Gab Chabrán
covers what's happening in food and culture for LAist.
Published April 9, 2025 1:38 PM
The Electric Margarita at Providence will set you back $100. But if you're already eating at Providence, maybe that's not a concern.
(
Caroline Pardilla
)
Topline:
At Providence, the two-starred Michelin restaurant on Melrose, beverage director Kim Stodel turns margarita-making into high art, making his Electric Margarita table-side, using ultra premium ingredients, and a good amount of showmanship. But is it really worth $100?
$100 for a margarita? Yes, you read that correctly! But is this not your run-of-mill happy hour margarita at Chili's. Instead, bar director Kim Stodel crafts an expert-level cocktail using super high-end ingredients, including estate-grown tequila, Grand Marnier mixed with XO cognac, and a house-made passion fruit cordial. All made table-side for your sipping pleasure.
What makes it electric? It's Stodel's take on the long-serving Cadillac margarita, a version known for using only top-shelf ingredients. Here, Stodel incorporates discarded passion fruit rinds, highlighting the restaurant's commitment to sustainability, which earned it a Michelin Green star.
Is it worth $100? Read on for Gab's opinion.
When I told people I was going to try a $100 margarita, I was immediately met with a reaction that I can only describe as shock and awe.
“Is it really $100?”
“Why would anyone pay that much?”
“Is this really what you call working?”
I’d learned about the uber-fancy cocktail on offer at upscale restaurant Providence from Caroline Pardilla, cocktail writer and author of Margarita Time, which I'd recently written about.
She’d suggested taking me on a margarita-tasting tour for a social media video, and had planned Providence as one of the stops. A $100 margarita? I was immediately game.
Before you roast me, I’m always intrigued when I hear of someone doing something unique and out of the ordinary, especially in the food scene.
Food has the power to change people's minds, and how they view the world, just from a single taste — or in this case sip. I wanted to find out if that could be the case here.
Melrose is the place
First, the context. Providence, on Melrose, is one of a handful of two-Michelin-star restaurants in L.A. Dinner itself costs $325 per person, so throwing in a $100 cocktail doesn't seem so crazy if that’s what you’re already spending.
Second, the margarita itself. Get rid of any notions that this is just an upgraded, overpriced cocktail from a profit-chasing bar. Its name, Electric Margarita, plays on the long-served Cadillac Margarita, which traditionally uses only top-shelf ingredients.
The Electric takes the Cadillac's standards and cranks them up even more, using ultra-premium craft ingredients which also have a sustainability lens. (Hence, Electric).
Then there’s the spectacle of how it's made.
“It’s margarita time!” exclaims Kim Stodel, the drink’s creator and Providence’s bar director, as he rolls out an ornate-looking bar cart into the main dining room. No, the Electric is not mixed at the bar. (That's a touch too prosaic). Instead, it’s prepared tableside, with Stodel carefully walking you through each ingredient.
Kim Stodel's bar cart at Providence comes complete with tools for embossing craft ice.
(
Gab Chabrán
/
LAist
)
Making the Electric
For the base spirit, Stodel uses a small-batch tequila, Fuenteseca Reserva Extra Añejo. The color — a dark, rich caramel similar to cognac or bourbon — indicates that this is not your average bottle of tequila.
He tells me it’s estate-grown, which means that Enrique Fonseca, the fourth-generation agave grower, is the same person who makes the liquor Stodel is holding, with no middlemen, a rarity in the tequila business these days.
Kim Stodel, bar director at Providence restaurant, pours the Electric Margarita tableside.
(
Josh Letona
/
LAist
)
The “extra añejo” label means it was aged for an extended period, five years in this case, in French oak barrels. According to Stodel, this allows the flavor properties to be more "dry and crisp, and a bit tannic.” This bottle retails at more than $200; for context, a bottle that has been aged 21 years is more than $1,000.
He also adds Grand Marnier Cuvee du Centenaire, an exclusive orange liqueur blended with XO Cognac from a 100 year old recipe. “ It's really about flavor, and the harmony of the orange and the Cognac that just go well together,” says Stodel.
Then it’s time to add a house-made passionfruit cordial from the leftover rinds of fruit grown at Rincon Farms in Carpinteria. Throwaway ingredients in an ultra-premium cocktail? That’s where the sustainability factor comes in.
Zero-waste cooking
The kitchen adheres to a zero-waste cooking philosophy, meaning nothing is thrown away; instead, things like produce peels or skins are repurposed in other dishes or used as compost for their rooftop garden program.
This effort has earned Providence a green Michelin star, which is awarded to restaurants for sustainability.
“We aren’t wasting food to make more flavor; we’re trying to use the whole ingredient. We are trying to maximize its potential”, he explains.
At this point, I find myself hanging off every word from Stodel, a man who can expertly tell a story just as much as he can craft a world-class cocktail. (I admit I’m a sucker for stories.)
The gravitas in his voice and the striking stare behind his glasses as he explains each detail makes me feel as if I'm the only person in the room.
Crafty ice
Then, with a flourish, Stodel produces a sizable single ice cube that he gets from West Coast Ice Provisions, a craft ice maker (yes, we have those; this is L.A.) from his vintage Penguin Ice Bucket.
You didn't know you needed diamond-shaped, embossed ice in your life.
(
Caroline Pardilla
)
“Don’t try this at home,” he says as he places it on a cutting board and delicately shaves off the edges with a Japanese fish knife usually used for butchering large sea creatures.
After a few moments, a massive ice diamond comes into view, almost cartoonish in size, like something you’d see on The Flintstones. I find myself gawking at all its silly beauty.
The story and the presentation are part of the $100 price tag.
(
Caroline Pardilla
)
Stodel places the heap of leftover ice shavings into a small glass reserved for what’s known as the sidecar. In this case, the sidecar is the leftover amount of the cocktail, usually 4 to 5 ounces, that can double as an extra cocktail. (Meaning that if you are still yapping about the cost of this beverage, you’re practically getting two drinks for the price of one, so chill.)
He places the ice diamond on a raised metal surface on his bar cart and embosses it with the Providence logo. He then tops the drink with a single blue borage flower from the restaurant garden and sets his immaculate creation before me.
I pause to appreciate the moment before picking up the glass ... and taking a sip.
Gab Chabrán takes in the moment -- and the drink.
(
Josh Letona
/
LAist
)
The verdict
It’s unlike anything I’d ever had. The tropical notes from the passionfruit cordial whisk you off to some exotic locale before the extra añejo tequila brings you back to earth.
The surprisingly light drink has a smooth body, which makes it go down easy — maybe too easy. But I manage to show restraint, taking small sips to unlock the nuances of each aspect of the drink.
I savor it as much as I can, catching a glimpse of little flying dollar emojis as they drift up toward the heavens.
So, the answer to the question you're all thinking? Is it worth it? (Drum roll please).
If you’ve got a little extra coin in your pocket, enough to splurge for dinner, which is the only way to enjoy this tableside experience at one of the best restaurants in L.A., then for me, the answer is a resounding yes.
Are you a Los Angeles County resident? What county programs and services do you find most valuable as the county heads into its fiscal year 2027-2028 budget?
(
Andrew Lopez
/
Boyle Heights Beat
)
Topline:
L.A. County is seeking residents’ input on what services should be prioritized, what programs should be cut and how else officials should be spending money through a series of short online surveys, open now through Saturday, Oct. 31.
Why it matters: In each of the surveys, residents can weigh in on any of the county’s 39 programs, including the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department, Public Health and Youth Development, or fill out the countywide questionnaire. “The County’s budget reflects its values. Our overarching goal in building the budget, especially during challenging times, is to ensure that we are maintaining safety net services and meeting the most essential needs of our communities,” L.A. County’s Chief Executive Officer Joseph M. Nicchitta said in a statement. “That includes everything from health and mental health care to making sure elections are secure and transparent, from emergency operations to supporting our justice system. Getting a broad view of how the public thinks about and values these services is an important part of the County’s work.”
Go deeper: ... read on for more details on how to weigh in
Are you a Los Angeles County resident? What county programs and services do you find most valuable as the county heads into its fiscal year 2027-2028 budget?
L.A. County is seeking residents’ input on what services should be prioritized, what programs should be cut and how else officials should be spending money through a series of short online surveys, open now through Saturday, Oct. 31.
In each of the surveys, residents can weigh in on any of the county’s 39 programs, including the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department, Public Health and Youth Development, or fill out the countywide questionnaire.
Survey responses are anonymous, unless respondents choose to share their contact information, and will be reviewed by the departments to inform their budget planning for fiscal year 2027-2028, which starts in July. The county’s 2027-28 budget recommendations will be presented to the Board of Supervisors in April.
“The County’s budget reflects its values. Our overarching goal in building the budget, especially during challenging times, is to ensure that we are maintaining safety net services and meeting the most essential needs of our communities,” L.A. County’s Chief Executive Officer Joseph M. Nicchitta said in a statement. “That includes everything from health and mental health care to making sure elections are secure and transparent, from emergency operations to supporting our justice system. Getting a broad view of how the public thinks about and values these services is an important part of the County’s work.”
The L.A. County Board of Supervisors oversees how the county serves its nearly 10 million residents; it’s one of the largest county governments in the country. Last month, the Board of Supervisors approved its final $54.2 billion budget for the 2026-27 fiscal year to prioritize housing and safety net services, wildfire recovery, emergency preparedness and civic engagement, among other things.
LA County offers free engineering advice for homes
Erin Stone
covers climate and environmental issues in Southern California.
Published October 27, 2026 5:00 AM
L.A. County civil engineer Eden Ly shares how water may flow at a property below a steep hillside.
(
Kerjon Lee
/
L.A. County Department of Public Works
)
Topline:
L.A. County is offering free, specific engineering advice for individual properties ahead of what's expected to be a wet El Niño winter.
How it works: Call the hotline, schedule an appointment, and civil engineers will come to your house to look at retaining walls, how water and mud will flow and more. They'll offer advice and, if you live in a high-risk area, a detailed report.
Who is this for? It'll be especially useful for people who live near burn scars or where debris flows are common during rain storms. It's open to all county residents.
Read on ... to learn about an LAist reporter's experience and how you can sign up.
A pair of Los Angeles County engineers knocked on my door a couple of weeks ago and handed me a booklet about how to prepare for flooding and mudflows. They also told me they offer free, specific engineering advice for individual properties.
I was definitely interested in this — I live in a neighborhood affected by the Eaton Fire, and the house I rent is tucked right against a steep hillside with vegetation that burned.
A few days later, two engineers, as well as the county’s public information officer, showed up at my door.
Eden Ly, a civil engineer with the county, looked up at the mountainside looming above my house.
“This mountainside is very steep, and that's the scary part,” Ly said.
The more recent the burn scar, the steeper the hillside and the closer your house is to it, the bigger the danger. The good thing, Ly said, is that much of the vegetation looked pretty recovered from the fire, so the roots should hold onto the dirt. And the property has a retaining wall that Ly said looks solid.
L.A. County civil engineer Eden Ly, right, assesses a retaining wall behind the house of reporter Erin Stone in a neighborhood affected by a recent wildfire.
(
Kerjon Lee
/
L.A. County Department of Public Works
)
How to get your free L.A. County property assessment
Call the L.A. County Public Works mudflow engineering advice hotline at (800) 933-0930. Services are offered in English, Spanish and Chinese. If you received a door hanger with the number (800) 675-HELP (4357), select option 6 for the mudflow engineering hotline.
In the past, this service was offered only in burn scar areas, but this year it was expanded. The service is open to all county residents, not only those who live in unincorporated areas.
You can also sign up for mud and debris flow alerts from L.A. County here and check the county’s latest forecasts for flows here. Find a mud and debris flow map for recent burn areas here.
Before coming to do a scheduled assessment of a resident’s property, Ly said he and his team analyze all kinds of data to understand how water — and thus mud and debris — may flow there.
“This will include a lot of geospatial information, a lot of mapping, such as topography,” Ly said. It also includes, Ly said, historical rain gauge data to understand how intense rain tends to be in different areas, soil types and more.
So far this season, Ly and his team have knocked on the doors of over 700 homes — 233 homeowners have received walk-through assessments of their properties, said Kerjon Lee, a spokesperson for the county’s Public Works Department.
“A lot of this data isn't public,” Ly said. "And even if it was public, how is the average Joe going to be able to understand what's going on? So our job is to try to bridge that gap.”
By Ly’s analysis, the terrain above my place is gravelly and muddy, not big boulders that can tear through a house. So if the hill does slide, we should be spared something like the deadly mudslides Montecito experienced in 2018, after the Thomas Fire.
“It's more of that kind of mud flow, that mud river that is more the concern in this case,” Ly said.
He suggests various areas to strategically place plywood planks and sandbags. I’m a renter, so there’s not much else I can do.
What if I have to leave?
Then Ly pointed to a weak spot that could lead to mud flowing where we park our cars.
“Heavy storm; we will probably recommend you try not to be there,” he said.
In a strong storm like that, I expect my neighborhood will get evacuation warnings — at least.
This winter, warnings or even orders to leave could become common.
Half an inch of rainfall in less than an hour — or more than 3 to 4 inches in a day — can trigger debris flows after a recent wildfire.
But that’s just a rule of thumb. As bare dirt becomes more saturated with back-to-back storms, less intense rainfall can be a trigger. So in addition to the engineering assessment and prep work, paying attention to forecasts and knowing how water flows where you live is key.
“Our best advice is that you try to deflect and guide everything,” Ly said. But “it's Mother Nature; you can't stop it.”
What you need to know about El Niño
El Niño years can be associated with lots of rain in Southern California, though there's no guarantee of a deluge.
And wet winters aren’t always disastrous. What matters is how much water falls within how much time. In fact, going back to when modern records began in 1950, most of the years when we've seen the highest flood-related costs were not during El Niño events.
But there are concerns beyond rain for late 2026 and early 2027.
El Niño this time will coincide with another natural phenomenon — the highest tides of the year in a nearly two-decade cycle known as “the declination of the moon.” We’re reaching the max this winter, according to Scripps scientist Mark Merrifield.
Because El Niño warms the ocean, it also raises sea levels temporarily. On top of that there’s an unprecedented level of human-caused global warming in the mix — that has already raised sea levels by as much as a foot along California’s coast over the last century, and is making normal weather patterns more extreme.
“So we start adding these things up, and they're actually not so small anymore,” said climate scientist Daniel Swain. “The risk of coastal flooding is actually very high and almost guaranteed.”
It’s not only the coast — inland areas, especially along creeks and rivers, are also at risk due to more extreme rainfall driven by El Niño as well as human-caused global heating, Swain and other experts said.
Talk to neighbors
Overall, Ly tells me the swales my landlord built behind the house, and those my neighbors built, look like they’ll direct water and mud to the street, which is generally the goal.
And that’s another piece of advice he gives — talk to my longtime neighbors, who have been through a storm or a few.
Ly tells me his team will email a more detailed report once they dig into a little more data. That’s part of the free service for higher-risk homes.
In addition to the plans I’ve got for our pets, important medications, possessions and other things I'll need if we have to evacuate, the county's assessment left me with valuable advice — and a little less anxiety too.
Keep up with LAist.
If you're enjoying this article, you'll love our daily newsletter, The LA Report. Each weekday, catch up on the 5 most pressing stories to start your morning in 3 minutes or less.
Elly Yu
reports on early childhood. From housing to health, she covers issues facing the youngest Angelenos and their families.
Published October 27, 2026 5:00 AM
Amid rising costs in childcare, families are racking on credit card debt to pay.
(
Illustration composite by Sabrina Sanchez/LAist
/
Images via Canva
)
Topline:
Childcare costs have been rising at a rate higher than inflation. To afford it, parents LAist spoke with told us they've had to significantly stretch their budgets — and some even racking up credit card debt.
What's new: Childcare costs are up 6.6% since January 2025 — and up 31.3% since Dec. 2019, according to Bureau of Labor Statistics data compiled by the Economic Security Project.
Why it matters: Childcare costs can often be one of the highest budget items in a family’s monthly budget. In a 2026 survey by Rocket Mortgage, nearly 60% of respondents said they’ve gone into credit card debt or taken on loans due to child-related expenses.
Little data: Unlike student loan debt, there's no good data on how much debt Americans are in because of childcare costs.
Key takeaways
Childcare costs far exceed inflation, and in L.A. County, childcare eats up nearly 20% of a median household income.
Families say they're shifting more costs onto their credit cards to accommodate the rising costs of childcare.
It's difficult to track how much consumer debt is related to childcare. That affects the ability of researchers and policymakers to know how childcare challenges affect a family’s financial circumstances in both the short and long-term.
Genny Richard constantly thinks about her family’s finances.
“The stress level has been immense,” she said. “Because childcare is our largest expense, that's been a big part of the reason.”
Her 5-year-old son is in his third year at a full-time Montessori school in Irvine. It costs her family $2,020 a month — more than their rent. They don’t have family nearby to help with childcare.
“We definitely had to start severely restricting our budget because of that cost,” Richard said. “We hardly eat out … we are part of a community garden, so we grow whatever vegetables we can on our own. … We only have one car.”
They’re also staying put in their two-bedroom apartment, which is offered through UC Irvine, as they expand their family; Richard is due next month. “We’re probably in a smaller apartment than we actually need, especially with a baby on the way,” Richard said.
Still, the bills began to pile up. Expenses like an unexpected trip to urgent care for an ear infection and Richard’s bout of pneumonia forced them to start putting costs onto their credit cards.
“It'd be like, ‘Oh, this thing came up. This medical bill came up. We can't pay that because we have to pay childcare,'” Richard said. “The credit card debt just sort of happened over time.” And they had to deal with high interest rates.
Genny Richard and her husband Fabricio have used credit cards to help pay for expenses because of the cost of their childcare.
(
Courtesy Genny Richard
)
Richard, who works at a nonprofit, and her husband, a postdoctoral fellow, have accrued tens of thousands of dollars in credit card debt over the last several years. They had to pay for their son’s childcare directly from their bank accounts — so they shifted other costs to cards when they could.
Their family is not alone — LAist heard from dozens of Southern California families who have had to go into debt to finance their childcare, or spend down their savings. Childcare can often be one of the largest costs in their monthly budgets, a problem reflected in state and national data:
In L.A. County, childcare eats up nearly 20% of a median household income, according to the Public Policy Institute of California.
In a 2026 survey by Rocket Mortgage, nearly 60% of respondents said they’ve gone into credit card debt or taken on loans due to child-related expenses.
And according to an LAist review of data from the Federal Reserve, the median cost for parents who paid for 20 or more hours of childcare a week went up from $1,100 in 2023 to $1,517 in 2025 — a 38% increase.
How big a problem is childcare debt?
But unlike student loans and other forms of debt, good data on how much consumer debt families have because of childcare isn't available, said Chloe Gibbs, a policy fellow at the Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research who studies the childcare market.
She explained that while student loans are specifically financed, families are “shifting” spending and financing other household costs to pay for childcare and housing.
“We can't really observe that in data because we just see the consumer debt, and we don't know the reason, the impetus behind families perhaps shifting to using credit cards to pay for expenses, so it's an area where we don’t know much,” she said. That affects the ability of researchers and policymakers to know how childcare challenges affect a family’s financial circumstances in both the short and long term, she said, and how they contribute to broader concerns about affordability.
“I think it really is just reflective of the very fragmented landscape around early childhood care and that we just haven't made a concerted public effort in this space at all. So we've kind of left families to navigate and figure out these challenges on their own,” she said. “In the same way, we have just kind of let the data float around in no way that we actually sort of systemically measure and collect.”
What is clear, Gibbs said, is that childcare costs have been rising higher than the rate of inflation, and it’s not surprising families are using credit cards to help with other living expenses. Childcare costs are up 6.6% since January 2025 — and up 31.3% since December 2019, according to Bureau of Labor Statistics data compiled by the Economic Security Project.
Why are costs rising?
At the same time, childcare providers have been struggling. Childcare providers are among the lowest-paid professionals nationwide. The workforce has also been shrinking, limiting the availability of care, which economists say drives up prices.
A national survey found that early educators are also grappling with the increasing cost of food, insurance and facilities costs in an industry that has already operated on thin margins. As a result, the majority of providers have had to pass along some costs to families by raising tuition, the survey found.
“There's just a fundamental mismatch in this market,” Gibbs said. State and federal childcare subsidies are usually tied to income, Gibbs noted, so families who earn too much to qualify get little help.
“It's insufficient in the current policy landscape because we still see lots of families, well up the income distribution, who face difficulties affording care,” Gibbs said.
What it means to rely on a credit card
Unable to qualify for subsidies, Pamela Arciaga, a mother of a 4-year-old in Glendale, accrued about $20,000 in credit card debt because of her son’s preschool costs. As the sole earner for her household, she couldn’t afford a full-time preschool program, so her son attended three days a week at $1,000 a month. Her parents would help her watch her son on the days he wasn’t in school, driving all the way from Riverside and back.
“What I relied on essentially was just my credit cards to pay for household groceries, sometimes to pay the water bill and power bill, because the preschool that he goes to, it's not as if I could have been on a payment plan, right? It was a monthly invoice that I had to pay so that he can stay in the program,” she said.
Pamela Arciaga and her son Finn. Arciaga has acquired about $20,000 in credit card debt because of childcare costs.
(
Courtesy A Golden State for Kids
)
Daniel Contreras and his wife were spending about $3,000 a month a young when their children were both in childcare. They didn't use credit cards, but had to forgo savings.
(
Courtesy Daniel Contreras
)
Arciaga works in early childhood advocacy, and said she also knew the value of preschool education for kindergarten readiness. She saw it as a short-term sacrifice. “It was an investment for me to actually enroll him in preschool,” she said. But the cost is that she’s blown through her emergency savings and is working to pay her debt off now that her son started transitional kindergarten. She pays about $300 a month for after-school care now.
“For emergencies, or anything like that, I still have to rely on the only credit card that I still have [with] a lot of credit on at this point or don't have a balance on,” she said.
She said she wishes that elected officials paid more attention to the issue of childcare costs.
“We have to work to keep the economy going,” Arciaga said. “However, we don't have any support, so it feels like we're paying double on, on top of taxes for not getting a lot of benefits.”
Early Head Start: a federally funded child development program for low-income families with infants and toddlers.The Los Angeles County Office of Education Head Start and Early Learning Division provides referrals based on your location.
A fill-in handout to take when you talk to providers and/or visit their facilities: The Child Care Resource Center defines the “keys to quality child care” as qualifications, cost, availability, learning, playing, health, safety, communication, COVID-19 precautions and caregiver/child interactions.
TrustLine Registry: A database of caregivers, including nannies and other un-licensed providers, who’ve passed background check that found with no substantiated child abuse reports or certain criminal convictions including murder and kidnapping.
California Department of Social Services guide to choosing child care: Answers to frequently asked questions and helpful checklist to take with you to child care facility visits.
Regional Centers: Community-based centers overseen by the state where families can get developmental disability assessments, case management support and learn about eligibility for therapeutic services.
These resources were recommended by community experts. Have a suggestion? Email ssanchez@laist.com.
How childcare costs affect families’ futures
For Daniel Contreras and his wife, the cost of childcare has made them reimagine having a large family.
“The reality sinks in pretty quickly when, you know, child number one comes in, and you're seeing your savings dissipate,” he said.
When Contreras’ children, who are now 7 and 10, were in childcare full-time in Whittier, the family was paying about $3,000 a month. “It was a fourth of our checks, and we had a mortgage still to pay. We had other items, just to keep the lights on.”
They couldn’t afford to save, and scaled back on buying new clothes for their kids. He said they avoided using credit cards to avoid falling into debt. His children are now older and in public school, but he said childcare still eats a large part of their monthly budget. After-school care costs $1,000 a month.
“So we're still paycheck to paycheck,” Contreras said. “It's like a heavy weight that's being pushed down at this moment.” At times, he’d had to negotiate with his rental's management to avoid a late fee when behind on rent.
He said he recently watched the gubernatorial debate and was disappointed not to hear very much about childcare.
“I don't see anybody really pushing the envelope and supporting the workforce,” he said. “Because the workforce needs help.”
Frank Stoltze
is a veteran reporter who covers local politics and examines how democracy is and, at times, is not working.
Published October 27, 2026 5:00 AM
LAPD Chief Jim McDonnell delivers the commencement address during graduation for a recruit class at the Los Angeles Police Academy in Los Angeles on Friday, May 2, 2025.
(
Myung J. Chun
/
Los Angeles Times via Getty Images
)
Topline
The Los Angeles Police Department has become a major issue in the race for L.A. mayor, with the fate of Chief Jim McDonnell at the center of the debate between incumbent Karen Bass and her challenger Councilmember Nithya Raman.
The details: Raman has called for the chief’s removal, saying his department was too cooperative with federal immigration agents during last year’s protests over raids. “I believe he’s lost the trust of Angelenos, especially in light of the ICE raids,” Raman said at a debate earlier this month.
Bass has backed the chief, whom she appointed in 2024, saying removing a chief so close to the 2028 Olympics would send the department into "disarray." She also points out crime is down across the city under McDonnell, mirroring crime trends nationwide.
Process for removal: The Police Commission decides the fate of the police chief. But the mayor appoints the five-member panel and therefore has a great deal of influence on that decision.
A vote from former opponent: Eight days before election day, billionaire developer Rick Caruso said he is backing Bass, who defeated him for the job four years ago. He said he had “serious concerns” about Raman, particularly her desire to remove McDonnell.
Read on ... for details on the city's previous relationships with police leadership.
The Los Angeles Police Department has become a major issue in the race for L.A. mayor, with the fate of Chief Jim McDonnell at the center of the debate between the candidates.
Councilmember Nithya Raman, who is challenging incumbent Mayor Karen Bass, has called for the chief’s removal, saying his department was too cooperative with federal immigration agents during last year’s protests over raids.
“I believe he’s lost the trust of Angelenos, especially in light of the ICE raids,” Raman said at a debate earlier this month.
Bass has backed McDonnell, whom she appointed in 2024, saying removing a chief so close to the 2028 Olympics would send the department into "disarray." She also points out crime is down across the city, mirroring crime trends nationwide.
"I don’t think you have any idea what it takes to remove a police chief," Bass said to Raman during the debate.
So what does it take to remove a police chief?
Here’s a closer look at L.A.’s famously contentious history with police leadership in the past and how that has resurfaced in the lead up to the current election.
Mayoral power to remove a chief
The police chief is among the most visible and powerful figures in city government, overseeing 8,500 officers and a budget of more than $3.5 billion dollars — a figure that amounts to more than half the city’s general fund.
Technically, a mayor can’t unilaterally oust a police chief. Only the Police Commission can do that. But the mayor appoints the five-member panel and therefore has a great deal of influence on that decision.
Mayors can always appoint commissioners who bend to their will.
An ousted chief may appeal to the City Council, but would need the support of two-thirds of its members to be reinstated.
Raphe Sonenshein, executive director of the Haynes Foundation, a group dedicated to effective governance in L.A., said it used to be nearly impossible to remove a police chief in the city of Los Angeles.
L.A.’s police chief once enjoyed civil service protection, a strong shield against termination, and was practically the most powerful political figure in the city, Sonenshein said. Removal “was almost a forbidden topic.”
“The police chief stayed as long as the police chief wanted to stay,” Sonenshein said.
Several major events in the 1990s changed that, including the 1991 beating of Rodney King, which followed years of complaints by Black and Latino residents of police abuse.
After the King beating, then-Mayor Tom Bradley called for then-Police Chief Daryl Gates to step down, but Gates refused to do so. Four police officers seen in video of the King beating were charged with felony assault and other charges, but were later acquitted on nearly all counts.
In the wake of the verdict and the riots that followed, voters approved Proposition F, stripping police chiefs of civil service protection and creating a five-year term limit, subject to one five-year extension.
The 1992 riots prompted liberal L.A. to elect a Richard Riordan, a conservative millionaire businessman, as mayor the following year.
Daryl Gates controversy
Earlier this month, Raman praised Gates for his policy of prohibiting officers from asking people about their immigration status. She called it the “gold standard” on police not cooperating with federal immigration agents
Bass said the comment showed Raman was out of touch with the history of L.A. and the role of Gates, a polarizing figure whose department often brutalized Black and brown communities.
Raman has since apologized. “I apologize for talking about an issue that I know causes real pain to Angelenos,” said Raman on the Yesi Ortiz podcast. She also apologized on CNN.
McDonnell has defended his officers’ response to ICE protests, saying demonstrators threw rocks, bottles and Molotov cocktails at them, necessitating the use of tear gas. He has called his officers’ actions “heroic.”
Robb Korinke, who runs the political consultancy group GrassrootsLab, said opposing McDonnell fits in with an "anti-establishment"-bent in this election.
“I don't think anyone is safe, whether you're an incumbent, elected or figurehead of a major city department,” he said.
On Monday, as the mayoral debate heated up, billionaire developer Rick Caruso said that he’s voting for Bass for mayor. Caruso, who lost to Bass four years ago by 10 percentage points, said he believed Bass had learned from her mistakes and that she had grown into the job.
Caruso also said he had "serious concerns" about Raman, particularly her desire to remove McDonnell.
Caruso said this is no time to turn the LAPD "into a laboratory for risking experimentation" by the Democratic Socialists of America, which has endorsed Raman.
Politics of policing have changed
Proposition F changed police politics in Los Angeles. But there were other factors as well, including a change in the election schedule.
L.A.’s switch from holding elections during off-years to during presidential and midterm years dramatically increased the number of voters who participated in city elections.
The electorate is much bigger, younger and more liberal, Korinke said.
“Until a few years ago, the city of Los Angeles held elections in odd years, meaning there was extremely low voter turnout, sometimes as low as in the high teens,” he said, adding that races were decided by more suburban parts of the city with mostly white voters.
“The politics of policing specifically have changed a lot from an environment that was very favorable to policing historically,” Korinke said.
He also explained that progressive voters have taken a greater interest in local issues in recent years, and police reform has become a big focus.
"The voting populace is just a little bit more skeptical of the expense that goes along with policing,” he said.
It's one reason police union spending on political races has become less potent in recent years.
Together with the firefighters union, the police union spent more than $1 million in an effort to defeat Raman’s reelection bid to the City Council two years ago. Raman narrowly won the race.
This year, the union is spending nearly $2.8 million to defeat Raman and elect Bass as mayor.
Bass approved big pay raises for officers in 2023. Raman voted against them, saying the money should be spent in other areas like parks and streetlight repair.