Support for LAist comes from
Local and national news, NPR, things to do, food recommendations and guides to Los Angeles, Orange County and the Inland Empire
Stay Connected
Listen

Share This

News

Nothing Can Fix LA Traffic, So Deal With It

(Photo by Pranav Bhatt / Flickr CC)
()

Congress has cut federal funding for public media — a $3.4 million loss for LAist. We count on readers like you to protect our nonprofit newsroom. Become a monthly member and sustain local journalism.


THIS STORY IS PART OF HOW TO L.A., OUR ONGOING SERIES OF PRACTICAL GUIDES FOR DAY-TO-DAY LIVING IN LOS ANGELES.


Here's a dirty little secret that politicians, agencies and transportation innovators probably don't want you to know: there is almost nothing they can do to fix traffic in a thriving city like Los Angeles.

Support for LAist comes from

This may come as a surprise, if you listen to claims about new train lines, freeway expansions, bike lanes, autonomous vehicles, flying Ubers and underground tunnel systems, which are promoted as ways to alleviate congestion.

But while some of these may indeed bring mobility benefits or quality-of-life improvements, none of them is a cure for traffic.

BUT ELON SOUNDED SO LEGIT

I know. And for those of us who aren't steeped in academic transportation theory, this gridlocked inevitability can seem depressing and/or counterintuitive.

But think about it -- can you name any major city in the world that doesn't have slow traffic?

Congestion persists no matter how awesome a city's transit system is, or how complete its bike network is, or how big the freeways are or how much new technology has advanced.

Transportation planners have been documenting this phenomenon for almost a century.

Support for LAist comes from

MORE CAPACITY = MORE TRAFFIC

Oft-cited research from economist Anthony Downs found -- as far back as the 1960s -- that traffic on urban freeways always increases to meet maximum capacity. He also found that adding new roads or lanes doesn't help.

A 2009 study called "The Fundamental Law of Road Congestion" reiterated these findings with modern evidence from U.S. cities.

"When we add highway capacity to a city, we see traffic increase at exactly the same rate," said Matthew Turner, co-author of the paper and a professor of economics at Brown University.

It's a well-documented but poorly understood paradox: adding more road capacity doesn't reduce congestion. It just causes more driving, as happened on the 405 Freeway after expansion. (Photo by Kevork Djansezian/Getty Images)
()

Even in Los Angeles' recent history, we have ample evidence of this road congestion phenomenon: the $1.6 billion expansion of the 405 Freeway's Sepulveda Pass. The project took five years and added another lane in each direction, and yet hasn't moved the needle on peak-hour delays.

In fact, a Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority study showed rush-hour travel times actually slowed by a minute on average during the year after completion in 2014, and traffic has only increased since then.

Support for LAist comes from

A USC/Metro study found the first phase of the Expo Line light rail from downtown to Culver City also had no effect on traffic on the parallel 10 Freeway or nearby streets. That's despite the fact the rail line attracted healthy ridership of more than 30,000 people a day.

IT'S NOT JUST ABOUT SPACE

The main concept to understand is that traffic isn't just about available space. Space is only one of the two major variables affecting congestion.

The other is demand -- how much people want to drive.

And in busy, crowded places like L.A., demand doesn't stay the same when you increase capacity; it's very dynamic.

Translation: The easier you make it to drive, the more people want to do it.

For instance, you might avoid visiting a good friend often in West L.A. because the traffic there is bad. But if new capacity is added, that makes it easier to drive and you'll visit your friend more often or at times you would have previously avoided.

Support for LAist comes from

Or if driving gets easier, you might take a job that's a little further away, decide to shop often or eat out more nights of the week than you used to, commute to work a little later, take an easier main route instead of backroads or stop making the effort to take transit.

"When you add up the millions and millions of people in the L.A. area, the aggregate effect of those individual decisions to venture out onto the roadway means that it's hard for adding a lane or even a couple lanes to really move the needle on traffic during peak hours," said Juan Matute, deputy director of the UCLA Institute of Transportation Studies.

This video of traffic crawling on the 405 freeway the day before Thanksgiving, November 21, 2017 is an extreme example of the delays caused by society converging on the roads at the same time, as we do on a daily basis to go to work, school and activities in metropolitan areas. Video by KABC
()

WHAT ABOUT THE AUTONOMOUS CARS / TUNNELS / FLYING TAXIS / NEXT-BIG-THINGS?

The problem all these ideas have in common is that they only address one variable in the traffic equation: capacity.

Autonomous vehicles do have the potential to make traffic flows more efficient, which will free up space on the roads. Routing traffic through the air or underground also adds extra capacity to the system. But they fail to address demand.

"We have a lot of experience with capacity increases," said Turner of Brown University.

"It's not clear that the capacity expansion that we get from these is going to be different than the capacity expansion that we get from adding lanes," which his research and that of others show does not reduce congestion because more space makes driving easier and thus increases demand.

History also proves that congestion in cities isn't a problem that can be solved with new technology.

In this undated file photo, passengers in a public transportation tram, right, look out the windows as they are stalled in a traffic jam in downtown Los Angeles. (AP Photo/File)
()

"The streetcar was a solution to the problem of congestion of animals and people in the streets, and the automobile was the solution to the problem of streetcars being congested and backed up on the streets," said Brian Taylor, director of the UCLA Institute of Transportation Studies. "So, if there's a constant through this, it's congestion within cities."

While each new development and expansion of capacity bestowed a temporary benefit on drivers, as when the new freeway system was built in Los Angeles, Taylor said the new freedom is always short-lived as travel patterns and demand adjust to the new realities.

"Nature abhors a vacuum and the transportation system abhors extra capacity. So things fill back in," he said.

FOR WHOM THE CAR TOLLS

One of the only research-proven methods that experts agree can reduce congestion is tolls, which attack the demand factor in the traffic equation.

"In the same way as if you made any other thing available for free, then people will use more of it," said Turner, comparing roads to any other commodity that can be priced according to the demand.

A tolling system has proven successful in cities like London, Stockholm and Singapore, where fees are charged to drive in the busiest central parts of town and adjusted up or down based on how crowded the streets are at any given time.

Revenues from the tolls are reinvested in driving alternatives, like improved transit or biking and walking infrastructure.

However, while Los Angeles and nearby counties have put in toll lanes on freeways, the idea of deploying them on a large scale to mitigate congestion remains highly controversial and unpopular.

Taxpayers, after all, already pay for the building and maintenance of roads, and some complain that charging tolls or use fees for roads would unfairly burden the poor.

FINDING ACCEPTANCE

This all leaves us with one last solution: acceptance.

UCLA's Taylor said we should look on the bright side: all this congestion is actually reflecting positive things about our economy and our access to the good things in life.

"Think about places that have no congestion -- Brownsville, Texas, or Salina, Kansas, or Detroit. We don't say, 'It's so great in those places because they don't have any congestion.' Congestion is a problem that arises from all of the activity we have in cities."

As Editor-in-Chief of our newsroom, I’m extremely proud of the work our top-notch journalists are doing here at LAist. We’re doing more hard-hitting watchdog journalism than ever before — powerful reporting on the economy, elections, climate and the homelessness crisis that is making a difference in your lives. At the same time, it’s never been more difficult to maintain a paywall-free, independent news source that informs, inspires, and engages everyone.

Simply put, we cannot do this essential work without your help. Federal funding for public media has been clawed back by Congress and that means LAist has lost $3.4 million in federal funding over the next two years. So we’re asking for your help. LAist has been there for you and we’re asking you to be here for us.

We rely on donations from readers like you to stay independent, which keeps our nonprofit newsroom strong and accountable to you.

No matter where you stand on the political spectrum, press freedom is at the core of keeping our nation free and fair. And as the landscape of free press changes, LAist will remain a voice you know and trust, but the amount of reader support we receive will help determine how strong of a newsroom we are going forward to cover the important news from our community.

Please take action today to support your trusted source for local news with a donation that makes sense for your budget.

Thank you for your generous support and believing in independent news.

Chip in now to fund your local journalism
A row of graphics payment types: Visa, MasterCard, Apple Pay and PayPal, and  below a lock with Secure Payment text to the right
(
LAist
)

Trending on LAist