were teaching more than a dozen online classes at a time at several California community colleges, California State University and University of California campuses. In some cases, they were earning well over $340,000. On Nov. 13, California Community Colleges Chancellor Sonya Christian sent an email to campus chief executives in response to the CalMatters story.
The backstory: The highest earner, ethnic studies professor, Thien-Huong Ninh Villarreal, made nearly $800,000 in 2024 by teaching at nine community college districts, Cal State Sacramento and UC Berkeley, according to a CalMatters analysis using public payroll records, university course listings and hiring documents. She has a similar course load this fall, encompassing about 1,100 students across 30 classes. Some faculty and college leaders say it’s impossible to provide students a quality education when a professor has such a large courseload. But technically, teaching multiple classes or holding multiple jobs, by itself, doesn’t prove anything about the quality of the instruction.
CalMatters found that some professors were teaching more than a dozen online classes at a time at several California community colleges, California State University and University of California campuses. In some cases, they were earning well over $340,000.
On Nov. 13, California Community Colleges Chancellor Sonya Christian sent an email to campus chief executives in response to the CalMatters story. “We should not characterize faculty as doing something inappropriate simply because they teach at more than one college,” she wrote. “At the same time, some of the practices described in the article are deeply troubling and warrant further scrutiny.”
Mac Powell, the president of the organization that accredits California’s community colleges, said he reached out to all the schools mentioned in the CalMatters story, asking about their compliance with those quality-education standards. “The issue of who teaches how much and when — that’s not what we’re most interested in,” he said. “We’re interested in the education that students get.”
The highest earner, ethnic studies professor Thien-Huong Ninh Villarreal, made nearly $800,000 in 2024 by teaching at nine community college districts, Cal State Sacramento and UC Berkeley, according to a CalMatters analysis using public payroll records, university course listings and hiring documents. She has a similar course load this fall, encompassing about 1,100 students across 30 classes.
Some faculty and college leaders say it’s impossible to provide students a quality education when a professor has such a large courseload. But technically, teaching multiple classes or holding multiple jobs, by itself, doesn’t prove anything about the quality of the instruction.
If online professors are not regularly interacting with their students in the ways the law and the accrediting body require, then schools — and ultimately students — could lose access to federal financial aid.
A ‘personal perspective’ from the state chancellor
It’s no secret that part-time faculty, or adjuncts, at California's colleges and universities often work multiple jobs. By law, part-time faculty in the community college system can teach only about three classes per district each semester. They are paid less than full-time faculty and have fewer, if any, benefits.
“I bring a personal perspective to this discussion,” wrote Christian. “When I first graduated, I taught at three California community colleges. I didn't own a car, so I rode the RTD bus from campus to campus to teach in person, piecing together assignments and barely making rent. I remember those days well. I understand firsthand why adjunct faculty teach at multiple institutions. For many, it is an economic necessity.”
Part-time faculty outnumber full-time faculty at every one of the state’s community college districts, sometimes by more than 5-to-1, but the total number of adjuncts statewide is unknown because professors who teach at multiple campuses are often counted repeatedly in the data.
In her email to college leaders, Christian acknowledged that there’s an “absence of a systematic way” to track faculty who teach at multiple campuses or across the community college, Cal State and UC systems. She said her team is looking into how college districts handle faculty with multiple jobs and what information about outside work faculty disclose. “The objective is to determine whether additional guidance, improved data sharing, or a common approach would strengthen institutional oversight.”
To find instructors who teach at multiple campuses, CalMatters used public payroll records gathered by Transparent California, a nonprofit organization advocating for limited government. CalMatters looked only at professors who taught at five or more community college districts, Cal State or UC campuses in 2024, the most recent data available.
Of the 72 professors who taught at five or more districts or universities, the median pay was about $190,000, though a few instructors made much more. CalMatters found 10 professors who made more than $343,000, which was the median salary of a community college president or chancellor in the same year. Most of the highest earners had full-time jobs along with numerous part-time gigs. Ninh Villarreal currently has at least two full-time tenured community college positions, along with other adjunct roles elsewhere.
Christian said these 72 professors are a "small group" compared with the tens of thousands of faculty employed by the state’s public higher education systems, and the highest earners "an even smaller one."
Are online professors interacting with students enough?
Because the federal and state governments dole out billions of dollars in financial aid to students, they regulate the kinds of courses and institutions where students can qualify for aid, and online courses in particular have undergone increased scrutiny in recent years.
The general rule that accreditors and state and federal lawmakers all share is that online professors need to interact with their students regularly. Research shows students are more likely to succeed when they interact with their professors.
Many online courses are asynchronous, meaning that the lectures are prerecorded and students can listen at any time. In these courses, and in many in-person ones, quizzes and tests are often graded automatically by computers.
Christian said that “prerecorded lectures, automated quizzes, and other instructional technologies” can be valuable in online classes, but professors must do more than that to meet the legal requirements. “Low-quality instruction is unacceptable, and we will not tolerate practices that compromise the education our students deserve.”
After the story was published here, online professors who taught at fewer than five districts or colleges shared their perspectives.
William Mead is a full-time lecturer in design and web development at UC Davis who also teaches part-time at two community college districts. He said his online courses are prerecorded but that doesn’t mean he is disengaged — quite the opposite. “My lectures take many hours to produce before a term begins,” he wrote in an email. “That front-loaded work is what frees me, during the semester, to focus on what matters most: individual feedback on student work and time with students. I hold a regular weekly office hour plus three additional appointment blocks each week (one morning, one afternoon, one evening) so that working students can meet with me on Zoom when it fits their lives.”
Jonathan Horn, who teaches one asynchronous online journalism course at San Diego Mesa College, said he writes his students “paragraphs and paragraphs of feedback on their assignments, sometimes worrying if it's too much.” He said it would be impossible to provide the same level of feedback for 30 or 50 classes.
Containers are transported by trains and trucks out of the Long Beach Container Terminal in the Port of Long Beach, Calif., April 8, 2025
(
Damian Dovarganes
/
Associated Press
)
Topline:
More than a dozen people were charged Thursday with allegedly orchestrating a massive train heist operation to steal over $22 million in cargo — from popular shoes to power tools — from major retailers.
The backstory: Trains that shuttle goods to stores and customers around the country have become a prominent target for large-scale theft in recent years, especially at large ports in the U.S. that receive hundreds of millions of dollars of shipments every day. The relatively low-tech robberies have demanded attention from the world’s largest retailers, including the likes of Amazon.
What's next: The 13 men were indicted for conspiracy and theft of interstate railroad cargo. Two were also charged with violence against railroad carriers. If convicted, the men could face anywhere from five to 20 years in federal prison.
More than a dozen people were charged Thursday with allegedly orchestrating a massive train heist operation to steal over $22 million in cargo — from popular shoes to power tools — from major retailers.
A federal indictment unsealed on Thursday paints a picture of an organized group that targeted more than three dozen trains carrying Nike sneakers, Crocs footwear, power tools and other consumer goods that were imported into the United States through Los Angeles and Long Beach, which are home to the busiest ports in the country.
Trains that shuttle goods to stores and customers around the country have become a prominent target for large-scale theft in recent years, especially at large ports in the U.S. that receive hundreds of millions of dollars of shipments every day. The relatively low-tech robberies have demanded attention from the world’s largest retailers, including the likes of Amazon.
The men would disable the trains at a planned location by busting the brakes, the indictment alleged, at which point the goods would be offloaded onto trucks. The goods were then peddled to an unnamed company that would resell the stolen merchandise for profit.
“The scale of the theft is staggering,” said First Assistant United States Attorney Bill Essayli, promising to prosecute any future efforts to steal the merchandise.
In group chats, the men shared numerous photos and videos of themselves busting into the hulking train cars, and posing with wads of cash and stolen merchandise. They also shared AI photos of themselves captioned “Los Trenes,” which means the trains in Spanish, beneath glamorized photos of men throwing boxes of shoes off trains into nearby cars while police helicopters descended overhead.
The 13 men were indicted for conspiracy and theft of interstate railroad cargo. Two were also charged with violence against railroad carriers.
If convicted, the men could face anywhere from five to 20 years in federal prison.
Keep up with LAist.
If you're enjoying this article, you'll love our daily newsletter, The LA Report. Each weekday, catch up on the 5 most pressing stories to start your morning in 3 minutes or less.
Libby Rainey
has been tracking how L.A. is preparing for the 2028 Olympic Games.
Published November 19, 2026 6:04 PM
Jose Ugarte (L) leads Estuardo Mazariegos (R) by 87 votes in the uber-tight race to represent L.A.’s Council District 9.
(
Courtesy of the Mazariegos and Ugarte campaigns
)
Topline:
Jose Ugarte leads Estuardo Mazariegos by 87 votes in the uber-tight race to represent L.A.’s Council District 9, as of Thursday’s evening ballot drop.
What changed: It’s a slight gain for Ugarte, who was 63 votes ahead as of the last ballot count.
Why it matters: Who wins will come down to ballot curing, the process through which the L.A. County Registrar flags ballots without signatures or with signatures that need further verification and gives voters the chance to fix the problem and have their ballot counted.
Read on… for more about the tight race to represent L.A.’s Council District 9.
Jose Ugarte leads Estuardo Mazariegos by 87 votes in the uber-tight race to represent L.A.’s Council District 9, as of Thursday evening’s ballot drop.
It’s a slight gain for Ugarte, who was 63 votes ahead as of the last ballot count.
With more than 39,000 ballots counted in the race so far, there are very few votes left to tally. The remaining ballots are all subject to curing, the process through which the L.A. County Registrar-Recorder/County Clerk flags ballots without signatures or with signatures that need further verification and gives voters the chance to fix the problem and have their ballot counted.
“The numbers continue to move in our favor,” Ugarte said in a statement via email. “We’re encouraged by today’s results and increasingly hopeful about our path to victory.”
The race to replace outgoing Councilmember Curren Price representing South L.A. has drawn intense scrutiny since Election Day, as Mazariegos narrowed in on Ugarte’s initial lead, at one point trailing by just 41 votes. Ugarte has gained ground in the last two vote drops.
It’s also been messy. Mazariegos accused the Ugarte campaign of voter fraud. Ugarte responded by calling his opponent a “pathetic bully.”
This election will bring change to South L.A., which has been represented by a Black council member since 1963. Ugarte and Mazariegos are both Latino.
The winner will help determine the balance of power in City Hall. Ugarte is a former staffer for Price and the establishment candidate, whose campaign was backed by the Los Angeles County Democratic Party, a number of labor unions and several council members, including Price. His campaign also had outside support from Airbnb and a major association for apartment landlords.
Mazariegos ran as an insurgent with backing from the Democratic Socialists of America, Los Angeles and United Teachers Los Angeles, as well as Councilmember Eunisses Hernandez, a member of the council’s progressive bloc.
With less than a week left in the vote count, the Mazariegos campaign says it’s focused on reaching out to voters whose ballots still need verification to be counted.
Meghan Choi, a consultant for Mazariegos, said the campaign has deployed volunteers to phone-bank and door-knock the small pool of voters with outstanding ballots, encouraging them to fix their signatures before it's too late.
“We have a lot of volunteers who are mobilizing every day,” Choi said. “It’s just really important that every single vote from the district is counted and people get their voice heard.”
Just 251 ballots in Council District 9 still needed verification ahead of this latest drop, according to the Mazariegos campaign.
California Attorney General Rob Bonta has issued an investigative subpoena to Nvidia related to former CEO Jensen Huang’s affair with a suspected Chinese spy. The California Department of Justice said Thursday it is asking Nvidia whether its advanced chips or confidential information may have gone to China and whether Nvidia misled investors and the public.
Why it matters: “The conduct of Nvidia and its former CEO raises bright red flags, including about the ways in which the company may have misled investors. My office is investigating whether Nvidia or Jensen Huang’s actions resulted in China obtaining advanced chips or confidential information — and if Nvidia misled investors and the public about this risk, in violation of the law,” Bonta said in a statement. “Nvidia is in a messy, transnational situation but the underlying principle of our corporate securities law is clear: Companies cannot mislead their investors.”
What's next: Huang will appear before congressional committees on Dec. 1, followed by the company’s general counsel, Tim Teter, on Dec. 2.
California Attorney General Rob Bonta has issued an investigative subpoena to Nvidia related to former CEO Jensen Huang’s affair with a suspected Chinese spy.
The California Department of Justice said Thursday it is asking Nvidia whether its advanced chips or confidential information may have gone to China and whether Nvidia misled investors and the public.
“The conduct of Nvidia and its former CEO raises bright red flags, including about the ways in which the company may have misled investors. My office is investigating whether Nvidia or Jensen Huang’s actions resulted in China obtaining advanced chips or confidential information — and if Nvidia misled investors and the public about this risk, in violation of the law,” Bonta said in a statement. “Nvidia is in a messy, transnational situation but the underlying principle of our corporate securities law is clear: Companies cannot mislead their investors.”
On Tuesday, key House lawmakers said that Huang has voluntarily agreed to appear for transcribed interviews as the company faces intensifying national scrutiny over sales of its advanced computer chips.
Huang will appear before congressional committees on Dec. 1, followed by the company’s general counsel, Tim Teter, on Dec. 2.
Nvidia did not immediately respond to a message for comment Thursday.