Sponsored message
Logged in as
Audience-funded nonprofit news
radio tower icon laist logo
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
Subscribe
  • Listen Now Playing Listen

The Brief

The most important stories for you to know today
  • Projects drain surrounding communities
    Heat radiates off of a field of solar panels of one of the solar farms in Desert Center, California.
    Heat radiates off of the panels of one of the solar farms in Desert Center, California, on Monday, May 8, 2023.

    Topline:

    Utility-scale solar farms spreading rapidly across the desert Southwest are stressing the region’s already overtaxed groundwater and communities are beginning to push back.

    Why it matters: Local wells in the area have gone dry since the construction of multiple utility-scale solar projects near Desert Center — threatening the only water source for hundreds of people and a handful of local businesses. Solar farms typically don’t use much water when operating, but during construction, the law requires developers to mitigate dust—which can spread health problems like Valley Fever.

    Read more ... for a deeper look at the effects of this solar surge on the communities around Desert Center.

    This story was originally published by Inside Climate News and is reproduced here as part of the Climate Desk collaboration.

    Solar farms stretch out mile after mile along Interstate 10 around Palm Springs, creating one of the densest areas of solar development in North America in the heart of California’s Colorado Desert. But the area’s success in meeting the state and the nation’s renewable energy goals is running up against the Southwest’s biggest climate challenge: Having enough water.

    Local wells in the area have gone dry since the construction of multiple utility-scale solar projects near Desert Center—threatening the only water source for hundreds of people and a handful of local businesses. Solar farms typically don’t use much water when operating, but during construction, the law requires developers to mitigate dust—which can spread health problems like Valley Fever. That requires water.

    The projects are being built on public land overseen by the Department of Interior’s Bureau of Land Management. The federal agency knew the construction of the solar projects could impact local wells and may even be over-drafting the aquifer beneath them, according to former BLM staff, studies on the basin and public documents from the agency’s environmental assessments of the projects.

    While the communities around Desert Center are small, the sunshine is nearly endless and it has all the infrastructure a solar project would need: transmission lines to distribute the power, roads for workers to get to the projects and a major highway nearby that allows the easy transportation of construction materials. When the nation began looking to transition away from the fossil fuels driving climate change, no place was better suited for solar energy development.

    Under the 2012 Western Solar Plan created by the BLM, 298,321 acres of public lands were divided up and labeled as “solar energy zones”—areas perfect for developing the resource. Nearly half of them are in the Riverside East zone, where Desert Center lies. That plan to “help accelerate and continue momentum for the clean energy economy,” is now being reviewed by the BLM, according to the agency, and has the potential to open up areas for solar development in five more states and across even more public land in states that are already being developed.

    A blue, man-made lake. In the background is a one-floor resort building and trees. Rocks are in the foreground.
    Lake Tamarisk, a man-made lake in Lake Tamarisk Desert Resort in Desert Center, California, on Monday, May 8, 2023.
    (
    Alex Gould
    /
    Inside Climate News
    )

    Seven utility-scale solar projects stretching out across nearly 19,000 acres of mostly public land have been approved by the BLM near Desert Center, with more projects under consideration. Together they would provide close to 3,000 megawatts of electricity—enough for around 2 million homes.

    If solar companies’ use of groundwater dries up local wells, the BLM requires them to reduce their pumping until the aquifer returns to levels that allow wells to resume operations and cover the expenses for replacing equipment and wells. But local well owners say they have received no help so far.

    Limited data exists about the aquifer—the Chuckwalla Valley Groundwater Basin—but studies over the past decade showed what was being pumped out likely exceeded what was going back in. Bringing in water from elsewhere would be too costly, so developers rely on groundwater during construction.

    A map outlines solar projects and Bureau of Land Management projects.
    (
    Inside Climate News
    )

    Demands on a scarce resource

    Across the drought-stricken Southwest, the importance of groundwater is coming to the surface. The resource has propped up development and agriculture in parts of the region lacking a diverse portfolio of water resources, leading to overuse of groundwater that has led the land beneath homes to sink and wells to run dry.

    In Desert Center and similar California communities, underground aquifers are the only source of drinking water. Across the border, Arizona announced this month that the Phoenix area would no longer be allowed to grow on groundwater alone. New developments will have to rely on other sources approved by the Arizona Department of Water Resources.

    But, unlike a lake or river in which the water is visible, monitoring groundwater levels is challenging. “It’s all happening beneath your feet,” said Jason Melady, a principal hydrogeologist at Summit Water Resources, a water resource management consulting company contacted by a local resident. Having data is key to assessing how a development will impact the resource, said Melday and other groundwater experts, but it can be hard to come by.

    The BLM reported there was enough groundwater for the most recently approved projects from Intersect Power and Clearway Energy Group in its environmental assessments of the proposed developments, but also found data was limited and the basin could already be overdrawn. Even if it wasn’t being overused, the project “may adversely affect operation of nearby wells,” the assessment stated.

    A different proposed solar project from Intersect Power would require another 1,000 acre-feet of water during two years of construction, and yet another proposed development would need a water supply, likely from the aquifer, but how much has not yet been determined. One acre-foot typically provides enough water for two households in a year.

    The water assessments for each recently approved project found the recharge of the aquifer from rain could range from 206 to just over 20,000 acre-feet a year.

    “That’s not a great information basis for your planning,” said Andrew Ayres, a research fellow at the Public Policy Institute of California’s Water Policy Center. In recent years, he said, other aquifers in the state have had to religiously document the recharge rate of their basins, how much water was being extracted and where it goes under California’s Sustainable Groundwater Management Act, passed in 2014.

    But none of that has been done for the Chuckwalla Valley Groundwater Basin. While the law requires basins in overdraft to form agencies that regulate the groundwater and restrict water use to avoid long-term issues, Chuckwalla Valley is designated as a low-priority basin that doesn’t have to do any of that. The law also doesn’t apply to federal lands, which is where most of the solar projects are being built.

    A tanker truck and construction machines litter a desert-area work site, where there is also a variety of metal structures.
    Construction crews use water tanker trucks to spray the dirt to mitigate dust kicked up by the construction of new solar developments near Desert Center, California, on Monday, May 8, 2023. Alex Gould / Inside Climate News
    (
    Alex Gould
    /
    Inside Climate News
    )

    The main complication of water issues in these projects is the disconnect between state and federal policies, said Dustin Mulvaney, a professor in environmental studies at San Jose State University whose research focuses on sustainable and just transitions to solar power.

    “It’s a consequence of a public lands project,” he said, noting that California doesn’t regulate or monitor water pumped on federal public lands, even though it comes from the same aquifer the state oversees. “This is a gap in the state’s plan, not just regulation or oversight, but just tracking. This is a huge gap for them.”

    Without oversight now, Riverside County, where the basin is located, “could get pulled into a situation in which you basically sleepwalk your way into more stringent regulation,” Ayres said, “and that can be really demanding and really costly.”

    The basin could already be overdrawn, or have too many wells competing with one another in an area, Ayres and Melady said. The only way to know, they said, is to invest resources into finding out more about the basin.

    Preventing further decline of the aquifer and getting help for those already impacted by shortages is top of mind for people who live here.

    Desert Center itself is little more than a “ghost town” where travelers between Los Angeles and Phoenix once stopped for food, gas and repairs. A few miles north lies Lake Tamarisk, a retirement community of around 200 where neighbors view each other as family and spend their days admiring the desert.

    Plumes of dust rise into the sky after being kicked up by construction on solar farms near Desert Center, California, on Monday, May 8, 2023.
    Plumes of dust rise into the sky after being kicked up by construction on solar farms near Desert Center, California, on Monday, May 8, 2023.
    (
    Alex Gould
    /
    Inside Climate News
    )

    But the views of the endless desert filled with sacred Indigenous sites, palo verde and ironwood trees, and endangered desert tortoises are now disappearing as solar panels spread around the local communities. The citizens of Desert Center and Lake Tamarisk, like others across the country, are beginning to push back. After being left out of conversations about previous solar development near their homes, they’re determined to be heard as two new solar projects are proposed in the area.

    “No one took into consideration a community lived out here,” said Teresa Pierce, a resident of Lake Tamarisk who has helped lead the community’s response to future solar development. While they aren’t entirely opposed to solar, she said, “we’re against it being so close to our community and stealing our water out from our aquifer.”

    ‘Dead without water’

    The first sign of trouble arrived this February, months after the most recently approved solar projects began construction, when John Beach got an email from his bank saying he hadn’t paid the electric bill for his property in Desert Center because it had exceeded his authorized limit. His land has no home on it, just two palm trees he’s been irrigating for 15 years, and his water pump was working overtime because it wasn’t getting any water.

    His electricity bill in January was $15. In February, it was $1,800.

    Later that month, a local RV park had its well go dry, too. The water table had dropped 50 feet, leaving about 70 residents, most of whom are construction workers for the solar projects, without water for a week. Fortunately, the well was deep enough that all that needed to be done was lower the water pump, which cost $16,000. But it can’t be lowered again should the water table continue to fall.

    “That park is dead without water,” said Nick Melendez, the property manager. “You can’t even get water trucked in out there.”

    Drilling a new well for either property would cost around $100,000.

    “I’m not hurt really. I just have palm trees that are gonna want water,” Beach said. “But if the Lake Tamarisk public water system goes out, you’ve got 200 people without water, and it doesn’t just get turned on again the next day. I mean that is a terrible thing to allow to happen.” Two commercial fish farming operations in the area also experienced reduced flows from their wells, he added.

    Intersect Power—the company behind Oberon and another proposed utility-scale solar project in the area—said in a statement to Inside Climate News it had been notified of the issue and was looking into it, but “the potential for the project to impact nearby wells was studied extensively by the agencies that authorized the project under State and Federal law. Science-based mitigation measures were imposed including ongoing monitoring of area wells. The project is in compliance with all mitigation measures.“

    Concerns over the impact of solar project development on the local aquifer have long existed.

    At a property outside of one of the solar farms, home made signs against the development are posted by the roadside in Desert Center, California, on Monday, May 8, 2023.
    At a property outside of one of the solar farms, home made signs against the development are posted by the roadside in Desert Center, California, on Monday, May 8, 2023.
    (
    Alex Gould
    /
    Inside Climate News
    )

    Three hours away from Desert Center, in Tempe, Arizona, two BLM staffers who had studied the hydrology of the Chuckwalla Valley Groundwater Basin and worked for the BLM’s Palm Springs office gave a presentation at the Arizona Hydrological Society in 2021. The topic: “Renewable Energy Impacts on Ground Water in a Desert Basin.”

    “That is ground zero for solar field developments in North America,” said Noel Ludwig, one of the presenters and now a hydrologist with the U.S. Forest Service in Colorado. At the time, he said, all the studies on the basin agreed: Groundwater was being pumped out at near or above the rate at which the basin can replenish the supply.

    It’s “simple math,” Ludwig said. You can’t remove more water from an aquifer than is added by return flows into it without eventually running out. The Chuckwalla Valley Groundwater Basin is an ancient aquifer, primarily refilled by rain, and takes a long time to replenish.

    “It’s just something that’s a groundwater issue—not just in that basin but around the country and around the world,” he said. “They’ve been treating it like a bottomless bank account, without accounting for the long-term and certain implications on people’s wells.”

    Individual solar projects don’t use much water, but when added all together, they can start to make an impact, Ludwig and groundwater policy experts said.

    Ludwig and his colleague’s groundwater presentation in Tempe “was never accepted by the BLM” and is not reflective of the current mitigation measures for groundwater use, a spokesperson for the agency said.

    The BLM did not answer questions about what mitigation measures are in place, if it is looking into the current situation of wells going dry, if it has been monitoring the basin or how it is working with local communities. 

    But in its environmental assessment for recently approved solar projects, the BLM found water used by solar project development could affect local wells.

    Under baseline conditions, it found the basin would have a surplus of 2,390 acre-feet. But the lack of data on the basin makes “performing a detailed analysis” challenging. And the water supply assessment found the aquifer could already be overdrawn by 6,685 acre-feet of water under lower precipitation and water inflow conditions.

    Communities see few benefits, all consequences

    Teresa Pierce’s porch provides a “front row seat” to Joshua Tree National Park. The view of the desert is nearly endless—until the solar farms interrupt it.

    The Lake Tamarisk community got its start as housing for workers at a Kaiser Steel iron mine before morphing into a home for everyone from school-aged children to retirees. In addition to a man-made lake and single tamarisk tree the community’s name suggests, it has a library, post office and fire station.

    At her home in Lake Tamarisk, Teresa Pierce flips through a college English paper on environmentalism that she wrote in 1984 on Monday, May 8, 2023.
    At her home in Lake Tamarisk, Teresa Pierce flips through a college English paper on environmentalism that she wrote in 1984 on Monday, May 8, 2023.
    (
    Alex Gould
    /
    Inside Climate News
    )

    But just outside of town, near Desert Center, what were once vast stretches of desert filled with washes providing essential habitats for the local wildlife are now the most built-out area of solar development in the nation.

    Solar farms started here over a decade ago with multiple projects arriving after the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009, said Mulvaney, the San Jose State University professor who has researched solar projects on BLM lands in the Southwest.

    Those projects, while still in view, are miles away from Desert Center. But the area is now seeing another wave of solar development as space on nearby transmission lines opens up, Mulvaney said. Those projects are slowly surrounding Lake Tamarisk, which would be encircled by solar farms on three sides, with the latest project’s panels being 750 feet away and its fences and other infrastructure even closer.

    Members of the community say they have long been left out of the decision-making process going back to when the Riverside East Solar Energy Zone was established. Community members said they were never notified directly about Oberon, the most recently approved project, near Lake Tamarisk and Desert Center. When the same company, Intersect Power, proposed another project, only one person received a direct notice about it, and he then informed his neighbors.

    When two of the projects in the area were approved for construction last summer, BLM Director Tracy Stone-Manning said in a press release that “Renewable energy development on BLM-managed public lands will continue to help communities across the country be part of the climate solution, while creating jobs and boosting local economies.”

    The water treatment facility and well for Lake Tamarisk in Desert Center, California, on Monday, May 8, 2023.
    The water treatment facility and well for Lake Tamarisk in Desert Center, California, on Monday, May 8, 2023.
    (
    Alex Gould
    /
    Inside Climate News
    )

    But most people here say they see few of those benefits but endure all the consequences of that development—dust storms that threaten their health, construction noise, intense glare and heat from nearby panels, disruption of delicate ecosystems and the removal of plants that make desert life livable for other species, a drop in home values and the lack of water.

    They hope to have their concerns remedied with berms put up around the solar farms, financial compensation for negative impacts like wells going dry, help with air conditioning bills if the development increases the temperature in the area during the summer, and larger buffer zones between the projects and their homes.

    “They’re willing to spend millions to schmooze communities but they don’t want to spend money on the project to protect the community,” said Mark Carrington, who once worked as a biologist for the BLM. He discovered the community while roaming the desert during the pandemic and has helped lead its response to solar developments.

    While renewable energy projects break ground at record pace, rural communities and vital ecosystems important for biodiversity are getting left behind, said Kevin Emmerich, a cofounder of the environmental group Basin and Range Watch who previously worked for the National Park Service. Emmerich said the projects in the area are being approved despite impacts to the nearby Desert Dry Wash Woodlands, desert tortoise habitat, and the killing of ironwood trees and other vegetation that help hold together a vital ecosystem.

    Two white men wearing hats and sunglasses stand outside in the sun talking among themselves.
    Skip Pierce and Mark Carrington discuss how around 3 p.m. the light reflecting off of solar panels to the east reflect into the homes of Lake Tamarisk Desert Resort in Desert Center, California, on Monday, May 8, 2023. Alex Gould / Inside Climate News
    (
    Alex Gould
    /
    Inside Climate News
    )

    Ripped-out ironwood trees pepper the vistas at many of the solar sites, and trash fills boxes meant to provide homes for desert tortoises.

    The country may have a mandate to develop more renewable energy sources and companies may have made investments in future projects around Desert Center—Intersect Power’s substation to allow for more development, for example—but people in the communities should come first, Emmerich said. “You (the BLM) don’t work for these companies—you work for us,” he said.

    As the water here begins to disappear, residents worry the Lake Tamarisk wells are next. The community is entirely reliant on groundwater. If their wells run dry, all they could do is drill deeper or hope the drawdown of the aquifer is just a short-term impact of the nearby construction and not a sign of overdraft for the entire region.

    “I have not seen anybody mitigate, or even kind of highlight (water) as a major concern” for any solar projects in the Southwest, Mulvaney said. “I think, in general, people aren’t aware of this issue across the U.S. because most solar farms don’t require groundwater wells. This is a Western phenomenon to even use groundwater wells for these things.”

    But the development is unlikely to end anytime soon. So far around 20,000 acres of land has been developed in the solar energy zone the community falls within. Another 120,000 acres are available for solar development.

    And there’s another renewable electricity-generating elephant in the room that would demand even more of the aquifer’s water—the Eagle Crest Pump Storage Project.

    That project would generate 1,300 megawatts of power by pumping water uphill from one former mining pit to another and then releasing it back downhill to spin turbines that would generate electricity during periods of high demand. It would use 4,456 acre feet of water a year during construction and then 2,050 acre feet during operation, “more than ten times the operational groundwater of all other cumulative projects combined,” according to a water assessment of the basin for the Oberon solar project from the BLM.

    The Chuckwalla Valley’s aquifer below the BLM’s land has just over 2,000 acre feet of water left before the basin begins to be over-pumped, according to the recent water assessments. One of the proposed solar projects would use half of that if approved. Even under the BLM’s baseline assumptions of how much water there is, further build out of renewable energy projects could quickly sip away what is left.

    Not far from the Riverside East Solar Energy Zone, above a different aquifer, lies the town of Blythe. The Colorado River runs by it, and agricultural operations dot the landscape. Those farming operations use far more water than any solar development, and as California looks to use both less groundwater and Colorado River water, replacing those fields with solar is being viewed as a viable alternative, said Mulvaney and Ayre, with the Public Policy Institute of California’s Water Policy Center.

    As long as the federal government’s policy is to encourage utility-scale solar development on federal lands, places like Desert Center and Lake Tamarisk will continue to see projects nearby, Mulvaney said. And as long as that development is occurring, residents like Teresa Pierce and Mark Carrington will be pushing back.

    Flipping through her old college papers, Pierce realized her fight against the solar development wasn’t the first time conservation issues had caught her attention. In 1984, her first college English paper—for which she got an A+—was on the importance of conserving the nation’s national parks and wilderness areas.

    “We should stop and reflect for a moment on the reasons why we need parks and wilderness areas,” she wrote. “If indeed the reasons are to achieve oneness with our world and our universe then we better do the best we can to hold onto what we have.”

    Her goal now is to hold on to what she found at Lake Tamarisk—the beauty of the desert.

    This story was originally published by Grist. Sign up for Grist’s weekly newsletter here.

    Grist is a nonprofit, independent media organization dedicated to telling stories of climate solutions and a just future.

  • What happened to all that encampment energy?
    Encampments of tents and plywood in front of a red brick building.
    Royce Hall at UCLA in 2024, when students set up encampments to protest Israel's war in Gaza.

    Topline:

    In 2024, a wave of student encampments took over universities. Organizers protested Israel’s war in Gaza and called on their schools to divest from companies making money off the conflict. Those protests became a significant talking point in the run up to the 2024 presidential election. But now, two years later, the encampments have disappeared.

    Two nights in April 2024 changed Catherine Hamilton’s life.

    At the time, she was a student at the University of California, Los Angeles and a journalist at the student newspaper, Daily Bruin. Hamilton was tasked with covering the encampment students set up to protest Israel’s war in Gaza when it was attacked by a mob. The attackers set off fireworks and used bear spray and mace on student protesters while security hired by UCLA and campus police stood watching. The Los Angeles Police Department and California Highway Patrol were called in, but the violence did not stop.

    The attackers also assaulted Hamilton, sending her to the ER. She later tweeted that UCLA’s then-Chancellor Gene Block was responsible for the attack; she said Daily Bruin editors asked her to take down the tweet, which she did.

    The next night she watched as the university called in dozens of law enforcement agents wielding “less lethal” weapons to break up the encampment.

    Soon after, Hamilton quit the Daily Bruin and started her own publication, Poppy Press.

    Several lines of police in helmets and other riot gear face off with protesters, many in hard hats and masks
    A November 2024 report faulted UCLA for how it involved police in breaking up student protests.
    (
    Brian Feinzimer
    /
    LAist
    )

    “Watching those two nights, I could not stay silent anymore, and I knew that there was also a need for students who were able to write well and express the opinions of our whole movement,” Hamilton, now a law student in San Diego, told LAist. “I had to speak out against the university and their actions.”

    It’s been two years since an audit found UCLA had a series of “shortcomings, performance failures, systems breakdown, and campus safety issues” that led to that fateful police intervention months prior. And in the intervening months, the students on the other end of that treatment — like Hamilton — have been injured, doxxed, suspended and some tried for misdemeanors.

    LAist spoke to a cross section of those students, who nevertheless maintained that while the encampments are gone, the protests and advocacy for Palestinian rights continues in other ways.

    Why students built encampments, and why they stopped

    In 2024, a wave of activism overtook college campuses in protest of Israel’s war in Gaza, which started after the October 7, 2023 attack on Israel by Hamas. Students and faculty called on their universities to divest from companies doing business with Israel. They pitched tents, erected barriers around the encampments, flew the Palestinian flag and spent their days with healing circles and teach-ins related to the cause.

    But soon after, college campuses came down hard on the protesters. Dozens of people were arrested at the University of Southern California and UC Irvine — and over 200 people were arrested at UCLA.

    A recent report from the ACLU and Amnesty International USA alleges UCLA was among a handful of universities where administrators came down particularly hard on protesters, violating free speech laws and imposing severe punishments on students, faculty and staff who expressed support for Palestinian rights. The universities’ responses “made it easier for the Trump administration to crack down on student activism, causing long-term damage to higher education,” the report’s authors said.

    In an emailed statement, a spokesperson for UCLA told LAist, “UCLA supports the right of students to express their views, including through peaceful protest and advocacy on issues they care deeply about. Our responsibility is to protect free expression while ensuring a safe and welcoming environment for everyone on campus. UCLA’s policies apply equally to all members of our community, regardless of the views they express.”

    Students who were involved in anti-war and Palestinian advocacy have lost job offers, they’ve been doxxed and they’ve been investigated by the federal government.

    The universities and the Trump administration’s actions, the report said, have “profoundly chilled student speech and advocacy, resulting in a steep decline in protests and a less visible protest movement on campuses across the country.”

    Students from MIT, Harvard University and others rally at a protest encampment at MIT's Kresge Lawn in Cambridge, Massachusetts on Monday.
    Students from MIT, Harvard University and others rally at a protest encampment at MIT's Kresge Lawn in Cambridge, Massachusetts.
    (
    Scott Eisen
    /
    Getty Images
    )

    Uma Jayakumar, a professor of higher education and policy at the University of California, Riverside, said that while the report can quantify a decline in protests, what it doesn’t capture is how movements go underground, as students build community with like-minded people.

    “That work that was initiated doesn't go away because the encampments were shut down. It has a life of its own, and it continues,” Jayakumar said.

    She drew parallels with the student organizers today and Black teachers during segregation who took their movement underground because they were policed by white administrators.

    “The people that choose to be a part of that space are having a liberatory experience within a largely oppressive institutional space, and [these] spaces coexist,” Jayakumar said.

    New iteration of Palestinian activism

    For Raeva Mv, a current student at UCLA who was involved in the encampment protest, the work has not stopped. Students are frightened to protest, she said, but the activism has taken another form.

    It is not just “big explosions of energy and of pressure that happen in things like a rally or an encampment or a funeral march, like the ones that we've done at UCLA,” she said.

    Instead, she said, students are building a strategic movement, bringing in people who watched the encampments in 2024 and realized there was “something wrong” in the university’s response, people who watched videos out of Gaza and wanted to do more. That work has looked like documentary screenings and bringing people who volunteered in Gaza to speak at events.

    “We have seen absolutely no deviation or bend from the university in the favor of the Palestinian people because it's so deeply entrenched with Zionism. What we have seen change is in student opinion,” Mv said.

    Mv has one quarter left at UCLA. She has spent most of her time at the university with a hold on her student account because of pending student code of conduct charges; she was also banned from campus. All that time she couldn’t be in classrooms, she spent organizing around Palestinian rights. The university’s punishments, she said, “emboldened her.”

    During UCLA’s 2026 Welcome Week, Mv said, she recruited for multiple organizations that touch on Palestinian rights.

    “We've seen more interest than ever,” she said. “There are dozens and dozens of people filling [out] our interest forms, talking to us about how they're excited to mobilize and to organize around Palestine.”

    Organizing around Palestinian rights has shifted her life trajectory, Mv said. Now she wants to work at a place more clearly aligned with her values.

    “The university, by threatening things like my education, threatening things like my career, or threatening things like my physical health and physical safety, it made me realize how fickle those things are and how contingent those things are on enacting violence on other people,” Mv told LAist.

    UCLA declined to provide further comment.

    Hamilton said her experiences have made her appreciate the value of journalism more.

    “There's a lot of news organizations where that doesn't fly, and you're not allowed to do that, and we saw so many reporters getting fired or let go from their papers because they were speaking out against the genocide in Gaza,” Hamilton said. “But that's ultimately not a place that I would want to work anyway.”

    Building bridges through other struggles

    For Malik Alrefai, it was a “burning need for justice” that led him to get involved in UC Irvine’s encampment.

    When UC Irvine’s encampment went up, Alrefai called his parents in Jordan. They cautioned him not to get involved, not to get into trouble. He listened to them — but not for long.

    Alrefai’s grandmother was forced out of the West Bank in 1947 and 1948, during what Palestinians call Nakba or catastrophe. An Israeli soldier shot his grandmother in the knee, and with no access to hospitals or medical care, she grew up with what he calls a “deformed knee.” Those stories are part of who he is.

    On the day the students were commemorating the Nakba on campus, Alrefai was lifting weights in the gym when a university-wide alert went out about a “violent” protest.

    A group of protestors stands on campus, many holding up their fingers in a peace sign.
    Protestors gathered at the UC Irvine campus.
    (
    Courtesy Amir Mertaban
    )

     ”Given I have read a history book on how violently student movements have been suppressed in the United States … It wasn't difficult to put two and two together and figure out where it would go from there,” Alrefai said.

    He said he made peace with his parents “in his head” and headed over to where the encampment was set up. “There is finally a global conversation that recognized the existence of something named Palestine,” Alrefai noted.

    He was eventually detained and charged with a misdemeanor. His next trial date is set for January. Alrefai has no regrets about joining the protesters.

    “I think the regret would have been if I walked away that day,” he said.

    Alrefai’s advocacy has not stopped. On his Substack, he writes about the connections between ramped-up immigration raids in the United States and the policing of Palestinians. It’s easy for people to empathize with someone when they are able to make connections to other struggles, he said.

    University values inspire activism

    Hasan Mirza was president of UCLA’s Muslim Student Association during the encampment. He is a third-generation Bruin.

    He's now a medical school student,

     ”We were there to be a part of an education that instilled these core values of ethics, of empathy, of excellence,” he said. “When you really try to internalize those, it was just plain as day that something as significant as ethnic cleansing and genocide is just not something that you can really feel comfortable being silent about.”

    He said he’s disillusioned with the institution he once held in so much regard. Mirza was present at the encampment the night the mob attacked it and felt let down by university officials and law enforcement.

    When he applied to med school, he said, he grappled with feeling  ”thrown under the bus and stigmatized for speaking for a cause that I found very important.” He wanted to talk about what drives his empathy and compassion but felt institutions didn’t value that.

    Mirza said he wanted his “convictions and values” to come through in his graduate school application. He said he tweaked his messaging and “just tried to portray myself in the most honest light and I'm very glad that it worked out and I am where I am.”

    Mirza wouldn’t change anything about his advocacy for Palestinian rights.

    “I  think that the only thing I would do differently is I would invest a lot more resources in the community around us instead of trying to prove that the university was what we thought it was,” he said.

    Driven by moral convictions

    If anyone understands how student protesters move forward, it is Asaad Traina. Traina, now an internal medicine and addiction medicine physician, was part of the group infamously dubbed the Irvine 11. Traina and his fellow students were arrested and charged when they disrupted a speech by Michael Oren, then-Israeli ambassador to the United States, to accuse him of war crimes.

     ”The district attorney, who was Tony Rackauckas at the time, charged all of us with two misdemeanors,” Traina told LAist. “It completely changed a lot of things about my life, changed the trajectory.”

    At the time, Traina was applying to medical school. Of the 16 schools he applied to, he only got into one, despite having a “competitive application.”

    Students now have it much harder, he said. While he had a criminal record, plus the case made national headlines, it was before the era of social media and websites that track protesters, like Canary Mission. Traina said he spoke to some students at Harvard University who had a billboard with their names and faces on it.

    “I never had to deal with anything like that, like the very aggressive kind of sinister level of doxxing that they're facing now,” he said.

    Despite the arrest and charges changing his life, Traina — who has since had his record expunged — says he has no regrets and that he learned a lot from that experience.

     ”As I get older, I have three kids now, I have a family, I don't wanna be arrested for protests,” Traina said. “But at the same time, I hope I don't give up that kind of courage and willingness to stand up for what's right, which is why I am very inspired by the students and all of their activism now that I think is having a much bigger impact than we ever imagined possible.”

  • Sponsored message
  • Agency requests drones and 40mm projectiles
    A close up of a large projectile weapon being held in two hands.
    A 40mm less-lethal weapon fires foam, flash bang or pepper powder-filled rounds.

    Topline:

    The University of California Regents gave the UCLA police department authorization Tuesday to purchase an array of additional military equipment, adding to their collection of patrol rifles, 40 mm launchers and pepperball round ball projectiles.

    The equipment UCLA PD requested includes:

    • 50 40mm projectiles, which are sponge rounds (intended to be “non-lethal”) fired at around 200 mph with its impact similar to being hit with a golf ball
    • Six drones
    • 1,950 pepperball projectiles, some of which include a “harmless” powder typically used for training

    Why it matters: A federal judge banned the Los Angeles Police Department from using 40 mm projectiles earlier this year.

    Richard Mejia, a spokesperson for UCLA PD, said the 40mm projectiles “are less-lethal tools intended to provide officers with additional options when responding to potentially dangerous situations. Their use is governed by state law, including AB 48, and department policy.”

    The UCLA purchase authorization drew condemnation from staff and faculty, over 400 of whom signed a petition urging against the purchase and deployment of the weapons.

    “I think it's unconscionable that University of California police are allowed to use a weapon which is banned in the LAPD,” said Michael Chwe, a political science professor at UCLA who started the petition. “It's unconscionable that students who go to the University of California are exposed to a greater degree of danger and a lower level of safety than citizens of Los Angeles.”

    The University of California Regents gave the UCLA police department authorization Tuesday to purchase an array of additional military equipment, adding to their collection of patrol rifles, 40mm launchers and pepperball projectiles.

    The equipment UCLA PD requested includes:

    • 50 40mm projectiles, which are sponge rounds (intended to be “non-lethal”) fired at around 200 mph, with an impact similar to being hit with a golf ball. 
    • Six drones
    • 1,950 pepperball projectiles, some of which include a “harmless” powder typically used for training. 

    Richard Mejia, a spokesperson for UCLA PD, said the 40mm projectiles “are less-lethal tools intended to provide officers with additional options when responding to potentially dangerous situations. Their use is governed by state law, including AB 48, and department policy.”

    A federal judge banned the Los Angeles Police Department from using 40mm projectiles at protests earlier this year.

    Staff and faculty are concerned about the weapons purchases

    The purchase authorization drew condemnation from staff and faculty, over 400 of whom signed a petition urging against the purchase and deployment of the weapons.

    “I think it's unconscionable that University of California police are allowed to use a weapon which is banned in the LAPD,” said Michael Chwe, a political science professor at UCLA who started the petition. “It's unconscionable that students who go to the University of California are exposed to a greater degree of danger and a lower level of safety than citizens of Los Angeles.”

    Chwe said in 2024 that a student, Jakob Johnson, had to spend two days in the hospital after he was shot with 40mm launchers. He is currently suing the university because he says he suffered from heart and lung injuries. LAist has reached out to Johnson for comment.

    “ The main purpose of the University of California is to educate people, so I don't know why we have this kind of quasi-military force on our campuses now,” Chwe said.

    Drone approval comes amid statewide pushback against them

    With the Regents' green light, UCLA PD can purchase six additional drones, bringing the agency’s stash to a total of nine. Five of the drones, the police department said, will be used “to reach over 95% of all priority police, fire, and EMS calls” as well as protect athlete residences during the 2028 Olympic and Paralympic Games. The other four will be used for training purposes.

    UCLA PD purchased three drones ("unmanned aircraft systems") worth $216,543 in 2025.

    Because of Assembly Bill 481, law enforcement agencies have to request permission to purchase military equipment such as drones. But that has also triggered wide-scale pushback from people concerned about warrantless searches and invasion of privacy.

    UC student regent Miguel Craven said during the Regents meeting on Tuesday that students have voiced concerns about drones being used for surveillance purposes.

    Mejia said the drones will be used as part of a “Drone as First Responder program to keep UCLA safe.”

    He added that the program includes “privacy protections and operational restrictions, and drones will not be used for random surveillance or without a legitimate law enforcement purpose.”

    “Recordings will be retained in accordance with applicable laws and department policy," Mejia added. "Any sharing of footage with other law enforcement agencies must be lawful and consistent with department policy. UCPD also remains subject to California law, including the California Values Act and TRUST Act, which restrict cooperation with federal immigration enforcement."

  • Gov. Newsom's policy recommendations
    The logo for "OPEN AI" is seen beyond a blur of several people in blues and white in the foreground.
    Attendees gather at the OpenAI DevDay 2026 conference in San Francisco on Sept. 29, 2026

    Topline:

    Gov. Gavin Newsom Wednesday released a wide-ranging set of policy recommendations to mitigate risks from artificial intelligence, including by letting state officials order an immediate emergency shutdown of AI systems they deem dangerous. Other recommendations would mandate that independent auditors test AI models and establish safety and security standards.

    Why it matters: The shutdown power, popularly known as a “kill switch,” would apply when companies like ChatGPT maker OpenAI and Claude maker Anthropic refuse to take action to contain systems that go awry.

    Why now: The recommendations were drawn up by a panel of experts brought together by Newsom earlier this fall, following high-profile cyberattacks by AI agents on governments, banks, and private companies.

    The backstory: California is home to some of the largest AI companies in the world, and the California Legislature has passed more bills to regulate AI than any other state in the country. Newsom signed dozens of bills passed by the California Legislature into law in September to do things like protect kids, workers, and people living near data centers from AI and related impacts.

    What's next: The recommendations come the same week as a lawsuit by Attorney General Rob Bonta against OpenAI in an attempt to hold the company legally responsible for cybersecurity attacks carried out by agents made by the company.

    Gov. Gavin Newsom Wednesday released a wide-ranging set of policy recommendations to mitigate risks from artificial intelligence, including by letting state officials order an immediate emergency shutdown of AI systems they deem dangerous.

    Other recommendations would mandate that independent auditors test AI models and establish safety and security standards.

    The shutdown power, popularly known as a “kill switch,” would apply when companies like ChatGPT maker OpenAI and Claude maker Anthropic refuse to take action to contain systems that go awry.

    The recommendations were drawn up by a panel of experts brought together by Newsom earlier this fall, following high-profile cyberattacks by AI agents on governments, banks, and private companies.

    The governor touted them as a blueprint for state legislation during a recent visit to Washington, according to a report in Politico. Newsom, who is widely expected to mount a presidential run, said the state is filling a vacuum left by a lack of AI rules at the federal level. “Instead of protecting the public, Donald Trump shrugs his shoulders and leaves AI regulation up to the companies themselves,” he said in a press release announcing the recommendations.

    California is home to some of the largest AI companies in the world, and the California Legislature has passed more bills to regulate AI than any other state in the country. Newsom signed dozens of bills passed by the California Legislature into law in September to do things like protect kids, workers, and people living near data centers from AI and related impacts. He also accelerated implementation of laws to create an AI auditor registry and set standards for auditors. Legislators can propose new bills when they return to Sacramento on December 7.

    The recommendations come the same week as a lawsuit by Attorney General Rob Bonta against OpenAI in an attempt to hold the company legally responsible for cybersecurity attacks carried out by agents made by the company.

    The group also recommends the state of California:

    • License auditors — known as independent verification organizations — and have the power to revoke the licenses of those who fail to maintain sufficient independence or technical expertise. Auditors are “under soft pressure to maintain good relationships with the [AI] labs so that they want to continue to work with us,” a staffer at auditing nonprofit METR, Rif Saurous, said during a California Senate hearing last month. 
    • Consider having state officials assign evaluations to auditors instead of AI companies hiring auditors  in order to maintain independence. 
    • Fund CalCompute, a public cloud initiative intended to provide equitable access to AI, with a surcharge on fees AI companies pay to auditors. Governor-elect Xavier Becerra supported CalCompute funding during his campaign.
    • Expand existing protections for AI whistleblowers to include contractors and former employees.
    • Expand reporting of AI safety incidents to government agencies and shorten the window to report critical safety incidents to 48 hours from 15 days.
    • Allow government limits on the use of AI to design AI, since some experts believe this practice makes systems more dangerous.
    • Require developers to disclose the amount of computing resources they’re using to automate AI development.
    • Require developers of large AI systems to demonstrate the ability to shut down models in emergencies.
    • Establish state standards for safety, security, and transparency while referring to national and international standards.

    The four-person panel of experts includes Alondra Nelson, who ran the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy during the Biden administration; Stanford University professor Rob Reich, who studies the governance of science and technology; ; former Google and Twitter executive Jason Goldman, who was the first White House Chief Digital Officer; and Gillian Hadfield, a John Hopkins professor who studies various issues related to AI.

    Becerra said in a written statement that he will move quickly with the Legislature to put “full incident reporting and real shutdown authority into law.”

    Anthropic, which makes the Claude AI system, is encouraged to see the report move the conversation forward on issues like the independent evaluation of AI models, according to the company’s chief global affairs officer, Tino Cuéllar.

    “We will continue working with leaders in California and throughout the world to make sure we keep making progress on these issues at a critical time,” he wrote.

    The recommendations by the governor’s panel and by auditors in recent weeks provide fodder to an incoming class of lawmakers in the California Legislature and Congress.

    State Senator Scott Wiener, who wrote a state law to mitigate catastrophic AI dangers and was recently elected to take Nancy Pelosi’s seat in Congress, has pledged to introduce AI safety regulation after he’s sworn in.

    State law currently defines catastrophic risk as a single event capable of killing more than 50 people or $1 billion in theft or property damage through a cyber attack or activity of an autonomous system. The report out today focuses only on catastrophic risk and does not explore ways to protect people from other AI harms, such as automated discrimination, job loss, or threats to the safety or mental health of children. Coauthors of the recommendations argue that building a system for credentialed auditors to test models for catastrophic risk will make it easier to evaluate models for other forms of harm.

    Recommendations released today are the latest ordered by Newsom since the start of the age of generative AI. A late 2023 executive order required the state compile and assessment of the opportunities and risks associated with government use of generative AI. A subsequent state report assessed the impact of generative AI on vulnerable and marginalized communities. A June 2025 expert panel report also concluded that in order to balance innovation and safety, the AI industry needs evaluations by an independent, outside party.

    This article was originally published on CalMatters and was republished under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives license.

  • Two sides to meet again Friday
    Shipping containers of a variety of colors sit on a dock. Several colorful ships are seen in the background, moored at the dock.
    Shipping containers being loaded or unloaded at the Port of Long Beach in Long Beach Thursday, Oct. 1, 2020

    Topline:

    A strike is looming Saturday at the ports of Long Beach and Los Angeles, threatening to disrupt the busiest year on record for the port complex.

    Why it matters: Shipping companies and a small security workers union have been negotiating for more than a year after their labor contract expired in July 2025. Union members have already voted to authorize a strike and “with little-to-no movement” on talks, the union has said it’s unwilling to work under the expired contract past Friday night, according to a statement from the Pacific Maritime Association, which represents the shipping companies at the port complex.

    The backstory: The PMA said it has offered a package that includes wage increases and pension improvements. Recently, federal mediators joined the negotiations, but the union’s demands “have not materially changed since negotiations began,” the PMA’s statement read. A spokesperson for ILWU Local 26 did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

    What's next: The two sides are set to meet again on Friday, according to the PMA. If the strike happens, thousands of longshore workers, clerks and foremen “are expected to honor its picket line, severely disrupting cargo movement at the nation’s largest port complex,” the PMA said in its statement.

    A strike is looming Saturday at the ports of Long Beach and Los Angeles, threatening to disrupt the busiest year on record for the port complex.

    Shipping companies and a small security workers union have been negotiating for more than a year after their labor contract expired in July 2025. Union members have already voted to authorize a strike and “with little-to-no movement” on talks, the union has said it’s unwilling to work under the expired contract past Friday night, according to a statement from the Pacific Maritime Association, which represents the shipping companies at the port complex.

    The private security workers, called watchmen, patrol terminals and check IDs and credentials of people coming and going. They are represented by International Longshore and Warehouse Union’s Local 26 and make up just 2% of the ILWU’s workforce at the ports. But their work takes place across six terminals, and those terminals handle about 85% of cargo at Long Beach and 33% at Los Angeles.

    If the strike happens, thousands of longshore workers, clerks and foremen “are expected to honor its picket line, severely disrupting cargo movement at the nation’s largest port complex,” the PMA said in its statement.

    The PMA said it has offered a package that includes wage increases and pension improvements. Recently, federal mediators joined the negotiations, but the union’s demands “have not materially changed since negotiations began,” the PMA’s statement read.

    A spokesperson for ILWU Local 26 did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

    The two sides are set to meet again on Friday, according to the PMA.

    A strike would throw a major wrench in any shipments. The ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach move more than 31% of the country’s containerized goods. Both ports moved record amounts of cargo in September.

    This story first appeared on Long Beach Post.