Villaraigosa Delivers State of the City & Releases New Budget
Amid the budget crisis, Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa this afternoon delivered his annual State of the City address and released the next fiscal year's budget. "This budget totals $4.34 billion dollars. Sets aside 6.5 percent or $284 million dollars for the reserve fund and it builds a smaller, more efficient city government," he said. Here are some key points, followed by the full speech:
- Instead of the traditional here's what we've done and here's my vision for the future spiel, Villaraigosa basically focused on fixing the budget.
- Part of that is acknowledging the LADWP and Carbon Surcharge controversy. Still, the city must pursue clean energy and a better-working utility. "We cannot afford to allow the economic storm to blow us off course," he said. "So, we will lay out a plan in the coming months, that begins to reform the Department of Water and Power making it more accountable to ratepayers and businesses alike and making an agency sometimes renowned for secrecy more transparent to us all. And we will lay out a plan that once and for all makes Los Angeles the undisputed national leader in green energy and green jobs."
- "We need to see the debate over LA’s budget in a much wider context. Over the last four years in LA, we’ve tried to make the case for investment in bold solutions. And we’ve seen that when we make the case, Angelenos are willing to make an investment in their city," he said, citing how residents in the past have approved a trash fee to increase the police force, the telephone users tax for the city budget and Measure R for transportation.
- "One year of cost-cutting won’t solve this crisis. We must make lasting, structural changes that not only balance this year’s bottom line, but puts us back into the black for future forecasts. This budget provides a beginning path towards that sustainability. It is balanced by using 68 percent of cuts and revenue changes that are structural and and just 32 percent that are one-time."
- "This budget begins with this first obligation and fortifies this foundation. This budget maintains our police force at its current level of just under 10,000 officers. And this budget makes NO cuts to our 9-1-1 emergency response system."
- "This budget funds the backbone of our transportation infrastructure: our street surfaces and street signals."
- "This budget also recognizes that it is not only necessary, but smart to create partnerships with the private sector in the delivery of city services that were once the sole domain of the public sector... This September, we will aim to close leases on a set of our city-owned parking garages. And working with the City Council we've already begun exploring the possibilities of partnerships at the Los Angeles Zoo, the Convention Center our municipal golf courses and the City’s parking meters."
- What the budget will not do: "While we opened new libraries this year, we are now asking our branch libraries to reduce their service from six days a week to five. While we are keeping pools open this summer, we are asking many parks to reduce the programs they offer. And while we are paving streets at a faster pace, we are slowing down at repairing potholes, paving alleys and trimming trees. You might find this strange. 'Why is the Mayor criticizing his own budget?' It is because I know we can do better."
- "I will be cutting my office budget and I ask the Council to do the same."
President Garcetti; Members of the City Council; City Controller Greuel; City Attorney Trutanich; Members of the School Board; Chief Beck; Chief Peaks; Presiding Judge McCoy;Judges Edmon & Espinoza; General Managers and Commissioners of our City departments; Consuls General; Fellow Angelenos: Pardon me if I break with the established ritual this afternoon. Instead of giving the traditional State of the City, complete with all things we’ve accomplished and all the things we intend to do, instead, I want to try and confine myself to a single topic: our city budget and what we must do to solve our deficit and hone our mission of the Angels. I think everybody realizes the urgency of our present financial condition. My
friends, this is a tough time for everyone right now in Los Angeles. We are
experiencing an historic economic collapse.
Before our eyes, the Dow dropped like a stone. Wealth accumulated over years
of hard work and sacrifice, was wiped out. Home equity evaporated, and in the
space of three short years, over 23,000 of our families lost their homes. Over the
last two years, new construction slowed by 25%; and with it, the new jobs and
revenue that support our city. 65,000 jobs gone; and with them, the security and
piece of mind provided by a steady paycheck.
This is our new economic reality.
A recession that is tearing at the fabric of our communities. A recession that is
tearing a gaping hole in our city budget and forcing us to take measures
unimaginable a few short years ago. Mandating that City employees take up to
26 days without pay; modifying the deployment plan of our firefighters;
eliminating departments and consolidating others; initiating lay-offs of more than
This is the new economic reality that is pitting the cruel irony of the growing
needs of Angelenos against the declining capacity of their own government to
answer their needs.
This is the reality that we face. And the reality that we will meet head on.
I think about what we are up against, and I think about how small it all seems in
comparison to the challenges that faced our grandparents. I think about my own
grandfather, Pedro Acosta. How he arrived in Los Angeles over 100 years ago
with little more than a shirt on his back and a willingness to work.
At first he worked the fields. Eventually he built a small thriving produce
business, achieving a life for his family well beyond his wildest dreams.
If only the story stopped there. Then the Great Depression came along and it all
came crashing down. He lost his business. He lost his wife. Things got so bad
he was forced to place his only two daughters into fostercare.
But my grandfather and my mother endured. They never lost hope. They never
stopped believing in each other. They never lost confidence that the future was
going to be better than the past. They never stopped working. Most of all they
never stopped believing that their futures were the ultimate product of their own
I always grew up believing that this is what it meant to be an Angeleno.
Now, I don’t have to tell you that over the last several weeks we have allowed
darkness to cloud our optimism. I think that you could even say that we have
allowed the strain of the challenges we face to undermine civic unity.
And I don’t have to tell you that the past several weeks have left many people
disappointed. The sparring over the budget and raising rates at the DWP
became far too negative. I would be the first to say in our effort to lead a green
economy in Los Angeles, I have stepped on more than a few rakes.
But I will also say this, we aren’t going to get blown off course by this economic
storm. We are bound and determined to lead the conversion of the Department
of Water and Power from dirty coal to renewable sources such as solar, wind and
geothermal. Producing reliable, affordable and sustainable energy to the
residents and businesses of Los Angeles is a matter of economic necessity. Not
just because we will be subject to hundreds of millions in state fines annually if
we don’t. We’ll give up our economic advantage as a city that owns its municipal
utility, conceding thousands of green jobs to more enterprising cities.
We cannot afford to allow the economic storm to blow us off course.
So, we will lay out a plan in the coming months, that begins to reform the
Department of Water and Power making it more accountable to ratepayers and
businesses alike and making an agency sometimes renowned for secrecy more
transparent to us all. And we will lay out a plan that once and for all makes Los
Angeles the undisputed national leader in green energy and green jobs.
Now, even though we began this debate with good intentions, we ended it
divided and fractured.
This must change.
We cannot allow our City Family to stand divided against itself. We must put the
long-term goal of sustainability ahead of short-term politics. This is a challenge
for all of us. It is a challenge that I acknowledge begins with me. And it is a
challenge that I accept.
Now, this challenge that we all face, will be difficult. It will call upon us to counter
the easy cynicism that always defaults to short-term thinking. That always says
we can kick the can down the road; defer the difficult decisions and choose quick
fixes over permanent solutions.
We need to see the debate over LA’s budget in a much wider context. Over the
last four years in LA, we’ve tried to make the case for investment in bold
solutions. And we’ve seen that when we make the case, Angelenos are willing to
make an investment in their city.
Yes, they’ve been willing to raise revenues. They are willing to raise fees. They
are willing to expand our tax base. They are willing to do all of these things if we
do our job and present them with a wise investment.
In 2006, when we asked residents to pay a higher trash fee, we offered a
commitment. A commitment that pledged that if the trash fee was raised, we
would hire the police officers that our neighborhoods needed and deserved. A
larger investment in a modern, community-centered, Twenty-First century police
department who understands that it is smarter to prevent crime, than just
We’ve built the largest police department in our city’s history, but more
importantly, it has allowed us to achieve historically low crime rates. Our
neighborhoods are the safest they have been since the Eisenhower
In 2007, we faced court challenges to what is called the telephone users tax. We
soon realized that if these challenges were successful, the City could lose over a
quarter of a billion dollars in revenue. We had a choice. Let the legal chips fall
where they may and risk a devastating loss in revenue to the city or go to the
voters and explain the need to keep the tax in place.
Again, the pundits clucked and again, the public proved the doubters wrong.
Proposition S passed with nearly two-thirds of the vote.
Again, in November of 2008, the voters showed their willingness to invest in the
future of their city. They passed Measure R with 68% support in the County of
Los Angeles over two-thirds countywide voted to raise the sales tax by half a
In doing so they secured $40 billion in revenue for new bus and rail lines, better
streets, and pedestrian and bicycle improvements.
Now, Angelenos’ willingness to invest has caught the attention of our national
leaders. We have been able to make the strong case that the federal
government should partner with Los Angeles to accelerate our historic
transportation investment. Instead of completing twelve major transit projects in
thirty years, Washington should help us do it in ten.
We are calling this the “30/10 Initiative.” By combining our investment with
federal support we could generate 166,000 construction jobs; 2,800 permanent
jobs over the next decade; increase transit boardings by 77 million per year; save
10.3 million gallons of gas; and keep 570,000 lbs of pollution out of the air.
Doing this will make Los Angeles more sustainable and reduce our dependence
on foreign oil. Measure R will double our transit system here in Los Angeles and
“30/10” would make us a national model showing how locally we can drive
transformative investments in the future of cities and our great nation.
Time and again, the citizens of Los Angeles have proven that they are willing to
invest when we explain the challenges accurately and present the options
Now it is time to present our city’s budget clearly and honestly as well.
Over the past four years we have tried to close the budget gap and put the city
on a path of fiscal sustainability. We made cuts; we raised revenue and we
replenished our reserve fund. City leaders, general managers, and most
importantly our city workers recognized the need to balance our expectations
with the resources at hand.
We pushed departments to find efficiencies. We measured productivity and
identified savings. We raised fees; accepted furloughs; provided an early
retirement program; transferred employees from positions paid for by the general
fund to special funds; and initiated the lay-offs of some city workers.
But these measures have not been enough.
The economic storm that has been pounding our private sector is now hitting the
public sector with full force. This coming year we are facing a deficit of $485
million dollars and pension costs have climbed to 19% of our General Fund.
So in crafting this year’s budget, where do we start? We start by recognizing that
LA’s long-term fiscal sustainability goes beyond just one budget year. One year
of cost-cutting won’t solve this crisis. We must make lasting, structural changes
that not only balance this year’s bottom line, but puts us back into the black for
This budget provides a beginning path towards that sustainability. It is balanced
by using 68 percent of cuts and revenue changes that are structural and and just
32 percent that are one-time.
It protects the reserve fund. It funds our first obligation public safety. It continues
the fight against gang violence. It protects our basic infrastructure by maintaining
streets. It forges new partnerships with the private sector and it balances our
expectations with our resources.
This budget totals $4.34 billion dollars. Sets aside 6.5 percent or $284 million
dollars for the reserve fund and it builds a smaller, more efficient city
A government that is focused on its first obligation, the public’s safety. You have
heard me say it before, and just as our City Council confirmed this past week,
safe streets is the foundation to every thing we are trying to build in the City of
This budget begins with this first obligation and fortifies this foundation. This
budget maintains our police force at its current level of just under 10,000 officers.
And this budget makes NO cuts to our 9-1-1 emergency response system.
I will not cut the services that support our residents at their greatest time of need
and protect our families when they are the most vulnerable.
This budget continues our successful work of fighting gang violence. Using
funding from both the state and federal governments, we will maintain support for
the city’s Gang Reduction and Youth Development program and the intervention
and prevention services that support our young people in need.
This budget funds the backbone of our transportation infrastructure: our street
surfaces and street signals. By leveraging Federal Stimulus dollars we will
budget 735 miles of street resurfacing. This keeps us on pace with the last two
This budget also recognizes that it is not only necessary, but smart to create
partnerships with the private sector in the delivery of city services that were once
the sole domain of the public sector. By balancing and sharing in the strengths,
skills and assets of both sectors, city services can be delivered to the public at
the same, or greater level of quality while creating new sources of funding for the
public sector and opportunities for the private sector.
This September, we will aim to close leases on a set of our city-owned parking
garages. And working with the City Council we've already begun exploring the
possibilities of partnerships at the Los Angeles Zoo, the Convention Center our
municipal golf courses and the City’s parking meters. All represent opportunities
for the City of Los Angeles to capitalize on the strengths of the private sector
while delivering a better quality of service for the people of Los Angeles.
To be clear, these partnerships won’t work if the public is not well served or if the
quality of services decline. So with every opportunity we explore we will follow
three guiding principles: first, we maintain public oversight and accountability for
the essential purpose of the service; second, we prioritize the needs of the
residents of Los Angeles and the quality of the core service above the profit of
the private sector; and third, we balance the strengths, skills and assets of both
sectors in the delivery of the service.
With these principles in place, these partnerships can offer Angelenos
advantages in the long-term with a better managed Convention Center and
parking garages, residents will see an improvement in the level of service. And
in the short-term, a substantial amount of revenue will be paid to the city’s
General Fund. This is new revenue that can only be found through these
partnerships and it is revenue that the city sorely needs.
But I will hold firm in arguing that any newly created revenue must be used to
replenish the city’s reserve fund. A healthy reserve fund is critical. Critical in
maintaining a good standing with the credit rating agencies. Critical in giving the
city the best chance for weathering this crisis and critical to protecting the city in
the aftermath of an unforeseen emergency.
But Angelenos, let me be the first to point out what this budget does not do. This
is not a budget that reflects why I ran for office. While we opened new libraries
this year, we are now asking our branch libraries to reduce their service from six
days a week to five. While we are keeping pools open this summer, we are
asking many parks to reduce the programs they offer. And while we are paving
streets at a faster pace, we are slowing down at repairing potholes, paving alleys
and trimming trees.
You might find this strange. “Why is the Mayor criticizing his own budget?” It is
because I know we can do better.
The cynics might say that politicians won’t make tough choices; that city workers
would rather pad their pensions than protect services. They are wrong. I know
they are wrong. And you know they are wrong.
I know because I have witnessed the dedication of our city employees. I have
seen the passion and energy they bring to their jobs. I have appreciated the
countless actions, both big and small, they have done to make this a better city. I
have watched our librarians ignite our children's imaginations through the pages
of books. I have seen our firefighters stand and face savage flames and searing
heat to protect the homes and lives of Angelenos. I have been moved by the
bravery of our police officers as they work everyday to make this a safer city. I
have been inspired by the professionalism of our general managers and the care
and imagination they bring to the enormous job of running a city of over 4 million
Like these individuals, we believe in the power of what we do to make the lives of
others better. We are here because we want to create a Los Angeles that is
more vibrant, more secure and more prosperous.
So, the proposed budget before you represents one version of our future; forced
on us by the economic downturn and our past failure to live within our means.
These lay-offs and service cuts I have proposed will be severe. And they will be
painful. But let me be first to say, we can we do better. We can avoid many of
these cuts and we can find better ways of protecting our fiscal health and
balancing our budget.
So, I issue another challenge the Mayor’s office, the City Council, labor leaders
and our city workers. We must all share in the sacrifice to stop the cuts in
services and prevent further lay-offs. We must all be willing to take cuts in our
pay, increase our pension contribution, and contribute more to our health care
I will be cutting my office budget and I ask the Council to do the same.
My friends, ultimately we are here today because we believe that people of good
faith can come together and find the common ground needed to secure a more
Let us commit ourselves to finding this common ground. Let us commit
ourselves to a frank and open conversation. Let us challenge ourselves to
engage in the sincere and honest search for solutions to avoid the austere future
represented by this proposed budget.
I stand here before you committed to the challenges before us. Committed to
reviving the spirit of cooperation. Committed to sharing in the sacrifice.
Committed to working side-by-side with you to create an even better budget.
I say this with the same optimism that Grandpa Pete brought with him to this
great country. I say this with the same optimism that the future will be better than
That there are sunnier days ahead for the City of the Angels.
And God bless you all