Sponsored message
Logged in as
Audience-funded nonprofit news
radio tower icon laist logo
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
Subscribe
  • Listen Now Playing Listen

The Brief

The most important stories for you to know today
  • There's been an epic effort to standardize design
    The Starbucks emblem on a green reusable cup.
    The Starbucks emblem on reusable coffee cup.

    Topline:

    Avoiding single-use plastic and creating a “waste-free future is a target being pursued by many American cities, and at the global level too. Disposable plastic foodware and packaging — which accounts for nearly 40% of all plastic production — can only be phased out if there are robust, efficient reuse systems to replace them. However, a web of logistical issues have hampered the effort to grow the presence of reusable containers.

    The ideal: A highly unusual level of coordination across company lines. At coffee shops, this would mean reusable mugs shared between Starbucks and Peets. For grocery stores, it could mean picking up a jar of olives at Safeway, dropping off the empty container at Walgreens, and then having the same jar refilled with jam and sold at Whole Foods. Achieving this would require companies to rethink the way they compete with each other and differentiate their products. It would also require big changes from consumers, who have been trained for 70 years to expect disposability in just about every aspect of daily life.

    Read more ... for a very deep dive into the facets of trying to build a reusable packaging system that could work for everyone ... in theory.

    For several months last year, patrons of a Seattle coffee shop called Tailwind Cafe had the option of ordering their Americanos and lattes in returnable metal to-go cups. Customers could simply borrow a cup from Tailwind, go on their way, and then at some point — perhaps a few hours later, perhaps on another day that week — return the cup to the shop, which would clean it and refill it for the next person. If it wasn’t returned within 14 days, the customer would be charged a $15 deposit, though even that was ultimately refundable if the cup was returned by the end of 45 days.

    This story was originally published by Grist. Sign up for Grist’s weekly newsletter here.

    Grist is a nonprofit, independent media organization dedicated to telling stories of climate solutions and a just future.

    Tailwind’s head chef, Kayla Tekautz, said her cafe started the program out of a desire to address the environmental scourge of disposable plastic foodware and other packaging, the vast majority of which cannot be recycled. It was a partnership with a reusable packaging and logistics company called Reusables.com, which provided Tailwind and another Seattle area store, Cloud City Coffee, with branded cups and a QR code-operated drop-off receptacle.

    But the cafe quickly ran into trouble. It was “overwhelming” to explain the return system to every interested customer, Tekautz said. Many were hesitant to participate after learning that they could only return the cups to Tailwind or the other drop-off location, 6 miles away. Plus, Tailwind’s QR code reader kept malfunctioning, requiring repeated visits from a mechanic. At the end of last summer, Tailwind quietly ended the return program. “It just didn’t work,” Tekautz said. (Reusables.com didn’t respond to Grist’s request for comment.)

    In an effort to reduce consumption of single-use plastic, Seattle has spent the past several years encouraging local businesses to offer reusable cups, dishes, utensils, and packaging. It has made some laudable progress. Concertgoers at the Paramount Theater and attendees of the Northwest Folklife Festival, for example, can now order their libations in reusable polypropylene cups. And since 2022, students at the University of Washington have been able to check out bright green reusable food containers from a company called Ozzi.

    Blue racks for reusable cups sit out on display. Attached to them is signage that reads "Return Cups Here."
    Reusable cups offered at the Northwest Folklife Festival in Seattle.
    (
    Courtesy Reuse Seattle
    )

    These programs are helping Seattle avoid single-use plastic and create a “waste-free future,” according to the city’s reuse website. It’s a target that’s being pursued by many American cities, and at the global level too. Disposable plastic foodware and packaging — which accounts for nearly 40 percent of all plastic production — can only be phased out if there are robust, efficient reuse systems to replace them.

    But some businesses, like Tailwind, have struggled to get reusable containers off the ground, often because of the small scale and disconnected nature of existing reuse programs. Instead of pooling resources and employing just one or two large cleaning and logistics services, businesses have so far chosen among several competing initiatives — or in some cases, have created and run their own programs. The result is a slew of incompatible containers, specific to just a few stores or locations, and inefficient systems for gathering, washing, and transporting between customers’ homes, sanitation facilities, and storefronts.

    Having so many companies creating their own designs and logistics can be expensive, causing them to miss out on economies of scale that could make reuse more affordable and easily adoptable. According to Ashima Sukhdev, a policy adviser for the city of Seattle, she should be able to “pick up a coffee from my local cafe, and then drop it off in the lobby of my office building. Or drop it off at the library, or at a bus stop.”

    What Sukhdev is describing would represent a highly unusual level of coordination across company lines. At coffee shops, this would mean reusable mugs shared not only between Tailwind and Cloud City, but also Starbucks and Peets. For grocery stores, it could mean picking up a jar of olives at Safeway, dropping off the empty container at Walgreens, and then having the same jar refilled with jam and sold at Whole Foods. Achieving this would require companies to rethink the way they compete with each other and differentiate their products. It would also require big changes from consumers, who have been trained for 70 years to expect disposability in just about every aspect of daily life.

    A group of four people with brown skin tone wearing black shirts stand around a "cup return" bin and smile at the camera.
    Pat Kaufman, right, with Reuse Seattle team members.
    (
    Courtesy Reuse Seattle
    )

    Experts say these changes are necessary. “For this solution to become a reality, you’re gonna need standards,” said Pat Kaufman, manager of Seattle Public Utilities’ composting, recycling, and reuse program.

    Kaufman is currently on a yearlong sabbatical working for a nonprofit called PR3, which is trying to create those standards. The questions they’re facing are: What will standardized reusable packaging systems look like — and what will it take to get companies, and consumers, to adopt them?

    Every year, the world produces about 400 million metric tons of plastic — almost entirely out of fossil fuels like oil and gas. Some of this is used in essential products like contact lenses and medical equipment, but a much greater fraction goes toward sporks, cups, bags, takeout containers, and other items that get thrown away after just a few minutes of use. Most of this plastic will never be recycled due to technical and economic restraints; more than 90 percent of all plastics get sent to a landfill or incinerator, or turn up as litter in the environment, where they degrade into microplastics and leach hazardous chemicals. Plastics manufacturing causes additional harms, including air pollution that disproportionately affects low-income communities and communities of color living nearby.

    For all of these reasons, public pressure to cut back on single-use plastics has escalated dramatically in recent years. Many companies have responded by launching trials and pilot programs allowing customers to borrow and return reusable cups, bottles, trays, jars, and other containers. These include small players like Ozzi, as well as behemoth brands like Walmart and Coca-Cola. There have been “more trials than Donald Trump,” said Stuart Chidley, co-founder of a reusable packaging company called Reposit.

    A grocery store display features shelves of returnable cylindrical containers.
    Returnable containers from Reposit are offered at Mark & Spencer grocery stores in the U.K.
    (
    Courtesy Reposit
    )

    As in Seattle, however, their efforts have been siloed, making it hard for the reuse sector to grow. According to a recent report from the Ellen MacArthur Foundation, or EMF — a nonprofit that advocates for a “circular economy” that conserves resources — even companies that have pledged to dramatically scale down their use of plastics have only replaced 2 percent or less of their single-use containers with reusables.

    “To realize the full benefits of return systems, a fundamentally new approach is required,” the authors concluded.

    The four types of reuse systems

    The Ellen MacArthur Foundation has identified four broad categories of reuse systems, based on who owns the containers and where they’re refilled or returned: refill on the go, refill at home, return on the go, return from home.

    Refill on the go: Consumers bring their own reusable containers to grocery stores and other locations, and refill them there — think the bulk section of a supermarket, where shoppers refill their own jars or bags with nuts, grains, and other foods.

    Refill at home: Consumers own their own reusable containers but instead of refilling them at a store, they order refills in the mail. For example, you order concentrated dish soap tablets and then dissolve them in a dispenser you already own.

    Return on the go: Businesses own containers and let consumers borrow them — often by charging a deposit that is refunded when the container is returned. This system involves container drop-off points at grocery stores, coffee shops, and other designated locations outside the home.

    Return from home: Businesses own the reusable containers, which logistics providers pick up from people’s homes and then transport to a washing facility so they can be used again — much like milkmen of old.

    The EMF report focuses on reusable containers that you can return to the coffee shop, grocery store, or another drop-off point — known as “return on the go” — as opposed to those that consumers own and bring with them to stores. It says that three things need to happen to make reuse mainstream. First, companies have to achieve high return rates, so they don’t lose inventory when people steal or forget to return their containers. Second, they have to share infrastructure for washing, collecting, sorting, and delivery in order to achieve economies of scale. Third, reusable containers must be standardized. The third pillar makes the other two much easier to achieve, since it’s simpler to share logistics, scale up, and familiarize customers with reuse systems if they share common characteristics — for instance, if containers are designed with similar shapes, sizes, and materials.

    To that end, PR3 has spent the past four years drafting standards for reuse systems, with a particular focus on container design. Through a “consensus body” composed of members from big business, the advocacy world, and government, PR3 is hoping to eventually certify the world’s first reuse standards under the International Organization for Standardization (known as ISO, to prevent confusion around different acronyms in different languages). This would lend legitimacy to the PR3 proposals, as the ISO maintains one of the world’s most widely accepted catalogs of standards. Others within its portfolio cover everything from food safety to the manufacturing of medical devices, and have been voluntarily adopted by many large companies and government bodies.

    PR3 released a draft of its standards last year, and it’s been updating them behind closed doors since then. Specific standards on washing protocols are set to be published for public review this week, and the nonprofit hopes that its consensus body will vote to finalize standards for container design later this year.

    At a large sink filled with sudsy water, a pair of gloved hands washes a mass of white cups.
    A worker from Taiwan’s Blue Ocean, an environmental protection company, cleans reusable mugs in Taoyuan.
    (
    Sam Yeh
    /
    AFP via Getty Images
    )

    So, what makes a good reusable container system? It’s complicated. Containers have to hold up under the stresses of logistics and transportation. They have to be relatively inexpensive. Perhaps most intangibly, they have to seem reusable, so customers don’t accidentally throw them in the trash. This can be accomplished through design elements — like containers’ color, texture, shape, and weight — or through other means, like easily recognizable drop-off boxes for used containers. Some reuse advocates support deposit fees, in which customers pay a small amount, usually just a dollar or two, in order to borrow a reusable container. They get the deposit back once they’ve returned the container.

    None of these features is guaranteed to work. In designing draft standards, PR3 has often had to make educated predictions about which ones consumers will respond to. And those predictions can have far-reaching implications. If you assume customers will frequently lose or forget to return their containers, for example, then it probably won’t make sense to design thick containers that are capable of withstanding hundreds of uses.

    “In the real world, return rates vary wildly,” Claudette Juska, PR3’s technical director and one of its co-founders, told Grist. “You don’t want to design a container for 400 uses if it’s only going to be used four times.” The most recent version of PR3’s standards say containers must be designed to withstand at least 20 uses and reused in practice at least 10 times.

    On the other hand, it may be counterproductive to design containers with the expectation that they won’t be returned. According to Chidley, with Reposit, cheap-looking and -feeling containers could actually cause low return rates, since people might be more careless with them. His philosophy is to use features like color, weight, and shape to communicate containers’ reusability, making it less plausible that people will confuse them for disposables.

    PR3 doesn’t have much specific advice on these characteristics, but some entrepreneurs Grist spoke with said they’ve hit higher return rates through particular design choices. For Chidley, this means making containers “beautiful” through high-quality, heavier materials with stylish branding. His containers are available at Marks & Spencer grocery stores across England and Scotland. Lindsey Hoell, founder of a reusable container logistics company called Dispatch Goods and a member of PR3’s standards panel, has forgone sharp-edged takeout food containers in favor of ones with smoother edges that “feel fancier.” And because so many single-use plastics are either black or white, her containers are bright red. “There’s a lot of soft science of what makes a consumer feel like something is durable,” she told Grist. Her containers are available across most of the U.S., mostly through grocery and meal delivery programs like Blue Apron and Imperfect Foods.

    To some extent, the discussion about expected use cycles and perceived quality is really just another way of asking what kinds of materials reusable containers should be made of: durable plastic or something else? Answering that question can bring into conflict businesses’ economic interests with concerns about health and the environment.

    In the published draft of its standards from last year, PR3 recommended that reusable containers be “plastic-free,” citing plastic additives’ wide-ranging impacts on human health and ecosystems. Plastic can be cheap, light, and durable, but plastic-related chemicals have been shown to build up in people’s bodies and the environment, where they may contribute to hormone disruption, cancer, and reproductive harm.

    PR3 panel members like Jane Muncke, chief scientific officer for the nonprofit Food Packaging Forum, supported the recommendation. “I don’t think plastics are suitable materials for reusable packaging,” she told Grist. She’s concerned about chemicals migrating into foods and beverages — especially hot, acidic, or fatty foods, which are better at soaking up some plastic additives. Durable plastics are also largely nonrecyclable; after being turned into new products a few times, they have to be thrown away or “downcycled” into lower-quality products like carpeting.

    Still, many entrepreneurs and even the PR3 founders themselves have moved away from a hard-line stance against plastics. Hoell, for example, originally got into reuse because she was frustrated by plastic-strewn beaches in California — “I’m a surfer and I hate plastics,” she told Grist. She started out making stainless steel containers but soon discovered that rigid plastics had much lower up-front costs, giving her more wiggle room to deal with lower return rates. She didn’t have to worry as much about frequently lost, stolen, or damaged containers.

    Plastic was also easier to transport because of its light weight, Hoell added, and she cited some analyses suggesting that it has a lower carbon footprint than alternatives like steel. (These findings are controversial, however; critics say it’s misleading to focus only on plastic-related carbon emissions and not the materials’ other dangers, like toxic chemicals leaching from landfills.)Dispatch Goods now only makes its containers out of polypropylene, a kind of plastic that’s generally considered more inert than others (although it can still leach hazardous chemicals). Other reuse logistics companies like R.world, which operates in Seattle and is also represented on the PR3 panel, have similarly opted for polypropylene containers instead of metal or glass.

    At Seattle Pacific University, a reusable container program for students eating at the Gwinn Commons dining hall also uses rigid plastic. The containers’ low cost allows Sodexo, the school’s foodservice provider, to charge students just $5 to participate in its reuse system all year, without tracking return rates or worrying too much about lost inventory. “We don’t have a list of subscribers,” said Andrew Chaplin, the dining team’s general manager. The program “runs itself.”

    Representatives from PR3 told Grist that plastic has been a hot topic of debate among consensus body members, and that the final version of the standards is likely to move away from the “plastic-free” recommendation. “The standards are going to address this with the understanding that if the world can move away from plastic, great, but in the meantime, before that’s feasible, we’d better move where we can,” said Amy Larkin, PR3’s co-founder and director, who pointed out that moving to reusable plastics will still make a huge dent in overall plastic demand. “Let’s get rid of 90 to 95 percent of the production of single-use packaging.”

    Rather than calling for specific container shapes and sizes, PR3 has drafted a few broad requirements — like that containers be designed to “optimize durability,” and that they follow “best practices for recyclability.” They must comply with existing food-safety regulations. Optionally, companies may label products with a universal symbol — kind of like the ubiquitous “chasing arrows” used to indicate recyclability. Such a symbol doesn’t yet exist for reuse, but PR3 has proposed one: a black, white, or orange rose-like pictogram along with the word “reuse.”

    More specific design elements are included only as recommendations. To make washing easier, for instance, PR3’s draft says reusable containers should have interior angles no smaller than 90 degrees, as well as “feet” to maximize airflow during drying. They also say containers should “nest” to save storage space and make transportation easier.

    A layered stack of small green plastic to-go containers sits on a shelf.
    A stack of reusable plastic to-go containers at a restaurant in Denver.
    (
    Hyoung Chang
    /
    The Denver Post via Getty Images
    )

    This flexible approach fits into a category that EMF calls “bespoke with shared standards,” where containers can vary from brand to brand while still sharing common characteristics — like where labels are placed, or the width of a bottle’s mouth. This leaves big brands free to design their own unique packaging if they want to.

    PR3’s approach aims to appease big businesses by allowing them to keep using containers that look and feel very different, so long as they conform to a set of broad requirements. “Product companies want that kind of autonomy,” Juska told Grist.

    Coca-Cola, for example, sets itself apart with its iconic — and patented — hourglass-shaped Coke bottle. And beauty companies are notorious for differentiated packaging: Walking down the perfume aisle, you might see bottles shaped like everything from a high-heeled shoe to a kitten.

    Many reuse advocates want to do away with those unique container designs, going even further than what PR3 has suggested in order to enable sharing among different companies — a situation where packaging is considered “pooled” within a market. So instead of an extravagant diversity of perfume bottles, all fragrances might come in interchangeable cylindrical jars.

    A small number of companies — especially in Europe — already do this. For example, through a German program called Mach Mehrweg Pool (roughly translated to “Make Reuse Pool”), brands share a collection of identical glass jars that can be filled with different foods. When consumers return the empty containers to a supermarket, a logistics provider picks them up and brings them back to food producers for cleaning. Another organization called the German Wells Cooperative runs a similar program for reusable soda and water bottles, counting more than 150 beverage makers as members.

    Other companies that have experimented with pooling, however, have only done so within the brands they control. Coca-Cola, for instance, has a “universal bottle” initiative in South America in which a single, standardized reusable bottle can be used for all of its beverage brands — Fanta, Sprite, Coke, and others. But the initiative is not universal across company lines; you couldn’t refill a Coke bottle with Pepsi.

    Tom Szaky, founder and CEO of Loop, a “global reuse platform” that is represented on the PR3 panel, said standard-setters shouldn’t try to resist companies’ impulses to differentiate. Brands should be allowed to experiment with both unique and standardized reusable packaging and then “let the market decide” which is preferable, he told Grist. He raised concerns that pooling might not make sense for some particular products — like baby food, since shared containers can increase the risk of contamination, and babies are more vulnerable to illness.

    There is already evidence, however, that companies are leaving money on the table by choosing not to pool their containers. According to EMF’s direct comparison of pooled and nonpooled standardized packaging, pooling containers reduces the cost of reusable packaging systems by up to 28 percent.

    Plus, at least some intervention — perhaps regulation or financial incentives — is likely required to create conditions that are more favorable to reusables; a hands-off, market-led approach is what has led to today’s proliferation of throwaway plastics. EMF’s modeling suggests that only reuse systems “built collaboratively from the outset” can reach cost parity with single-use. Exactly what that collaboration will look like, however, is unclear, since the kinds of government regulations that could help foster it might be incompatible with the United States’ free market ethos and antitrust laws. Internationally, some cities and countries have done more than the U.S. to promote reuse, but none has gone as far as what EMF is suggesting.

    Even in the absence of robust regulations, PR3’s standards are likely to nudge the country — and the world — in the right direction. Once they’re finalized, PR3 plans to submit them to the American National Standards Institute, the U.S. member organization of the ISO. From there, the standards would be opened up to public comment, potential revisions, and then final approval. PR3 would have to go through a separate submission and review process to get the standards approved by member countries of the ISO.

    What would happen next is unclear. Other ISO standards — like for information security and energy efficiency — have been voluntarily adopted by individual companies or industry groups, either because they contain genuinely useful guidance on a complicated issue or because they increase businesses’ perceived trustworthiness.

    ISO standards can also inform government regulations and international agreements. According to Juska, PR3 is already in talks with Canada’s environment ministry to shape new rules on reusable packaging, and the same thing could happen in any number of other jurisdictions. Juska is also hopeful that PR3’s standards will be acknowledged by or incorporated into the United Nations’ global treaty to end plastic pollution. The latest draft of the treaty mentions the need for standards — including for reusable packaging systems — some three dozen times, which Juska said is indicative of how “desperately needed” they are.

    “If we want everyone to move in the same direction, we need to set some design parameters for how we want the system to function,” she said.

    This article originally appeared in Grist at https://grist.org/business/what-will-it-take-to-get-companies-to-embrace-reusable-packaging/.

    Grist is a nonprofit, independent media organization dedicated to telling stories of climate solutions and a just future. Learn more at Grist.org

  • What happens to it once Nithya Raman is mayor?
    Nithya Raman, a woman with medium brown skin and long dark hair, with both arms raised in a wave at a podium, stands behind a yellow campaign sign reading “Nithya for LA Mayor,” against a dark blue-lit night sky.
    Los Angeles mayoral candidate Nithya Raman speaks during an election night watch party at the Greek Theatre plaza in Los Angeles, on Nov. 3, 2026.

    Topline:

    The city of Los Angeles now knows who its next mayor will be. But for residents of District 4, that means their City Council representative is a giant question mark.

    Why now: Nithya Raman will be sworn in Dec. 14 after unseating incumbent Karen Bass. But Raman’s current term as city councilmember runs through December 2028. Raman’s move to the mayor’s office means her constituents in Council District 4, which stretches from the San Fernando Valley to Griffith Park, could temporarily be without a City Council representative.

    The big picture: Raman’s mayoral win could open up an opportunity for someone to join the powerful city council while bypassing the typical election process.

    Read on ... for more details about when a decision might be made, and what the City Council's options are for replacing Raman at the table.

    The city of Los Angeles now knows who its next mayor will be. But for residents of District 4, that means their City Council representative is a giant question mark.

    Nithya Raman will take office Dec. 14 after unseating incumbent Karen Bass. But Raman’s current term as city councilmember runs through December 2028. Raman’s move to the mayor’s office means her constituents in Council District 4, which stretches from the San Fernando Valley to Griffith Park, could temporarily be without a City Council representative.

    Raman’s mayoral win could open up an opportunity for someone to join the powerful City Council while bypassing the typical election process.

    What's on the agenda for next term?

    Whoever gets the seat will join the council during a pivotal time for the city: the lead-up to and through the 2028 Olympics. (Wondering who that person might be? So is everyone else in L.A.’s power circles. LA Material interviewed around two dozen City Hall staffers, potential candidates, and others for a look at who might want the job.)

    The new city councilmember will also weigh in on major topics, such as housing, homelessness and the city’s budget priorities, and will influence local services and development in the district’s neighborhoods, such as Los Feliz, Encino and Studio City.

    What are the options for filling the seat?

    According to the city charter, the City Council has three options for filling the vacant seat:

    • It can appoint someone to the position for the rest of Raman’s term until the next second Monday in December of an even-numbered year.
    • It can call a special election to fill the position for the rest of the term. 
    • It can do a combination of both options, and appoint someone to temporarily fill the role until the special election occurs.

    When will we know more?

    But details are currently sparse on when the City Council will decide which path to take, and on when any appointment or special election might take place.

    “Because the election is not yet certified, the process and timeline are not yet finalized,” Josué Marcus, a public information officer for the Los Angeles City Clerk’s office, wrote in an email to LAist.

    City Council President Marqueece Harris-Dawson’s office also offered little indication of which option the council might choose.

    In an email, Martin Schlageter, senior advisor to Harris-Dawson, wrote: “The Council President remains committed to working with the appropriate stakeholders and Council to review all available options under Charter Section 409. The main goal is to address the impending lack of representation for CD4 residents.”

    Harris-Dawson told the Los Angeles Times this week that the council won’t decide on how to fill Raman’s vacancy until next year.

    In an email, Stella Stahl, Raman’s director of communications, said the Chief Legislative Analyst has briefed Council District 4 staff on potential next steps, and those options have been shared with Raman.

    “The Mayor Elect recognizes the importance of this decision for the district and believes Council District 4 residents deserve effective representation and continuity of services. She looks forward to a thoughtful process that puts their interests first,” Stahl added.

    Raman was first elected to L.A.’s City Council in 2020, when she defeated incumbent David Ryu. She was reelected to a second four-year term in 2024.

    How to attend an LA City Council meeting

    • The City Council generally meets at 10 a.m. on Tuesdays, Wednesdays and Fridays.
    • Meetings take place in the John Ferraro Council Chambers, Room 340, at Los Angeles City Hall located at 200 N. Spring St., in Los Angeles
    • You can keep up with agenda, upcoming meetings, and past meetings here.
    • Meetings are broadcast live on Cable Television Channel 35, online here, and on YouTube.
    • You can find information about offering up public comment in person, in writing or via teleconference here.
  • Sponsored message
  • Key dates approaching for Eaton Fire survivors
    Three signs are affixed to a fence: "Altadena: Our town has soul"; "Altadena not for sale!"; and "Black Homes Matter." In the background is a small trailer.
    A trailer where Eaton Fire survivors live in Altadena.

    Topline:

    The window is closing for survivors of the Eaton Fire to apply for direct compensation through Southern California Edison. The deadline is Nov. 30.

    Why it matters: Nearly two years since that fire killed 19 people and destroyed more than 9,400 homes and businesses, many survivors remain stuck in the fog of trauma, in battles with their insurance companies or overwhelmed by the day-to-day struggle of rebuilding their lives. They’re also weighing whether to accept the Edison payouts or hold out for a lawsuit.

    Read on ... to learn what experts say and what more than two dozen survivors are considering.

    The window is closing for survivors of the Eaton Fire to apply for direct compensation through Southern California Edison. The deadline is Nov. 30.

    Nearly two years since that fire killed 19 people and destroyed more than 9,400 homes and businesses, many survivors remain stuck in the fog of trauma, in battles with their insurance companies or overwhelmed by the day-to-day struggle of rebuilding their lives.

    They’re also weighing whether to accept the Edison payouts or hold out for a lawsuit.

    “The community is in a state of fatigue at a time where they can't afford to be,” said Elise Preston Mallory, a longtime Altadena volunteer, member of the Pasadena NAACP and community liaison for United Policyholders.

    Legal and community experts LAist spoke with emphasized that the decision is deeply personal and unique to each circumstance, but that survivors can no longer wait to take action as it takes time to retain a lawyer for a lawsuit, as well as put together paperwork for the Edison direct compensation program.

    “You can be doing both things in parallel until you get an offer that you have decided to accept,” said Amanda Riddle, a court-appointed liaison counsel for the Eaton Fire lawsuits.

    Edison faces thousands of lawsuits, with the first of three bellwether trials set to begin March 8. Lawyers representing Eaton Fire survivors say they expect each trial to take up to eight weeks. If Edison doesn't appeal the verdicts, they expect the rest of the cases to be settled relatively quickly, with the goal being under two years.

    Upcoming deadlines for Eaton Fire survivors

    • Nov. 30, 2026: Deadline to apply for SoCal Edison’s Wildfire Recovery Compensation Program.
    • Jan. 7, 2027: Deadline to file a lawsuit against Edison for claims involving wrongful death, personal injury and emotional distress.
    • Jan. 7, 2028: Deadline  to file a lawsuit for claims solely involving property damage.

    Survivors can apply for the SoCal Edison direct compensation program and file a lawsuit at the same time. If you do both, you’ll have to have your lawyer also do the paperwork for Edison’s program. Edison says it will add an additional 20% of net damages to offers submitted through an attorney. If you accept the offer from Edison, you’ll have to drop your lawsuit and waive your right to sue over damages related to the Eaton Fire. 

    Regarding the expected timing of lawsuits, you can hear directly from court-appointed liaison counsels for Eaton Fire cases Jerry Singleton and Amanda Riddle at this recent webinar hosted by Every Fire Survivors Network.

    Taxes and public assistance

    Legal experts said it’s important to look closely at any attorney retainer agreement and speak with a tax adviser about how the state may tax these payments in your specific situation.

    Settlements through Edison’s programs or lawsuits will be largely exempt from federal taxes, thanks to a new law. At the state level, another new law does something similar.

    Experts also emphasized that if someone in your household receives public assistance, it’s important to discuss with Social Security, a benefits administrator or an attorney how any settlement payment may affect eligibility for those services.

    Resources for legal help

    The following organizations have offered free legal consultations or information for fire survivors.

    Bet Tzedek Legal Services

    Public Counsel

    Neighborhood Legal Services of L.A. County

    Legal Aid Foundation of L.A. 

    L.A. Fire Justice

    United Policyholders is hosting an assistance clinic on Nov. 19 to help survivors gather the paperwork they need for the Edison direct pay program, insurance and other aspects of recovery.

    Experiences with the Edison program

    LAist heard from more than two dozen fire survivors weighing the decision between a lawsuit and Edison’s direct compensation program.

    Some rejected the Edison offer, saying it was far too low and didn’t sufficiently compensate for emotional distress, including a homeowner with smoke and ash damage and a renter who had to relocate.

    Others accepted, often with mixed feelings, including a homeowner with a total loss who found the offer would be just enough to bridge the gap between what they have and what they need to get back home as soon as possible.

    Multiple survivors LAist spoke with worry that permitting, construction delays and rising building costs may mean they still end up in a financial hole.

    Survivors LAist spoke with also expressed frustration that the Edison offer deducts the full insurance policy limit, not what a household has actually received.

    “The Fast Pay offers are a little formulaic,” said Lloyd Dixon, director of the Feinberg Center for Catastrophic Risk Management and Compensation at RAND and co-author of a recently published review of Edison’s Wildfire Recovery Compensation Program so far. “Some people are going to end up doing well just by luck of the draw.”

    Though Dixon cautioned that RAND’s analysis has limits, the report identified some commonalities between survivors who accepted offers, including:

    • Households who need the money now for living expenses and cannot wait until claims are resolved through traditional litigation
    • Residents who are older or in poor health
    • Residents who worry litigation would be too stressful
    • Residents in a situation where the Edison compensation protocol happens to generate a more favorable offer than they may expect through other avenues. That may include people without significant noneconomic damages, or those who were severely underinsured compared to the value of their property.
    • Residents who do not have disputes with their insurers over certain coverage. For example, a total loss for which insurers have agreed to pay policy limits.
    An aerial view of properties cleared of fire debris that burned in the Eaton Fire seen on July 7, 2025 in Altadena.
    (
    Mario Tama
    /
    Getty Images
    )

    Many say process is lengthy

    Most survivors LAist spoke with said the Edison compensation process took months longer than they expected. They also found it convoluted, with repeated asks for paperwork and other holdups, adding frustration to an already difficult recovery.

    One of the most common reasons for delay relates to a state law that requires the court to approve settlements involving minors, called the “minor’s compromise.”

    Others described to LAist an exasperating back-and-forth with the third-party contractors answering the phones.

    “We take all that feedback seriously,” said Edison spokesperson Joel Kennedy when LAist described these issues. Kennedy emphasized that, per the utility’s surveys of participants, 82% “have reported a favorable opinion of the program.”

    Kennedy said the utility has, on average, sent offers 36 days “after a claim is considered substantially complete.”

    One lawyer representing dozens of clients in the program said the detailed review on average took four to six months, and up to nine months when minors were involved.

    Still, legal experts told LAist the process is likely to be shorter than litigation.

    “The compensation program is still quite likely to pay people earlier,” said Nicholas Lampros, an attorney with Bet Tzedek Legal Services. “We don't know exactly how much faster.”

    An electrical tower is seen on a barren hillside
    The electrical towers above Eaton Canyon in Altadena, where the LA wildfire known as the Eaton Fire originally started. Feb. 8, 2025.
    (
    Jules Hotz
    /
    CalMatters
    )

    How ‘fair’ are the Edison offers?

    Jerry Singleton, a court-appointed liaison for the Eaton Fire lawsuits and an attorney who has settled past California wildfire cases, said at a recent webinar hosted by local grassroots group Every Fire Survivors Network that he has about three dozen clients who have chosen to go with the Edison compensation program.

    He estimates the payments to those clients were 30 to 50 cents on the dollar, compared to what they may be able to get through litigation. Edison maintains that its goal is “to offer compensation in line with settlement values for similar claims in past wildfire lawsuits, with a more streamlined and faster approach than litigation.”

    It’s difficult to truly compare since such settlements are confidential, said Dixon, the RAND researcher.

    “We don't have data on what the actual settlements look like from other litigation of other fires, so it's really hard for us to assess whether there really is a gap or not,” he said.

    The SoCal Edison Wildfire Recovery Compensation Program by the numbers, so far

    SoCal Edison so far has paid out about $680 million through its direct pay program, according to Joel Kennedy, a spokesperson for the utility. Nearly 6,000 claims have been submitted, 42% through an attorney, and more than 3,400 offers extended, totaling more than $1.1 billion. 

    On average, homeowners with a total loss have been offered $890,000 through the program, and have received $1 million through their insurance. 

    The highest total paid out to a homeowner so far is $6 million. That household was a total loss with no insurance, Kennedy said. 

    The lowest payment for a tenant with smoke and ash damage so far is $15,000

    The average payment for a tenant with smoke and ash damage is $60,000.

    The utility says it takes about two hours on average to submit a claim and 80% of offers so far have been accepted. 

    Edison will host a final virtual community meeting about the program on Thurs., Nov. 19 at 6 pm. You can sign up to attend here. 

    You can submit a claim online or call 888-912-8528 for assistance. Find answers to Frequently Asked Questions here.

    The ‘minor’s compromise’ 

    Casty Fortich had been attending meetings held by law firms for months before he decided to apply for, and later accept, the direct compensation offer from Southern California Edison.

    Fortich, his wife, Tracey, and their two daughters, now 15 and 20, lost their Altadena home of more than two decades in the Eaton Fire. While Fortich doesn’t think the offer reflects the trauma of their evacuation and grief of their loss, he was far enough along in his rebuild process to have a good idea of the costs, and the Edison offer turned out to be what he needed to bridge the gap between what his insurance paid out and what he needs to rebuild. His insurance covered about two-thirds of his expected rebuild costs. About three months ago the family received their offer and decided to accept, given the uncertainty of timing with the lawsuits, he said.

    “To be able to continue with my rebuild and know that I have the funds to cover the construction costs, it allows me to sleep at night,” Fortich said.

    But the process to receive that money has taken far longer than expected. They applied about a month after the program launched at the end of October 2025. They’re still waiting to receive the offer they accepted because of a state law that requires any settlement involving a minor to be approved by the court, called the “minor’s compromise.”

    Despite using an attorney to go through the process, they faced hurdles to get a court date. The process to find a bank that would receive such a settlement was also complicated and frustrating.

    “It’s a daunting process,” said Tracey Fortich, Casty Fortich’s spouse. “I hate to think there’s someone out there not getting the funds they need because it’s so hard to navigate this process.”

    The Fortiches are not alone. Lawyers representing people who accepted Edison offers said on average it’s taken one to three months to get through the minor’s compromise process.

    If all goes to plan, the Fortiches should receive their money before the end of the year.

    Meanwhile, Casty Fortich expressed frustration with the struggle survivors continue to face while Edison executives make millions.

    For him, the choice to accept was purely practical.

    “The main factor in that decision,” he said, “is do we have the funds to rebuild?”

    A partially built wooden structure stands among empty dirt lots. A few trees are peppered between the property lines.
    A house under construction in Altadena, CA on Friday, June 20, 2025.
    (
    Myung J. Chun
    /
    Los Angeles Times via Getty Images
    )

    Weighing litigation 

    For Alphonso Browne, who was dropped from his insurance just months before the Eaton Fire, the Edison compensation program has only recently become more appealing. He and his wife suffered a total loss and are living in a trailer on their lot in Altadena.

    Browne said he’s become fed up with lawyers asking for 25% to 30% of a potential settlement through litigation. The nonprofits connecting people to financial support, he said, have been “a disappointment” too.

    “I've been hearing from many others who say, ‘Oh, my lawyer says don't take the settlement,’” Browne said. “I say, ‘Yeah, they're going to tell you that because the more money they could get from Edison means the more money for them in their pocket.'"

    Meanwhile, unexpected costs have piled up — he recently had to pay a fee of more than $2,000 to connect his trailer to electricity on his lot, for example.

    After hearing from others who were happy with their offers from Edison, he decided to take the leap this month and begin the application.

    “I'm optimistic,” Browne said. “We’re holding up the best that we can. It’s all we can do.”

    An older man with dark skin tone in profile. He has long dreadlocks and stands in a mostly dirt lot.
    Alphonso Browne looks at the remains of his home, which burned in the Eaton Fire.
    (
    Erin Stone
    /
    LAist
    )

    For some older residents, Edison program made sense

    Diann and Mike Danneker moved to Altadena in 1977, where they raised their kids. Their home of decades burned in the Eaton Fire. But they had good insurance through USAA. They expect it will cover their rebuild.

    Because of their age — Diann is 78; Mike is 82 — they wanted to get home as quickly as possible.

    “I was feeling that at our age, if we go with attorneys, cases tend to go on forever, and so we'll be very, very old by the time this case is settled,” Mike Danneker said.

    With a mortgage still to pay, they hope the Edison funds will assist with unexpected costs they’re facing as part of their rebuild — like building a retaining wall. Still, it’s taken nearly a year to finish the process after back-and-forth on documents and a delay caused by the minor’s compromise for their daughter’s child. Nearly a year after applying, they have yet to receive their payment.

    “We’re just kind of waiting,” Diann Danneker said.

    Still, the Dannekers said, they’re grateful to be alive and designing a home they love. They expect to move back in the spring or summer.

    Construction workers stand on the roof of a home being rebuilt in Altadena.
    Construction workers stand on the roof of a home being rebuilt in Altadena.
    (
    David Wagner/LAist
    )

    Their experience was similar to that of Tommy McMullins and his wife, Gwendolyn, both in their early 80s. They moved from Georgia to California in 1968, and bought a house in Altadena in the mid-1970s. It burned in the Eaton Fire. When they heard about the Edison direct pay program, they applied soon after it launched.

    “We decided that rather than wait for the attorney lawsuit to go through, we would actually check out Edison and find out what they could offer us,” Tommy McMullins said. They ended up going through the detailed review process with an attorney after receiving the first offer.

    They’re still deciding whether to accept it, but Tommy McMullins said they’re likely to. They’re waiting on quotes from contractors first.

    Unlike others LAist spoke with, the process was fairly quick for them, Tommy McMullins said. They received an initial offer well within 90 days. The detailed review process then took a bit longer.

    The reaction to the final offer?

    “Relatively fair,” Tommy McMullins said. “How can you measure it, what's fair, what's unfair? But  it was sufficient to cover our basic needs.”

  • How typical hospice fraud works in SoCal
    A federal indictment document lists charges including health care fraud and identity theft against three defendants in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California.
    Charging documents in one prosecution that went in front of a grand jury earlier this year. Prosecutors allege the lead defendant used federal funds to put a downpayment on lease-to-own Rolls Royce Phantom.

    Topline:

    Billing fraud involving hospice agencies is on the rise in recent years, particularly in Southern California, which has been one of the epicenters for fraudsters. Bad actors use all sorts of methods.

    What we know: In many schemes, recruiters approach older adults at shopping centers or at their homes, offering cash, gift cards or free supplies in exchange for their Medicare ID numbers, according to prosecutors and advocates. Others rely on phishing tactics.

    Keep reading... for a look at some recent cases and for more on a series on hospice fraud in L.A. County.

    Read the full series

    Monday

    LAist findings: In LA County, hospice fraud warning signs persist despite state and federal crackdowns, records show

    Coming soon:

    • Tuesday: New California hospice rules target fraud. Will they fix LA County’s problems?
    • Wednesday: How to find good hospice care in LA County and avoid Medicare fraud

    Billing fraud involving hospice agencies is on the rise in recent years, particularly in Southern California, which has been an epicenter for fraudsters. Bad actors use all sorts of methods.

    In many schemes, recruiters approach older adults at shopping centers or at their homes, offering cash, gift cards or free supplies in exchange for their Medicare ID numbers, according to prosecutors and advocates. Others rely on phishing tactics.

    “It can happen through misleading paperwork. It can happen through aggressive marketing tactics,” said Catherina Isidro, statewide director for Senior Medicare Patrol. “It could also be somebody saying, “Hey, I'm calling from your insurance provider.”’

    Senior Medicare Patrol helps Medicare beneficiaries identify, report and recover from fraud. The federally funded program staffs a hotline, investigates complaints and works with federal authorities to pursue cases against scammers. Isidro said older adults targeted in fraudulent schemes have often signed forms they don’t understand and end up enrolled in end-of-life care they don't need.

    How to reach me

    I'm interested in hearing from people who have worked in the hospice industry. If you have a tip, you can reach me on Signal. My username is aschrank.80

    Hospice fraud in LA County

    According to one federal indictment, alleged fraudsters from an Artesia hospice approached a married couple at a market about signing up for hospice, later paid them $600 in cash monthly in exchange and sent them items they didn’t need like protein drinks, vitamins and wheelchairs.

    The indictment alleges the hospice agency paid kickbacks to marketers for the referrals and also discharged about 85% of its patients alive — nearly five times the national average. The hospice’s operator was indicted in April, pleaded not guilty and is awaiting trial.

    In June, federal prosecutors charged a Los Angeles man who allegedly owned and operated four Southern California hospices, along with two other people, in a $27.7 million Medicare fraud and kickback scheme. According to the federal indictment, he sometimes paid marketers about $700 a month for each living patient they referred, for as long as the patient was billed to Medicare. He also allegedly paid at least $1,000 to $3,000 for each person he enrolled in hospice after the person had died. Those payments included one to a funeral home employee.

    The indictment alleges he enrolled people after they had died and falsely claimed to have provided hospice care before their deaths. That made it appear the hospices were caring for dying patients and masked a high rate of patients discharged alive. The hospice owner pleaded not guilty, with a trial set for June 2027, according to federal court records.

    In another case, a Glendale woman — who had been barred from Medicare after earlier convictions for taking illegal payments for patient referrals — bought two hospices through her daughter and husband to hide her ownership, a federal jury found. The jury convicted her of health care fraud and paying kickbacks for patient referrals, and she was sentenced last year to nine years in prison. Prosecutors said the hospices billed Medicare about $10.6 million for patients who weren’t dying.

    The cases keep coming. In October, federal prosecutors charged three more people in L.A.-area hospice fraud schemes. False billing to Medicare in that case totals more than $40 million, according to charging documents.

    Those charged include a Torrance doctor who has agreed to plead guilty, in a plea agreement filed in court, to falsely signing papers saying patients were terminally ill. Medicare covers hospice only when a doctor certifies a patient has six months or less to live, and prosecutors say the doctor knew hospices would bill Medicare based on those certifications.

    How to avoid getting caught in Medicare fraud

    Avoiding Medicare fraud comes down to keeping your personal information secure, knowing your rights and monitoring your monthly benefits statements. California Senior Medicare Patrol, a federally-funded program focused on Medicare fraud, recommends taking specific steps to protect yourself and your family members.

    Call the hotline

    The California Senior Medicare Patrol urges anyone who believes they’ve been scammed to call: 855-613-7080

    Quick tips

    • Never share your Medicare number in an unsolicited text, email or phone call
    • Never accept a gift or bribe in exchange for your Medicare number

    Coming soon: More detailed advice on tips to avoid hospice fraud, along with help on vetting legitimate service providers and guidance on where to report fraud.

  • U.S. lost measles elimination status

    Topline:

    The U.S. has lost its status as a country where measles is eliminated, a public health triumph secured a quarter century ago.

    Why it matters: In public health parlance, measles elimination depends on a country's sporadic outbreaks ending within a year. That's no longer happening in the United States — even though measles outbreaks are entirely preventable:

    Why now: In the past two years, over 830 people have been hospitalized with measles in the U.S. More than 8,000 people have been sickened in outbreaks that have cost roughly $125 million in medical care, public health response and productivity losses, Johns Hopkins University researchers estimate.

    The U.S. has lost its status as a country where measles is eliminated, a public health triumph secured a quarter century ago.

    Researchers with direct knowledge of the deliberations on the country's status told KFF Health News that the Pan American Health Organization reached the conclusion this week: Measles has reestablished regular transmission in the country.

    PAHO had planned a public announcement on Nov. 17.

    In public health parlance, measles elimination depends on a country's sporadic outbreaks ending within a year. That's no longer happening in the United States.

    "It's a very sad moment," said Anne Schuchat, an epidemiologist and a former deputy director at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention who was not involved in PAHO's decision.

    "Measles causes so much unnecessary suffering, everything from a high fever and missed work and school to long-term complications like progressive degenerative nerve disease and death," Schuchat said.

    Measles outbreaks are entirely preventable: Two doses of the measles-mumps-rubella vaccine prevent about 97% of infections, so when almost everyone in a community is fully vaccinated, the virus can't spread.

    In the past two years, over 830 people have been hospitalized with measles in the U.S. More than 8,000 people have been sickened in outbreaks that have cost roughly $125 million in medical care, public health response and productivity losses, Johns Hopkins University researchers estimate.

    States have reported 13 measles-associated deaths, including a 7-month-old in New York and infants in Pennsylvania and Wisconsin in recent months. Babies typically aren't vaccinated before they're a year old.

    PAHO, an international group that oversees health in the Americas and works with the World Health Organization, based its assessment on two analyses: one by the CDC and another by an independent group of measles experts.

    Researchers anticipated this conclusion after an outbreak in Utah surpassed the one-year mark in June.

    A spokesperson for the Department of Health and Human Services, Emily Hilliard, attributed the resurgence of measles to vaccination gaps that opened years before this administration. Indeed, rates of childhood vaccination have steadily declined since the COVID pandemic started.

    But many scientists also blame the Trump administration for spreading vaccine misinformation and stifling a swift, strong response to outbreaks.

    For example, the administration cut millions of dollars from children's immunization programs run by state health departments and terminated funds for research on vaccine hesitancy.

    After Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. sacked CDC director Susan Monarez in August 2025, she told Congress she was fired because she would not preapprove changes to vaccine recommendations "without reviewing the evidence."

    Monarez added that "we already have seen the largest measles outbreak in more than 30 years" and that, "if vaccine protections are weakened, preventable diseases will return."

    Spokespeople for HHS and the White House defended the administration, and Kennedy, who led a prominent anti-vaccine organization before he took the helm at HHS. "The President and the Secretary have repeatedly encouraged measles vaccination, coordinated with states, and facilitated the deployment of vaccine doses across the country," White House spokesperson Allison Schuster wrote in an email.

    Past administrations sounded alarms

    For more than three decades, the federal government treated measles as a preventable tragedy, with sizable outbreaks triggering national efforts to boost vaccination and stop the virus from spreading.

    That's no longer the case, said Patsy Stinchfield, executive director of the Measles Collaborative, a new initiative that educates the public about vaccines and assists health workers responding to outbreaks.

    Stinchfield was a pediatric nurse at a children's hospital in Minnesota during the nation's last surge of measles before elimination, from 1989 to 1991. She recalled an entire ward devoted to children with measles and the enormous effort required to prevent the virus from spreading to kids with cancer and weakened immune systems.

    Two children at the hospital died of measles. "That changed my career forever," she said.

    Back then, she said, the federal government "saw the urgency." Officials held press conferences, spoke on the news about vaccines, issued clinical guidelines, and published reports in the CDC's flagship journal — the Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, or MMWR — that drove policies.

    When data suggested that some children weren't mounting a strong response to a single dose of the measles-mumps-rubella vaccine, a CDC advisory committee recommended two doses of the shot.

    When CDC analyses found that many children with measles hadn't been vaccinated due to cost, the government launched the Vaccines for Children program to make immunizations available free of charge to underinsured families.

    Cases plummeted. By 2000, the CDC and PAHO determined that measles was no longer a national threat — measles transmission had been eliminated.

    "Elimination" allows for occasional outbreaks, because measles is not eradicated worldwide and a small fraction of people, such as young infants, can't be protected by vaccines.

    People infected abroad sparked occasional outbreaks after U.S. elimination, but — until now — those fizzled out because of herd immunity, when 95% of people within a community are immunized. In those situations, outbreaks peter out and vulnerable people are protected.

    It would be 14 years before another significant outbreak in the U.S. Then in 2015, the virus took off among unvaccinated children at Disney parks in California, giving rise to outbreaks elsewhere. Congress saw some 125 cases as an emergency and summoned the CDC's Schuchat to testify on the situation.

    "Vaccination wasn't a partisan issue," she recalled. "This was about problem-solving: What can we do about this?"

    National television aired a video of then-U.S. Surgeon General Vivek Murthy talking with Sesame Street's Elmo about vaccination. HHS officials worked with vaccine experts on strategies to boost public confidence in vaccines. California and Vermont tightened vaccine requirements.

    In 2019, House and Senate committees met again about measles, as a large outbreak took hold in Orthodox Jewish communities in New York and New Jersey took hold. Congress asked HHS leaders how the administration planned to curb the rise of vaccine misinformation online.

    "Internet fraudsters who claim that vaccines are not safe are preying on the unfounded fears and daily struggles of parents, and they are creating a public health hazard that is entirely preventable," Lamar Alexander, then a Republican senator from Tennessee, said at the time.

    Alex Azar, health secretary during the first Trump administration, and then-CDC Director Robert Redfield held a press conference stressing the "importance of on-time vaccination."

    And during the 2014, 2015, and 2019 outbreaks, the CDC's MMWR published detailed articles within weeks of data collection. Timing matters since the reports guide emergency response. "The MMWR is the voice of the CDC," Schuchat said, "alerting the nation, the media, clinicians, and public health experts to events that require action."

    'The dog didn't bark'

    Just after President Donald Trump took office in 2025, a measles outbreak exploded in West Texas. Within seven months, it surpassed the size of any in the U.S. since 1992, spread to Mexico and at least three other states, sickened more than 4,500 people in the two countries, and killed at least 16.

    Instead of broadcasting clear, repeated messages on the importance of measles vaccines, Kennedy falsely claimed on Fox News that they lead to "deaths every year."

    Congress didn't call a hearing, and HHS didn't send funds until after the emergency in West Texas had subsided. Besides an annual measles update, the MMWR didn't publish a single report on the outbreaks that year.

    "A lot of this is the dog didn't bark," said Dorit Reiss, a vaccine policy researcher at the University of California Law San Francisco. "Something that normally happens isn't happening."

    Political appointees have delayed or blocked several MMWR articles, according to multiple CDC officials whom KFF Health News agreed not to identify because they feared retaliation for speaking with the press. "There's a deliberate effort to downplay vaccine-preventable diseases by the administration," one official said.

    "Measles reports from West Texas and New Mexico were intentionally shelved," another scientist at the agency said. In April, The Washington Post reported that Jay Bhattacharya, who temporarily led the CDC this year and remains head of the National Institutes of Health, had blocked the publication of a study in the MMWR finding that COVID vaccines halved the likelihood of emergency department visits.

    "The suggestion that HHS is deliberately suppressing information about measles or other vaccine-preventable diseases is false," Hilliard, the HHS spokesperson, said in an email to KFF Health News.

    Hilliard said Kennedy and the CDC have provided approximately $100 million in additional funding to respond to outbreaks. The timing of MMWR reports, she added, varies due to factors such as data analysis and scientific review.

    More than a year after data was collected from Texas, a few reports came out in the CDC's journal. One study on 60 people hospitalized for measles in West Texas revealed that two required intubation and mechanical ventilation and that a baby born to a mother with measles experienced dangerous brain swelling due to the virus.

    The MMWR still hasn't published detailed reports on massive outbreaks in South Carolina, Utah and Pennsylvania. The CDC's national measles update hasn't appeared in the MMWR this year either. Instead, the journal has featured less urgent articles on scientific techniques that may help characterize future outbreaks.

    CDC scientists told KFF Health News that they continue to analyze data but no longer expect to publish their findings in the MMWR because the process has become slow, opaque, and unpredictable. An urgent CDC report on the risks of measles to pregnant women was withheld, The Washington Post reported recently.

    "We have two CDCs now," an official at the agency said. "One is staffed by CDC scientists and civil servants who are committed to public health, and the other is political appointees who go in and change the website."

    The CDC's measles dashboard counts four fewer measles deaths than state health departments have reported this year. Kennedy has disputed some deaths and made unsubstantiated claims that Pennsylvania health officials misrepresented data.

    Kennedy personally instructed the CDC to alter language on a webpage that said vaccines do not cause autism, he told The New York Times last year.

    The page now suggests a potential link between the two and no longer lists a slew of peer-reviewed studies that rigorously searched for an association and found none. These have been replaced with speculation about a correlation and unsubstantiated accusations that the scientific establishment has buried a potential link in order "to prevent vaccine hesitancy."

    The Trump administration has muddied the message on vaccines in other ways, Reiss said. Trump incorrectly said in August that the measles-mumps-rubella vaccine could be "quite lethal," and he repeated the debunked idea that vaccines may cause autism.

    Stephen Miller, now Trump's White House chief of staff, has falsely said doctors "pump your kids full of shots days after birth with no understanding of the long-term consequences." Recommended vaccines and the vaccine schedule have been thoroughly studied.

    Kennedy has made such claims for two decades, including as health secretary. "Having top leadership disseminating rumors, disinformation and flat-out falsehoods has been unforgivable," Schuchat said.

    When pressed by journalists and Congress, Kennedy and Trump have recommended measles vaccines. But they haven't repeated the message clearly and unprompted on social media or on the podcasts and videos that Kennedy regularly appears in.

    Kennedy also replaced vaccine experts on a panel advising the CDC with fringe researchers holding anti-vaccine views. And under his leadership, the CDC has laid off or forced out many vaccine specialists, including all of those in a group that partners with community organizations and pharmacies, the Immunization Services Division partnership branch.

    At the same time, Kennedy has devoted resources to searching for potential harms from vaccines, including through an attempted clinical trial considered unnecessary and unethical by medical societies and the WHO.

    To regain measles elimination status, the current U.S. outbreaks must end — then, future outbreaks must stop spreading within a year, said Paul Rota, a microbiologist and former CDC official. With outbreaks expanding in several states, he said, that moment isn't on the horizon.

    "Bigger fires create more embers, and any one of those embers can seed another fire," he said.

    KFF Health News is a national newsroom that produces in-depth journalism about health issues and is one of the core operating programs at KFF—an independent source of health policy research, polling, and journalism. Learn more about KFF.
    Copyright 2026 KFF Health News