Protect local news!

Be one of 5,000 supporters to make a monthly gift during our fall member drive and help strengthen our nonprofit newsroom.
3,766 sustainers of 5,000 goal
Logged in as
Audience-funded nonprofit news
radio tower icon laist logo
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
Subscribe
  • Listen Now Playing Listen

The Brief

The most important stories for you to know today
  • Podcast pulls back the curtain on the Magic Castle
    An illustration of various dark blue playing cards scattered around a purple background. In the center, one card is facing up featuring a person with a blazer, short hair, and heart shaped glasses. Below them is an illustration of a castle. The top right and bottom left corners of the card have two red hearts.

    Topline:

    This week, LAist Studios debuts Imperfect Paradise: The Castle. It's the story of how one hobbyist magician fell in love with a Los Angeles institution cloaked in mystery — the Magic Castle. And what happened when that love was confronted with the realities of an exclusive members-only club and an internal reckoning brought on by the summer of 2020.

    What is the Magic Castle? It's a members-only club for magicians and lovers of magic. Besides being invited by a member, there are several workarounds to getting in — for example if you book a stay at the Magic Castle hotel. But gaining longer-term access is more difficult.

    What will I hear in the podcast? The story centers around Carly Usdin, a magician who managed to get an audition to join the Magic Castle. It was like being handed a golden key. But was the key tarnished?

    How can I listen? Here's Part 1 of the three-episode story:

    About this series

    This week, LAist Studios debuts Imperfect Paradise: The Castle, the latest in our weekly podcast series.

    It's the story of how one hobbyist magician fell in love with a Los Angeles institution cloaked in mystery — the Magic Castle. And what happened when that love was confronted with the realities of an exclusive members-only club and an internal reckoning brought on by the summer of 2020.

    This is Part 1 of 3.

    Carly Usdin was the kind of kid who spent a lot of time in imaginary worlds: reading comic books, imagining superheroes and watching David Copperfield specials.

    Whenever their parents hit the garage door button, Carly liked to stand next to it with their arm out, as if they were controlling the lifting and lowering of the heavy metal gate.

    A person with medium-light skin tone, short hair and glasses sits at a wooden table with many decks of playing cards in boxes stacked on it.
    Carly Usdin in 2023.
    (
    Natalie Chudnovsky
    /
    LAist
    )

    Carly knew they didn’t have real magical abilities, but in pretending they found something they needed — a sense of power.

    “I think many kids feel powerless,” they say, “but especially the kid that I was, getting teased at school for being smart and being queer and being Jewish, and not even knowing I was queer yet, and wanting out of that so badly.”

    A child with medium-light skin tone wearing a yellow sweater and white top holds a toy
    Carly Usdin as a child.
    (
    Courtesy of Carly Usdin
    )

    Carly did get out. They left their small town in central New Jersey, became a filmmaker and married their now-wife. And then in 2013, at the age of 30, they moved to Los Angeles.

    In L.A., Carly was reminded of their childhood interest in magic, and started to get curious about why there were so few famous women magicians. At the time they were identifying as a woman, their gender assigned at birth (they now are non-binary and trans). While in a research rabbit hole, they started reading about the Magic Castle, an exclusive members-only Los Angeles club for magicians and lovers of magic.

    Carly had heard of the Magic Castle. They knew it had a reputation for being frequented by celebrities, that its former president was Neil Patrick Harris and that it was invitation-only. And Carly desperately wanted to get in.

    Besides being invited by a member, there are several workarounds to getting into the Magic Castle — for example, if you book a stay at the Magic Castle hotel. But gaining longer-term access is more difficult.

    “I started doing research into the Magic Castle,” Carly remembers, “and I found the Magic Castle website and it said ‘we offer adult magic classes.’ And the kicker is that while you're enrolled in lessons, you basically have a temporary membership to the castle.”

    A large structure that resembles a fairy tale castle has blue and white trim, a round turret at the entrance and a balustrade across a roof. A number of vehicles are parked in the driveway.
    The Magic Castle in Hollywood on Oct. 13, 2021.
    (
    Valerie Macon
    /
    AFP via Getty Images
    )

    Carly had found a backdoor into the Castle.

    And Carly was aware they didn't fit the magician stereotype. Actually, that’s what made them excited about it.

    I was like, I'm gonna infiltrate. I'm gonna take my queer self in there, cause it's a space that's clearly not meant for me.
    — Carly Usdin

    “If you say magician, you get a very specific image in your head," says Carly. "It's probably an older cis white heterosexual man, because that has long been the archetype of the magician in American popular culture. So I was like, I'm gonna infiltrate. I'm gonna take my queer self in there, cause it's a space that's clearly not meant for me.”

    Why is the Magic Castle a big deal? 

    The Magic Castle , or just “The Castle” as many members call it, is run by the Academy of Magical Arts. Just a few blocks from the tourist center of Hollywood, the Castle, with its stained glass windows and turrets, looks like a French chateau plucked out of a Disney movie. It was built as a private home around 1909. And then in 1963 it opened as a private clubhouse for magicians, complete with a liquor license.

    An evening at the Castle requires not only an invitation but adherence to a dress code, an admission charge, parking fees and the purchase of an entree. If you throw in a cocktail, that’s at least a $100 night out. There are no photos or videos allowed inside. The exclusivity of the experience is part of the allure.

    Besides its mystique to the layperson, the Castle is an important institution in the world of magic because being a member, or better yet, a booked performer, serves as a stamp of legitimacy.

    “There isn't a Ph.D. in magician,” says magician and Castle member Paul Draper. “So, when I'm auditioning for a television show, when I speak to an event planner, the first question I'm asked is, 'Have you ever performed at the Magic Castle?'"

    A woman with light-skin tone and wearing a blue dress sits at a green felt-covered table with a deck of cards arrayed in front of her. Members of an audience sit close by in partial darkness.
    Magician Kayla Drescher performs at the Magic Castle on Oct. 13, 2021.
    (
    Valerie Macon
    /
    AFP via Getty Images
    )

    The Castle is also a coveted and somewhat rare performance venue, especially in contrast to the kinds of gigs that sustain many magicians.

    “You know who doesn't wanna watch magic? A bunch of people at their company holiday party. They wanna get drunk and just talk about how weird the year was,” says magician Kayla Drescher.

    But at the Castle?

    “People actually put in the effort to come watch magic,” says Kayla. “They're all dressed up and they're so excited to see you.”

    Membership at the Castle comes with other benefits: access to its library, spaces to workshop tricks and a place to connect with some of the best magicians in the world.

    “You have all these magicians that have performed here, you have all this history,” says Kayla. “There's a library of all these books with secrets. The guy who made the Statue of Liberty disappear for David Copperfield? He's just sitting at the bar. All the people, all the tricks, all the stories, it all just exists in one place.”

    Beginner's magic

    Carly was full of nerves driving to their first class at the Magic Castle in the fall of 2014.

    Inside, there was a small reception area lined with bookshelves and no doors. Unsure of what to do next, Carly examined the bookshelves, drawn to one particular statue of an owl.

    “The people working at the front told me you have to say the magic word in order for the owl to grant you admittance to the Castle,” says Carly. So they spoke the magic words (“Open Sesame”) and the bookshelf pulled back to reveal the Castle.

    “Just that moment alone, I was giddy,” Carly says. “Basically you're in a parlor-looking bar area and there's like a big old timey fireplace. The color palette is like reds and golds and purples. All the wood is old, dark wood. It is Victorian, dark, moody, so much old art and old artifacts of magic. It feels like exactly this thing that's plucked out of time.”

    A sign that reads WELCOME TO THE CLOSE-UP GALLERY with a hand drawn beneath it with its finger pointing to the left is mounted on a wood wall. In the background is an audience dressed in business attire seated beneath an ornate ceiling with a purple light.
    The Close-up Gallery at the Magic Castle, in Hollywood on Oct. 13, 2021.
    (
    Valerie Macon
    /
    AFP via Getty Images
    )

    The Castle can feel maze-like, with its various floors and bars. Every week there’s a new schedule of booked magicians performing at the many theaters, from the intimate Close-up Gallery to the larger stage at The Palace of Mystery. There are tables for magician members to set up impromptu shows. And a self-playing piano takes song requests (if they’re directed to the ghost of Irma — and yes, she also takes tips).

    After several wrong turns, Carly found their way to a small instructional classroom. And they were delighted by every aspect of that first class.

    “It felt like being back in school,” they say. “We went over the rules of being a magician. Some of the primary ones being, you don't do the same illusion for the same audience more than once. Obviously, you do not reveal your secrets.”

    Carly remembers the initial classes being focused on card tricks: how to handle a deck, different ways of shuffling and grips. And Carly was delighted that they learned it all easily.

    Carly has obsessive compulsive disorder — OCD. In high school, before they got proper care, they had a tough time focusing because of it. But learning magic tricks engaged their attention in a very specific way.

    “When I was doing these tricks, I wasn't experiencing my OCD symptoms," Carly says. "It's just this perfect blend of mental and physical working in harmony where you have to be paying attention on both levels really closely.”

    A person with medium-light skin tone and short haircut, wearing glasses and a white top, sits in front of a deck of cards laid out face down on a black felt cloth
    Carly Usdin practicing close-up magic, circa 2014-2015.
    (
    Courtesy of Carly Usdin
    /
    Courtesy of Carly Usdin
    )

    Carly was in love. They didn’t want to become a professional magician, but they were constantly thinking about magic, carrying a deck of cards everywhere to practice, savoring the feeling of delight that came with successfully pulling off a trick.

    After the beginner course ended, Carly took Magic 2 and then Magic 3 and Magic 4, learning coin tricks and more complicated illusions. After class, Carly would catch magic shows at the Castle with their classmates.

    And they noticed that the Castle’s demographics matched their initial assumptions.

    Stepping back in time

    Several current and former Magic Castle members have described the experience of going to the club as stepping back in time, which comes with charms and also, drawbacks. Most glaringly, the demographics of the Castle.

    A bronze sculpture of two hands breaking a chain at the wrists is mounted on a wall in partial darkness
    A shelf hangs at The Houdini Seance Room at The Magic Castle on Oct. 24, 2008.
    (
    Angela Weiss
    /
    Getty Images North America
    )

    Several members have described the club as mostly white and mostly male. In an email, a Castle representative said the club doesn’t keep data on the race of its members and did not provide data on the gender of members, either.

    But according to one former member who gathered numbers from a Castle membership representative, in 2019 magician membership was 12% women.

    Numbers of women performers at the Castle are even lower — the Castle’s own records identify only about 8% of performers over the last three years as being women.

    That tracks with national estimates of women magicians in the U.S. For much of its history, performance magic in the Western world was exclusively male.

    For magic historian and Magic Castle member Angela Sanchez, the story starts as far back as the Witch Trials in 16th century Europe.

    “In a patriarchal society, for women to know something that men do not, is a bad thing. And so to be accused of being a witch is to be accused of having secret knowledge that a man does not have access to,” says Angela. “And so this notion that a witch, a woman who holds power, is adverse to what a woman should and ought to be, is something that cues you into how women in magic are generally treated in Western European societies.”

    At the same time as women were being burned at the stake for witchcraft, there were men who earned money doing magic tricks at carnivals. In the 18th and 19th centuries in Europe and the U.S., magic made its way from street entertainment into Broadway theaters and the parlor rooms of upper classes.

    There were some famous women magicians, notably English performer Adelaide Hermann, who was billed “the Queen of Magic,” as well as female assistants who would vanish or levitate, but many onstage assistants at the time were boys and for the most part, magic was a field for men.

    And then in 1921, magic introduced a new role for women: being in peril.

    A young woman with light skin tone stands on a stage bathed in purple light with a rope tied around her. A man with light skin tone holds the rope
    John Shryock and his daughter Jasmine, 16, rehearse before their performance at the Magic Castle on Oct. 13, 2021.
    (
    Valerie Macon
    /
    AFP via Getty Images
    )

    In 1921, illusionist P.T. Selbit specifically called for women to participate in what would become an iconic trick: sawing a woman in half.

    “This was very much a situation that would go forward in branding magic with very clear gender roles,” says Angela. “The magician is a guy in a tux and a woman on stage is the individual who gets sawed in half, split apart and lit on fire.”

    Carly was seeing echoes of this history at the Magic Castle in the ways that some magicians spoke about or interacted with women onstage, but they also saw signs of progress. They recalled their magic class being fairly diverse, and were inspired by a women magician’s group at the Castle, co-founded by Angela.

    Carly dreamed about starting a group for queer magicians. Of getting to spend as much time as they liked in the immersive magical space of the Castle. And of being able to invite whomever they wanted.

    Carly realized that they wanted to become a member.

    The audition

    There are different levels of membership at the Castle (for example, Junior, or Associate for magic-lovers) but to become a Magician Member requires several steps, including an application with essays and, most nerve-wracking for Carly, an audition.

    A person with medium light-skin tone, a short haircut, wearing eyeglasses and a black suit, a gray shirt and tie, stands in front of a black awning with white lettering that reads Welcome to the Academy of Magical Arts
    Carly Usdin at the Magic Castle.
    (
    Courtesy of Carly Usdin
    )

    Carly had heard horror stories about people bombing auditions and about how hard it was to impress the panel.

    They picked out four tricks that they practiced for months.

    “I was full of fear and dread driving there,” Carly says.

    Carly remembers about five other people auditioning. All of them, hanging out at the bar, getting called downstairs, one … by one. Until finally … it was Carly’s turn to go before the panel.

    “And I went in and there was like, I wanna say four or five magicians in there. I don't believe any of them were familiar to me, but they were all cis men. It was an incredibly intimidating room. They do a little interview. And then they're like, all right, show us your tricks.”

    It didn’t go as smoothly as Carly had practiced.

    A deck of cards with red backing spread out on a black felt table. All are face down except the 4 of clubs
    Carly Usdin with a spread of cards.
    (
    Natalie Chudnovsky
    /
    LAist
    )

    “The thing with close-up magic especially, is that it's all about your hands,” Carly says. “And the thing with anxiety is that my hands were shaking. I felt like I fumbled stuff and it wasn't as clean as it could have been.”

    The panel stopped Carly, telling them they had seen enough. Carly felt like they’d blown their chance and went back to the bar to wait for the bad news.

    “And then they came and, and got us. And so we had to go back to the room downstairs. And they're like, congratulations, all six of you made it. And I wanted to cry.”

    Carly was officially a member.

    They were on the inside of this private, exclusive, prestigious magicians club. For Carly it was like being handed a golden key, because members can invite any guests they want. It meant Carly could open up the Castle to their friends ... people who didn’t necessarily look like the typical magic showgoer.

    A certificate that reads The Academy of Magical Arts Inc, Carly Usdin
    (
    Courtesy of Carly Usdin
    )

    “I had no misgivings of like … I'm gonna change the face of the community,” Carly says. “It was on a very small scale of like, I just wanna bring my friends and then from there, if I can start a group for queer magicians, that would be really cool.”

    Did Carly think the Castle would be receptive?

    “I really didn't know.”

    In Part II, Carly finds out. Coming Dec. 6, 2023. 

  • The program comes from Trump's 'big' bill
    Adult with medium skin tone and long dark hair sits on a wooden stool, hands raised mid-gesture, facing about 15 children in navy and plaid school uniforms seated on a colorful rug in a classroom.
    Isabel Dueñas teaches her transitional kindergarten students how to read at San Miguel Catholic School in the Watts neighborhood of Los Angeles.

    Topline:

    Before he heads out the door, Gov. Gavin Newsom must decide whether California will join 31 states in a new multibillion-dollar school choice program, funded by private donations, that President Donald Trump included last year in his One Big Beautiful Bill.

    Why now: Like most Democratic governors, Newsom hasn’t signaled whether he’ll opt in to the law that advocates promise will greatly increase full or partial scholarships to private and religious schools, while potentially paying for auxiliary services in public schools, like tutoring.

    The backstory: The law’s intentionally broad, unrestricted language has made it contentious, with contrasting scenarios for how the Federal Scholarship Tax Credit program, also called the Education Freedom Tax Credit, will play out. Under the program, an individual taxpayer can donate up to $1,700 annually to a qualifying grant-making organization, up to $3,400 for couples, and then receive a federal tax credit that lowers their taxes by the full amount. The nonprofit “scholarship-granting organizations” then combine individuals’ donations and distribute the money to school districts or to eligible families for private schools.

    Before he heads out the door, Gov. Gavin Newsom must decide whether California will join 31 states in a new multibillion-dollar school choice program, funded by private donations, that President Donald Trump included last year in his One Big Beautiful Bill.

    Like most Democratic governors, Newsom hasn’t signaled whether he’ll opt in to the law that advocates promise will greatly increase full or partial scholarships to private and religious schools, while potentially paying for auxiliary services in public schools, like tutoring.

    The law’s intentionally broad, unrestricted language has made it contentious, with contrasting scenarios for how the Federal Scholarship Tax Credit program, also called the Education Freedom Tax Credit, will play out.

    Under the program, an individual taxpayer can donate up to $1,700 annually to a qualifying grant-making organization, up to $3,400 for couples, and then receive a federal tax credit that lowers their taxes by the full amount. The nonprofit “scholarship-granting organizations” then combine individuals’ donations and distribute the money to school districts or to eligible families for private schools.

    Advocates say federal tax credits will boost tuition assistance for families in voucher states, while introducing school choice in states like California, which bans using state funding for private and religious schools.

    Although it was not their main intent, Republicans included public schools in the law. One nonpartisan analyst, Marguerite Roza, director of the Edunomics Lab at Georgetown University, predicts that public schools will eventually become the biggest beneficiary, once they figure out how to tap into it.

    “Given that anyone and everyone can donate without it costing them, it’s like a cost-free donation. We think the average taxpayer is going to lean toward donating to a [grant maker] that serves public schools.”

    But opponents argue the program is a tactic to undermine public schools, which are already facing declining enrollments in blue states that have historically opposed voucher-like programs. One critic characterized the program as “a Trojan horse designed to bring the chaos of privatization into Democratic strongholds.”

    Others say the program will primarily subsidize existing private school parents, not help low-income families trapped in their neighborhood schools. And the law’s free-market focus, its lack of oversight and failure to require civil rights protections will reinforce inequities and lead to abuse.

    “The FSTC will become the largest source of waste, fraud and abuse we’ve seen in education — and most of it will be legal,” wrote Jon Valant, the director of Brown Center on Education Policy at Brookings.

    Congress’ hands-off policy

    Valant and other critics blame Congress for tying governors’ hands. Under the law, governors cannot add accountability provisions or favor some scholarship-granting organizations, called SGOs, over others, such as those that give to public schools. Once they opt in and submit a list of all SGOs, their job is done.

    SGOs must check students’ income eligibility and audit the money, but they’re not required to monitor programs or keep school achievement records.

    Thomas Toch, founding director of FutureEd, an independent education policy institute at Georgetown University, said Congress should have learned from the No Child Left Behind Act of 2001. The law provided billions of dollars for parents in low-performing schools to obtain tutoring from contractors who were often unvetted, inexperienced and unmonitored. The Education Department’s inspector general found widespread fraud, falsified records, conflicts of interest and deceptive marketing.

    “Sounds familiar,” Toch said.

    Governors can’t tell the SGOs which students to serve, but SGOs can determine where to funnel dollars — to a public or private school, an elementary or high school, only to parochial school students or for specific programs. They’ll determine the scholarship amounts and the public school programs they’ll support.

    There will be a wide universe of students to serve.

    Students in families earning up to 300% of an area’s median income will be eligible — more than $400,000 in some wealthy Californian cities. Some donors may give to SGOs committed to services and scholarships for low-income children, but others may not.

    The American Federation for Children, a proponent of the tax credit, projects that 51.7 million children — 90% of the total public and private school students — will be eligible for the benefits.

    Based on an analysis of donors to a similar tax credit program in Ohio, Brookings predicts that more tax-credit program money will end up in wealthy communities. “We expect the FSTC to become a regressive funding source, even where those funds go to public school students.”

    Lance Christensen, who has drafted school choice proposals as vice president of tax policy and government relations for the conservative California Policy Center, says the Brookings analysis is “shortsighted.” If 100,000 people — not even 1% of California’s 17 million income tax filers — donated $1,700, it would generate $170 million, he said. That amount would rise to $1.7 billion if one million taxpayers — only 6% of the state total — gave the maximum.

    “You’re talking about real money that could impact the way that parents legitimately think about their kids’ education,” Christensen said. “We have a lot of kids right now that are stuck in a system that doesn’t work for them and hasn’t worked for them for a long time, and the parents are just really frustrated.”

    The Treasury Department and the IRS estimate that, by 2030, more than 11 million taxpayers will contribute $26 billion for scholarships and other grants.

    Two visions for California donations

    So far, New York Gov. Kathy Hochul and Colorado Gov. Jared Polis are the only Democratic governors among the 31 participating states to opt in. (Virginia joined before Democratic Gov. Abigail Spanberger took office.) This year’s opt-in deadline is Jan. 1.

    Two Californians who hope for different reasons that Newsom will sign on are Rachel Elginsmith and Evan Marwell.

    Elginsmith is chief executive of the BASIC Fund in Oakland, the state’s largest nonsectarian SGO. Since its founding in 1998, it has distributed $200 million in partial scholarships for 30,000 students, from preschool to eighth grade attending 266 Catholic and nonreligious schools in the Bay Area.

    The BASIC Fund would be well positioned to capitalize on the tax-credit by expanding its base of donors. “It would be more money, more kids, bigger scholarships — more of what we’re doing. It would be exciting,” she said.

    Marwell, a San Francisco nonprofit entrepreneur, founded EducationSuperHighway, which helped districts plan and fund high-speed internet during the pandemic, and then co-founded Ignite Reading, an online tutoring for the early grades. His new mission: rechartering the EducationSuperHighway into a national SGO that will compete for taxpayers who want to choose first grade tutoring in reading for their tax credit donation.

    Marwell said he has reached out to 45 governors, and expects that Democratic states will opt in. They will see the success of Colorado and New York, he said, and “they will start to hear from voters, ‘Why the heck are you not allowing our kids to get these scholarships that we’re contributing to?’ ” 

    Newsom’s dilemma

    Newsom will get grief whether he opts in or out. The National Education Association and teachers unions in California will thrash him if he signs on. “Taxpayer dollars should go to public schools open to all students, not private schools that can pick and choose their students,” the NEA said in a press release.

    If he doesn’t opt in, he’ll be criticized for denying low-income families money to close the achievement gap, while forcing California taxpayers to give to out-of-state SGOs. As New York Gov. Hochul said in her Oct. 9 announcement, “I’m not going to leave money on the table when it could help our kids.”

    There is a third option — do nothing, citing fatal flaws in the tax credit program’s design. That’s the advice of Rachel Cantor, director of education policy at the Progressive Policy Institute.

    “If I was advising a Democratic governor, I would say, ‘No, don’t opt in. Expand public school choice in your state so that people do have choices. But this is a risky way to do it if your goal is to improve educational quality and open opportunity for people who don’t have it.’ ”

    What we know about Trump’s Federal Scholarship Tax Credit program

    Gov. Gavin Newsom must decide whether California will join 31 other states in participating in President Donald Trump’s school choice program. Here is how the program works: 

    • Governors must opt in by Jan. 1 annually to participate in the program.
    • Federal income tax filers, whether living in a participating state or not, can receive a tax credit of up to $1,700 ($3,400 for couples) by donating to a state-approved Scholarship Granting Organization (SGO).
    • Governors cannot determine which organizations can serve as SGOs, beyond requiring 501(c) (3) nonprofit status and compliance with state nonprofit laws.
    • SGOs certify scholarship recipients; the family income of recipients must be below 300% of the median income in the counties they live in (more than $400,000 in wealthy counties).
    • SGOs determine the size of scholarships and grants and where the money they collect can be spent; they must spend 90% of the money they collect on scholarships and grants.
    • The FSTC law does not require academic reporting and accountability requirements of private schools receiving program funds.
    • Private school scholarships can cover tuition, fees, uniforms, books, technology, transportation and certain room-and-board costs.
    • Grants for public school recipients can cover tutoring, extended-day and summer programs, college credit or Advanced Placement courses and potentially services and other expenses not covered by students with disabilities’ individualized education programs.

    Timeline for the Federal Scholarship Tax Credit

    July 4, 2025: President Trump signs the One Big Beautiful Bill that includes the  Education Freedom Tax Credit, also known as the Federal Scholarship Tax Credit.

    Oct. 1, 2026: U.S. Treasury Departmentreleases draft regulations for the Federal Scholarship Tax Credit (FSTC) program; 60-day public comment period begins.

    Dec. 15, 2026: The Treasury Department will host a public hearing at the IRS building in Washington, D.C.

    Dec. 31, 2026: Deadline for states to submit their participation in the FSTC.

    Jan. 1, 2027: Individual taxpayers can begin donating contributions to eligible SGOs.

    Feb. 15, 2027: Deadline for states to submit their list of eligible scholarship-granting organizations to the IRS.

    EdSource is an independent nonprofit organization that provides analysis on key education issues facing California and the nation. LAist republishes articles from EdSource with permission.

  • Sponsored message
  • He sued the BBC for $10 billion for defamation
    Close-up of Donald Trump, a person with a tan skin tone and light blond hair, head tilted down with eyes lowered and lips pressed together, lit in warm red tones against blurred lights.
    President Donald Trump speaks to reporters after arriving on Air Force One, Wednesday, Oct. 21, 2026, at Joint Base Andrews, Md.

    Topline:

    A federal judge on Thursday ordered President Donald Trump to sit for a deposition in his $10 billion defamation lawsuit against the BBC by Dec. 11.

    Why now: The order from U.S. Magistrate Judge Enjoliqué Lett came as lawyers for the British broadcaster complained that Trump had delayed his appearance. Charles Tobin, attorney for the BBC, said that with two months left in the discovery period, “we still haven’t been able to depose the plaintiff.” He noted there was an agreed-upon date of Oct. 16, but that Trump had canceled it for a “matter of national importance.” Tobin said the Republican president was in fact campaigning in Georgia that day. “He was participating in party politics and prioritized that over sitting for the deposition,” Tobin said.

    The backstory: Trump, who has often avoided depositions, filed his lawsuit against the BBC last December. He accused the publicly funded broadcaster of defamation as well as deceptive and unfair trade practices related to a documentary, “Trump: A Second Chance.” The BBC acknowledged that filmmakers spliced together quotes from different sections of the speech Trump delivered to his supporters on Jan. 6, 2021, before the storming of the U.S. Capitol, to make it seem he was directly urging violence. The broadcaster apologized over the editing, and the head of the BBC and its top news executive both resigned. But the BBC has denied Trump’s claims that it defamed him.

    What's next: Lett said Trump must sit for a deposition by Dec. 11, or face sanctions up to dismissal of his lawsuit -– unless the discovery period was extended past Dec. 18.

    A federal judge on Thursday ordered President Donald Trump to sit for a deposition in his $10 billion defamation lawsuit against the BBC by Dec. 11.

    The order from U.S. Magistrate Judge Enjoliqué Lett came as lawyers for the British broadcaster complained that Trump had delayed his appearance. Charles Tobin, attorney for the BBC, said that with two months left in the discovery period, “we still haven’t been able to depose the plaintiff.”

    He noted there was an agreed-upon date of Oct. 16, but that Trump had canceled it for a “matter of national importance.” Tobin said the Republican president was in fact campaigning in Georgia that day. “He was participating in party politics and prioritized that over sitting for the deposition,” Tobin said.

    Lett said Trump must sit for a deposition by Dec. 11, or face sanctions up to dismissal of his lawsuit -– unless the discovery period was extended past Dec. 18.

    Discovery, where lawyers for both sides exchange documents and other evidence, is scheduled to end Dec. 18, and the BBC’s attorneys want to make sure they have Trump’s deposition before that deadline. Lett said only the presiding judge assigned to the case can alter the trial schedule, and the defense said it would be open to scheduling the deposition at a later time if the trial schedule was also moved back.

    Trump, who has often avoided depositions, filed his lawsuit against the BBC last December. He accused the publicly funded broadcaster of defamation as well as deceptive and unfair trade practices related to a documentary, “Trump: A Second Chance.”

    The BBC acknowledged that filmmakers spliced together quotes from different sections of the speech Trump delivered to his supporters on Jan. 6, 2021, before the storming of the U.S. Capitol, to make it seem he was directly urging violence. The broadcaster apologized over the editing, and the head of the BBC and its top news executive both resigned. But the BBC has denied Trump’s claims that it defamed him.

    Trump’s lawyers say Jack Smith lacks ‘personal knowledge’ of issues in the case

    To bolster its defense, the broadcaster subpoenaed former special counsel Jack Smith earlier this month. Trump’s lawyers argued, in a joint filing asking for a hearing on the matter, that there was no good reason for Smith, who is not a party to the case, to appear.

    Tobin, the BBC lawyer, told the judge Thursday that Smith has not objected to being deposed for this case, meaning the only objection is coming from Trump. Tobin said the BBC is not trying to relitigate the events of Jan. 6, but that Smith is one of the leading experts in what happened that day, and his deposition could lead the BBC to evidence that could help their case.

    “We can argue later on whether his testimony is admissible,” Tobin said, “but we are entitled to that deposition.”

    Trump’s lawyer, Alejandro Brito, said Smith has no personal knowledge of Trump’s Jan. 6 speech or Trump’s state of mind when he gave it. All of Smith’s knowledge about the case is secondhand, Brito argued, and the special counsel’s report, along with Smith’s testimony before Congress, is all public and available to the BBC’s attorneys, he said.

    There was no immediate ruling with the hearing expected to resume in the afternoon after a lunch break.

    Judge says the BBC can see membership records for Mar-a-Lago

    Turning to the damages issue, the judge agreed that the BBC should be allowed to see records for the total number of applications for membership at Trump’s Mar-a-Lago resort in Florida from Jan. 6, 2020, through Jan. 6, 2026, as well as the total cost of membership and initiation fees for new applicants.

    Tobin said one aspect of any defamation case is showing actual damages, and the popularity of Mar-a-Lago is a significant indicator of Trump’s reputation. The BBC’s lawyer described the private club as “a place where he exhibits his reputation in front of people who are important to him.”

    Brito argued that Trump does not actually run Mar-a-Lago, and that his reputation is not associated with the club.

  • 12 ways to celebrate on the Eastside
    A ghostly graveyard display on a black metal gate of a home with Halloween decorations.
    A ghostly graveyard display on the block of 2nd and Chicago streets features tombstones and jack-o’-lanterns.

    Topline:

    From parties and scary movie screenings to galleries and trunk-or-treats, here are events to check out on the Eastside this spooky season.

    East LA Film Shop: East LA Film Shop is partnering with Amigas Photogenicas to bring a Halloween-themed exhibit showcasing local photographers. The night will include music, giveaways, a photo booth, treats and more. Costumes are encouraged and prizes will be awarded to the best-dressed.

    Trunk or treat: Wilson High School’s 5th annual Trunk or Treat event will include spooky activities, surprises and treats for the entire family. Don’t miss the opportunity to take photos at the pumpkin patch and create something special at the arts and crafts table.

    Read on... for more Halloween events on the Eastside.

    This story first appeared on The LA Local.

    Get your costumes ready because the Halloween festivities are here!

    From parties and scary movie screenings to galleries and trunk-or-treats, here are events to check out on the Eastside this spooky season. 

    Halloween gallery at East LA Film Shop 

    East LA Film Shop is partnering with Amigas Photogenicas to bring a Halloween-themed exhibit showcasing local photographers. The night will include music, giveaways, a photo booth, treats and more. Costumes are encouraged and prizes will be awarded to the best-dressed.

    When: 6 - 11 p.m., Oct. 23

    Where: East LA Film Shop, 3541 E. 1st St., Los Angeles

    More info here.

    Museum on Haunted Hill: A celebration of Vincent Price

    The Vincent Price Art Museum will host a celebration honoring horror actor icon Vincent Price. Enjoy screenings of his films as well as a costume party, with music, a photo booth and access to the exhibitions.

    When: 5 - 8 p.m., Oct. 23

    Where: Vincent Price Art Museum, 1301 Avenida Cesar Chavez, Monterey Park

    Cost: $50, free for VPAM members 

    More info here. 

    Horror movie night at Birrieria Don Boni

    Writer and director Glitzel Gonzalez is hosting a double feature horror movie screening of “Lost Boys” and “Trick R Treat” to help fund her film, “NecalliI,” which highlights generations of immigrants facing ICE raids. The night will also include horror trivia, a costume contest, vendors and themed drinks and food.

    When: Doors open at 7 p.m., Oct. 24

    Where: Birrieria Don Boni, 1845 1st St., Los Angeles

    Cost: $20

    More info here.

    Halloween party at Eastside Luv

    Enjoy a fun night out at Eastside Luv’s Halloween Party presented by Bad Taste and Last Rockeros. Live bands will perform sets of garage rock, punk, and rock en español. Vinyl DJs will also play a set. 

    Age: 21 and over

    When: Doors open at 8 p.m., Oct. 31

    Where: Eastside Luv, 1835 1st St., Los Angeles

    Cost: $13

    More info here. 

    Boyle Heights: Most Haunted Tours 

    A black and white photo of a building with signage near bushes that reads "Hollenbeck Terrace."
    Hollenbeck Terrace used to be Linda Vista Hospital.
    (
    Alma Lucia
    /
    Boyle Heights Beat
    )
    Interested in visiting the haunted spots of Boyle Heights? Join Shmuel Gonzales, a local historian, for a night of scary stories from the community. You’ll stroll along the former Linda Vista Hospital, Hollenbeck Park, the Sanatorium and Orphans House and more. 
    When: 6 - 9:30 p.m., Oct. 31

    Where: Hollenbeck Park, 415 S. St. Louis St., Los Angeles

    Cost: $28.52

    Get your tickets here. 

    Halloweenizate 2026

    Join The Wall Las Memorias’ 4th annual Halloween celebration, a night of community, wellness and costumes created for LGBTQ+ adults. The event will feature food, dancing, performances, mental health and wellness resources, and prizes for best costumes.

    Age: 18 and over

    When: 7 - 9 p.m., Oct. 30

    Where: The Wall Las Memorias, 2020 E. 1st St., Los Angeles

    Register here.

    Trunk or Treat at Wilson High School

    Wilson High School’s 5th annual Trunk or Treat event will include spooky activities, surprises and treats for the entire family. Don’t miss the opportunity to take photos at the pumpkin patch and create something special at the arts and crafts table. 

    When: 3 - 5 p.m., Oct. 24

    Where: Wilson High School, 4500 Multnomah St, Los Angeles

    More info here. 

    Legacy’s Halloween Harvest 

    A girl tries on a Halloween costume
    Get your costumes ready because the Halloween festivities are here!
    Legacy LA is hosting its Halloween Harvest, which will feature a haunted house, activities and free food. The haunted house is recommended for youth over 10 years old and has elements of gore and flashing lights. 
    When: 4 - 7:30 p.m., Oct. 26

    Where: Legacy LA, 1350 San Pablo St., Los Angeles

    More info here.

    Halloween party at Lincoln Park

    The Lincoln Park Recreation Center is hosting a Halloween party for the entire family. Enjoy a spooktacular night of carnival games, mariachi performances, jumpers and a costume contest that begins at 6:30 p.m. A screening of the movie  “Coco” will start at 7:15 p.m.

    When: 5 - 9 p.m., Oct. 30

    Where: Lincoln Park Recreation Center, 3501 Valley Blvd., Los Angeles

    More info here.

    Halloween Slime Party

    The El Sereno Walking Club and Amara Colectiva are teaming up to bring a slime party for kids this Halloween. The community event will include a slime station, music, treats and drinks for the kids. The event is free but space is limited to 30 kids, so be sure to register online here. 

    When: 10 a.m. - noon, Oct. 31

    Where: Guardia Park, 410 Garden Homes Ave., Los Angeles

    More info here. 

    Wababoo! Bash Halloween

    The Wabash Recreation Center is hosting an all-ages Halloween costume party. Kids will have the opportunity to trick-or-treat, play games, do face painting and enjoy some food.

    When: Noon - 4 p.m., Oct. 31

    Where: Wabash Recreation Center, 2765 Wabash Ave., Los Angeles

    “It’s the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown” screening at Libros Schmibros Lending Library

    Libros Schmibros will screen “It’s the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown” to mark the film’s 60th anniversary. Costumes are encouraged and free candy will be provided for those who attend. 

    When: 4 - 6 p.m., Oct. 31

    Where: Libros Schmibros Lending Library, 103 N Boyle Ave., Los Angeles

    More info here.
  • Neighbors are stepping up as fears of ICE persist
    A man walks by a building and sign that reads "I Voted" with an arrow pointing in that same direction.
    Voter education forums are being held across the state as California experiences a surge in immigration enforcement.

    Topline:

    Voter education forums are being held across the state as advocates warn that increased immigration enforcement is an effort to intimidate voters.

    Boyle Heights training: A training on Friday was held in partnership with the nonprofit Catalyst California, through its coalition known as We Are California, which includes partners like CHIRLA and PICO California. The Can’t Stop California campaign is holding statewide vote protector trainings in Koreatown, the Inland Empire and the San Fernando Valley.

    The backstory: In Los Angeles, immigrant rights advocates and elected officials have urged residents to remain vigilant and to vote early, either by mail or by dropping their ballot off at an official ballot drop box as soon as possible.

    Read on... for more on the the Boyle Heights training.

    This story first appeared on The LA Local.

    On a Friday evening in Boyle Heights, several dozen people gathered on Whittier Boulevard for a night out.

    It was open mic night at InnerCity Struggle, but a crowd of about 60 got there an hour early. Elders, youth, Spanish and English speakers packed a room inside the community center with a larger mission in mind: They were training to become neighborhood vote protectors. 

    Trainees were advised to encourage voters to stay in line. To observe, document and report any form of voter suppression. To know their First Amendment rights.

    “These are your everyday community members … that came out for a common goal, which is to learn how to protect our community,” said Michelle Benavides, InnerCity Struggle’s director of civic engagement.

    Voter education forums are being held across the state as California experiences a surge in immigration enforcement that community and labor organizations condemn as a coordinated campaign by the federal government to intimidate voters. That’s on top of the U.S. Department of Justice’s deployment of 1,000 federal election observers that State Attorney General Rob Bonta has labeled as “the source of interference.”

    In Los Angeles, immigrant rights advocates and elected officials have urged residents to remain vigilant and to vote early, either by mail or by dropping their ballot off at an official ballot drop box as soon as possible.

    “The timing of these actions, just weeks before the midterm elections, is no accident,” CHIRLA’s policy director Jeannette Zanipatin said at a convening with election leaders last Friday. “These tactics seek to silence immigrant communities, suppress civic participation and divide our neighborhoods.”

    Commerce resident Martha Moya attended the training at InnerCity Struggle last Friday and shared an experience she had at a polling place some years ago when she was asked if she was a U.S. citizen as she prepared to drop off her mail-in ballot.

    “It was ridiculous. If I wasn’t a citizen, then I wouldn’t have been there at all,” Moya recalled telling the worker. 

    That experience emboldened her to fight for voter rights, she said.

    A mural in the background as silhouettes of people are shown at the ballot booth voting for their candidates.
    A voter casts their ballot in the California Primary Election at Weingart East LA YMCA on Tuesday, June 2, 2026, in Los Angeles, Calif.
    (
    Dania Maxwell
    /
    The LA Local
    )

    The training on Friday was held in partnership with the nonprofit Catalyst California, through its coalition known as We Are California, which includes partners like CHIRLA and PICO California. The Can’t Stop California campaign is holding statewide vote protector trainings in Koreatown, the Inland Empire and the San Fernando Valley.

    About 20 who attended the training signed up to monitor polls. Organizers said they can choose which poll locations they’d like to monitor. They’re encouraged to show up with a partner. Trainees will be provided with “NEIGHBORHOOD VOTE PROTECTOR” hats and T-shirts.

    A crowd of people sitting in chairs in a room face one direction as a couple of people raise their hands.
    Residents were taught how to observe, document and report voter suppression at a training on Friday, Oct. 16 at InnerCity Struggle.
    (
    Alejandra Molina
    /
    Boyle Heights Beat
    )

    Attendees of the training in Boyle Heights learned that intimidation tactics can include voters being blocked from accessing polling locations, being threatened with criminal actions or being questioned about their citizenship. People holding signs reading “Only Citizens Can Vote – We’ll Be Checking” are a form of voter intimidation, they learned.

    The training covered how election workers are also at risk of intimidation if they’re disrupted from opening or closing polling locations or from counting ballots, and offered a hotline number to call if they witness any kind of suppression happening at their local polling sites.

    Trainees discussed their First Amendment right to photograph or film anything in plain view, including law enforcement. However, they were told, filming anyone within 100 feet of a polling place could be interpreted as intimidation. 

    Directing focus to voters and encouraging them to stay in line is key, they learned.

    What community members learned about voter protection

    Stay in line. If you are in line to vote when polls close, you have the right to vote.

    You do not have to show ID to vote in a state election in CA. 

    Call or text 866-OUR-VOTE to speak with a trained volunteer if you experience any challenges voting.

    If asked to prove citizenship or observe someone being asked for proof, you can document the incident here: bit.ly/cantstopcareport

    Source: Can’t Stop California

    Kaylanie Santos, an 18-year-old first-time voter, attended the training. “There’s a lot more intimidation tactics than I realized,” she said. 

    Santos said she planned to monitor polling sites on Election Day from a safe distance, despite the fear of being profiled.

    “There should be people there protecting other people, help out the village, be there for another person even if you don’t know them. That’s your people. … It’s important to look out and defend,” Santos said.