Sponsored message
Logged in as
Audience-funded nonprofit news
radio tower icon laist logo
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
Subscribe
  • Listen Now Playing Listen

The Brief

The most important stories for you to know today
  • Listen: Storm updates, rescues and more

    Today's headlines:

    Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts to get The L.A. Report delivered to you twice on weekdays, with special editions on Saturday and Sunday.

  • Inglewood mayor gets one against Council candidate
    A judge on Monday granted Inglewood Mayor James Butts’ request for a permanent civil harassment restraining order against Leonard Redway, City Council District 1 candidate, which will be in effect for the next three years.

    Topline:

    Inglewood Mayor James Butts’ request for a permanent civil harassment restraining order against Leonard Redway, City Council District 1 candidate, which will be in effect for the next three years. Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge Lucy Armendariz ordered Redway to stay at least 100 yards away from the mayor, his home and his vehicle, except for when the pair are at City Hall. In that case, Redway must keep a 20-yard distance and stay out of the dais for the next three years. 

    The backstory: The restraining order stems from a Sept. 19 confrontation between Butts and Redway in which the mayor claimed Redway “chest bumped” and threatened to fight him outside of a community event for Hispanic Heritage Month, according to court documents Butts filed on Oct. 7. While on the stand, Redway denied physically touching and threatening Butts, testifying that the confrontation began when Butts walked past his car and threatened to “end him” while making a throat-slashing hand gesture — something that Butts denied having done. Redway admitted in court to verbally confronting the mayor following the alleged threat. 

    A judge on Monday granted Inglewood Mayor James Butts’ request for a permanent civil harassment restraining order against Leonard Redway, City Council District 1 candidate, which will be in effect for the next three years. 

    Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge Lucy Armendariz ordered Redway to stay at least 100 yards away from the mayor, his home and his vehicle, except for when the pair are at City Hall. In that case, Redway must keep a 20-yard distance and stay out of the dais for the next three years. 

    “The result speaks for itself,” Butts said, following Monday’s decision. “Restraining order for three years, the result speaks for itself.” 

    The restraining order stems from a Sept. 19 confrontation between Butts and Redway in which the mayor claimed Redway “chest bumped” and threatened to fight him outside of a community event for Hispanic Heritage Month, according to court documents Butts filed on Oct. 7. 

    Jaaye Person-Lynn, Redway’s lawyer, questioned the court’s decision and stated that aside from the incident in September, the men have never had any negative interactions since first meeting in 2014. Redway plans to appeal, the attorney said.

    “I don’t think there was any showing of unlawful violence. There certainly wasn’t any showing that any negative conversation would even happen with them again,” Person-Lynn said. “The mayor himself testified that Mr. Redway had never stalked, harassed, or showed up to a place he was going to be. … I am confident an appeal will be successful.” 

    While on the stand, Redway denied physically touching and threatening Butts, testifying that the confrontation began when Butts walked past his car and threatened to “end him” while making a throat-slashing hand gesture — something that Butts denied having done. Redway admitted in court to verbally confronting the mayor following the alleged threat. 

    Bernard McCrumby, Inglewood’s development services director, witnessed part of the September confrontation and testified Monday to seeing the men arguing in an alley near Locust and East Queen streets. McCrumby said he saw Redway visibly upset while standing in an “aggressive stance.”

    “I always respect what the law and court says even though I don’t agree with that,” Redway said. “At no point ever did I touch the mayor, threaten the mayor, but this is a political environment.” 

    As of Friday afternoon, Redway was in third place in the race for the City Council District 1 seat with 23% of the vote behind Keokia Childress and Yolanda Davidson. Redway told The LA Local he had no plans to concede until the votes are certified on Nov. 27. 

    Redway said he believes Monday’s decision is the result of placing himself in the middle of a political “firing squad” for supporting “a father who was looking for help with a situation that happened with his daughter,” a reference to Redway’s involvement in sounding the alarm on Sept. 16 about allegations that the mayor inappropriately touched an Inglewood High School student, which Butts denies.

    The restraining order also prohibits Redway from owning firearms, ammunition and body armor with the exception of when he’s at work as an armed security guard at a local museum.

    The post Inglewood mayor gets restraining order against City Council candidate appeared first on LA Local.

  • Sponsored message
  • New licensing rules
    A two-story tan and brown building with two cars parked in front of it.
    The Merabi Medical Plaza in Van Nuys is considered a flagship example of licensed hospices clustered in one building. As of November 2026, it is home to 11 licensed hospices. In May 2026, there were 44.

    Topline:

    Amid crackdowns on widespread billing fraud in L.A. County, California regulators this June approved the state’s first-ever comprehensive licensing rules for hospices. These new regulations are meant to keep out the kinds of bad actors that have spilled through the open door of the state’s end-of-life care industry by the hundreds in recent years. The new rules are set to expire Jan. 1, unless made permanent or renewed.

    The details: The temporary standards approved in June apply to all 1,961 licensed hospice agencies statewide — including 1,132 in Los Angeles County, according to state licensing records updated in mid-October.

    The context: The new rules target “significant indicators of fraud” in L.A. County that were uncovered by a state audit, such as hospices sharing addresses and managers overseeing too many agencies. The audit also found unusually long stays and high rates of patients discharged before death.

    The pattern is well known to state and federal officials: Fraudsters approach older adults in public, by phone and through online phishing tactics to obtain their Medicare ID numbers, and then sign them up for hospice benefits.

    Victims are often signed up without their knowledge and then denied coverage for regular medical care.

    The cost to taxpayers has been steep. A 2022 report by the California State Auditor estimated that hospices in Los Angeles County — which federal officials describe as the national epicenter of hospice fraud — likely overbilled Medicare by more than $100 million in a single year.

    Amid crackdowns on widespread billing fraud in L.A. County, California regulators this June approved the state’s first-ever comprehensive licensing rules for hospices. These new regulations are meant to keep out the kinds of bad actors that have spilled through the open door of the state’s end-of-life care industry by the hundreds in recent years.

    They took effect June 22 of this year as temporary “emergency” regulations, after two years of delays that pushed back an initial deadline set by state lawmakers.

    State Sen. Ben Allen, who represents many of L.A.’s Westside cities and communities, co-authored a 2022 law (AB 2673) that requires the new rules.

    “These regulations will help us restart our hospice industry that has been in a state of emergency for years,” he said.

    Currently, those new rules — which are aimed at eradicating many of the hallmarks of potential hospice fraud — are set to expire Jan. 1, unless made permanent or renewed. State health officials proposed permanent versions of the rules last month, and public comment is open until Dec. 14.

    And there’s another looming deadline. Since 2022, a state moratorium has frozen all new hospice licenses, meaning no new hospices could enter the market. That freeze will lift on Jan. 1, according to the California Department of Public Health, or CDPH.

    Once the moratorium lifts, industry advocates say the state’s new hospice licensing standards will be the primary safeguard against the next wave of potentially fraudulent operators.

    “They will make it significantly harder for fraudulent billing agencies to masquerade as hospice providers,” said Sheila Clark, president of the California Hospice and Palliative Care Association, a statewide organization representing hospices and patients.

    The new rules target “significant indicators of fraud” in L.A. County that were uncovered by the state audit, such as hospices sharing addresses and managers overseeing too many agencies. The audit also found unusually long stays and high rates of patients discharged before death.

    The temporary standards approved in June apply to all 1,961 licensed hospice agencies statewide — including 1,132 in Los Angeles County, according to state licensing records updated in mid-October.

    The number of licensed hospice agencies has exploded in L.A. County in recent years. In 2010, there were 109 agencies and by 2021 there were 1,841, far outpacing growth in the rest of the country and any plausible medical need, according to the state audit report. State licensing data show the number of hospices peaked at more than 2,000 in 2022.

    L.A. County’s population over age 65 grew by 40% between 2010 and 2021, while the number of licensed hospice agencies increased by more than 1,500%, the audit found.

    In 2019, the county had 36 hospices per 100,000 people 65 and over — more than six times the national average. County hospices likely overbilled Medicare by $105 million that year alone, according to the state auditor’s report.

    An LAist review of state hospice licensing records found some of those red flags for potential fraud remain, including an overall glut of hospice agencies — as well as dozens of licenses clustered at the same addresses or in the same neighborhoods. The review also found 119 active L.A. County hospices that list an administrator whose name also appears on a revoked hospice license.

    After adjusting for regional wage differences, Medicare paid L.A. County hospices about $19,600 per patient in federal fiscal year 2024, 29% more than the roughly $15,200 paid to hospices elsewhere in California, according to LAist’s analysis of CMS hospice utilization data.

    Federal and state crackdown

    Since April, federal prosecutors have charged 15 people in 10 L.A.-area hospice fraud cases, totaling more than $90 million in alleged Medicare overbilling. Two have pleaded guilty, and one has agreed to plead guilty under a plea agreement filed in court. The rest have pleaded not guilty, and none have gone to trial.

    The cases include a doctor accused of helping drive the fraud by falsely signing paperwork saying patients had six months or less to live — a medical judgment required for Medicare to cover hospice care.

    In an operation this spring dubbed “Never Say Die,” federal prosecutors charged the operators of seven hospices across four cities — in Glendale, Tarzana, Artesia and Simi Valley — accused of billing Medicare more than $23 million for patients who were not dying.

    The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, or CMS, says its hospice oversight efforts have led to more than 600 revocations of Medicare billing privileges nationwide since July 2023, including “several hundred providers in the L.A. area,” a CMS spokesperson told LAist.

    In May, the federal government imposed its own six-month moratorium on new Medicare hospice enrollment nationwide. On Nov. 12, CMS extended it for another six months. The freeze now applies only to newly enrolling hospices, not to those already enrolled that want to add locations.

    CMS also recently temporarily suspended payments to several hundred L.A. County hospice companies that it suspects of fraud, according to the agency.

    Separately, the California attorney general’s office charged 21 people in an alleged fraud ring in April, alleging the group billed Medi-Cal, California’s Medicaid program for low-income residents, for tens of millions of dollars, through more than a dozen sham hospice agencies that operated under false names to conceal the real owners. Those arrested have been arraigned, and at least some have pleaded not guilty, according to court records. Others remain at large. The cases are pending.

    The California Department of Public Health has revoked more than 500 hospice licenses in L.A. County between January 2022 and October 2026 — 79% of all revocations statewide. The department provided LAist a list of those revoked hospice agencies, which were at 330 different addresses, largely concentrated in Van Nuys, Burbank and Glendale.

    How hospice care works in California

    Hospice is end-of-life care for terminally ill patients who agree to give up curative treatment.

    Medicare, the federal health insurance program predominantly for people 65 and older, pays hospices a flat daily rate for each enrolled patient, regardless of what care is actually delivered.

    The Medicare hospice benefit hinges on a medical judgment by a doctor that a patient is terminally ill with a life expectancy of six months or less.

    In 2024, more than half of all Medicare beneficiaries who died nationwide received hospice services — a record high, according to the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission, an independent congressional watchdog agency.

    The vast majority of hospice care is delivered wherever a patient lives, according to the commission. That could be a private home, nursing facility or assisted-living facility, rather than in a dedicated hospice building.

    Most hospice fraud in L.A. County is, at its core, Medicare billing fraud. Operators enroll patients who aren't dying and collect the daily rate.

    Medi-Cal covers a small share of hospice care and has been a secondary target for fraud alongside Medicare.

    Why the problems are hard to fix

    New state licensing rules won’t fix the entire problem. Advocates say a tangled web of government jurisdictions makes reforms challenging.

    In L.A. County, hospices are licensed by the California Department of Public Health.

    But CMS, the federal agency led by Dr. Mehmet Oz, is responsible for certifying those hospices to receive Medicare payments, where most of the financial fraud occurs.

    A man with gray hair and a navy suit stands with flags behind him. He has on a red tie.
    Dr. Mehmet Oz attends an event with President Donald Trump in the Oval Office of the White House on Oct. 20, 2026.
    (
    Andrew Harnik/Getty Images
    /
    Getty Images North America
    )

    The state’s public health department contracts with the L.A. County Department of Public Health’s Health Facilities Inspection Division to carry out hospice inspections and investigations. (L.A. County is the only county in the nation that conducts health facility inspections on behalf of the state and federal government.)

    The federal government is also responsible for investigating and prosecuting Medicare fraud through the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services — Office of the Inspector General and the U.S. Department of Justice.

    The California Department of Justice also investigates and prosecutes Medi-Cal fraud, and the state’s Department of Health Care Services determines eligibility and processes payments for that system.

    Advocates and L.A. County officials urge more coordination between state and federal authorities to combat fraud within the hospice industry, pointing to persistent gaps that allow some fraudsters to go undetected.

    What’s in the new regulations?

    Advocates say the rules matter because enforcement alone can't keep pace.

    “We are not going to convict our way out of this," Clark, president of the California Hospice and Palliative Care Association, told a congressional committee in April. “We have to stop them from entering the system.”

    Some states, including New York and Florida, have state laws requiring new hospices to demonstrate unmet need before opening. That’s something California has not had until the new temporary regulations went into effect in June.

    The California Department of Public Health’s emergency regulations target patterns of fraud described by prosecutors, auditors, reporters and industry watchers.

    They include the following:

    1. Management cap: Administrators, medical directors and patient care services directors can work for only one hospice at a time, with narrow exceptions for rural areas.
    2. Real office requirement: Every hospice must have exclusive, unshared commercial office space with permanent exterior and interior signage, posted hours and a 24/7 phone line.
    3. Unmet need requirement: The state can deny a new license or a renewal if the hospice can't demonstrate that the counties it serves need another hospice, using a specific formula.
    4. Ownership transfer lockdown: A hospice license generally cannot change owners within five years of initial issuance, to cut down on license flipping.
    5. Ownership disclosure requirement: Anyone with a 5% or greater direct or indirect ownership or control interest in a hospice and all management personnel must be disclosed, along with a 10-year work history.
    6. Bad-actor screening: The California Department of Public Health must deny a license or renewal if the hospice’s management personnel have had professional license discipline in the past seven years and aren't replaced after the department flags it. Examples include fraudulent billing, forgery and felony convictions.
    7. Nurse caseload and travel-time limits: No licensed nurse may be assigned more than 12 hospice patients at a time. A hospice must guarantee a licensed nurse can arrive in person within two hours of learning a patient has a medical need or safety concern, 24/7.

    Clark said new state rules are a good first step toward curbing hospice fraud.

    “It starts with licensing,” she said. “In these emergency regulations, we increased the visibility. Put your eyes on these people. Are they real?”

    She said the next step must involve the federal government — which oversees Medicare enrollment and billing.

    “Most of the hospice benefit is paid at the federal level,” Clark said. “It’s a shared responsibility.”

    How a hospice gets licensed — and who watches it afterward

    When a hospice agency wants to open in L.A. County, it first submits an application to the state health department. Once that paper application gets approved, county health inspectors step in to perform an initial, on-site licensing inspection.

    This visit is a snapshot check to ensure basic operations are in order — equipment, policies, trained staff members. Passing this initial check earns the agency a state license.

    A state license only allows the hospice agency to open, but it does not automatically allow them to collect payouts from the federal Medicare system. To get federal Medicare funds, the hospice must pass a separate audit showing it meets federal standards.

    Hospice agencies can wait for government inspectors to do that audit, or they can hire private accrediting agencies to do it instead. According to an August report from the L.A. County Department of Public Health, more than half of L.A. County’s hospice agencies choose the private path, earning them what’s known as “deemed status.”

    Once a hospice has deemed status, routine inspections are handled by the private accreditor — which is paid by the hospice agency — not by L.A. County inspectors. Under federal rules, county inspectors don’t routinely survey deemed hospices and need authorization from CMS to investigate a complaint against one, according to the county’s report.

    This creates a major system breakdown, according to L.A. County officials. Once they transition to private oversight, fraudulent hospices could bill Medicare for fake patients or turn into completely unstaffed "ghost" offices without local inspectors ever knowing.

    The California Hospice and Palliative Care Association raised concerns in an April 2024 letter to CMS about accreditors certifying hospice agencies at auto body shops, restaurants and vacant lots, sometimes without ever entering a building to inspect what’s going on inside.

    Joan Teno, a hospice researcher at Brown University’s School of Public Health, raised a similar concern in a recent analysis. Accrediting organizations “are paid by the hospices they survey,” Teno wrote.

    “I am very concerned that flagrant problems were missed, problems as obvious as many hospices listing the same building address in public files,” she continued.

    The county's report says that if a deemed hospice is accused of fraud but there are no complaints about quality of care, the county would be unaware and not involved in any later regulatory action.

    Under federal rules, L.A. County’s health inspectors don’t routinely inspect deemed status hospices and need federal authorization to investigate a complaint against one.

    The state’s public health department has also directed the county to investigate only complaints alleging patient harm, citing staffing shortages tied to state funding, according to the report. Less serious complaints are referred to the private accreditor that certified the hospice.

    Those accreditors are approved and overseen by CMS, not the state. CMS periodically re-reviews them and spot-checks a sample of the hospices they certify.

    L.A. County reports receiving 332 hospice complaints from January 2025 through mid-August — 262 involving deemed status agencies and 70 involving agencies that are not deemed status. Forty-five were ranked as the most serious, involving allegations that patients were seriously harmed or at risk of serious harm or death.

    The county’s contract with the state to carry out these inspections was cut from $135 million to $126 million in fiscal year 2025-26, which the report says kept the county from hiring additional staff to conduct inspections.

    What's next?

    The licensing rules expire Jan. 1 unless state regulators finalize the permanent version proposed Oct. 30, or renew the temporary ones. Even then, some gaps will remain.

    The federal government, for example, tracks which hospice agencies are certified to bill Medicare, while the state tracks who is licensed and allowed to operate as a hospice.

    When California revokes a hospice license, that revocation is recorded in the state system, but nobody automatically flips a switch to deactivate the hospice’s 10-digit National Provider Identifier number it uses to bill Medicare.

    The California Department of Public Health said it informs CMS and the state Department of Health Care Services when it revokes a license, so they’re aware the agency is no longer approved to provide services.

    “Not having a valid license is grounds to terminate an agency’s certification and remove their ability to bill Medicare and/or Medicaid,” a department spokesperson said via email.

    But the state has no authority to shut off a provider’s billing number, and it gets no confirmation from the federal government that it was ever deactivated.

    CMS did not respond to questions about the gap. The federal agency recently proposed expanding its authority to revoke Medicare billing privileges when a provider's owners or managers have had their license suspended or revoked by a state. The rule has not yet taken effect.

    CMS monitors for abnormal billing patterns and complaints from beneficiaries and will suspend payments, revoke billing privileges and refer cases to law enforcement when appropriate, a spokesperson told LAist. “CMS does not comment on the specific data analytics, thresholds, or investigative methods used to identify providers for review, as doing so could undermine ongoing program integrity efforts,” the statement said.

    L.A. County officials are urging more coordination between state and federal agencies.

    In April, county supervisors directed the public health department to recommend ways to improve coordination with state and federal fraud enforcement. In its August report, the department suggested tying Medi-Cal payments more closely to licensing status and strengthening oversight of the private accreditors that handle deemed hospices.

    Amid the crackdown on L.A. County hospice fraud and licensing moratorium, some suspicious activity appears to be migrating from the hospice industry to the home health industry, where no state moratorium existed prior to this year.

    L.A. County home health agencies grew from 825 a decade ago to more than 3,100 last year, before dipping to about 2,900 this year, according to state data.

    Clark, with the California Hospice and Palliative Care Association, said it’s some of the same applicants. “They literally just crossed out hospice on the application and put in home health,” Clark said.

    Federal officials agree.

    “I'll just warn everybody that when you stomp on hospice, those criminals, they don't go away,” Oz, the head of CMS, told reporters in January. “They just move over to home healthcare. You stomp on home healthcare, they're gonna move to pharmacy. You stomp on that, they're gonna do behavioral therapy.”

    How to reach me

    I'm interested in hearing from people who have worked in the hospice industry. If you have a tip, you can reach me on Signal. My username is aschrank.80

    How we reported this

    To report this series, LAist reviewed state licensing records, federal Medicare data, court records and government reports. We also interviewed researchers, regulators and industry representatives.

    We analyzed California Department of Public Health licensing records (updated in mid-October) to count active hospice licenses in L.A. County and see where they’re registered. The department also gave us a list of 505 L.A. County hospices whose licenses it revoked between January 2022 and early October 2026.

    To map the hospice locations, we compared the state’s data against local parcel data. This enabled us to group licenses registered to the same property even if they were in different units, and it allowed us to correct a few mapping errors in the state data. Brian Frank, a data journalist, used AI to help write the analysis code, then reviewed and tested it before use.

    We also compared administrators’ names, phone and fax numbers and suites with those on revoked licenses. Contact details for revoked hospices come from archived versions of the state’s licensing list. Names can belong to more than one person, so matches alone don’t prove the same people are involved.

    To compare L.A. County with the rest of the country, we used the following federal Medicare data:

    • To count hospices eligible to bill Medicare: hospice enrollment file from fourth-quarter 2026.
    • For Medicare terminations: the provider of services file.
    • For length of stay and live discharges: CMS’ Service and Spending Variation Index (fee-for-service Medicare, fiscal year 2025).
    • For payments per patient: CMS's geographic variation and hospice utilization files.
    • And we adjusted payment comparisons for regional differences in payment rates.

    We visited six San Fernando Valley office buildings where state records showed multiple hospices registered to suites. We checked every listed suite for a hospice and compared those hospices against warning signs of potential fraud, including ties to revoked hospices, high live-discharge rates and administrators listed at more than one.

    We also reviewed the 2022 state audit, the state’s emergency and proposed regulations, and the L.A. County Department of Public Health’s August report on hospice oversight. Information about fraud cases comes from charging documents, court records and announcements from the U.S. Department of Justice and the California attorney general’s office.

  • Are restrictions improving student engagement?
    A number of high school students with varying skin tones stand in a line holding pouches that say "Yondr" on them.
    The results of LAUSD's annual student engagement survey show mixed results from the district's cellphone restrictions.

    Topline:

    A majority of students are complying with Los Angeles Unified’s cellphone ban and paying more attention in class, at least according to school staff. But there are still unanswered questions about what effect, if any, LAUSD’s student phone-use restrictions have on student learning and behavior, including recent gains on state tests.

    Why now: The results of the spring 2026 School Experience Survey, which queries staff, students and parents on a number of topics, are the first public, quantitative measure of how LAUSD’s updated cellphone policy has changed student behavior on campus since it was implemented in February 2025. While some survey answers are available online, results of the questions specific to the cellphone policy were only released only to LAist upon request.

    The backstory: LAUSD joined a growing number of districts and states clamping down on student cellphone use in June 2024 when the school board voted to extend the existing class-time ban to include lunch and passing periods.

    Read on … to see how students say the policy has changed their school experience. 

    A majority of students are complying with Los Angeles Unified’s cellphone ban and paying more attention in class, at least according to school staff.

    That’s one finding from the first survey of students and staff to include questions about bell-to-bell restrictions implemented in February 2025.

    “It's a big difference in terms of [students’] ability and willingness to focus on whatever we're doing in class,” said Elizabeth Ruff, an English teacher at Garfield High School. “Obviously there are always some kids who are distracted … even if it's not their phone. But that has decreased a lot really, really markedly.”

    But there are still unanswered questions about what effect, if any, LAUSD’s student phone-use restrictions have on student learning and behavior, including recent gains on state tests.

    Compliance varies, too: Middle school staff estimated that two-thirds of students “mostly” abided by the restrictions. Among high school staff, that number dropped to just over half.

    More than 160,000 students answered the survey, as did more than 21,000 staff members.

    The results of the spring 2026 School Experience Survey, which queries staff, students and parents on a number of topics, are the first public, quantitative measure of how LAUSD’s updated cellphone policy has changed student behavior on campus. While some survey answers are available online, results of the questions specific to the cellphone policy were released to LAist only upon request.

    LAUSD’s policy predated the state of California’s requirements for all schools to restrict student cellphones by July 2026. At least 40 states and the District of Columbia have similar restrictions, according to Education Week, largely based on the premise that phones and social media distract students from learning and amplify conflicts, among other concerns.

    How middle and high school students differ

    LAUSD middle and high school students are split nearly evenly on whether the policy improved their focus in class.

    Myson Thomas, 17, is a senior at King/Drew Magnet High School. He said he doesn’t use his school’s magnetically sealed Yondr pouches, but he also isn’t on his phone in class.

    “I'm at school to learn, so I'm gonna turn my phone off,” Thomas said. “I already take rigorous courses, so it's no point of me using my phone at school.”

    Fewer than half of high school students reported they focused better in class all or most of the time without their phone compared to nearly 58% of their peers in middle school.

    “In implementing a phone-free policy across the district, we recognized that changing long-standing habits would take time,” a district spokesperson said in a statement to LAist. “We recognize there is still work to do and will continue listening to students, families and staff as we refine our approach to support focused learning and meaningful in-person connections.”

    Board Member Nick Melvoin, who co-sponsored the cellphone policy, said he was “really encouraged” that most middle and high school student respondents said they were interacting with each other more without their phones.

    “This isn't just about trying to be punitive adults,” Melvoin said. “This is about [students] having a much more engaging day, a more fulfilling day when you're not just scrolling or texting.”

    How we got here

    LAUSD joined a growing number of districts and states clamping down on student cellphone use in June 2024 when the school board voted to extend the existing class-time ban to include lunch and passing periods.

    Board members cited concerns about the effect of phones and social media on youth mental health, bullying and distraction from classroom instruction.

    Educators who spoke in support of stricter rules said their schools had few resources or administrative support to enforce the existing rules and said that policing phone use ate up time and created conflicts with students.

    “It definitely felt a little bit like playing Whac-A-Mole in terms of trying to do everything else I'm supposed to be doing in the classroom and also be looking out for who secretly has a cellphone behind their book,” said Ruff, the Garfield High School teacher.

    How LAUSD enforced phone restrictions

    The board’s vote allocated $7 million to implement the policy. Schools could choose whether they wanted to purchase pouches or lockers to store students’ phones or rely on the “honor system,” and ask students to keep their devices powered off and in their backpacks.

    About half of schools purchased devices to enforce the ban, according to a district spokesperson at the time the policy went into effect.

    Documents provided to LAist through a public records request show LAUSD spent about $6.35 million on products related to cellphone policy implementation during the 2024-25 school year. Of that, the district spent $5.42 million on Yondr products (including phone pouches) and nearly $930,000 on products from Amazon, including phone lockers.

    Listen 46:11
    Did the cellphone ban in high schools work?
    At the end of the 2024-25 school year, we headed to Venice High School to see how the cellphone ban actually went. Listen to the full episode of "Imperfect Paradise."

    What we know about the effectiveness of phone restrictions

    LAist first spoke to Miles, a student at the Sherman Oaks Center for Enriched Studies, when the restrictions began in 2025. At the time, he called the phone-free policy “really, really annoying.”

    “I think it's still a pretty useless policy,” Miles, now a junior, said.  ”It doesn't change anything other than how we hide our phones.”

    LAist agreed not to publish Miles’ last name to protect his privacy.

    He, like Thomas, said he doesn't use his school’s phone storage pouches and doesn't use his phone in class.

    Students have also reportedly circumvented the pouches by storing a dummy phone or breaking open the locks.

    However, a national study of school campuses found phone use declined when students are required to stow their phones in locking pouches.

    “Even though the compliance isn't perfect, it actually still has a big impact on how many phones are being used at school,” said  Matthew Gentzkow, a professor of economics at Stanford and study co-author.

    The study evaluated GPS data to measure phone activity at more than 40,000 schools. Gentzkow said even though the data is “imperfect” because it does not distinguish student phone use from adults on campus, the usage “falls really quite dramatically” after the pouches are introduced — there are about 30% fewer GPS pings measured three years after the ban is adopted on a campus.

    Yondr, the company that makes the pouches, provided the data for the study, but did not influence the findings, Gentzkow said.

    The study also examined disciplinary actions, student test scores, attendance data and surveys, finding:

    • Disciplinary incidents increase in the first year a phone policy goes into effect, but decline in subsequent years. 
    • A “close to zero” effect on test scores and attendance. 
    • Student well-being takes a couple of years to improve. 

    LAist also asked Gentzkow to respond to LAUSD’s school survey data.

    He noted that students were more likely to report socially interacting more with their peers without their phones than they were to focus better in class.

    “That dovetails with our finding that the academic benefits here, at least as measured by test scores, are maybe somewhat disappointing or somewhat smaller than we might have expected,” Gentzkow said. “Whereas things like these well-being benefits may reflect these important changes outside of the classroom as a result of these policies.”

    The study Gentzkow worked on is one of several that have found mixed results after schools implement stricter cellphone policies. For example, a study of Florida schools found a modest test score increase after a state-mandated cellphone ban, particularly in schools with high phone usage before the policy went into effect.

    LAUSD students increased their scores on the state’s standardized reading and math tests over the last three years, but those gains began before the district’s cellphone ban began.

    East Valley High School social studies teacher Mario Narciso said his school has used both pouches and lockers to try to curb students’ cellphone use. Even though enforcement varies on campus, he said he doesn’t see phones as a “huge problem” anymore.

    “At the end of the day,” he said, “it's more about that relationship that you have with your kids.”

    Find your LAUSD board member

    LAUSD board members can amplify concerns from parents, students and educators. Find your representative below.

    District 1 includes Mid City, parts of South L.A. (map)
    Board member: Sherlett Hendy Newbill

    District 2 includes Downtown, East L.A. (map)
    Board member: Rocío Rivas

    District 3 includes West San Fernando Valley, North Hollywood (map)
    Board member: Scott Schmerelson

    District 4 includes West Hollywood, some beach cities (map)
    Board member: Nick Melvoin 

    District 5 includes parts of Northeast and Southwest L.A. (map)
    Board Member: Karla Griego

    District 6 includes East San Fernando Valley (map)
    Board Member: Kelly Gonez

    District 7 includes South L.A. and parts of the South Bay (map)
    Board Member: Tanya Ortiz Franklin

  • Department investigates alleged ICE communication
    An Orange County Sheriff’s deputy in an olive-green uniform and black face covering walks toward the glass entrance of a beige concrete building labeled “Intake and Release Center” with a gold sheriff’s star. Signs on the doors include a visitors’ entrance notice and a COVID-19 symptom warning. Trees and a planter of birds-of-paradise line the walkway.
    An Orange County Sheriffs deputy walks into the Intake and Release center at the the Orange County Central Men's Jail in Santa Ana.

    Topline:

    At least two employees of the OC Sheriff’s Department are on administrative leave as the department investigates a report that a deputy and sheriff’s special officer were seen communicating with ICE agents, according to OCSD.

    What do we know: The department on Friday pointed to surveillance video from Oct. 31 was taken outside the Orange County Jail. It shows two OCSD employees “appearing to have a five-second conversation” with ICE agents in an unmarked vehicle parked outside the Orange County jail, according to the department. The conversation took place minutes before a man, who was hiding in the public courtyard, was arrested by the agents.

    Background: State sanctuary law, known as the California Values Act, limits police cooperation with federal immigration agents and prohibits state and local law enforcement from investigating or arresting people for immigration enforcement purposes.

    Read on… for how the Sheriff and OC officials are responding.

    At least two employees of the Orange County Sheriff’s Department are on administrative leave as the department investigates a report that a deputy and sheriff’s special officer were seen communicating with ICE agents, according to OCSD.

    The department on Friday pointed to surveillance video from Oct. 31 that was taken outside the Orange County Jail. It shows two OCSD employees “appearing to have a five-second conversation” with ICE agents in an unmarked vehicle parked outside the Orange County jail, according to the department. The conversation took place minutes before a man, who was hiding in the public courtyard, was arrested by the agents.

    State sanctuary law, known as the California Values Act, limits police cooperation with federal immigration agents and prohibits state and local law enforcement from investigating or arresting people for immigration enforcement purposes.

    Sheriff Don Barnes said in a statement that the department does not enforce federal immigration law but that he will fully cooperate with ICE to the extent the law allows.

    “Personnel acting outside the law and department policy will be held appropriately accountable,” Barnes said.

    He added the department will enforce state and local laws equally, without bias and without concern for anyone’s citizenship.

    Carlos Perea, executive director of the Harbor Institute for Immigrant and Economic Justice, told LAist this incident shows OCSD’s culture.

    “The department has expressed time and time again that they will work with ICE to the fullest extent of the law,” Perea said. “OC Sheriff Barnes should use this as a learning lesson to end all collaboration with ICE.”

    Hector Bustos, communications director for political organizing group Chispa, told LAist he’s glad to see an investigation launched, but he’s not completely surprised by the incident.

    “We have known for a very long time that the Orange County Sheriff's Department has had a very close relationship with ICE,” Bustos said. “Our hope is that there is an independent investigation here because we know that historically when law enforcement agencies are investigating themselves, we don't see accountability.”

    OC Supervisor Vicente Sarmiento said he’s encouraged by the investigation, but that anxiety among residents is already heightened by the presence of ICE.

    “What it does is it chills the average person from wanting to trust law enforcement when it comes to becoming a witness to a crime, or as a victim to a crime,” Sarmiento said. “The average person may not know state law and just believes that there is collaboration because you see many times federal agents calling local law enforcement for assistance.”

    OC Supervisor Doug Chaffee, in a statement to LAist, welcomed the investigation and said any action that undermines trust or creates fear is concerning.

    “Our local law enforcement agencies should not be participating in federal immigration enforcement,” Chaffee said. “Orange County must remain committed to protecting our residents, upholding California law, and ensuring that local law enforcement remains focused on public safety – not federal immigration enforcement.”

    LAist is working to reach the family of the man who was arrested in the surveillance video.