Sponsored message
Logged in as
Audience-funded nonprofit news
radio tower icon laist logo
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
Subscribe
  • Listen Now Playing Listen

The Brief

The most important stories for you to know today
  • State has missed chances to stop it
    This illustration features a grey hand holding an EBT card that's dissolving into pixelated bits.

    Topline:

    Amid pandemic, California pushed off a plan to prevent EBT theft. Now $10 million a month is stolen from the poor, at taxpayer expense.

    The backstory: The COVID-19 pandemic hit, and with it would come an influx of public aid and a tsunami of benefits theft that hit recipients of everything from stimulus checks to unemployment aid. The state, facing a potential economic downturn, in the spring of 2020 abandoned a $565,000 plan to bolster EBT theft investigations, according to Social Services’ public budget documents.

    By the time the Department of Social Services quietly resurrected the plan two years later in April 2022, California was losing nearly $2 million a month to EBT thieves, according to figures released by the department. Now thieves were also stealing food stamps, a benefit used by nearly three million California households, and purchasing expensive items like pallets of energy drinks to resell.

    Read on .. for a deeper examination into the issue.

    In May 2019, police entered a 12th-floor room at a Residence Inn near the Los Angeles International Airport and found various tools for credit card theft and duffel bags holding more than $930,000 in cash.

    The room had been rented by Jawuan Gibson, who eventually pled guilty in Sacramento County Superior Court to grand theft and identity theft.

    The case caught the attention of the California Department of Social Services. Gibson had been accused of sending mass text message scams to trick cash aid recipients into giving away their Electronic Benefits Transfer card information. He then stole their money, withdrawing the cash from duplicated cards.

    At the time, the amount reported stolen from EBT users was in the tens of thousands of dollars a month — a small fraction of the millions the department sent out in cash assistance each month that year to more than 350,000 poor families. When recipients were victimized, they could generally get the money back, albeit with some delay.

    But officials feared the case indicated more theft was coming. So in early 2020, the department came up with a plan to hire investigators specifically focused on EBT theft.

    Separately, a group of county welfare fraud investigators said they asked the social services department to add security chips to EBT cards, a layer of fraud protection commercial bank customers had already been enjoying on debit and credit cards for years.

    The state did neither.

    The COVID-19 pandemic hit, and with it would come an influx of public aid and a tsunami of benefits theft that hit recipients of everything from stimulus checks to unemployment aid. The state, facing a potential economic downturn, in the spring of 2020 abandoned a $565,000 plan to bolster EBT theft investigations, according to Social Services’ public budget documents.

    By the time the Department of Social Services quietly resurrected the plan two years later in April 2022, California was losing nearly $2 million a month to EBT thieves, according to figures released by the department. Now thieves were also stealing food stamps, a benefit used by nearly three million California households, and purchasing expensive items like pallets of energy drinks to resell.

    Both cash and food benefits are largely federally funded, but California must pay out of its own funds to reimburse theft victims.

    The delayed plan raises questions about whether the state missed an opportunity to stem the theft. The Department of Social Services said it responded appropriately with some security measures to the Sacramento County case, but that it only prevented scams, while theft skyrocketed thanks to fraudsters’ use of hidden devices to steal card numbers, known as skimming.

    Between July 2021 and this March, taxpayers paid $87 million for this theft. Throughout the current fiscal year that began in July, the department is expecting to pay $178 million, according to budget documents.

    In 2019 and 2020, lawmakers introduced a bill requiring social services to examine weaknesses in the EBT system for online transactions and come up with solutions. Both years the bill died in the Assembly Appropriations Committee via the suspense file process by which lawmakers kill numerous bills in one hearing without explanation.

    When Gov. Gavin Newsom’s administration committed this year to making California the first state to use EBT cards with chips, public benefits were being stolen to the tune of $10 million a month.

    Chip cards, which payments industry experts say could significantly cut the thefts, would allow recipients to use EBT cards without being as vulnerable to their card numbers being stolen. The state has earmarked $50 million for the upgrades. The soonest those upgrades will go into effect is May 2024, at least six months from now.

    Few policies in place to protect theft victims

    Guadalupe Rosales found herself in a panic on a recent Saturday morning.

    It was the second of the month, the day California typically deposits cash assistance onto the El Monte single mother’s EBT card. Rosales checked her account in preparation for a trip to the ATM. But the money, all $1,300, was gone, withdrawn by someone else at an ATM in another city.

    Rosales relies on CalWorks, the state’s cash assistance program for poor families, to support her three children as they get back on their feet after experiencing domestic violence.

    It was the second time Rosales’ benefits had been stolen. She had bills to pay and a car to fill up to take the kids to school. Her oldest son had senior portraits to take, and she could barely afford tickets to his football games.

    Worse yet, it was Labor Day Weekend. By the time the Los Angeles County welfare office opened the following Tuesday for her to request a reimbursement, rent and utilities were past due. She’s since gotten the money replaced, but not before paying a slew of late fees and borrowing money.

    “I feel like I’m in more debt than I was,” she said.

    We told them, ‘You need to chip the cards now.’
    — Glenn Allen, legislative and policy chairman, Welfare Fraud Investigators Association

    California initially appeared to be at the forefront of protecting public benefits recipients.

    In 2013, the state began reimbursing welfare recipients who have their benefits stolen electronically. In 2020 it was the first state to extend reimbursements for victims of food stamp theft even if they didn’t lose their EBT card.

    That’s the case for most EBT theft, investigators say. Victims are either scammed into giving away their card numbers, or the numbers are stolen through a method called skimming, which involves installing a hidden device at checkout counters, ATMs or gas pumps to record the card numbers of those who swipe the magnetic stripes.

    In December 2018, the welfare fraud investigators association’s legislative and policy chairman Glenn Allen said the group met with Social Services leaders and asked the state to add security chips to EBT cards, but were told that would be “too expensive.”

    “We told them, ‘You need to chip the cards now,’” Allen said.

    Meeting notes provided by the association say the group’s then-president Guy Christian told officials including then-director Will Lightbourne that the cards needed security upgrades. Among the issues they discussed, according to the association’s notes: the department’s concern about growing “cloning/skimming of cards” and “the lack of sophistication such as ‘chipped’ cards.”

    California Department of Social Services spokesperson Jason Montiel declined to comment on the meeting. He said chips were not considered prior to 2023 because earlier waves of EBT theft were primarily theft from scams, such as the one in the Sacramento County case. Skimming targeting EBT cards, he said, “did not fully emerge until fall of 2021.”

    In the summer of 2019, the Department of Social Services gave a presentation at a national conference about the rising concern of EBT theft. It cited two cases — one in Sonoma County and the Gibson case, which was cracked by Sacramento County welfare fraud investigators and the Department of Justice, who teamed up to find patterns in the victims’ accounts and watch ATMs where withdrawals were being made.

    A copy of the presentation, obtained by CalMatters, spells out what the department saw as the problem: Numerous state and federal policies designed to curb fraud in the welfare system were all directed at either the government or public benefits recipients. There weren’t enough policies to prevent “third-party fraud,” in which the recipients are the victims.

    “The theft of benefits by those outside the system has not been a significant part of the welfare fraud prevention framework,” the presentation said.

    The department recommended adding three-digit card verification value codes to EBT cards, strengthening the EBT call center’s security and limiting when PINs can be changed.

    The following January, the department proposed spending $565,000 to hire four investigators to examine EBT theft statewide.

    “These occurrences involving EBT theft could be mitigated using data analytics and may have been identified earlier if (the California Department of Social Services) had the staff dedicated to monitoring suspicious EBT transactions,” the proposal said. “Due to the lack of investigative resources statewide, including county, state and federal investigators, there is an operational need for California to employ its own investigators to prevent, identify, and help recover these significant losses of public assistance funds.”

    In an emailed response to questions from CalMatters, Montiel said the social services department dropped the plan a few months later because of a projected revenue shortfall due to the pandemic, which prompted departments statewide to cut budget requests.

    But the department did not resubmit the plan later that year when it proposed other new spending, or the following year when revenues came in higher than expected — even as it issued more benefits to recipients’ cards thanks to pandemic federal aid. Montiel did not answer why.

    The investigative unit was proposed again in April 2022 and approved by the Legislature. Montiel said the team was created in March 2023, hiring a supervisor, two officers and an investigator. It’s currently “providing intelligence and support to local, state, and federal investigation teams and is assisting with detecting and deterring theft,” he wrote.

    These occurrences involving EBT theft could be mitigated using data analytics and may have been identified earlier if (the CA Department of Social Services) had the staff dedicated to monitoring suspicious EBT transactions.
    — 2019 EBT theft proposal by the Department of Social Services

    Gerry Bonilla, division chief of program compliance at the Los Angeles County Department of Public Social Services, said an earlier statewide effort could have helped counties.

    Bonilla’s welfare fraud investigative staff primarily handle cases involving recipients getting benefits for which they’re ineligible, which he said “is not very widespread.” They investigate 800 to 900 of these cases a month, “most of which come back negative,” and look into them by parsing through each client’s income statements and other paperwork.

    By contrast, Bonilla said anywhere from 4,000 to 10,000 Los Angeles County residents now claim their benefits were stolen each month. In recent arrests, police point to organized crime groups with international ties.

    “It would have certainly been helpful to have a team deployed to that,” Bonilla said. “Our investigators are not equipped to handle that type of investigation.”

    Other investigators said they haven’t seen the department take a major role in theft prevention, despite many cases that cross county lines.

    Heather Tallent, a board member of the California Welfare Fraud Investigators Association and supervisor of the welfare fraud division in the Ventura County District Attorney's Office, said she receives historical data from the state of ATMs where cards are cashed out, but less help with live surveillance of suspicious transactions.

    “From what I can see, there's no proactive investigative response to skimming,” Tallent said. “I haven't seen it. And it's not necessarily a criticism, it may be a resource issue for (social services).”

    Not everyone believes social services departments should beef up their law enforcement arms. The term “welfare fraud” is fraught among advocates for the poor, evoking 1990s-era stereotypes about people cheating to get public assistance that many anti-poverty organizations blame for burdensome bureaucratic hurdles for people to get aid and unnecessary scrutiny on recipients.

    Earlier this year, advocates supported the state dropping a requirement for EBT theft victims to file a police report in order to get their benefits reimbursed, which welfare fraud investigators said was a bad idea.

    Upgrades at least six months away

    With a more generous social safety net than most states, California has been particularly hard-hit in the EBT theft wave.

    Thieves who had initially targeted the simple debit cards of state stimulus check recipients moved on to the similarly vulnerable EBT cards, said David Babcock, a senior investigator on the L.A. County District Attorney’s Cyber Investigation Response Team.

    “Some of these crews that were deploying these skimming techniques started to recognize that the only cards they’re gonna get successfully skimmed are cards without chip technology because people still have to swipe those cards,” Babcock said, calling EBT cards “the last cards without chip technology” in the state.

    The social services department has been slow to release more detailed and up-to-date monthly tallies of the theft in response to public records requests from CalMatters, saying in September that it would not produce the data until December.

    “These are the most vulnerable people in our community,” Bonilla said. “It’s really just mushroomed.”

    Some of these crews that were deploying these skimming techniques started to recognize that the only cards they’re gonna get successfully skimmed are cards without chip technology because people still have to swipe those cards.
    — David Babcock, senior investigator, L.A. County District Attorney Cyber Investigation response Team

    In October, the county board of supervisors approved creating its own investigative unit in the D.A.’s office just to focus on this type of theft.

    Chip card upgrades are more than six months away at the earliest.

    In the meantime, the Department of Social Services said it will launch a mobile app this fall, ebtEDGE, that would allow cardholders to freeze their cards or block online or out-of-state transactions.

    Until the chip cards arrive, local departments have shifted staff to process a flood of reimbursement requests while recipients try to remain vigilant, changing their PINs and checking their accounts. The state this year has also budgeted more than $30 million in administrative funding for counties to process reimbursements.

    Federal rules also in play

    In June 2022, the department added the three-digit CVV codes, which Montiel said cut scamming theft by 90%. It was no match against skimming, and overall benefits theft has only skyrocketed since then.

    Chips have been developed since the 1990s and were common in Europe before being widely adopted in the U.S. eight years ago. That’s when the card companies Mastercard and Visa set a deadline for American banks to issue chip cards and merchants to accept them, or bear the liability for theft and fraud.

    Though credit card fraud still happens, Jason Bohrer, executive director of the payments industry group Secure Technology Alliance, said it’s largely done by getting access to users’ accounts online through methods far more sophisticated than skimming. Adding chips to credit cards in the U.S. has nearly eliminated fraud that takes advantage of users’ physical cards, he said.

    Other California departments have already taken the security measure. In 2021 the Employment Development Department said it would start rolling out chip cards for unemployment benefits recipients.

    But no state yet puts chips on their EBT cards. Payments experts say it’s always been a cost-benefits consideration.

    “Until the cost of the fraud outweighs the cost of issuance, there's not a lot of incentive to make the transition,” said Tracy Kitten, director of fraud and security at the financial security firm Javelin Strategy & Research.

    Federal regulations direct states to use a payments industry standard that limits the delivery of food benefits to cards with magnetic stripes only, Montiel said. The U.S. Department of Agriculture and California are working to modify the restrictions to allow for chip and tap cards, both departments said.

    Until the cost of the fraud outweighs the cost of issuance, there's not a lot of incentive to make the transition.
    — Tracy Kitten, director of fraud and security, financial security firm Javelin Strategy & Research

    There are also back-end technological upgrades needed before chip cards are rolled out, because EBT transactions run through different systems than commercial banks.

    “Incorporating chip cards requires significant changes to the underlying infrastructure on which the EBT system is built,” Montiel wrote. “Without these underlying, back-end technological upgrades, a transaction using a chip/tap EBT card would fail.”

    In one other response to the theft wave, California fell behind.

    A year ago, Congress passed a spending bill to reimburse states for paying recipients back up to two months of stolen food benefits. California pays theft victims back, but only for one month.

    California in October became the last state in the country to get its reimbursement plan approved by the USDA. Other states had been approved as early as February. The federally-paid plan goes into effect in California in December. Neither federal nor state agency would explain what caused the delay.

    It’s frustrated recipients like Marshall Epstein who have been victims of theft multiple months. Epstein, a Los Angeles resident, said he had $1,400 worth of food assistance funds on his EBT card when it was skimmed earlier this year. After filing a report he only got about $200 back.

    He scans the news frequently, waiting to find out when he’ll get a card with a security chip.

    “I'm not looking for extra money, just to get my benefits back,” he said.

  • A safe path for animals
    Aerial view of a wildlife crossing under construction over a multilane freeway, with planted vegetation on its deck and construction equipment at its edge.
    An aerial view shows the Wallis Annenberg Wildlife Crossing over U.S. Highway 101 in Agoura Hills, Calif., Wednesday, Nov. 11, 2026

    Topline:

    About 300,000 cars a day travel that stretch of the 101 in Agoura Hills, a small city surrounded by a patchwork of protected wildland that the new crossing will connect. Fencing along the freeway funnels animals to the crossing. The bridge, with a landscape that’s indistinguishable from surrounding hillsides, stretches 1,250 feet (380 meters) in two sections over the roadways to give animals hemmed in by urban sprawl a safe path to the nearby Santa Monica Mountains and beyond.

    The backstory: It is named the Wallis Annenberg Wildlife Crossing for the late philanthropist whose foundation donated $25 million toward the $114 million total budget. The cost ballooned from an initial $92 million, and the money came from donations from 6,000 members of the public, as well as grants from nonprofits and state funds set aside for conservation purposes. Leonardo DiCaprio was one of the earliest donors after a funding drive was launched a decade ago.

    Touring the world’s largest wildlife crossing, Beth Pratt stepped carefully through freshly planted native vegetation and held up her hand for silence.

    “Hear that? We’re listening to birdsong right now, on top of one of the busiest freeways in the U.S.!” a beaming Pratt, one of the project’s leaders, said excitedly. “That makes my heart glad.”

    The warbling was the latest sign that the bridge, spanning U.S. 101 and a feeder road about 35 miles (56 kilometers) northwest of downtown Los Angeles, is already in use by animals ahead of the official Dec. 2 opening ceremony.

    Just two weeks earlier, motion-sensor cameras captured a lone coyote believed to be the first mammal to make the trek safely across. Days after that momentous crossing, three juvenile coyotes were seen on camera playing in the brush beneath the 10-foot (3-meter) sound-dampening walls that line the span.

    “They don’t care about ribbon cuttings,” laughed Pratt, president of the nonprofit Wildlife Crossing Fund.

    About 300,000 cars a day travel that stretch of the 101 in Agoura Hills, a small city surrounded by a patchwork of protected wildland that the new crossing will connect. Fencing along the freeway funnels animals to the crossing.

    The bridge, with a landscape that’s indistinguishable from surrounding hillsides, stretches 1,250 feet (380 meters) in two sections over the roadways to give animals hemmed in by urban sprawl a safe path to the nearby Santa Monica Mountains and beyond.

    It is named the Wallis Annenberg Wildlife Crossing for the late philanthropist whose foundation donated $25 million toward the $114 million total budget. The cost ballooned from an initial $92 million, and the money came from donations from 6,000 members of the public, as well as grants from nonprofits and state funds set aside for conservation purposes. Leonardo DiCaprio was one of the earliest donors after a funding drive was launched a decade ago.

    Waiting for the cougars

    Pratt said for her the real official opening will be when a mountain lion, a species listed as threatened in California, finds its way to the overpass.

    The star of the campaign to build the bridge was the cougar — known as P-22 — an LA celebrity in its own right who traveled across freeways and made a home in a huge Los Angeles park. P-22, who was euthanized in 2022 after likely being hit by a car, became a symbol of the shrinking genetic diversity of wild animals that must remain all but trapped by sprawling development or risk becoming roadkill. Thousands attended a memorial service for him.

    Scientists tracking mountain lions fitted with GPS collars found over decades that roadways were largely confining animals in mountains that run along the Malibu coast and across the middle of Los Angeles to Griffith Park, where P-22 settled.

    During the tour last week, Pratt wore a shirt emblazoned with an image of the beloved cougar. She hopes to eventually erect a statue of P-22 on the side of the new bridge.

    Caged by concrete, killed by cars and sickened by rat poison, the isolated pumas risk inbreeding themselves into extinction, scientists and state wildlife officials say. A report just last week from the University of California, Davis, found that at least 780 mountain lions — or 18% of the state’s population — are killed by vehicles each year.

    “The story of P-22 was just so compelling,” said Mari Galloway, California program director for the nonprofit Wildlands Network. “We saw the peril in what happened to that particular cat. It was demonstrative of what these mountain lions are facing in this part of the landscape.”

    Galloway’s group, which was not involved in the Annenberg crossing, hopes the new bridge will spur the construction of many others across California and the nation. The Wildlands Network is working with state transportation officials in the early stages of planning a wildlife bridge for a stretch of highway in the Mojave Desert east of Los Angeles where bighorn sheep roam.

    Wildlife crossings — bridges and tunnels — are common in western Europe and Canada. A famous one in Banff National Park in Alberta spans the Trans-Canada Highway and is frequently used by bears, moose and elk.

    A large overpass in Colorado over Interstate 25, along with other mitigation efforts including underpasses and fencing, has contributed to a 91% decrease in wildlife collisions, that state’s parks and wildlife department announced in September.

    Hummingbirds, bees and spiders too

    Atop the Annenberg crossing, Anthony Deascentis, a field inspector for the California Department of Transportation, waved Pratt over to some scrub brush. He pointed out an orb-weaver spider, as big as a silver dollar, building an elaborate circular web.

    “There’s also a good amount of bees enjoying the native plants,” said Deascentis. In addition, he’s spotted an oak titmouse, sparrows and hummingbirds — further evidence that wildlife are taking to the new terrain even as crews using heavy machinery continued to fill in the landscape on the bridge’s south side.

    Jeff Sikich, a biologist for the National Park Service who collars and tracks cougars and other wild animals, said the next step will be to implant “biologgers” that will allow scientists to also monitor physiological data like heart rate, body temperature and activity levels. With that information, they’ll be able to tell if the animals are stressed while using the wildlife bridge, or “if they’re relaxed up there.”

    Sikich said in recent weeks scientists have detected multiple mammals in the hills nearby the new span, including bobcats, deer, gray foxes and a female mountain lion with two kittens.

    He said they’re “sniffing around,” hopefully getting ready to make the crossing.

  • Sponsored message
  • Contracts with Flock and Motorola canceled
    A camera on a pole has a small solar panel. The sky beyond is mostly filled with clouds.
    The Santa Ana City Council canceled its automated license plate reader (ALPR) contracts with Motorola Solutions and Flock Safety during its meeting Tuesday night.

    Topline:

    The Santa Ana City Council canceled its automated license plate reader contracts with Motorola Solutions and Flock Safety during its meeting Tuesday night. Staff were directed to immediately turn the cameras off.

    Why it matters: The move followed growing concerns over privacy and protecting immigrant communities from immigration enforcement.

    Read on … for details on Santa Ana’s contracts and what it’s looking into next.

    The Santa Ana City Council canceled its automated license plate reader contracts with Motorola Solutions and Flock Safety during its meeting Tuesday night. Staff was directed to immediately turn off the dozens of cameras.

    The council voted 6-0, with Councilmember Phil Bacerra absent, to end the agreements and asked staff to find out if a citywide ban on private businesses is enforceable.

    “It feels like, in a small way, the first step towards real accountability by moving forward and following the steps of other jurisdictions that have also canceled this contract,” Councilmember Jessie Lopez said at Tuesday’s meeting. “It's not just about canceling the contract; it is about shutting the cameras [down] tonight and removing them from our community as soon as possible.”

    The move followed growing concerns over privacy and protecting immigrant communities from immigration enforcement.

    What we know about the cameras

    The Santa Ana City Council approved spending more than $700,000 on the city’s automated license plate reader, or ALPR, program in May 2025. The Flock systems were up and running by September 2025 and Motorola’s in January.

    At least 365 Santa Ana Police Department officers had access to Motorola or Flock data in the last year, and 120 had access to both programs, according to an SAPD report. Internal audits showed that SAPD shared data with 217 outside California agencies through Flock and 165 outside agencies through Motorola.

    SAPD shared data with the El Cajon Police Department and the Northern California Regional Intelligence Center, according to the department’s report. Both ran searches or shared information from Santa Ana’s Flock data systems on behalf of multiple federal and out-of-state agencies. These types of data sharing by law enforcement are prohibited under California law.

    “The Santa Ana Police Department became aware of instances where NCRIC conducted searches, which included SAPD ALPR network(s), related to investigations associated to federal law enforcement agencies and the State of Washington,” the report states.

    Searches were not immigration enforcement-related, and no federal employees had access to the data, according to the report. However, the department opted to stop sharing data with the center in September.

    What could this mean for private businesses? 

    It’s not clear if the city of Santa Ana can enforce an outright ban that also dictates whether private business owners can use the technology. But it’s an interesting question, City Attorney Sonia Carvalho said.

    “I would be happy to research … to see if it could be banned citywide,” Carvalho said. “I could see private property owners arguing that they have a duty to protect and secure their own operations.”

    Mayor Valerie Amezcua said she’s concerned this type of enforcement could drive business owners out of Santa Ana.

    “I just remind people, the community, those that will be up here, that we will start to lose revenue very quickly when businesses are told that in the city of Santa Ana, the Home Depots, the Walmarts, the Targets … you cannot have those cameras on your property, even though you put it there for your protection and for the success of your business,” Amezcua added.

    Lopez said she believes the city doesn’t have jurisdiction to “encroach on private property rights” of businesses but urged business owners to consider the community’s fears and concerns.

    “While I would love our business owners to consider our families and their pain and their trauma that they're going through right now and not using this technology, I don't know that it is feasible for us to tell our community members that the city is going to take on businesses,” Lopez added.

    What are other cities doing about ALPRs? 

    The city of Fullerton temporarily shut off its license plate reader cameras in October following privacy concerns and public backlash. In January, Santa Cruz canceled its Flock agreements.

    Los Angeles is also contending with its own ALPR systems. The L.A. City Council last month was just one vote shy of nixing a new license plate reader pilot program.

  • Bonuses tick up for 3 executives
    A low angle view of signage that reads "CALSTRS" in front of a building.
    The California State Teachers' Retirement System offices in West Sacramento on Nov. 12, 2024.

    Topline:

    The investment staff at California’s two biggest public pension funds received larger performance incentives this year, with three executives landing seven-figure bonuses, according to newly released summaries of the extra pay.

    Why now: Both funds beat their investment targets for the last three years, accounting for some of the bonus pay.

    More details: The California State Teachers’ Retirement System earlier this month disclosed it paid $21.8 million in incentives to investment staff, up from $20.3 million last year. The California Public Employees’ Retirement System disclosed this week that it distributed $37.9 million in bonuses to its staff, up slightly from $37.7 million in incentives last year.

    Read on... for more on the bonuses.

    The investment staff at California’s two biggest public pension funds received larger performance incentives this year, with three executives landing seven-figure bonuses, according to newly released summaries of the extra pay.

    Both funds beat their investment targets for the last three years, accounting for some of the bonus pay.

    The California State Teachers’ Retirement System earlier this month disclosed it paid $21.8 million in incentives to investment staff, up from $20.3 million last year.

    CalSTRS Chief Investment Officer Scott Chan received a $1 million bonus in addition to his $576,000 salary; CalSTRS Chief Executive Officer Cassandra Lichnock earned a $750,000 incentive on top of her $500,000 salary.

    Chan’s bonus in the previous year was $881,000, while Lichnock’s was $675,000.

    The California Public Employees’ Retirement System disclosed this week that it distributed $37.9 million in bonuses to its staff, up slightly from $37.7 million in incentives last year.

    As previously reported by CalMatters, the biggest bonuses went to Chief Executive Marcie Frost at $1.1 million and Chief Investment Officer Stephen Gilmore at $1.7 million. Frost in the previous year earned a $766,000 performance incentive and Gilmore took home a $1.5 million bonus.

    Both funds characterize the bonuses as essential to recruiting and retaining investment staff. They’re also sensitive to the perception that the bonuses are excessive.

    Each system described the incentives as a small fraction of the funds’ earnings in reports to their boards.

    CalPERS included an artificial intelligence-generated graphic that depicted the incentives as the equivalent of 6 cents for every $1,000 the fund held in its portfolio as of July 1, when its assets were valued at $637 billion. It provides retirement plans for about 2 million people.

    CalSTRS as of last month had a portfolio valued at $415 billion. It provides pension plans to about 1 million people.

    This article was originally published on CalMatters and was republished under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives license.

  • Holiday craft fairs, burger deals and more
    A performer in a voluminous black Victorian dress holds up a blue book on stage as another actor in period vest and mustache looks on.
    'Oh, Mary!' is on now at the Ahmanson.

    In this edition:

    Check out holiday craft fairs, burger deals, Oh, Mary! at the Ahmanson and more of the best things to do this weekend and beyond.

    Highlights:

    • There are still six weeks to knit that Christmas present for your loved one, so kick things off and get crafty at the SoCal Fiber Fair. You can meet fellow knitters, take a class, watch demos and much more.
    • The best burger deal (and my favorite grain bowl!) is coming to West Adams. The Win-Dow’s West Adams location will officially open Thursday and features a week of opening promotions, including free burgers, merch and more.
    • Oh, Mary! is a totally made-up send-up of Mary Todd Lincoln, with RuPaul’s Drag Race star Alaska Thunderf*ck tearing it up and making it their own in the role originated by the show’s writer, Cole Escola, in New York. It’s a madcap 80 minutes, so grab your friends and have a laugh.

    Nature gave us something new to be thankful for this year — baby sea turtles hatching along the shores of Seal Beach and Huntington Beach. These magical creatures are making their way home to the ocean, with a close eye kept on them by Long Beach’s Aquarium of the Pacific. It may be a side effect of the warming ocean temperatures (not great), but we’ll take the silver lining.

    Elsewhere on LAist, you can read up on the new James Bond, Robert Pattinson, catch up on the 2027 Grammy nominations and take a pop culture road trip down Route 66.

    Music

    In music this week, Licorice Pizza’s picks include:

    WEDNESDAY

    THURSDAY

    FRIDAY

    SATURDAY

    SUNDAY

    MONDAY 

    TUESDAY

    Events

    Oh, Mary!

    Through Sunday, Dec. 6
    Ahmanson Theatre
    135 N. Grand Ave., Downtown L.A. 
    COST: FROM $49; MORE INFO

    Actors in period costume, one in a top hat, stand under a red-lit archway beside an American flag in a theater scene.
    (
    Evan Zimmerman
    /
    The Center Theatre Group
    )

    I will not be the spoiler for anyone who hasn’t read up on Broadway’s silliest sensation, Oh, Mary! It’s a totally made-up send-up of Mary Todd Lincoln, with RuPaul’s Drag Race star Alaska Thunderf*ck tearing it up and making it their own in the role originated by the show’s writer, Cole Escola, in New York. It’s a madcap 80 minutes, so grab your friends and have a laugh. Tickets are scarce (which makes me really happy for the theater scene in L.A.), but there are rush seats daily and cancelations available for the run, which goes through early December.


    The Win-Dow opens in West Adams

    From Thursday, Nov. 19 
    3701 W. Jefferson Blvd., West Adams
    COST: VARIES; MORE INFO 

    The best burger deal (and my favorite grain bowl!) is coming to West Adams. The Win-Dow’s West Adams location will officially open Thursday and features a week of opening promotions, including free burgers, merch and more. The new 80-seat restaurant features a spacious patio garden and, of course, the burger joint’s signature burgers, chicken sandwich and other offerings.


    Lungs 

    Through Sunday, Dec. 6
    Huron Station Playhouse 
    2640 Huron Street, East Los Angeles
    COST: FROM $25; MORE INFO 

    Poster for 'Lungs' at Huron Station Playhouse shows two black-and-white portraits, with dates October 29 to November 29 and cast names Zoe Lister-Jones and Ashley Zukerman.
    (
    Courtesy Huron Station
    )

    It’s not every day we get a brand new independent theater in L.A. — much less one with quite the Hollywood pedigree! Huron Station Playhouse is the brainchild of actor Alden Ehrenreich, and its first show, Lungs, is a moving play by Every Brilliant Thing author Duncan MacMillan, starring Zoe Lister-Jones and Ashley Zuckerman. Don’t miss it.


    Annual Venice Oceanarium reading of Moby-Dick 

    Saturday and Sunday, Nov. 21 and 22
    Windward and the sand, Venice Beach 
    COST: FREE; MORE INFO 

    A sign reading 'Moby Dick on the Beach' stands in sand near people seated in chairs facing the ocean.
    (
    Courtesy the Venice Oceanarium
    )

    The most Venice of all the Venice things is happening once again this weekend, as the Venice Oceanarium crew gathers the community for the annual reading of Moby-Dick. There have been lots of ocean wildlife sightings with all the crazy weather this year, so a whale tale/tail wouldn’t be unthinkable. Make your way to the beach and clear your throat to read a chapter on the sand.


    Titmouse Holiday Bazaar 

    Saturday, Nov. 21, 12 p.m. to 8 p.m. 
    1121 Seward St., Hollywood 
    COST: FREE; MORE INFO 

    A poster shows Santa Claus holding a knife and a gift box, promoting the Titmouse Holiday Bazaar event in Hollywood.
    (
    Titmouse
    /
    Facebook
    )

    Check out the wares from more than 50 indie vendors at Titmouse Animation Studio’s free, all-ages market. Visitors can catch holiday cartoons in the studio’s screening room, check out the food trucks and DJ, and browse for gifts for everyone on their lists.


    Manic Street Preachers 

    Wednesday, Nov. 18, 7 p.m.
    The Belasco 
    1050 S. Hill Street, Downtown L.A. 
    COST: $53.50; MORE INFO

    A guitarist in sunglasses sings into a microphone on stage, bathed in pink and purple lighting, with a drummer visible behind.
    Singer James Dean Bradfield of Manic Street Preachers performs onstage during the Darker Waves Festival at Huntington City Beach.
    (
    Scott Dudelson
    /
    Getty Images
    )

    Hot off their Darker Waves Fest set in Huntington Beach, '90s Britpop stars Manic Street Preachers play the Belasco. Even after the mysterious disappearance of lead singer Richey Edwards in 1995, the band has continued to thrive, playing festivals and getting crowds to their feet with hits like "La Tristesse Durera" and "Design for Life."


    Outlander in Concert 

    Thursday, Nov. 19, 7 p.m.
    Fox Performing Arts Center 
    3801 Mission Inn Ave., Riverside 
    COST: FROM $26.50; MORE INFO 

    Musicians play strings and a conductor gestures onstage as a large screen displays a woman in a red period gown.
    (
    Courtesy Outlander in Concert
    )

    I just got back from five days in the Scottish Highlands, so forgive me if I have Outlander on the brain. You can travel there, too, with this special screening and concert celebrating the beloved books and series.


    SoCal Fiber Fair

    Saturday and Sunday, Nov. 21 and 22
    Fairplex
    1101 W. McKinley Ave., Pomona
    COST: $15; MORE INFO

    Five people smile and crochet around a table with yarn, water bottles, and craft supplies at an indoor event.
    (
    Courtesy SoCal Fiber Fair
    )

    There are still six weeks to knit that Christmas present for your loved one, so kick things off and get crafty at the SoCal Fiber Fair. You can meet fellow knitters, take a class, watch demos and much more.


    The Muppet Christmas Carol

    Friday to Sunday, Nov. 20 to 22
    El Capitan 
    6838 Hollywood Blvd., Hollywood
    COST: $23; MORE INFO

    A man wrapped in chains recoils from two ghostly puppet figures bound in heavy chains and tattered cloth.
    (
    Courtesy Buena Vista Pictures
    )

    Is there a better holiday movie than The Muppet Christmas Carol? I’ll wait while you grab tickets to this special screening of the classic at El Capitan. Plus, director Brian Henson joins for a Q&A after the Friday night showing.