Fire survivors slam purported bills to shift costs
By Levi Sumagaysay | CalMatters
Published July 30, 2026 10:00 AM
Construction workers build a home to replace one of the 6,000 destroyed in the 2025 Eaton Fire in Altadena on March 19, 2026.
(
David McNew
/
Getty Images
)
Topline:
Survivors, insurance industry slam purported last-minute bills to shift wildfire costs away from utilities.
Why now: If you live in California, chances are you’ve seen the ads that say “Home insurance rates skyrocket” and “The FAIR Plan is broken.” They urge you to contact your state representative to ask them to “fix our wildfire problem to make California more affordable.” Those ads are connected to what Los Angeles fire survivors, consumer advocacy groups and the insurance industry say is a secretive, last-minute attempt by Gov. Gavin Newsom to help utilities reduce how much they pay for wildfires they cause.
More details: Every Fire Survivors Network, a group started by survivors of last year’s Eaton Fire, and Consumer Watchdog, a consumer advocacy group that focuses on insurance and other issues, say the bills would shift recovery costs from utility companies to insurance policyholders. Insurance industry representatives agree. The strange bedfellows are calling out the late political maneuvering known as “gut-and-amend,” which lawmakers use to create bills by gutting other pending bills and replacing their language for a different purpose and are meant to be fast-tracked.
Read on... for more on the bills.
If you live in California, chances are you’ve seen the ads that say “Home insurance rates skyrocket” and “The FAIR Plan is broken.”
They urge you to contact your state representative to ask them to “fix our wildfire problem to make California more affordable.”
Those ads are connected to what Los Angeles fire survivors, consumer advocacy groups and the insurance industry say is a secretive, last-minute attempt by Gov. Gavin Newsom to help utilities reduce how much they pay for wildfires they cause.
With the legislative session set to resume next week and run through the end of the month, the governor’s staff has been talking with state lawmakers about addressing challenges around wildfire recovery and rising catastrophic risk in California, a spokesperson for his office confirmed.
Lawmakers have not released the text of the proposals. Newsom spokesperson Anthony Martinez would not say whether the legislation will do the following, as alleged by fire survivors and a consumer advocacy group:
Limit compensation for fire victims’ pain and suffering.
Eliminate insurance companies’ right to recover wildfire costs from utilities or other corporations.
Cap attorneys’ fees, making it harder for fire survivors to get representation.
Every Fire Survivors Network, a group started by survivors of last year’s Eaton Fire, and Consumer Watchdog, a consumer advocacy group that focuses on insurance and other issues, say the bills would shift recovery costs from utility companies to insurance policyholders. Insurance industry representatives agree. The strange bedfellows are calling out the late political maneuvering known as “gut-and-amend,” which lawmakers use to create bills by gutting other pending bills and replacing their language for a different purpose and are meant to be fast-tracked.
The groups are speaking out against the purported bill package, which appears to align with the goals of Wildfire Survivors First, a campaign funded by utilities that, despite its name, has no wildfire survivors groups among its supporters.
“Californians deserve a government that works in the open, not behind closed doors,” said Joy Chen, leader of the Every Fire Survivors Network, in a press conference last week. She urged the governor to “choose democracy over corporate special interests.”
In an open letter to the governor, Chen laid out how she said Newsom has, over the years, already helped utilities shift responsibility for wildfires they cause.
The state's three major utilities, San Diego Gas & Electric, Southern California Edison and Pacific Gas & Electric, have tremendous influence in California. They have what seems to be an unlimited number of names, entities and affiliates; donate to campaigns by Democrats and Republicans; and together employ hundreds of lobbyists who advocate for hundreds of bills every session. In the 2025-26 session, their donations to sitting legislators totaled more than $1.2 million, according to CalMatters’ Digital Democracy Database.
Martinez said the discussions between the governor’s office and California lawmakers are informed by a report released in April by the California Earthquake Authority, which under Senate Bill 254 was tasked with studying how the state should “responsibly and equitably allocate the burdens from natural catastrophes.”
That bill — rewritten so late last year that it required the Legislature to extend its session — also allows utilities to shift additional wildfire costs to consumers if their costs exceed a wildfire fund created in 2019 through legislation also backed by the governor. The three major utilities paid half of the $21 billion fund. Californians paid the other half through monthly surcharges on their electric bills. Eaton Fire survivors have sued Edison over what they say is negligence that led to the fire; the cost of claims from the fire are expected to exceed what’s in the fund.
Among the April report’s many recommendations is to put more money in the wildfire fund by increasing the surcharge on utility customers by $8.50 a month, bringing the total to $11 a month.
Nathan Click, a spokesperson for Wildfire Survivors First, said the campaign is calling on lawmakers to “urgently implement” many of the conclusions in the SB 254 report, which he said “highlighted how payouts to financial middlemen — like trial attorneys, hedge funds and insurance companies — are often paid out before wildfire victims receive a single dollar for rebuilding.”
Click did not answer CalMatters’ question about why there are no fire survivors groups on the list of more than 200 organizations that support the effort. Most are local chambers of commerce or business groups.
CalMatters contacted nearly a dozen of the organizations. Ten did not respond or would not make their executives available for an interview.
But the chief executive of one of them, Jennifer Gray Thompson, said she changed her mind about participating once she realized the coalition did not include fire victims groups. Her organization, After the Fire, which helps support leaders in communities around the country that have experienced mega fires, was briefly on the list but was removed promptly at her request, she said.
“I’m from Sonoma,” Thompson told CalMatters. “I’m a national advocate for fire victims. I’m definitely not on their side,” she added. Former state Sen. Bill Dodd, a Democrat whom she said did a lot of good for fire survivors when he was in office, was among those who contacted her to solicit her group’s support for the effort, according to emails she shared with CalMatters.
Dodd did not return a phone call and text message from CalMatters.
A construction crew works on a home as Eaton Fire survivors and community supporters attend a news conference in support of Senate Bill 1090, the “Keep Altadena Land in Altadena Hands” Act, in Altadena on June 29, 2026. The bill aims to limit high-density development by outside investors on lots where single-family homes stood before the Eaton Fire.
(
Mario Tama
/
Getty Images
)
The Bay Area Council, another supporter, counts PG&E among its member businesses. Spokesperson Rufus Jeffris said the council “generally supports sensible policies and investments that reduce wildfire risk and increase community wildfire resilience and balance the diverse needs of business, consumers and residents.”
A Consumer Watchdog analysis of utilities’ required financial disclosures shows that 66% of the non-governmental organizations on the list have received utility-industry contributions, grants, sponsorships and more worth about $7.3 million from 2023 to 2025.
Click called Consumer Watchdog a “shadow lobby firm for trial attorneys” and said “it should come as no surprise that they are trying to protect a system that prioritizes trial attorneys over wildfire victims.”
Spokespeople for PG&E, Edison and SDG&E referred CalMatters to the Wildfire Victims First campaign regarding the campaign and the legislative proposal.
What state lawmakers are saying or not saying
Sen. Ben Allen, a Democrat from the Los Angeles area whose constituents include survivors of the Palisades Fire, attended the Friday press conference.
“Any solutions that we have have to (hold) the responsible parties accountable,” Allen said in a room full of fire survivors.
Who’s responsible for the costs of wildfire recovery is important to both Allen’s current job and possibly his future one: He is chair of the Senate energy and utilities committee, and is running forinsurance commissioner.
Allen’s spokesperson, Ben Cheever, said the senator was not available for an interview about the specifics of the legislative package.
But he sent the following statement from Allen: “I will carefully review any proposal put forth to ensure we hold responsible parties accountable while meaningfully reducing risk to improve affordability. We should not simply shift around the costs consumers pay without addressing this more holistically.”
Fellow Democrat Sen. Sasha Renee Perez, who represents Eaton Fire survivors, said in an interview with CalMatters that if a legislative package contains the proposals fire survivors suspect they do, she would have a “tremendous issue” with them being presented at the last minute. She also said she has talked with other members of the Legislature who “are very upset with what’s taking place.”
Perez said she would oppose any proposal that limits non-economic damages for fire survivors: “I represent Altadena. I have a friend who lost his sister in the fire. How do you put a price tag on losing your sibling?”
The senator also said she was “so frustrated and shocked” that SB 254, which started off as a bill intended to reduce profits for investor-owned utilities, ended up helping utilities instead during the last three days of last year’s session.
“That’s not the way government should work,” she said.
CalMatters also contacted several other lawmakers or their offices, especially ones who lead related committees. The following Democratic lawmakers’ offices did not respond: Assembly Speaker Robert Rivas; Assemblymember Lisa Calderon, who leads the insurance committee; and Assemblymember Cottie Petrie-Norris, who leads the utilities and energy committee.
Spokespeople for Senate President Pro Tem Monique Limon and Sen. Josh Becker responded with emailed statements similar to that sent by Newsom spokesperson Martinez: “The current system is unsustainable and not working for fire survivors, utility customers, or insurance policyholders.”
The insurance industry’s concerns
Insurance industry representatives say if insurance companies can’t recover wildfire costs from utilities, also known as subrogation, they will inevitably raise premiums.
“We don't think it's fair to make insurance policyholders pay more to bail out utility shareholders,” said Denni Ritter, a vice president at the American Property Casualty Insurance Association.
Ritter also pushed back against the assertion by the utilities’ campaign that insurance companies usually recover their costs from utilities before paying out claims to their policyholders: “It's not like AAA goes, ‘OK, we'll pay you once we've recovered from the utilities’.”
Rex Frazier is president of the Personal Insurance Federation of California, which represents the largest insurers operating in the state. He said this campaign is the latest attempt by utilities to chip away at their industry’s possible liability for wildfires. Sometimes, the insurance industry has had conversations with utilities, he said. That’s not happening this time, he said.
Now he, like other Californians, is seeing the ads from the Wildfire Victims First campaign, whose website says it’s funded by PG&E, SDG&E and SCE shareholders and three other organizations.
“We’re trying to understand why they’re talking about the insurance market,” Frazier said. “We can’t get a clear answer about what they have in mind.”
Jill Replogle
covers public corruption, debates over our voting system, culture war battles — and more.
Published November 20, 2026 5:50 PM
Sunset Beach, an enclave of Huntington Beach between the Pacific Ocean and Huntington Harbour, is preparing for major flooding during the ultra-high king tides expected over the Thanksgiving holiday.
(
Jill Replogle
/
LAist
)
Topline:
The highest ocean water levels of the year, known as king tides, will land over the Thanksgiving holiday, threatening this quaint, coastal enclave of Huntington Beach with major flooding.
How can people prepare? The city has sandbags and filling stations set up around the harbor. There’s more information on their website about when the highest tides are predicted, how to sign up for alerts, where to get sandbags and how to properly stack them for flood control.
Live elsewhere? Check out our guide to prepping for this year’s Super El Niño.
A week before Thanksgiving, residents of Sunset Beach stacked sandbags, cleared garages and built makeshift barriers around their homes in a race against a gravitational clock. The year's highest ocean water levels, known as king tides, will arrive over the holiday, threatening this quaint coastal enclave of Huntington Beach with major flooding.
The king tides, which hit the California coast every year in November, December and January, are a normal phenomenon. They occur when the sun, moon and Earth align, combining their gravitational pull. But this year, the tides will be compounded by a prolonged marine heat wave, El Niño-fueled Kelvin waves and long-term sea level rise, which combined will likely add around 1½ feet to the predicted high tide, according to forecasters.
“We’re expecting the tides to be much higher than in October,” said Jessica Cuchilla, a spokesperson for the city of Huntington Beach. In late October, flooding during high tides damaged 114 homes in the harbor area, forcing some to move out. One home caught on fire when saltwater soaked a lithium-ion e-bike battery.
The Huntington Beach Fire Department made its own tide chart that accounts for the added sea level expected in this El Niño year.
(
Screenshot
/
LAist
)
On the upside, Cuchilla said, “We’re much better prepared than we were in October.”
Bayview Drive on Sunset Island (part of Sunset Beach and also Huntington Harbour) was in full prepper mode on a recent morning. It was one of the hardest-hit areas during the high tides in late October. This time around, residents plan to be ready for the November arrival of the king tides.
Volunteers shoveled sand into bags, residents shuttled belongings out of their low-lying garages, and Tony Nobles, head of the Sunset Beach Community Association, strode down the street, making a mental checklist of work still needing to be done.
“ I think everybody here knows who I am now because I'm the one sending out all the emails,” he said before stopping to chat with a woman about plans for protecting her home and her elderly father’s home next door. ”If you need anything, you know you can ask me, and I'll come,” Nobles told her.
Tony Nobles, head of the Sunset Beach Community Association, has been working around the clock to help fellow neighbors prepare for the king tides.
(
Jill Replogle
/
LAist
)
Some of the homes on Sunset Island date back to the early 20th century, when the area was known for duck hunting in the adjacent marshes and as a landing spot for liquor smuggled in by boats during Prohibition. Each home is in charge of its own seawall or bulkhead to keep the harbor water at bay, and they are built to withstand a variety of sea-level heights. But ocean water that breaches a lower seawall can quickly become a problem for the whole neighborhood.
After the October high tides, the city of Huntington Beach sent code enforcement employees out to survey the entire harbor area, including Sunset Beach, totaling more than 3,000 homes. Workers posted notices ordering people to take measures to protect their property from flooding.
Cuchilla, the city spokesperson, said most homeowners complied. The several dozen that didn’t, she said, were largely occupied by elderly or disabled residents who were unable to do the work themselves, she said. The city passed that list of homes to Nobles and Team Rubicon, a disaster response group, to help assess needs and deliver and stack sandbags.
Huntington Beach is planning to shut down streets around the harbor during the upcoming king tides period, Nov. 23-27, to protect drivers, but also homeowners and businesses that can get flooded by the wakes left when vehicles plow through standing water. The city has also asked harbor residents to be ready to evacuate or shelter in place, if necessary.
What you need to know about El Niño
El Niño years can be associated with lots of rain in Southern California, though there's no guarantee of a deluge. And wet winters aren’t always disastrous. What matters is how much water falls within how much time. In fact, going back to when modern records began in 1950, most of the years when we've seen the highest flood-related costs were not during El Niño events.
But there are concerns beyond rain for late 2026 and early 2027.
El Niño this time will coincide with another natural phenomenon — the highest tides of the year in a nearly two-decade cycle. Because El Niño warms the ocean, it also raises sea levels temporarily. On top of that, there’s an unprecedented level of human-caused global warming that has already raised sea levels by as much as a foot along California’s coast over the last century and is making weather more extreme.
It’s not only the coast — inland areas, especially along creeks and rivers, are also at risk due to more extreme rainfall.
The uncertainty had some residents feeling anxious. On Sunset Island, Laurie Hamblin had just gotten a delivery of plastic barriers, which she hoped would do a better job of blocking seawater than the sandbags she tried during the October high tide event. Despite the sandbags, water flooded her entryway and seeped into her garage, ruining her washer and dryer.
Sandbags waiting to be stacked on Sunset Island, Nov. 18, 2026.
(
Jill Replogle
/
LAist
)
“Nobody knows what's really going to work,” she said. “That's the scary part, you know? We're just all trying different things, and you walk down the street and look at what everyone's doing and think, ‘Is that gonna work?’
“I'm going to try and protect what I can,” she said.
How can people prepare?
In Huntington Beach, the city has sandbags and filling stations set up around the harbor. There’s more information on their website about when the highest tides are predicted, how to sign up for alerts, where to get sandbags and how to properly stack them for flood control.
How to reach me
If you have a tip, you can reach me on Signal. My username is @jillrep.79.
For instructions on getting started with Signal, see the app's support page. Once you're on, you can type my username in the search bar after starting a new chat.
And if you're comfortable just reaching out by email I'm at jreplogle@scpr.org
O.C. Supervisor Katrina Foley, left, celebrates in Costa Mesa with supporter Susan Seely of Newport Beach as the first vote drop is announced during California's primary election on June 2, 2026.
(
Erin Stone
/
LAist
)
Topline:
Orange County voters ensured a Democratic majority on the Board of Supervisors and gave the boot to three incumbent Republican state legislators in the 2026 election — a glaring signal that the once-red SoCal county failed to escape the party’s bruising defeats nationwide.
Why it matters: A "bluenami" was all the talk nationwide after the general election, and that effect didn’t stop at parts of Orange County.
Read on … for more on where the "bluenami" hit and where it didn’t.
Orange County voters ensured a Democratic majority on the Board of Supervisors and gave the boot to three incumbent Republican state legislators in the 2026 election — a glaring sign of just how much demographics have changed in the once-red county and, local observers say, how much residents dislike the president.
“The outcome was way worse than we had anticipated,” said Will O’Neill, chairman of the Orange County Republican Party.
“The ‘bluenami’ … certainly didn't stop at the Pacific Ocean. We got swamped.”
What's left to count?
The Orange County Registrar of Voters announced Nov. 18 that all valid ballots had been counted. Still, there are still about 14,000 returned ballots that have not been counted, either because the voter didn’t sign the envelope or was a first-time voter who didn’t provide a government ID when registering.
The Registrar has notified those voters that they need to take extra steps to get their ballots counted, called “curing” (instructions are also available on the Registrar’s website), which voters need to complete by Nov. 25.
Final election results will be certified by December 11.
After the last general election in 2024, eight of the county’s 13 representatives in the state Assembly and Senate were Republicans. Come December, O.C. may send as few as four Republican representatives to Sacramento. (In one race, the Democratic candidate is ahead, but it’s still too close to call.)
Are these results evidence that this former bastion of the California GOP has abandoned the party? Not so fast, observers say. “ Orange County is still not Berkeley,” said Mike Moodian, a lecturer at Chapman University in Orange who specializes in local politics. “This isn't San Francisco. This isn't L.A. It's still a purple county, and there is still a strong Republican party in Orange County.”
“Purple” refers to a place with roughly equal portions of voters from different political parties. In O.C., Democrats make up 37% of registered voters, Republicans 33%, and voters who state No Party Preference or who belong to smaller parties make up 30%, according to data from the Orange County Registrar of Voters.
O’Neill, the county GOP chair, pointed out that Republicans maintained, and in some cases gained, control over many city governments in the county. Those are technically nonpartisan races, meaning a candidate’s party does not appear next to their name on the ballot — a good thing for Republicans this year, he said.
“A lot of people just didn't want to vote for a Republican in this [election] cycle,” he said.
The reason for the party’s major losses this time around is simple, both O’Neill and Moodian said — President Donald Trump. But other observers cautioned against writing the election off to extreme dislike of the president.
“Clearly these are the demographics now,” said Tim Lineberger, an O.C.-based Republican political and PR consultant. Lineberger blamed the losses in part on the local GOP’s decision to divert resources to riskier races, away from ones he thinks they could have won. “You have to defend the places you can defend,” he said.
There are also indications that parts of the county where Democrats reliably win, in Santa Ana and surrounding cities, moved even further to the left in November.
Here’s a look at several key shifts that took place in the November election
Orange County Supervisor Katrina Foley won re-election in the November 2026 general.
(
Brian Feinzimer
/
LAist
)
A more progressive Board of Supervisors
A win in one of the two races on the ballot for the O.C. Board of Supervisors would have given Republicans a majority on the powerful board, which they last had in 2022, but the party came up short in both races.
In District 4, Democrat Connor Traut beat Republican Tim Shaw for the open seat by more than 8,000 votes. In District 5, incumbent Katrina Foley beat state Assemblymember Diane Dixon by close to 13,000 votes.
Along with Supervisor Vicente Sarmiento, who easily won re-election in the June primary, the new Democratic majority has a more progressive bent than the current one, where Democrat Doug Chaffee often votes with Republicans. Chaffee even endorsed Republican Dixon over Foley, his fellow Democrat and board colleague. What will that mean for the next term?
“I think we're going to see a Board of Supervisors that is aligned very well with labor,” Moodian said, noting that Traut and Foley were both heavily supported by labor unions in the election. Moodian said he’ll be watching how the new board approaches housing, homelessness, healthcare and plans for the LA28 Olympic and Paralympic Games, when O.C. will host several events.
Even fewer Republicans in Sacramento
Perhaps the most stunning Republican loss in O.C. was that of incumbent state Senator Tony Strickland in District 36, where Republicans have a five-percentage-point advantage in party registration over Democrats. Strickland, a Republican who lives in Huntington Beach, handily won a special election to fill the seat last year. He also beat out Democrat Chris Duncan in this year’s June primary, paving the way for a fall showdown.
But the tables turned in the Nov. 3 election, with Duncan winning by more than 12,000 votes. Strickland conceded on Nov. 10 in a social media post, writing “it looks like the numbers aren’t going to turn in our direction.”
The other O.C. legislative districts where Republicans either lost seats or are close to doing so are:
Assembly District 70, centered in Little Saigon. Democratic political newcomer Paula Swift beat Republican incumbent Tri Ta with 52% of the vote. Ta conceded in a social media post earlier this month.
Assembly District 72, centered in Newport Beach. Democrat and political newcomer Chris Kluwe is more than 800 votes ahead of Republican Gracey Van Der Mark, a firebrand member of the Huntington Beach City Council — in a district where Republicans have a five-percentage-point advantage in registration over Democrats. The race has yet to be officially called. (This is the seat that opened up when Dixon opted to run for the Board of Supervisors.)
Assembly District 74, which covers south O.C. as well as Oceanside and Vista in San Diego. Democrat Sergio Farias, a councilmember in San Juan Capistrano, beat Republican Laurie Davies, who had held the seat since 2020. Davies has also conceded.
There were three state legislative seats where Orange County Republicans held on to their seats — Assembly Districts 59 and 71 and Senate District 32. In each of those cases, those districts also included large swaths of territory stretching beyond Orange County, including inland San Diego and the Inland Empire.
Santa Ana embraces progressives
Dan Shimell, an attorney and a new face in local politics, is Santa Ana’s next mayor after an unexpected win against incumbent Valerie Amezcua.
(
Courtesy of Dan Shimell
)
The city of Santa Ana, a Democratic stronghold for decades, moved further left in this latest election. About 50% of registered voters in Santa Ana are Democrats, and just 19% are Republican, according to county data. Voters rejected incumbents backed by the city’s police union for more progressive candidates endorsed by groups like the Democratic Socialist Association.
Incumbent Mayor Valerie Amezcua was ousted by newcomer Dan Schimell. Schimell ran on promises to address the immigrant communities’ fears and concerns head-on. Immigrant advocate Sandra de Anda beat incumbent Phil Bacerra; and in Ward 6, Isuri S. Ramos, executive director of political group Chispa OC, won against lawyer Giovanni Chavez, who had support from Amezcua and the police union.
Progressive candidates’ wins capture “a lot of the spirit of the times, the zeitgeist in Santa Ana right now,” Moodian added.
“This is an idea of the police union-backed establishment versus the progressive resistance,” Moodian said. “And there was a very large amount of money that went in to back the incumbent candidates, but it wasn't enough.”
In Westminster and Huntington Beach, an apparent move to the left
In the Westminster mayoral race, Democrat Carlos Manzo beat incumbent Republican Mayor Chi Charlie Nguyen by just over 1,200 votes. Nguyen had served as mayor since 2022 and was first elected to city council in 2018. Manzo joined the Westminster City Council in 2020.
Westminster voters also ousted Republican Councilmember Amy Phan West, who once compared her legal troubles to those of President Donald Trump (she was accused of bribery, denied the claim and the charges were later dropped).
And in Huntington Beach, the once proudly all-MAGA City Council will give way to a mostly MAGA council after the election. Democrats and the local police union backed a slate of four candidates to challenge the conservative majority.
One of those candidates, Ben Davis, won his race, while voters re-elected two incumbents, Casey McKeon and Pat Burns, and elected Andrew Gruel, who was appointed to his seat last year. A second candidate, Erin Spivey, on the progressive slate, was behind by less than 60 votes in the latest count.
You can follow the path your ballot took during this election cycle at Ballottrax.
Keep up with LAist.
If you're enjoying this article, you'll love our daily newsletter, The LA Report. Each weekday, catch up on the 5 most pressing stories to start your morning in 3 minutes or less.
Frank Stoltze
is a veteran reporter who covers local politics and examines how democracy is and, at times, is not working.
Published November 20, 2026 4:24 PM
A view of Los Angeles City Hall.
(
Tom-Kichi/Getty Images
/
iStockphoto
)
Topline:
The Los Angeles City Council on Friday referred to committee two proposed charter changes that would allow the council to overturn mayoral executive directives and remove department general managers, something only the mayor can do now. Any changes to the charter would require voter approval.
The details: Councilmember Monica Rodriguez authored the motion on executive directives, which are orders to department heads by the mayor. If approved, the council would need a two-thirds vote to override such an order. Rodriguez said the move was not aimed at incoming Mayor Nithya Raman, whom the council member did not support in the election. She said it's important that there be “healthy checks and balances ... regardless of who sits in the Mayor’s Office."
Councilmember Ysabel Jurado, who authored the motion on general managers, said it “grew out of serious concerns about the LAPD’s handling of protests” and the council’s “limited authority over department leadership.” As specified in the other motion, if approved, the City Council would need a two-thirds vote to remove a department manager.
Raman's reaction: Liz Garcia, a spokesperson for the mayor-elect, said Raman believes “eroding executive authority makes city government less efficient, less accountable and ultimately less effective in delivering services to residents."
What’s next: The City Council’s Ad Hoc Committee on Charter Reform plans to conduct a series of hearings on numerous proposed charter changes — including expanding the size of the council. It will be up to the full City Council to decide what changes to place before voters — likely on the November 2028 ballot.
Air tanker planes and helicopters drop water over flames over the Palisades wildfire in Los Angeles on Friday.
(
Tayfun Coskun
/
Anadolu via Getty Images
)
Topline:
The man accused of sparking last year’s deadly Palisades Fire was found guilty of arson charges Friday after his first federal case earlier this year ended in a mistrial.
About the conviction: Jurors convicted Jonathan Rinderknecht, 30, of lighting a fire on Jan. 1, 2025, that burned undetected deep in root systems before flaring back up Jan. 7
Why it matters: The fire became one of the most destructive in California history. The Palisades Fire killed 12 people as it incinerated entire neighborhoods in Los Angeles and Malibu.
The backstory: Prosecutors continued to pursue the case after Rinderknecht’s first jury deadlocked 10-2 in favor of acquittal after a two-week trial in June. They dropped a third charge of timber set afire when they filed a new indictment for the retrial.
Read on... for more on the case and backstory.
The man accused of sparking last year’s deadly Palisades Fire was found guilty of arson charges Friday after his first federal case earlier this year ended in a mistrial.
Jurors convicted Jonathan Rinderknecht, 30, of lighting a fire on Jan. 1, 2025, that burned undetected deep in root systems before flaring back up Jan. 7, becoming one of the most destructive wildfires in California history. The Palisades Fire killed 12 people as it incinerated entire neighborhoods in Los Angeles and Malibu.
Rinderknecht, with little apparent reaction, gave his attorneys hugs before leaving the courtroom. His father was present for the trial and as the verdict was read.
Rinderknecht pleaded not guilty to federal charges of destruction of property by means of fire and arson. The scope of the first charge was narrowed to only include the Jan. 1 blaze, known as the Lachman Fire, and the second addresses the Palisades Fire. He was convicted on both charges.
Prosecutors continued to pursue the case after Rinderknecht’s first jury deadlocked 10 to 2 in favor of acquittal after a two-week trial in June. They dropped a third charge of timber set afire when they filed a new indictment for the retrial.
During the second trial, prosecutors presented a more tightly organized case that presented digital forensic data, expert testimony and Rinderknecht’s state of mind in the hours leading up to the fire. They did not focus as much on his resentment toward the rich and powerful to present the crime as arson motivated by “societal revenge” like they previously did.
Prosecutors zeroed in on evidence placing him at the fire’s origin area, such as photographs that showed his car parked at the base of a trail leading up to where the fire started and cellphone tower data pointing to his movement on the hill. Fire detection camera images showed the time window the blaze ignited, and experts eliminated any other source of ignition that night, including fireworks.
They established that Rinderknecht was acting erratic and angry in the hours leading up to the fire through the testimony of Uber passengers and texts sent to his girlfriend at the time.
“He was mad at everything, and frustrated,” said Assistant U.S. Attorney Mark Williams.
After the fire began, Rinderknecht called 911 more than a dozen times as he walked down the hill. Prosecutors presented the video he screen-recorded on his phone while calling. As he was calling, he asked ChatGPT: “Are you at fault if a fire is lit because of your cigarettes?”
These were part of an alibi Rinderknecht was trying to create for himself, prosecutors said.
They also presented extensive testimony on how fire investigators determined the Palisades Fire was a holdover fire from the initial blaze Rinderknecht sparked. Jurors were instructed not to consider the Los Angeles Fire Department’s role in putting out the fire.
Rinderknecht’s defense attorney Steve Haney casted doubt on the government’s case and said that their evidence proves nothing.
Haney said the fire scene could have been compromised because the area was accessible to the public until the Palisades Fire started Jan. 7.
“Six days of anyone and everyone walking across the spot the government now calls a crime scene,” he said.
The defense called their own expert witnesses, including a retired fire investigator for the U.S. Forest Service who argued the fire origin area was different from what the government concluded.
Haney argued the government could not conclusively say there was no one else by the fire ignition point that night because of missing cell data records, and pointed to a neighbor’s testimony that he saw a group of teenagers running away from the direction of the trailhead.
He told jurors to disregard any evidence related to Rinderknecht’s character, such as his angry text messages, because they were “evidence of the man, not evidence of the act.”
Finally, Haney presented an alternate explanation for what ignited the fire — fireworks. Multiple witnesses, including two neighbors and a local firefighter, all said they heard a loud bang or explosion from the direction of the hill the fire purportedly started on.
In the thousands of images of the evening collected from cameras in the area, none showed fireworks in the sky above the hill where the fire started, prosecutors said.