One year ago, Congress defunded public media. Now that we're 100% community funded, please become a sustaining member or increase your existing membership today.
To bird or not to bird, that's the question this Thanksgiving
Even raising the possibility of a turkey-less Thanksgiving is enough to get people passionately defending their viewpoint.
Team Turkey: How can you eviscerate a four-hundred-year-old tradition?
Team No Turkey: Why cook a whole turkey with all the fixings when many secretly dislike it? (And some don’t want to celebrate the holiday at all. I should know — a few of them are my relatives.)
In a 2024 online survey by the travel website The Vacationer, about 35% of respondents said turkey was their most disliked Thanksgiving food.
Restaurants and hotels are beginning to offer alternatives, like “Give Thanks for Duck” at Fairmont Breakers in Long Beach and grilled branzino, ssam-style, at the Hollywood Roosevelt.
We asked two food experts to give us their views on the debate.
Team No Turkey
Chef and cookbook author Kiano Moju is a committed member of Team No Turkey. In a recent Threads post, she said her family has probably been turkey-free for almost a decade.
Moju, author of AfriCali, a cookbook inspired by growing up in California with a Kenyan mother and a Nigerian father, said she’s never been a fan of the bird. “I personally don’t like the taste. I hate the smell.”
Eventually, after years of turkey-filled Thanksgivings, the rest of the family admitted they felt the same. “It became clear that none of us cared for turkey as a protein,” she said.
Moju said her family has created their own ways of giving thanks around the table, just without the turkey centerpiece. But they didn’t drop it cold turkey (pun intended). It was a slow phase-out. For years, whole birds sat as leftovers and were eventually tossed. She came to see that turkey was there “for the sake of American tradition versus for what people actually enjoyed eating.”
So they looked elsewhere for main dishes, drawing inspiration from her mother’s family. They’re Kenyan Maasai ranchers who raise cows, goats and sheep, and their celebratory meals have never centered on a single “hero meat.”
“It’s never just one,” she said.
Now her holiday table has three meat dishes:
- Roasted lamb shoulder seasoned with cumin, coriander, ginger and garlic, cooked over a bed of carrots and potatoes
- A roasted chicken
- Pili pili beef fry with green beans
Stuffing, mashed potatoes, cranberry sauce and pumpkin pie have all made a quiet exit too. Instead, they eat beef wet fry with green beans, jollof rice and Kenya chapati (a flatbread)
It may feel sacrilegious for some, but for Moju, it’s a truer version of how family eats.
“We’re gonna eat the food we like, instead of the food we’re told to eat.”
Team Turkey
Meanwhile, Jon Regalado, head butcher at Gwen, a Michelin-recognized restaurant with a world-class butcher shop in Hollywood, defends the fowl. He says turkey’s bad reputation usually comes down to how it’s cooked.
Whole turkeys are in demand at Gwen, and he expects to sell out. But even with the bird’s enduring popularity, he does hear the same complaint every year: Turkey is dry. “It can be if you don’t cook it properly,” he said.
His fixes:
- Start with a brine: Regalado prefers a wet brine, but a dry brine can be easier at home.
- Use a probe thermometer: Take the bird out about 10 degrees short of 165, since it keeps cooking after it leaves the oven.
- Let it rest for 20 to 30 minutes: “If you cut that turkey while it’s hot, all the juices will seep out,” he said.
For smaller gatherings, Regalado suggests skipping the whole bird. “You don’t need a whole 16-pound turkey,” he said. Instead, perhaps order turkeys spatchcocked — when the backbone is removed and the bird is laid flat to cook faster — or as a turkey crown, the breast with the wings attached, as his customers do.
And he’s seeing some slow acknowledgment of individual taste preferences. He said some customers now add a ham or a dry-aged duck for anyone at the table who isn’t a turkey fan.
When it comes down to it, Regalado said, the bird isn’t really the point of the holiday. “It doesn’t have to be turkey dinner,” he said. “You can go out for Chinese food, and as long as you’re celebrating it with family, I think that’s totally fine.”
Moju is a little more blunt: “Leave these birds alone. If you don’t want to eat them, don’t.”
Where to get your Thanksgiving main
Gwen Butcher Shop & Restaurant (Hollywood)
Turkeys: Organic broad-breasted turkeys from Willie Bird in California, or Black Spanish heritage turkeys from Joyce Farms in North Carolina.
How to order: 323-946-7500 or info@gwenla.com.
Playa Provisions (Playa del Rey)
Dine-in: Family-style dinner of herb-and-citrus roast turkey with all the sides.
To go: Roasting your own bird? Preorder sides that serve four, plus pies. Order by noon Nov. 23; pickup Nov. 25 or Thanksgiving morning.
Pontu (Santa Monica, takeout)
Peruvian pollo a la brasa feasts: $89, feeds 4–6, or $169, feeds 8–10.
Order by Nov. 24; pickup Thanksgiving Day, 11:30 a.m.–2 p.m.
Sky Room at Fairmont Breakers (Long Beach, dine-in)
"Give Thanks for Duck,” a two-course duck dinner, $125 per person, 3–8 p.m. on Thanksgiving. Reservations through the hotel’s site.
Gable at Hollywood Roosevelt (dine-in)
A live-fire, three-course prix fixe ($95 with grilled branzino, from Nov. 19–28.
Reservations at gable.la or 323-785-7000.