Students participate in an interactive conversational exercise during one of Professor Rachel Cerdenio's non-credit English as a Second Language classes at Los Angeles Pierce College in Woodland Hills on May 8, 2025.
(
Jules Hotz
/
CalMatters
)
Topline:
At California's community colleges, more than 290,000 students take free, non-credit English as a Second Language classes. But as news of international student visa revocations and reports of Immigration and Customs Enforcement raids during President Donald Trump’s second term spread across the state, many community colleges have seen some of these students switch to online learning, or stop showing up to class altogether.
Fears of ICE on campus: California’s community colleges are public campuses, meaning they are limited by federal laws from attempting to prevent ICE agents from coming onto or near spaces that are generally considered open. An estimated 100,000 college students live in California without permanent legal status, and 3.3 million Californians live in mixed-status households, according to data from Equity Research Institute, a USC research group. Some of these students question whether coming to class is worth the risk of entering a public campus where ICE has access.
Enrollment numbers have dropped: Several anecdotes from professors and enrollment numbers from individual community colleges paint a similar picture: A heightened fear of ICE is driving students away. In the San Fernando Valley, one professor has lost about 15% of her enrollment this semester. In San Marcos, several classrooms abruptly transitioned from mostly in-person instruction to walls of Zoom squares.
They speak Farsi, Cantonese, Spanish and at least two dozen other languages. Some earned master's degrees in their home countries, while others never finished middle school. At California's community colleges, more than 290,000 students take free, non-credit English as a Second Language classes.
As immigrants, many of these students enroll in the classes to integrate into American life, advance in their jobs, support their children or build community. The classes have grown in popularity in recent years — an enrollment bright spot for the state’s community college system, which has struggled to fully rebound to pre-pandemic student counts.
But as news of international student visa revocations and reports of Immigration and Customs Enforcement raids during President Donald Trump’s second term spread across the state, many community colleges have seen some of these students switch to online learning, or stop showing up to class altogether.
So far there’s no statewide data on 2025 enrollment in non-credit ESL courses at California’s community colleges. But several anecdotes from professors and enrollment numbers from individual community colleges paint a similar picture: A heightened fear of ICE is driving students away. In the San Fernando Valley, one professor has lost about 15% of her enrollment this semester. In San Marcos, several classrooms abruptly transitioned from mostly in-person instruction to walls of Zoom squares.
As the semester goes on, ESL professors are offering “Know Your Rights” cards to students and informing their classes of the community college system’s pledge to not participate in federal immigration enforcement efforts. They’re also continuing to connect their students with campus resources such as food pantries and tutoring centers.
ESL classes have expanded post-pandemic
Los Angeles Pierce College began offering non-credit ESL in 2021, and last year the college hired a full-time professor to boost the program. Enrollment in the classes skyrocketed from about 50 in 2021 to more than 350 in 2024. Dennis Solares, the adult education coordinator at Los Angeles Pierce College, said that students seeking to improve their job opportunities drove the recent ESL enrollment growth.
“We offer an opportunity that can help them communicate more, get acclimated with the community and get better jobs,” Solares said.
The classes attract a diverse swath of students. Azucena Hernandez, 42, enrolled in ESL at Palomar College in San Marcos so that she could better support her three kids with day-to-day tasks. She started as a monolingual Spanish speaker, but after several semesters she can comfortably have conversations in English.
Hernandez now volunteers in the beginner levels of ESL as a peer instructor. She said her most important takeaway from these courses is “the family made at school.”
“Every day we are learning something new, and there is companionship,” Hernandez said. “We are united to learn.”
Students in one of Professor Rachel Cerdenio’s non-credit English as a Second Language classes at Los Angeles Pierce College in Woodland Hills on May 8, 2025. Photo by Jules Hotz for CalMatters
Hernandez’s professor, Sheri Cully, has taught ESL for more than 40 years. She prioritizes civic engagement and real-world learning in her classes. One long-term project that her students work on is maintaining a community garden and advocating for its affordability and accessibility at local government meetings. Cully said she admires her students’ work ethic and resilience.
There were 30,000 more students enrolled in non-credit ESL courses across California’s community colleges during the 2023-24 academic year compared to the 2018-19 academic year, according to state data. The growth has been driven by several factors, including heightened demand for workforce training as the state’s economy expands and the college system's push to expand ESL after the pandemic, according to a written statement to CalMatters from the California community college system’s chancellor’s office.
ESL courses bring state funding to community colleges based partially on enrollment, so several colleges have been working to continue this expansion after enrollment dropped during the pandemic. But student fears about immigration enforcement may thwart those efforts.
Fears of ICE entering schools
An estimated 100,000 college students live in California without permanent legal status, and 3.3 million Californians live in mixed-status households, according to data from Equity Research Institute, a USC research group. Some of these students question whether coming to class is worth the risk of entering a public campus where ICE has access, and they have opted to take courses virtually. But not all students have access to a computer or Wi-Fi at home, and some older students may not be comfortable with the technology required for college courses.
Jessica Buchsbaum, the ESL department chair at City College of San Francisco, oversees a program serving about 6,000 students, ranging from teenagers to octogenarians. She said the non-credit ESL enrollment was “growing intensely in the fall semester, but it has now softened.”
“We’ve definitely heard that students may be afraid to come to school,” Buchsbaum said. “In an environment when there’s so much hate directed at immigrants, we are here to serve this population. These are people who bring incredible energy and hope to our communities.”
On campus at Pierce College. (Photo courtesy of Pierce College/Facebook)
In January, the Trump administration threw out policies implemented in 2011 that limited the ability of ICE agents to arrest people at churches, schools and other areas designated as “sensitive locations.” A statement from the Department of Homeland Security said the change was necessary so “criminals will no longer be able to hide in America’s schools and churches to avoid arrest.”
California’s community colleges are public campuses, meaning they are limited by federal laws from attempting to prevent ICE agents from coming onto or near spaces that are generally considered open.
Over the years, the California community college system has supported immigrant students, such as offering Dream Resource Centers and connecting students with nonprofit legal services. The system has pointed college administrators to a 2017 state law that prohibits campus police departments from “generally providing personal information… about an individual for immigration enforcement purposes, including, but not limited to, the individual’s home address or work address, unless that information is available to the public.”
The chancellor’s office refused an interview request from CalMatters for this story. In a written statement, the office said, “The mission of the California Community Colleges is to educate and provide social and economic mobility to all Californians seeking to improve their workforce and workplace skills as well as improve their English language literacy.”
ESL professors provide support and students keep learning
Rachel Cerdenio is an ESL professor at Los Angeles Pierce College and the daughter of immigrants from the Philippines. She said the years she spent watching her parents struggle to navigate life in the United States without strong English skills spurred her to teach ESL.
Professor Rachel Cerdenio teaches a non-credit English as a Second Language class at Los Angeles Pierce College in Woodland Hills on May 8, 2025.
(
Jules Hotz
/
CalMatters
)
For Cerdenio’s intermediate courses, she created a curriculum focused on connection to the college and student success. She recently assigned students to visit a campus resource like the student health center or the library, ask questions about it and share the information with their classmates.
“I wish my parents had the experiences that I am giving my students now,” Cerdenio said. “I want them to succeed, and I want them to be part of the campus and know about the resources that are here.”
Solares has given presentations in adult education courses, including Cerdenio’s classes, about immigrant students’ rights and the resources available to students, regardless of their immigration status.
“We had a huge influx of students, but with the change in politics students are naturally scared, and so there's students who choose not to come to classes anymore,” Solares said. “The vibe is more tense. It’s more scary. But we support the students, and we equip the professors to support their students.”
Delilah Brumer is a fellow with the College Journalism Network, a collaboration between CalMatters and student journalists from across California. CalMatters higher education coverage is supported by a grant from the College Futures Foundation.
CA elected its most diverse group of lawmakers yet
By Nadia Lathan | CalMatters
Published November 20, 2026 9:00 AM
At center, Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra addresses the media during a news conference at the state Capitol in Sacramento on Nov. 5, 2026. Becerra is joined by Assembly Speaker Robert Rivas, left, and Senate President Pro Tem Monique Limón, at right.
(
Miguel Gutierrez Jr.
/
CalMatters
)
Topline:
From Congress to the governor’s office, this election was a year of many firsts. That includes the California statehouse where, for the first time, women will hold an equal number of seats as men. Black, Latino and LGBTQ members were also elected in record numbers.
Why it matters: At least 70 out of the 120 legislators, or 58%, will be people of color, up from a record 67 in 2025, according to the California State Library. While that is still behind the 68% Californians who are nonwhite, the Legislature did achieve gender parity for the first time with 60 women lawmakers. The gains are big wins for gender equity and racial, ethnic and sexual diversity in the chambers and signify a shift in the electoral power of minorities in California.
Record numbers: Currently, 59 women hold office in the Legislature, with 20 in the Senate and 39 in the Assembly. Next year’s class will add one more woman in the Assembly.
Read on... for more on group of California lawmakers.
From Alaska to Georgia, historic firsts abounded this November as newly-elected candidates for federal and state offices broke through racial and gender barriers nationwide.
California was no different: more women, Latino, Black and LGBTQ lawmakers are set to take office in January than at any other point in state history, and its top three leaders will all be of Latino descent.
At least 70 out of the 120 legislators, or 58%, will be people of color, up from a record 67 in 2025, according to the California State Library. While that is still behind the 68% Californians who are nonwhite, the Legislature did achieve gender parity for the first time with 60 women lawmakers. The gains are big wins for gender equity and racial, ethnic and sexual diversity in the chambers and signify a shift in the electoral power of minorities in California.
Women and Latinos make up the two biggest caucuses, giving them sway over the legislative agenda, USC political scientist Christian Grose said.
“On issues where the Latino Caucus might agree, the Latino Caucus is going to flex more power,” he said, adding that the same will hold true for women. “Certain issues are going to dominate the agenda in ways that 10 years ago, or even 20 years ago, especially, that wouldn’t be the case.”
The increases coincide with Democratic gains in California and across the country with the liberal party cultivating voters and candidates from diverse backgrounds. The incoming Democrats will boost the party’s supermajority in the Legislature next year to historic levels, which will likely be 100 out of 120 members.
Record numbers
Currently, 59 women hold office in the Legislature, with 20 in the Senate and 39 in the Assembly. Next year’s class will add one more woman in the Assembly.
Close the Gap California Executive Director Susannah Delano said this month’s election results surprised her. Close the Gap advocates for electing progressive women in state government. Nine of the candidates it recruited in California won their races.
More women and people of color were on the ballot than any ever, many of whom emphasized affordability, which contributed to their successes this year, Delano said.
“It really is the culmination of more than a decade of hard work and investment,” she said.
Six of the group’s 14 recruits this cycle flipped their seats in what amounted to a bloodbath for Republicans in the statehouse. GOP Assemblymembers Jeff Gonzalez and Leticia Castillo were among the casualties.
Latinos will make up 42 of all members, up from the 2025 record of 40, according to the state library. Black lawmakers will see their presence grow to 14 from 12 members. LGBTQ legislators will increase from 14 to 15 representatives.
These gains allow the majority party identity-based coalitions to exert more influence and accomplish their policy goals. For the Black delegation, that means continuing to push for criminal justice reform and, more controversially, cash reparations for slavery.
“It gives us more opportunities to build the alliances and coalitions that we need, and to send a message that the Black Caucus will never stop trying to deliver on reparations,” said Assemblymember Corey Jackson, a Democrat and incoming chair of the Legislative Black Caucus.
The big 3
The Latino Caucus is likely to benefit from the fact that the state’s top three leaders, Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra, Assembly Speaker Robert Rivas and Senate President Monique Limón, are all Hispanic.
And electoral wins for LGBTQ candidates outside of San Francisco, such as Annalisa Perea in the Central Valley and Clarissa Cervantes in the Inland Empire, hold symbolic meaning, Equality California spokesperson Jorge Reyes Salinas said.
The group, which backs LGTBQ candidates, spent at least $25,000 in independent expenditures to support Cervantes this election.
“It challenges the assumption that a candidate’s sexual orientation is a barrier to winning elected office in these communities,” he said.
Kyle Chrise
is the producer of Morning Edition. He’s created more than 20,000 hours of programming in his 25-plus-year career.
Published November 20, 2026 7:21 AM
Location of quake that struck in the early morning Friday.
(
Courtesy USGS
)
Topline:
An earthquake with a preliminary magnitude of 4.2 struck near Commerce overnight, rattling the region overnight but doing no major reported damage.
What we know: It happened shortly before 3:30 a.m. The epicenter was about a half-mile from Commerce, with people feeling it as far away as Lancaster and even Poway, about 115 miles away.
Keep reading... for more about this quake and how to get ready for the Big One.
An earthquake with a magnitude of 4.2 struck near Commerce, rattling the region overnight.
It happened shortly before 3:30 a.m.
The epicenter was about a half-mile from Commerce, with people feeling it as far away as Lancaster and even Poway, about 115 miles away. As of 7 a.m. Friday, nearly 13,000 people had reported feeling the shaking to the United States Geological Services (USGS).
Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass said there are no immediate reports of damage or impact to operations, including at LAX. The L.A. Fire Department also said there were no reports of major damage or injuries.
The Fire Department said residents should use the event as a reminder to prepare for the next quake.
The Southern California Seismic Network reports aftershocks may be expected, with the largest likely to be about 1 magnitude smaller that the initial quake. The network also said it appeared the fault that trigged the quake is probably the Lower Elysian Park fault.
No shake alert was issued.
At a news conference Friday morning at Caltech's Seismological Lab, Bob de Groot, a USGS scientist, said "the system operated exactly as designed."
"We posted to our, our X account, @usgs_shakealert, within a few minutes to let people know that the system was activated. But the threshold for this earthquake, the threshold for alert delivery to cell phones is magnitude 4.5, and the, the earthquake did not reach that threshold this morning."
The ShakeAlert system estimated this quake at less than magnitude 4.5. Alerts were *not* delivered to cell phones or other devices by our Alert Delivery Partners in California through cell phone operating systems and mobile apps.@USGS_Quakes
We don't want to scare you, but the Big One is coming. We don't know when, but we know it'll be at least 44 times stronger than Northridge and 11 times stronger than the Ridgecrest quakes in 2019. To help you get prepared, we've compiled a handy reading list:
Experience what the first hours after a massive earthquake could be like and get motivated to get ready.
Keep up with LAist.
If you're enjoying this article, you'll love our daily newsletter, The LA Report. Each weekday, catch up on the 5 most pressing stories to start your morning in 3 minutes or less.
A community college student looks through her class schedule for next semester on her laptop at a Panera Bread in Stockton on May 7, 2026.
(
Larry Valenzuela
/
CalMatters
)
Topline:
After CalMatters reported last week on the heavy course loads of some part-time faculty, California’s community college chancellor is reviewing whether online professors are providing a quality education to students.
Why now: CalMatters found that some professors were teaching more than a dozen online classes at a time at several California community colleges, California State University and University of California campuses. In some cases, they were earning well over $340,000. On Nov. 13, California Community Colleges Chancellor Sonya Christian sent an email to campus chief executives in response to the CalMatters story.
The backstory: The highest earner, ethnic studies professor, Thien-Huong Ninh Villarreal, made nearly $800,000 in 2024 by teaching at nine community college districts, Cal State Sacramento and UC Berkeley, according to a CalMatters analysis using public payroll records, university course listings and hiring documents. She has a similar course load this fall, encompassing about 1,100 students across 30 classes. Some faculty and college leaders say it’s impossible to provide students a quality education when a professor has such a large courseload. But technically, teaching multiple classes or holding multiple jobs, by itself, doesn’t prove anything about the quality of the instruction.
CalMatters found that some professors were teaching more than a dozen online classes at a time at several California community colleges, California State University and University of California campuses. In some cases, they were earning well over $340,000.
On Nov. 13, California Community Colleges Chancellor Sonya Christian sent an email to campus chief executives in response to the CalMatters story. “We should not characterize faculty as doing something inappropriate simply because they teach at more than one college,” she wrote. “At the same time, some of the practices described in the article are deeply troubling and warrant further scrutiny.”
Mac Powell, the president of the organization that accredits California’s community colleges, said he reached out to all the schools mentioned in the CalMatters story, asking about their compliance with those quality-education standards. “The issue of who teaches how much and when — that’s not what we’re most interested in,” he said. “We’re interested in the education that students get.”
The highest earner, ethnic studies professor Thien-Huong Ninh Villarreal, made nearly $800,000 in 2024 by teaching at nine community college districts, Cal State Sacramento and UC Berkeley, according to a CalMatters analysis using public payroll records, university course listings and hiring documents. She has a similar course load this fall, encompassing about 1,100 students across 30 classes.
Some faculty and college leaders say it’s impossible to provide students a quality education when a professor has such a large courseload. But technically, teaching multiple classes or holding multiple jobs, by itself, doesn’t prove anything about the quality of the instruction.
If online professors are not regularly interacting with their students in the ways the law and the accrediting body require, then schools — and ultimately students — could lose access to federal financial aid.
A ‘personal perspective’ from the state chancellor
It’s no secret that part-time faculty, or adjuncts, at California's colleges and universities often work multiple jobs. By law, part-time faculty in the community college system can teach only about three classes per district each semester. They are paid less than full-time faculty and have fewer, if any, benefits.
“I bring a personal perspective to this discussion,” wrote Christian. “When I first graduated, I taught at three California community colleges. I didn't own a car, so I rode the RTD bus from campus to campus to teach in person, piecing together assignments and barely making rent. I remember those days well. I understand firsthand why adjunct faculty teach at multiple institutions. For many, it is an economic necessity.”
Part-time faculty outnumber full-time faculty at every one of the state’s community college districts, sometimes by more than 5-to-1, but the total number of adjuncts statewide is unknown because professors who teach at multiple campuses are often counted repeatedly in the data.
In her email to college leaders, Christian acknowledged that there’s an “absence of a systematic way” to track faculty who teach at multiple campuses or across the community college, Cal State and UC systems. She said her team is looking into how college districts handle faculty with multiple jobs and what information about outside work faculty disclose. “The objective is to determine whether additional guidance, improved data sharing, or a common approach would strengthen institutional oversight.”
To find instructors who teach at multiple campuses, CalMatters used public payroll records gathered by Transparent California, a nonprofit organization advocating for limited government. CalMatters looked only at professors who taught at five or more community college districts, Cal State or UC campuses in 2024, the most recent data available.
Of the 72 professors who taught at five or more districts or universities, the median pay was about $190,000, though a few instructors made much more. CalMatters found 10 professors who made more than $343,000, which was the median salary of a community college president or chancellor in the same year. Most of the highest earners had full-time jobs along with numerous part-time gigs. Ninh Villarreal currently has at least two full-time tenured community college positions, along with other adjunct roles elsewhere.
Christian said these 72 professors are a "small group" compared with the tens of thousands of faculty employed by the state’s public higher education systems, and the highest earners "an even smaller one."
Are online professors interacting with students enough?
Because the federal and state governments dole out billions of dollars in financial aid to students, they regulate the kinds of courses and institutions where students can qualify for aid, and online courses in particular have undergone increased scrutiny in recent years.
The general rule that accreditors and state and federal lawmakers all share is that online professors need to interact with their students regularly. Research shows students are more likely to succeed when they interact with their professors.
Many online courses are asynchronous, meaning that the lectures are prerecorded and students can listen at any time. In these courses, and in many in-person ones, quizzes and tests are often graded automatically by computers.
Christian said that “prerecorded lectures, automated quizzes, and other instructional technologies” can be valuable in online classes, but professors must do more than that to meet the legal requirements. “Low-quality instruction is unacceptable, and we will not tolerate practices that compromise the education our students deserve.”
After the story was published here, online professors who taught at fewer than five districts or colleges shared their perspectives.
William Mead is a full-time lecturer in design and web development at UC Davis who also teaches part-time at two community college districts. He said his online courses are prerecorded but that doesn’t mean he is disengaged — quite the opposite. “My lectures take many hours to produce before a term begins,” he wrote in an email. “That front-loaded work is what frees me, during the semester, to focus on what matters most: individual feedback on student work and time with students. I hold a regular weekly office hour plus three additional appointment blocks each week (one morning, one afternoon, one evening) so that working students can meet with me on Zoom when it fits their lives.”
Jonathan Horn, who teaches one asynchronous online journalism course at San Diego Mesa College, said he writes his students “paragraphs and paragraphs of feedback on their assignments, sometimes worrying if it's too much.” He said it would be impossible to provide the same level of feedback for 30 or 50 classes.
Containers are transported by trains and trucks out of the Long Beach Container Terminal in the Port of Long Beach, Calif., April 8, 2025
(
Damian Dovarganes
/
Associated Press
)
Topline:
More than a dozen people were charged Thursday with allegedly orchestrating a massive train heist operation to steal over $22 million in cargo — from popular shoes to power tools — from major retailers.
The backstory: Trains that shuttle goods to stores and customers around the country have become a prominent target for large-scale theft in recent years, especially at large ports in the U.S. that receive hundreds of millions of dollars of shipments every day. The relatively low-tech robberies have demanded attention from the world’s largest retailers, including the likes of Amazon.
What's next: The 13 men were indicted for conspiracy and theft of interstate railroad cargo. Two were also charged with violence against railroad carriers. If convicted, the men could face anywhere from five to 20 years in federal prison.
More than a dozen people were charged Thursday with allegedly orchestrating a massive train heist operation to steal over $22 million in cargo — from popular shoes to power tools — from major retailers.
A federal indictment unsealed on Thursday paints a picture of an organized group that targeted more than three dozen trains carrying Nike sneakers, Crocs footwear, power tools and other consumer goods that were imported into the United States through Los Angeles and Long Beach, which are home to the busiest ports in the country.
Trains that shuttle goods to stores and customers around the country have become a prominent target for large-scale theft in recent years, especially at large ports in the U.S. that receive hundreds of millions of dollars of shipments every day. The relatively low-tech robberies have demanded attention from the world’s largest retailers, including the likes of Amazon.
The men would disable the trains at a planned location by busting the brakes, the indictment alleged, at which point the goods would be offloaded onto trucks. The goods were then peddled to an unnamed company that would resell the stolen merchandise for profit.
“The scale of the theft is staggering,” said First Assistant United States Attorney Bill Essayli, promising to prosecute any future efforts to steal the merchandise.
In group chats, the men shared numerous photos and videos of themselves busting into the hulking train cars, and posing with wads of cash and stolen merchandise. They also shared AI photos of themselves captioned “Los Trenes,” which means the trains in Spanish, beneath glamorized photos of men throwing boxes of shoes off trains into nearby cars while police helicopters descended overhead.
The 13 men were indicted for conspiracy and theft of interstate railroad cargo. Two were also charged with violence against railroad carriers.
If convicted, the men could face anywhere from five to 20 years in federal prison.