This story is free to read because readers choose to support LAist. If you find value in independent local reporting, make a donation to power our newsroom today.
New Bill Targets Legacy Admissions At Private Colleges
Stanford University
(
Jason Leung
/
Unsplash
)
The law would ban state financial aid for private universities in California that consider legacy in admissions.
A new bill introduced by Assemblymember Phil Ting would ban state financial aid for private universities in California that consider legacy when admitting students.
Ting, who represents western San Francisco and northwestern San Mateo County, joined LAist’s daily news program, AirTalk to discuss the legislation along with Jerry Lucido, professor of clinical education and senior scholar at the Center for Enrollment Research, Policy and Practice at USC.
What the bill would do and who's affected
The bill aims to take away Cal Grant funding from institutions that consider family ties during the admissions process.
“The Cal Grant … is a very powerful way that colleges and universities — the private ones, as well as the public ones — advance their equity agenda by having more financial aid for students who need it. The prospect of taking that away makes this bill a very powerful disincentive for colleges to do legacy admission,” explained Lucido.
Said Ting, “What we're talking about is really only three major institutions in the state, which is Stanford, USC, and Santa Clara, who admit between 13 to 15% of their class and give preferential treatment to donors and alumni.”
Sponsored message
He further contextualized those numbers, “That's 50% more than the number of African Americans they admit to their class, and almost the same number of Latinos they admit.”
Legacies and equity
Proponents of legacy admissions say they strengthen alumni networks, leading to increased donations that can cover more scholarships. Legacy students are also more likely to pay full tuition to attend.
“People who do college admissions care a lot about equity, but they have to balance many competing interests … And when you change one aspect of that ecology, other aspects are impacted. That said, I agree with the Assemblyman that legacy admission should end.” explained Lucido. “I would favor being very transparent about how all of these spaces are being used and who gets them.”
Ting referenced a study by Opportunity Insights, a group of Harvard economists, that found that “if you were a family from the top 1% of the country, which is a family making over $600,000, you were twice as likely to get admitted to those same institutions as anybody else, the other 99%. And that is for children or for students who have the same grades, the same test scores, roughly the same activities.”
Second time's the charm?
Ting attempted to pass a similar bill in 2019. “We couldn't get it out of the Assembly Higher Education Committee, which is why we decided to turn it into a study bill and ask the institutions to report data … Now that we actually have data, we see what institutions really heavily rely on preferential treatment for wealthy donors and wealthy alumni.”
Sponsored message
2024’s political climate is markedly different from 2019’s, particularly since the Supreme Court struck down affirmative action last year.
“I think we have a much better chance of having it pass this year,” said Ting.
Listen here
Listen
15:37
A New Bill Is Targeting Legacy Admissions In California
Trending on LAist
-
Sharpen your pencils and open your spreadsheets. We’re going to talk about pregnancy and work — from family leave to accommodations during pregnancy, and where you can pump when you return to work. -
She sat down with us in April, nearly 50 years after the night she turned down Marlon Brando's Best Actor Oscar — which is still among the most memorable and contentious in Academy Awards history. -
The goal is to reduce the often inequitable police enforcement of crossing the street. In Los Angeles, nearly a third of citations each year are written to Black pedestrians, who make up about 9% of the city’s population. -
A year after inception, LA's once-a-month thrifters' paradise Black Market Flea is still ‘Black as Hell’ -
You asked us for tips on how to feel confident and prepared to raise concerns, ask questions— and more importantly, get answers — about your care during pregnancy and childbirth. We got the experts. -
L.A. parking rules are confusing (and enraging). This guide will help.
Best of LAist
