Sponsored message
Logged in as
Audience-funded nonprofit news
radio tower icon laist logo
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
Subscribe
  • Listen Now Playing Listen

The Brief

The most important stories for you to know today
  • Will Newsom sign bills this time?
    An aerial view of a large building in a downtown area.
    An aerial view of the Digital Realty SFO12 Data Center in the Rincon Hill neighborhood of San Francisco, on Dec. 16, 2025.

    Topline:

    Two bills requiring data centers to disclose water use head to Newsom’s desk. Data centers are using billions of gallons of California’s water. Will Newsom make them say how much?

    The backstory: As fights about data centers erupt nationwide, California lawmakers have approved a pair of bills to make data center developers disclose how much water they really use. The bills are a new test of whether California will set limits on an industry that’s becoming a flashpoint over water, electricity and the environmental consequences of artificial intelligence.

    Why it matters: Lawmakers on Monday cleared Assembly Bill 2469 by Assemblymember Diane Papan, a Democrat from San Mateo. The bill bars local governments from approving new or expanded data centers unless the developer discloses its water plans and covers the full cost of any new water pipes, treatment or storage for the facility.  This bill will now join Papan’s Assembly Bill 2619 on Gov. Gavin Newsom’s desk.

    Read on... for more on the bills.

    As fights about data centers erupt nationwide, California lawmakers have approved a pair of bills to make data center developers disclose how much water they really use.

    The bills are a new test of whether California will set limits on an industry that’s becoming a flashpoint over water, electricity and the environmental consequences of artificial intelligence.

    Lawmakers on Monday cleared Assembly Bill 2469 by Assemblymember Diane Papan, a Democrat from San Mateo. The bill bars local governments from approving new or expanded data centers unless the developer discloses its water plans and covers the full cost of any new water pipes, treatment or storage for the facility. 

    This bill will now join Papan’s Assembly Bill 2619 on Gov. Gavin Newsom’s desk.

    California senators last week, in a decisive 30 to 9 vote, approved the measure requiring data center operators to report their estimated or actual water sources and use — under penalty of perjury — when seeking and renewing a business license or permit.

    It’s almost identical to a bill Papan authored last year, which Newsom vetoed amid pressure from the tech industry.

    Newsom said at the time he was “reluctant to impose rigid reporting requirements … without understanding the full impact on businesses and the consumers of their technology.”

    Papan said she’s often asked whether she thinks her do-over will survive Newsom’s desk, this time.

    “To which I say, the opportunity for leadership has not gone away. If anything, it has been amplified,” Papan told CalMatters.

    Since Newsom’s veto last year, public sentiment has shifted, with bipartisan backlash building against facilities that have become the ganglia of artificial intelligence.

    A Public Policy Institute of California survey found that a majority of residents oppose construction of data centers in their areas, and are concerned about the environmental impacts.

    “We currently are seeing a phase of heightened concern because of the rapid evolution of the industry — and the lack of transparency,” said Iris Stewart-Frey, an environmental science professor at Santa Clara University who led a study this year highlighting how rarely data center developers disclose their water use.

    “I think that's where these bills can really make some progress in getting the sides back to the table and conversation,” Stewart-Frey said, “and also recreate some of this public trust.”

    Lack of oversight, local bans

    Opacity around data centers’ environmental impact is fueling fights around the state, from the desert and parched Imperial County to cities and farm towns.

    With little oversight and even less state direction, local governments are saying no to data centers, citing concerns about environmental issues, electricity rates, and often, water.

    Monterey Park, in the San Gabriel Valley, led the way when voters approved a permanent ban in June. The Coachella City Council approved its own ban last week to public applause. Others including the Tulare County Board of Supervisors are pausing as they weigh more permanent moratoriums.

    Nationally, New York State has enacted a yearlong moratorium, and 70% of Americans told a Gallup poll that they oppose the facilities.

    A fight over a data center in the city of Gilroy, in Santa Clara County, recently made national news, which Stewart-Frey attributed to growing public awareness and distrust of the secretive industry.

    “It's also emblematic of the fact that the data center industry in California has not been releasing actual water use data, right?” said Stewart-Frey. “This lack of transparency is also biting them in the back here.”

    Papan said that’s the point of her bills.

    “I don't think we should be eliminating anything without sufficient knowledge about what their needs are, and then how can we meet those needs,” Papan said. “Help us help you,” she said, to data center developers, “because if you go into an area that doesn't have sufficient water supply for you, it's not going to work.”

    The usual suspects, and new wildcards

    The usual coalitions have lined up. Environmental and community groups back the bills, seeking more transparency over how much water these facilities really use. On the other side are the heavy-hitting and big-spending tech industry and business groups.

    Khara Boender, a Western government affairs director for the Data Center Coalition, said the trade association is concerned that these bills single out data centers from other non-agricultural water users.

    Reporting tied to receiving a business license or permit “should apply to other similar commercial and industrial users, as that would provide context and a holistic view of water demands,” Boender told CalMatters.

    A few wildcards have also entered the fight. As of mid-August, the League of California Cities, the California State Association of Counties, and the Rural County Representatives of California opposed Papan’s bill requiring developers to disclose water plans and pay for upgrades.

    In a July letter the groups said the measure — which would bar local governments from approving data centers that fail to disclose required information about their water plans — “undermines local governments’ ability to protect and represent their communities through established permitting mechanisms and community engagement processes.”

    Water agencies have mostly stayed quiet, raising only technical issues, with one exception: Santa Clara Valley Water District, a water wholesaler in a data center hotspot, supported both bills.

    “Despite local efforts to mitigate the impact of data center water demand, more information on water use could help local water agencies, such as Valley Water, plan for actual needs,” Joshua Golka, head of state government relations for Valley Water, said in a letter to Papan Friday.

    Necessary but not sufficient 

    Michael Kiparsky, director of the Wheeler Water Institute at the UC Berkeley Center for Law, Energy, & the Environment, called Papan’s bills “necessary, but not sufficient.”

    He expects that even with more data, small communities with limited resources and staff will still struggle to assess the benefits and risks. The version of AB 2619 that senators approved last week cut an earlier provision requiring California agencies to develop guidance for local governments.

    Papan said that guidance would have been nice to have, but that there were state costs associated with developing it. An Assembly analysis estimated that developing water-use and emerging technology guidelines would cost $2 million the first year, and $1 million annually after that.

    “The main goal has been transparency. Let me give you the data, and let's go from there,” Papan told CalMatters. “I just didn't want anything to divert from that main goal.”

    Kiparsky called for the state to establish a strike team to help small communities analyze the data that would be produced under the legislation. He also thinks the state should post this information in one place so officials and academics can assess the impacts of data centers and the policies regulating them.

    “To be really clear, data centers are not bad or good … we use them every day for just about everything we do involving technology,” Kiparsky said.

    The real question, he said, is whether a given community — and its specific mix of land, water, and energy resources — is the right spot for one.

    “You can’t answer those questions just with what’s required from this bill — you need to have the understanding that comes from experts looking at it,” Kiparsky said. “The state, in my opinion, can and should provide that.”

    This article was originally published on CalMatters and was republished under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives license.

  • Days after FAA stoppage, airline has system outage
    A worker with a light skin tone, wearing a yellow safety vest and sunglasses, walks between baggage carts as a United Airlines jet taxis on an airport tarmac.
    A worker manages baggage carts as a United Airlines flight taxis at George Bush International Airport on Saturday, Nov. 14, 2026, in Houston, after the Federal Aviation Administration lifted nationwide ground stops.

    Topline:

    United Airlines confirmed it was having a systemwide outage Monday afternoon just days after a malfunction in the Federal Aviation Administration’s network prompted a nationwide ground stop. Chicago-based United said in a statement that the technology problem it is troubleshooting affects departing flights, but it does not have any impact on flights in progress or United Express flights.

    The backstory: The United computer problem is just the latest high-profile technology meltdown. Earlier in the day, thousands of people reported being unable to access their online accounts at several major U.S. banks after JP Morgan Chase had a technical problem. On Friday, the Federal Aviation Administration ordered every flight grounded because a new router that was installed malfunctioned and overwhelmed the aging air traffic control system. And one day earlier, Microsoft experienced a major disruption to its Outlook email service. Microsoft said Saturday that services were fully restored.

    United Airlines confirmed it was having a systemwide outage Monday afternoon just days after a malfunction in the Federal Aviation Administration’s network prompted a nationwide ground stop.

    Chicago-based United said in a statement that the technology problem it is troubleshooting affects departing flights, but it does not have any impact on flights in progress or United Express flights.

    United apologized to customers for the inconvenience on social media.

    A recording posted on the ATC app showed a United pilot in Houston asking the tower for permission to stay put at the gate until the system was working again. The app combines live air traffic control radio feeds with real-time visual aircraft tracking.

    The United computer problem is just the latest high-profile technology meltdown. Earlier in the day, thousands of people reported being unable to access their online accounts at several major U.S. banks after JP Morgan Chase had a technical problem. On Friday, the Federal Aviation Administration ordered every flight grounded because a new router that was installed malfunctioned and overwhelmed the aging air traffic control system. And one day earlier, Microsoft experienced a major disruption to its Outlook email service. Microsoft said Saturday that services were fully restored.

  • Sponsored message
  • County workers reach new labor deal
    Men walk in front of county buildings holding signs that say, "Fighting for a fair contract."
    Hundreds of Orange County workers ratified a new deal with the County of Orange, bringing a 24-day strike to a close.

    Topline:

    Hundreds of workers with the Teamsters 952 ratified a new contract with the County of Orange, marking the end of a 24-day workers’ strike. The deal covers workers across several county departments, including OC Public Works, OC Waste and Recycling, OC Community Resources, and Orange County Animal Care.

    What we know: More than 90% of the represented members approved a two-year contract that comes with a 4% raise in year one and a 4.25% raise in year two, as well as a $1,000 signing bonus, according to union officials.

    Workers say: Workers first walked off the job on Oct. 13. Eric Jimenez, secretary-treasurer for Teamsters Local 952, told LAist workers made a tremendous sacrifice by walking off the job.

    “Our members showed that in the future with the county, if they ever decide to drag their feet again, then they're going to go up against a membership that's willing to fight for what's right and willing to get what they deserve,” Jimenez said.

    What’s next? The OC Board of Supervisors will vote on the contract at a future meeting, according to a county spokesperson.

  • SCOTUS rejects Trump admin appeal
    Gloved hands position a small glass slide with a blue coating under a lab microscope on a workbench.
    Tré Willingham, 31, works inside a lab in Rowland Hall at UC Irvine on June 15, 2026. Willingham is pursuing his Ph.D. in applied physics

    Topline:

    The U.S. Supreme Court rejected the White House’s bid to have the high court review a case that forced the Trump administration to return hundreds of research grants to academics at the University of California. The court issued the decision today.

    The backstory: The case is known as Thakur v. Trump and concerns grants on U.S. history, disease research and biology, among many others. Between January and July of last year the White House terminated more than $900 million in grants to UC researchers, including nearly $600 million at UCLA alone. Almost all of those grants were restored after a lower court judge ordered the federal agencies to restore them across multiple court decisions.

    Federal response: Lawyers for the U.S. Department of Justice argued that federal agencies had the right to terminate the grants because they ran afoul of the Trump administration’s executive orders on defunding so-called Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts, plus research on the effects of global warming. But attorneys for the UC researchers depicted that rationale as dangerous to science and to the academics’ constitutional rights.

    The U.S. Supreme Court rejected the White House’s bid to have the high court review a case that forced the Trump administration to return hundreds of research grants to academics at the University of California.

    The court issued the decision today. No justice filed a brief explaining the decision, which is common.

    Lawyers for the U.S. Department of Justice argued that federal agencies had the right to terminate the grants because they ran afoul of the Trump administration’s executive orders on defunding so-called Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts, plus research on the effects of global warming.

    But attorneys for the UC researchers depicted that rationale as dangerous to science and to the academics’ constitutional rights. “What begins as material harm – loss of money, staff, graduate and post-doctoral students – quickly becomes expressive harm: the inability to publish research and affect public discourse. This is a quintessential First Amendment violation,” the lawyers for the UC researchers wrote in a legal brief to the high court.

    The case is known as Thakur v. Trump and concerns grants on U.S. history, disease research and biology, among many others.

    Between January and July of last year, the White House terminated more than $900 million in grants to UC researchers, including nearly $600 million at UCLA alone. Almost all of those grants were restored after a lower court judge ordered the federal agencies to restore them across multiple court decisions. After the federal government appealed, the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals upheld those decisions that said the White House likely violated the researchers’ First Amendment rights.

    Agencies terminated the grant funding of researchers through keyword searches of grant applications that used words such as “diversity” or “climate change,” CalMatters previously reported. The Department of Energy cut grants specifically to states that voted for Kamala Harris over Trump in 2024.

    Grants issued by the National Institutes of Health also required academics to research a diverse pool of Americans. When the agency terminated a $36 million grant on dementia led by a UC Davis professor in April of last year for focusing on diversity, CalMatters reported that the first Trump administration required a focus on diversity in the grant applications. The National Institutes of Health restored the grant shortly after CalMatters ran its story.

    Some of the research projects the National Science Foundation terminated had nothing to do with diversity and equity initiatives, lawyers for the researchers wrote. They say the foundation targeted grants that included the word “diversity” in describing a scientific approach. Those included projects with titles such as the “Effects of Leaf Diversity on Aquatic Insect Colonizer Diversity” and “Revealing the Vast Diversity Within the Legume-Rhizobia Mutualism.”

    Claudia Polsky, a lawyer for the UC researchers, said the Supreme Court’s decision is a boon to similar cases across the country. Lawyers for other researchers whose grants the federal government canceled are also arguing that the White House violated their First Amendment rights. Those lawyers can point to the fact that the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals agreed with the UC researchers and the Supreme Court rejected the White House’s challenge.

    Those courts are “not technically bound by anything. But I think they will find it quite persuasive,” Polsky said. She doesn’t think the White House will attempt to appeal again, since the justices showed no dissent in their rejection.

    She added that this decision directly benefits Cal State professors who sued the Trump administration last month over the termination of National Science Foundation grants.

    The lawyers for the UC researchers will return to a lower court hearing Tuesday to argue that the Trump administration’s termination of Department of Energy grants were also illegal. That case is technically unrelated to today’s Supreme Court decision.

    Legal dispute

    A central dispute in the case is determining when the federal government can cancel grant funding. Lawyers for the researchers said that once a grant is awarded to academics — regardless of which administration issued it — the academics should be allowed to complete their research, even if the current administration views the research as a waste of taxpayer money.

    But the Department of Justice was adamant that the federal government can cancel already-funded grants. That’s not a First Amendment violation, the agency argued, because the White House isn’t preventing the researchers from seeking private funding to conduct their research.

    The UC researchers didn’t break any rules set by Congress in how they carried out their research and complied with detailed guidelines on how to use federal money, the federal agencies affirmed in signed statements this summer.

    But to the Trump administration, that didn’t matter. The agencies terminated the grants anyway because they no longer aligned with the president’s directives.

    Lawyers for the researchers wrote that the legal precedent argued by the White House would end stability for federal science and humanities research. They argued any project funded for multiple years that extends into the tenure of a new U.S. president would be susceptible to early cancellation. Science cannot operate under that kind of caprice, the lawyers for the researchers argued.

    A lower court judge, appointed by Biden, agreed when ordering the agencies to restore the grants. “They face unexpected funding shortfalls, will likely have to lay off staff, and will experience career and reputational harm if they cannot complete their projects. They also must spend time seeking alternate funding, a time-consuming process with little chance of success,” wrote the judge, Rita F. Lin of the U.S. District Court for Northern California.

    The Department of Justice represented several federal agencies specifically, including the Department of Defense, the Department of Transportation, the National Endowment for the Humanities, the National Institutes of Health, and the National Science Foundation.

    The lawyers settled with the Environmental Protection Agency over similar issues this year.

    Can the White House cancel grants already approved?

    Department of Justice lawyers argued that as long as the administration isn’t forcing researchers to adopt the views of the White House in their private affairs, their rights aren’t violated.

    Lawyers for the researchers blasted that logic. The White House “can point to no case” in which any federal court “has held that the President and federal agencies may terminate grants awarded through a merit-driven competitive process based on the perceived viewpoint of the research,” they wrote in their legal brief urging the Supreme Court to reject the case.

    The legal team for the researchers wrote that the White House is disregarding the processes that Congress established for terminating existing grants. The lawyers for the researchers noted that Congress embedded language in the laws governing the research agencies to encourage research that focused on women, people of color and individuals with disabilities, including at the National Science Foundation. Similar language governs the National Endowment for the Humanities, such as giving “particular regard to scholars, and educational and cultural institutions, that have traditionally been underrepresented.”

    This article was originally published on CalMatters and was republished under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives license.

  • Largest data centers put heat-trapping gas in air
    Aerial view of the Core Scientific data center, a long white industrial building with rooftop cooling equipment, surrounded by forest.
    A Core Scientific data center is visible, Sept. 4, 2026, in Dalton, Georgia.

    Topline:

    The 400 largest data centers in the United States put more heat-trapping gas in the air in one year than the entire nation of Denmark did, and that was before the artificial intelligence boom really got going, according to a Harvard University study published Monday.

    Why it matters: Harvard researchers looked at 403 of the largest U.S. data centers between May 2024 and April 2025 using available data and modeling to analyze their electricity use and emissions. They estimated electricity use by the centers produced around 28.3 million tons (25.7 million metric tons) of carbon dioxide, according to a study in Monday’s Nature Sustainability. More than half their 82 terawatt hours of electricity use — enough to power nearly 7 million homes for a year — came from fossil fuels, which are the primary cause of global warming, the researchers found. The emissions estimate is two to three times what previous studies had shown, said study senior author Francesca Dominici, a Harvard biostatistics professor.

    Why now: Negotiators at the United Nations COP31 climate talks in Antalya, Turkey, launched a voluntary pledge Monday for companies and countries to power the world’s data centers with clean energy and be more open about their power and water consumption and emissions. The pledge also calls for focusing the power of artificial intelligence on solving the so-far intractable problem of climate change and reflects burgeoning concerns about AI’s ever-expanding environmental footprint. The political backlash has played out in U.S. elections and major local objections for new sites.

    The 400 largest data centers in the United States put more heat-trapping gas in the air in one year than the entire nation of Denmark did, and that was before the artificial intelligence boom really got going, according to a Harvard University study published Monday.

    Meanwhile, negotiators at the United Nations COP31 climate talks in Antalya, Turkey, launched a voluntary pledge Monday for companies and countries to power the world’s data centers with clean energy and be more open about their power and water consumption and emissions.

    “We cannot ask people to accept higher bills, more planet-heating pollution and deeper inequality today in exchange for promises of a better tomorrow,” United Nations climate chief Simon Stiell said Monday during the launch of the pledge. “Claims about future emissions savings cannot excuse rising pollution now, making climate disasters even worse.”

    The pledge also calls for focusing the power of artificial intelligence on solving the so-far intractable problem of climate change and reflects burgeoning concerns about AI’s ever-expanding environmental footprint. The political backlash has played out in U.S. elections and major local objections for new sites.

    The explosion of new and planned data centers also has prompted a push for new sources of power generation that has the biggest tech companies failing to reach their climate goals, with their electricity consumption rising 240% between 2022 and 2025, according to a new report by the advocacy group Climate Action Against Disinformation.

    Study quantifies how much big data centers pollute

    Harvard researchers looked at 403 of the largest U.S. data centers between May 2024 and April 2025 using available data and modeling to analyze their electricity use and emissions. They estimated electricity use by the centers produced around 28.3 million tons (25.7 million metric tons) of carbon dioxide, according to a study in Monday’s Nature Sustainability.

    More than half their 82 terawatt hours of electricity use — enough to power nearly 7 million homes for a year — came from fossil fuels, which are the primary cause of global warming, the researchers found.

    The emissions estimate is two to three times what previous studies had shown, said study senior author Francesca Dominici, a Harvard biostatistics professor.

    “It is the equivalent to the CO2 emission of an entire state like Michigan or a small European country,” Dominici said, adding that plans for 2,000 more data centers make that quantity more worrisome for the future. “We are going backwards toward the goal of controlling CO2 emissions.”

    Several outside experts in climate, energy and artificial intelligence said Monday’s study made sense and reached realistic conclusions, finding the use of modeling reasonable because companies aren’t open about power consumption and pollution.

    “We cannot manage environmental impacts effectively without reliable measurements and disclosure,” said Fengqi You, a Cornell University energy systems scientist who wasn’t part of the study. “Ultimately, the environmental footprint of AI is not fixed. It depends on where we build data centers, how efficiently they operate, and how we supply their electricity.”

    A voluntary pledge proposed at climate talks

    The “Antalya Artificial Intelligence Pledge,” launched by U.N. climate talks host Turkey and the International Telecommunication Union, says data centers should use clean power and efficient energy and water systems.

    The pledge also calls for AI systems to be designed and managed responsibly, using environmental standards and reusing or recycling infrastructure and hardware. It says the environmental impacts of data centers should be assessed and shared and signatories should support using artificial intelligence as a climate solution.

    COP31 President Murat Kurum has said world leaders at the talks must openly discuss AI’s growing energy consumption and start setting the terms.

    AI produces pollution but also offers hope

    One of the biggest climate fighters, former U.S. Vice President Al Gore, said while it is essential that data centers are powered by carbon-free energy, he is less concerned about the emissions from AI than others. And he is hopeful that its computing power can find novel ways of fighting climate change.

    In an Associated Press interview, Gore quoted a study by prominent British economist and climate advocate Nicholas Stern who predicted by 2030 “we will see 6 to 9% reduction in emissions of greenhouse gases because of the use of advanced AI in finding new ways to be far more efficient in the use of materials and energy.”

    Caleb Max, president of the National Artificial Intelligence Association said, “AI will solve not only the energy usage issues that data centers face, but unlock numerous currently unknown advances in science and technology that will address climate change and make lives better for humanity. I respect the concerns about energy and water consumption from data centers, but the fears may be overblown.”

    But Climate Action Against Disinformation spokesman Philip Newell was skeptical.

    “We have hope in one hand and then harms in the other,” Newell said. “They’re selling us hope while hiding the harms from us.”

    Capturing heat from data centers

    The computing equipment in data centers generates a lot of waste heat that is vented into the atmosphere. One approach to reducing data centers’ environmental impact is to capture heat that can be used for nearby homes and businesses.

    The Danish engineering and manufacturing company Danfoss said waste heat is “the world’s largest untapped energy source,” and reusing it can replace natural gas as a heat source. It identified data centers as a significant source of constant heat, particularly as their power consumption grows.

    The International Energy Agency estimates data centers could provide enough heat for around 10% of European homes by 2030, if that heat was fully integrated into district systems that supply heat and hot water to residents.

    In remarks broadcast during COP31, European Commissioner for Energy and Housing Dan Jørgensen said Europe must replace imported fossil fuels by capturing heat that is going to waste and tapping into geothermal.

    In another example of this approach, industrial development firm BaRupOn is building an advanced manufacturing campus in Texas that plans to use recaptured heat to generate additional electricity on site, CEO Balaji Tammabattula said. In North Dakota, the company is planning a data center that could feed heat to the community.

    University of Colorado Boulder Professor Gregor Henze said it’s a perfect marriage because modern data centers that rely on liquid rather than air cooling are a fairly constant source of heat at the right temperature for thermal energy networks.

    The Associated Press’ climate and environmental coverage receives financial support from multiple private foundations. The AP is solely responsible for all content. Find the AP’s standards for working with philanthropies, a list of supporters and funded coverage areas at AP.org.