Sponsored message
Logged in as
Audience-funded nonprofit news
radio tower icon laist logo
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
Subscribe
  • Listen Now Playing Listen

The Brief

The most important stories for you to know today
  • The crunchiest, tastiest loaves in the city
    Three sliced baguettes with golden, crackled crusts show an airy, open crumb on a floured wooden cutting board.
    L-R: cut baguettes from Monsier Marcel, Republique, Bub and Grandmas.

    Topline:

    After a daily diet of high quality baguettes in France this summer, writer Maureen Grady set out to find something similar in L.A. She discovered that while finding “a baguette” is just as easy as going to the local supermarket, finding “the baguette” requires some footwork and return visits to L.A.’s best bakeries.

    Why it matters: You’ve already splurged on that fancy French butter, so you may as well slather it on the finest baguette you can find.

    What we found: République in Miracle Mile, Bub and Grandma's in Glassell Park, Maison Matho in Melrose Hill, Monsieur Marcel in the Original Farmer's Market. But of course it's subjective - go try them yourself!

    This summer, I was lucky enough to spend a month in France with my family. For breakfast each day, we'd head to the local boulangerie and, for around $1.35, get a deliciously crusty, chewy and tasty baguette that made you excited to go home and slather it in butter (or maybe that’s just me).

    Back in Los Angeles, jet-lagged, I hungered for something similar. The baguettes in my local Ralphs weren't quite cutting it, so I did what any other millennial would do and reached out to my cohorts via Instagram stories, asking for recommendations to satisfy my cravings.

    I got many great suggestions — so many, in fact, that I ended up driving around the city, checking each one out. It quickly turned into a quasi-obsessive quest to find the best baguettes in L.A., the results of which I'm now sharing.

    Criteria

    While this is, of course, a subjective ranking, I decided to approach it in a somewhat scientific way. I came up with a rubric to judge each baguette, rating each factor on a scale of 0 to 5 and tallying it all up to arrive at a total score out of 20.

    • Looks: Since we eat first with our eyes, looks definitely mattered (and this is L.A., of course).
    • Crust: Firm, not too thick, a little crispy but not overly crunchy.
    • Inside: Airy and chewy, not too dense, but thick enough to hold a slab of French demi-sel butter.
    • Flavor: A nice yeasty and salty flavor, not overly salted, that lets the filling shine.

    (Note: Many of the recommendations were for amazing bakeries that make sourdough baguettes. No shade, but I was looking for the traditional French version, so unfortunately Friends and Family in Thai Town, Michelina in the Original Farmer's Market, Petitgrain in Santa Monica and Gjusta in Venice had to be excluded from my rankings.)

    My top four spots for baguettes in L.A.

    Here are the all-star four that made it to the top (highest to lowest):

    1) République (Miracle Mile)

    A hand holds a long baguette in front of Republique bakery's blue storefront window.
    Republique's baguette sent Grady back to France — no plane ticket required.
    (
    Maureen Grady
    /
    LAist
    )

    Ranking: 20 points
    Price: $6

    I can still recall when this was Campanile, many years ago. I always adored the space, although not so much the line to get in, but now with a walk-up window for coffee and baked goods, I was able to avoid the wait. The baguette looked amazing with its length and pointed nubs (5 points), and a deep, toasted brown color. It had a firm outer crust (5 points), with an airy yet pleasingly dense interior (5 points). The flavor was great, not too salty or bland, but yeasty and bready (5 points). For me, this was the baguette that brought me the closest to France — no plane needed.

    Location: 624 S. La Brea Ave.
    Hours: Sunday - Monday 8 a.m. - 2 p.m.; Tuesday - Friday 8 a.m.- 2 p.m., 5:30 p.m.- 10 p.m.; Saturday 8 a.m. - 2 p.m., 5 p.m.-10 p.m.

    2) Bub and Grandma’s (Glassell Park)

    A hand holds a crusty baguette wrapped in paper outside a storefront with a 'Bub and Grandma's' sign.
    The delight of a perfectly baked, fresh, crusty baguette at Bub and Grandma's
    (
    Maureen Grady
    /
    LAist
    )

    Ranking: 19 points
    Price: $4.50

    This adorable neighborhood restaurant has a fun aesthetic, and I loved their branding and fonts. They also have a great window to order from with minimal lines (depending on the time). I walked up and quickly received a fresh baguette. It looked toasted and golden (5 points), with a crispy and firm crust (5 points), and a spongy, airy inside — maybe a little too airy? (Is that possible?) (4 points). The flavor of the baguette had good salinity, but wasn't overpowering (5 points). The price is also unbeatable. Overall, pretty close to perfect.

    Location: 3507 Eagle Rock Blvd.
    Hours: Monday - Friday 8 a.m. - 3 p.m., Saturday - Sunday 8 a.m. - 3 p.m., 5 p.m. - 10 p.m.


    3) Maison Matho (Melrose Hill)

    A hand holds a pastry in a paper bag labeled "Maison Matho" outside a colorful muralled storefront.
    Maison Matho's baguette hit the spot.
    (
    Maureen Grady
    /
    LAist
    )

    Ranking: 17 points
    Price: $6.50

    The baguette did not appear to be on the menu, but I’d heard through the grapevine that this was one of the best. A disclaimer: It’s a demi baguette (half a baguette), which is typically sold with jam and butter and not for solo takeaway situations. They allowed me to just buy the baguette, but let me know it was a one-time courtesy. The look of the baguette was cute and nicely toasted (4 points), and the crust texture was perfect (5 points). The insides looked like the ideal mixture of air and density (5 points), while the flavor of the baguette had a mild whole wheat flavor, which wasn’t the flavor I was looking for (3 points). Overall, a nice choice and their sandwiches and breakfast items looked delicious.

    Location: 4770 Melrose Ave.
    Hours: Monday - Thursday 7 a.m. - 3 p.m., Friday 7 a.m. - 4 p.m.; Saturday - Sunday 8 a.m - 4 p.m.

    4) Monsieur Marcel (Beverly Grove in the Original Farmers Market)

    A long baguette dusted with flour and scored diagonally rests on a wooden cutting board.
    Monsieur Marcel's baguette, which goes beautifully with the multiple French provisions you can also buy there.
    (
    Maureen Grady
    /
    LAist
    )

    Ranking: 16 points
    Price: $3.85

    This baguette was warm and squishy, and even though I waited to eat it until we got home, it was still surprisingly good. The loaf looked great (5 points), with a nice firm and chewy crust (5 points). The flavor felt authentic, if a bit bland (3 points). The inside looked a little dense and wasn’t as airy as I would have liked (3 points). Still, a strong contender at an even better price! Additionally, it’s pretty great to be able to purchase the baguette in the same place you can also buy imported French butter, cheese and any other snack for your apéro table (e.g., Bret’s chips, cornichons, wine).

    Location: 6333 W. 3rd St., Stall 150.
    Hours: Monday - Saturday 11 a.m, - 9 p.m., Sunday: 11 a.m. - 8 p.m.

    Living in Los Angeles is such a privilege. An incredible city where we can find all the flavors we miss from home (or vacation), we just may need to traverse a few freeways to get them. But trust me, all that driving is worth le pain.
  • Nothing concerning found in testing
    Exterior of a single-story, mid-century modern school building with a stone-textured wall bearing the metal lettering “James Monroe School,” shaded by a large tree.
    Monroe Elementary School in Lakewood on Friday, Oct. 16, 2026.

    Topline:

    Long Beach Unified says it conducted two rounds of environmental testing and found nothing concerning in a Monroe Elementary School building where dozens of children have reported falling ill with unexplained symptoms, including headaches, nosebleeds and nausea.

    Why now: After immense pressure from parents, the district temporarily moved all students out of the building in October “as an added precaution” and announced Monday that students would not return “to provide stability and avoid another move,” acceding to parents’ requests, according to emails sent to parents and shared with the Long Beach Post.

    The backstory: LBUSD closed the Monroe campus more than a decade ago, but it currently serves as a temporary site for upper grades at Patrick Henry Elementary while their campus undergoes upgrades. Once students moved into the Monroe campus in August, more than 50 fourth and fifth graders across eight classrooms began reporting a suite of similar symptoms. Some parents said they initially thought the symptoms were heat-related because the classrooms were not air-conditioned, and Long Beach experienced a scorching heat wave during the early weeks of school. Yet as parents began comparing notes, many wondered if something else could be making their children sick and pushed the district to test classrooms, they said.

    This story was originally published by Long Beach Post.

    Long Beach Unified says it conducted two rounds of environmental testing and found nothing concerning in a Monroe Elementary School building where dozens of children have reported falling ill with unexplained symptoms, including headaches, nosebleeds and nausea.

    After immense pressure from parents, the district temporarily moved all students out of the building in October “as an added precaution” and announced Monday that students would not return “to provide stability and avoid another move,” acceding to parents’ requests, according to emails sent to parents and shared with the Long Beach Post.

    The backstory

    LBUSD closed the Monroe campus more than a decade ago, but it currently serves as a temporary site for upper grades at Patrick Henry Elementary while their campus undergoes upgrades.

    Once students moved into the Monroe campus in August, more than 50 fourth and fifth graders across eight classrooms began reporting a suite of similar symptoms. Some parents said they initially thought the symptoms were heat-related because the classrooms were not air-conditioned, and Long Beach experienced a scorching heat wave during the early weeks of school. Yet as parents began comparing notes, many wondered if something else could be making their children sick and pushed the district to test classrooms, they said.

    Initial tests for just one classroom showed very high temperatures (102.6 degrees on the hottest day measured) and high humidity but did not reveal dangerous levels of mold or volatile organic compounds (man-made chemicals found in paint and cleaning supplies).

    Parents, unsatisfied, demanded the district test all the classrooms and expand the panel to include asbestos, hydrogen sulfide, methane, ammonia and formaldehyde.

    ‘Normal air ecology’

    On Oct. 24, the entire building was tested, and environmental experts did not detect levels of mold, volatile organic compounds or moisture that would pose a health risk, according to a report released by the district.

    During a meeting with parents on Tuesday, one of the experts, Gloria Chan, walked parents through her process and instruments: an infrared camera to detect moisture, a photoionization detector to measure gases in the air, and samplings of mold and particulate matter. None of the tests revealed any health hazards, Chan said.

    LBUSD Environmental Health & Safety Manager Karlin Cisco said he personally reviews all the testing, checks it for accuracy and can recommend additional testing. He called the testing “favorable” and said it “indicated normal air ecology.”

    In the most recent report, Chan suggested the students’ symptoms may have been explained by the high temperatures, which can strip moisture from the nose, causing small blood vessels to burst and produce nosebleeds. The additional symptoms — including dizziness, headaches and nausea — may also have been heat-related, according to the report.

    Some parents pushed back, saying that their children endured heat waves without air conditioning at Henry and had not experienced those symptoms. But the test results did not yield other leads.

    Deputy Superintendent Tiffany Brown said that based on the assessment, it would be safe to move students back into the building that was tested, but to minimize disruptions for students, staff will use the building instead.

    At the meeting, parents stated relief that their children would remain out of the rooms where they had reported falling ill, yet some remained worried about undetected hazards.

    One parent expressed a “real fear that 10 years from now, we’re going to get a call from the next Erin Brockovich that something happened at that Monroe campus,” she said. “These are our babies. We entrust you with their care every day. We need to know that they’ll be safe.”

    Renovations at Henry Elementary are on track and expected to be completed in time for students at Monroe to return to that campus for the 2027-28 school year, according to David Miranda, assistant superintendent of facilities and operations.

  • Sponsored message
  • Ban on public funding of candidates stays in place
    A voter stands behind a white cardboard voting booth marked “I Voted!” with an American flag graphic, filling out a ballot at a Kern County, California polling place. A blurred Kern County ballot box stands in the foreground.
    A voter casts their ballot at the Weill Institute of Bakersfield College in Bakersfield on Nov. 3, 2026

    Topline:

    California’s ban against public funding for most state and local candidates running for office will remain in place now that the defeat of Proposition 4 is official. The Yes on Prop 4 campaign conceded Thursday, after weeks of trailing by a thin margin. The proposition would have lifted the 1988 ban and allowed state and local governments to set up public campaign financing.

    Why it matters: Critics said the public should not subsidize political campaigns, period. Others argued that fraudulent candidates could scam the system, and taxpayers could end up subsidizing candidates or types of political speech they don’t support. Some were also skeptical that public campaign financing could curb private spending in politics, saying there’s little evidence it works.

    The backstory: The ballot measure may have been confusing to voters, which could be why the race was so tight, said Mindy Romero, founder and director of the nonpartisan Center for Inclusive Democracy. Even though polling consistently shows that voters think there’s too much money in politics, there’s no consensus on how to address it, she said.

    California’s ban against public funding for most state and local candidates running for office will remain in place now that the defeat of Proposition 4 is official.

    The Yes on Prop 4 campaign conceded Thursday, after weeks of trailing by a thin margin.

    The proposition would have lifted the 1988 ban and allowed state and local governments to set up public campaign financing.

    With 99% of the votes counted as of Thursday morning, 50.2% of voters opposed the measure, with 49.8% in favor.

    “The razor-thin margin shows just how close California is to embracing a democracy where running for office doesn't require personal wealth or connections to wealthy donors,” said Jenny Farrell, executive director of the League of Women Voters of California and co-chair of the Yes campaign.

    She said the campaign would not hesitate to bring the issue back to voters.

    Other good government groups and Democratic leaders also backed Prop. 4, arguing it would make it easier for candidates without wealthy donors to run for office. They argued it would boost competition and counter the influence of major donors, especially as statewide elections in recent years have grown more expensive.

    “We need to change the way we finance election campaigns so candidates can run and win without having to raise big money, and they can spend their time listening to voters rather than their donors,” said Trent Lange, president of California Clean Money Campaign and co-chair of the Yes campaign.

    Voters 'quite clear'

    “The voters have been quite clear they don’t want taxpayer money being used for politics,” said Assemblymember Carl DeMaio, a San Diego Republican. “Unfortunately, politicians simply can’t take no for an answer.”

    Critics said the public should not subsidize political campaigns, period. Others argued that fraudulent candidates could scam the system, and taxpayers could end up subsidizing candidates or types of political speech they don’t support. Some were also skeptical that public campaign financing could curb private spending in politics, saying there’s little evidence it works.

    Voter confusion?

    The ballot measure may have been confusing to voters, which could be why the race was so tight, said Mindy Romero, founder and director of the nonpartisan Center for Inclusive Democracy. Even though polling consistently shows that voters think there’s too much money in politics, there’s no consensus on how to address it, she said.

    “I think people want to know what that means. Does it mean directly from my pocket? Does it mean additional taxes? Like, what does that look like?” Romero said.

    Seven charter cities in California, including San Francisco, Berkeley and Oakland, were spared from the 1988 ban and already have public campaign financing. Prop. 4 would have given state and other local governments the option to set up similar systems if they choose to.

    The funds wouldn’t have been available to just anybody: To qualify, candidates would have had to prove they had a certain number of small donors or agree to cap how much they would raise and spend on their campaign.

    This article was originally published on CalMatters and was republished under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives license.

  • Message sent from 1 light-day away
    Person in a white coat and cap holds up an American flag in front of a spacecraft in a cleanroom, with two gold discs on a table below.
    This image provided by NASA/JPL-Caltech shows John Casani, Voyager project manager in 1977, holding a small Dacron flag that was folded and sewed into the thermal blankets of the Voyager spacecraft.

    Topline:

    NASA’s Voyager 1 has phoned home from one light-day away, humanity’s first emissary to cross this monumental threshold way out in interstellar space.

    Why now: Flight controllers received the spacecraft’s call Thursday, exactly 24 hours after it was sent. That’s how long it took for the radio signal to traverse the more than 16 billion miles (26 billion kilometers) at the speed of light. “Voyager 1 light-day distance confirmed ... Voyager 1 continues its journey into the unknown,” controller Nshan Kazaryan announced to cheers and applause.

    The backstory: Launched in 1977, Voyager 1 swept past Jupiter in 1979 and Saturn in 1980, snapped the most distant photo ever taken of our “Pale Blue Dot” in 1990, became the most distant human-made object in 1998, and crossed from the sun’s sphere of influence into the vast void between stars in 2012. NASA could not confirm the newest distance record until the signal reached the control team at California’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory via the deep space telescope near Madrid. But that didn’t stop the space agency from wishing everyone a “Happy Voyager light-day … day!” via social media on Wednesday.

    NASA’s Voyager 1 has phoned home from one light-day away, humanity’s first emissary to cross this monumental threshold way out in interstellar space.

    Flight controllers received the spacecraft’s call Thursday, exactly 24 hours after it was sent. That’s how long it took for the radio signal to traverse the more than 16 billion miles (26 billion kilometers) at the speed of light.

    “Voyager 1 light-day distance confirmed ... Voyager 1 continues its journey into the unknown,” controller Nshan Kazaryan announced to cheers and applause.

    For a spacecraft already loaded with historic firsts, it was an especially momentous milestone.

    “Once again Voyager breaking records, breaking boundaries and taking humanity on a voyage,” NASA’s science mission chief Nicky Fox said. “There’s no end for the Voyager mission.”

    Launched in 1977, Voyager 1 swept past Jupiter in 1979 and Saturn in 1980, snapped the most distant photo ever taken of our “Pale Blue Dot” in 1990, became the most distant human-made object in 1998, and crossed from the sun’s sphere of influence into the vast void between stars in 2012.

    NASA could not confirm the newest distance record until the signal reached the control team at California’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory via the deep space telescope near Madrid. But that didn’t stop the space agency from wishing everyone a “Happy Voyager light-day … day!” via social media on Wednesday.

    Voyager 1 and its twin, Voyager 2, are NASA’s longest-operating space missions, churning out data for nearly a half-century despite powering down most of their instruments to keep exploring.

    Voyager 2 actually beat its twin into space by two weeks. But its route to Jupiter and Saturn plus Uranus and Neptune was slower and longer, and it did not reach interstellar space until 2018. It won’t reach the one-light-day mark until 2035.

    Both spacecraft are doing well for their 49 years of age, plowing through space at 38,000 mph (61,000 kph) with plutonium for power. Picture-taking ended long ago, but they typically send back bits of precious data almost every day on their never-before-explored environment.

    Over the weekend, though, Voyager 1’s stream of science and engineering data came to an abrupt halt. The carrier signal that normally conveys that data kept coming in strong and, along with flight path calculations, allowed the team to confirm the light-day milestone. Controllers are trying to figure out why the flow of science and engineering data stopped. A similar problem three years ago was traced to an onboard computer.

    Each Voyager carries a so-called Golden Record brimming with the sounds of Earth. The project was led by the late Cornell University astronomer Carl Sagan, who also coined the phrase “Pale Blue Dot” for Voyager 1’s farewell glimpse of Earth.

    NASA expects the gold-plated phonographic records — time capsules for anyone or anything that might encounter them — to last more than 1 billion years.

    “No matter how long it takes or how dark things get or what we think our limitations are, we should never stop shining and never stop reaching for the stars. For we never know how far we will go,” said deputy project scientist Jamie Rankin of Princeton University. “Shine on, Voyager, shine on.”

    ___

    The Associated Press’ health and science coverage receives financial support from the AP Fund for Journalism and private foundations. AP is solely responsible for all content. Find AP’s standards for working with philanthropies, a list of supporters and funded coverage areas at AP.org.

  • CA told schools to make sure kids see dentists
    A dentist wearing a burgundy coat, face mask, and eyewear, inspects the mouth of a small child wearing a jacket.
    Dentist Don Call checks the teeth of a kindergartner at De Vargas Elementary School in San Jose.

    Topline:

    A 20-year-old initiative requiring California’s youngest students be screened for cavities and untreated tooth decay before they enter public school is falling short.

    Why now: The state created the Kindergarten Oral Health Assessment in 2006 to ensure families connect with dentists, and to identify students’ dental needs and reveal roadblocks to care. But the effort has been dogged by challenges, according to a new California State Auditor report that focused on six school districts and the California Department of Public Health.

    Why it matters: Tooth decay is largely preventable, yet it’s the most common chronic disease in kids nationwide. About 61% of third grade students had tooth decay during the 2018-19 school year, according to a 2021 state report, and experts find that children’s oral health has declined further since the start of the pandemic.

    Read on... for more on the report.

    This story was originally published by CalMatters. Sign up for their newsletters.

    A 20-year-old initiative requiring California’s youngest students be screened for cavities and untreated tooth decay before they enter public school is falling short.

    The state created the Kindergarten Oral Health Assessment in 2006 to ensure families connect with dentists, and to identify students’ dental needs and reveal roadblocks to care. But the effort has been dogged by challenges, according to a new California State Auditor report that focused on six school districts and the California Department of Public Health.

    Tooth decay is largely preventable, yet it’s the most common chronic disease in kids nationwide. About 61% of third grade students had tooth decay during the 2018-19 school year, according to a 2021 state report, and experts find that children’s oral health has declined further since the start of the pandemic.

    Untreated dental problems can lead to missed school days. The California Health Interview Survey from the UCLA Center for Health Policy Research found nearly 7% of children 5 and older who attend school missed class due to dental problems in 2025.

    The review of the districts found that they did not maintain reliable data about all aspects of the program and reported incorrect information to the state. The audited districts are Los Angeles Unified School District, Merced City School District, Milpitas Unified School District, Oakland Unified School District, San Luis Coastal Unified School District, and Woodland Joint Unified School District.

    No state agency is assigned oversight of the kindergarten oral health program, the audit found, and neither the California Department of Education nor the Department of Public Health oversees program activities. The state health department, which is responsible for the state’s efforts to improve dental health, hasn’t verified the data reported by districts, the audit said, and isn’t using the data to measure the state’s progress in improving kids’ oral health.

    The department doesn’t publish annual analyses of the data on its website; the most recent program data available online, from the 2020-21 school year, is on the California Dental Association website. The audit also revealed that the program’s source of funding — a 2016 tax on tobacco products — is dwindling.

    “We determined that unreliable data reported by districts and insufficient statewide oversight of the [Kindergarten Oral Health Assessment] program’s requirements threaten the goals of the program,” State Auditor Grant Parks wrote in a Nov. 5 report.

    Department of Public Health spokesperson Kristine Tuzon, citing state education code, said the agency isn’t responsible for tracking kindergarten oral health program submissions or notifying county offices of education when districts don’t report data. Tuzon said the statute doesn’t give the health department authority to require districts and county offices to comply with the program’s data reporting mandate.

    One method of reducing barriers to kids’ obtaining dental assessments, the audit found, is to conduct more on school campuses, as is done for state-required vision and hearing screenings. That solution, too, has had data-reporting challenges.

    Esther Yepez is the associate director of wellness programs and oral health at The Los Angeles Trust for Children’s Health, which coordinated oral health screenings at L.A. Unified schools for five years. After completing the assessments, her team left the completed forms with the schools. But oftentimes, she said, schools didn't enter those screenings in the district’s system, resulting in a mismatch between the number of students screened and the number reported to the state. It was unclear, she said, who at each school was responsible for compiling the data.

    “It was frustrating,” Yepez said, “because we had information that the screenings had happened, but the schools didn’t have that data.”

    L.A. Unified did not answer CalMatters’ questions regarding data accuracy in the kindergarten oral health program. In a response to the audit published as part of the report, Joel Cisneros, executive director of L.A. Unified’s student mental health and wellness services, said the district plans to train school staff on data-entry procedures and program documentation requirements and establish a standardized process for recording all returned forms and waivers.

    Rotten teeth and huge pain

    The American Academy of Pediatric Dentists recommends that children see a dentist when their first tooth appears, or no later than their first birthday.

    Early childhood dental visits are “extremely important,” said Dr. Francisco Ramos-Gomez, UCLA School of Dentistry’s pediatric dentistry chair and director of the UCLA Center for Children’s Oral Health. But he said many families don’t access care due to transportation challenges, language barriers and few providers treating low-income kids.

    “If we start seeing these children by age 3 or 4,” he said, “they already come with rotten teeth, abscesses and huge pain.”

    The kindergarten program directs school districts to notify families enrolling in public school for the first time in transitional kindergarten, kindergarten or first grade that they need to present proof of an oral health assessment. State law allows parents to waive the assessment requirement due to a financial burden, lack of access to a dental provider or nonconsent.

    The program mandates that districts submit specific data to their county education offices or a system designated by the state’s dental director, which since at least 2021 has been the System for California Oral Health Reporting. It directs the health department to periodically evaluate the kindergarten program requirements.

    But the audit found none of the districts provided families with all required information regarding the assessment requirement. The six audited districts also lacked formalized procedures for following up with families that didn’t return assessment forms, the audit said, or that returned waivers indicating a barrier to obtaining an assessment.

    The audit found that five districts reported data to the state system that was “significantly different” from their local data. For example, L.A. Unified, the state’s largest school district, for the 2024-25 school year incorrectly included all first-graders in its count of students subject to the program requirements, instead of only those who had not previously enrolled in kindergarten in the district, the audit said. The district also overreported the number of students who presented proof of the assessment, the audit said.

    “The magnitude of the reporting errors by Los Angeles Unified School District alone,” Parks wrote, “skews any statewide analysis of the collective data.”

    The audit recommended that the districts provide parents with all required program information and report complete and accurate data to the state system. In responses submitted to the state, the Milpitas and Oakland districts said they would implement the audit’s recommendations, while the L.A. and San Luis Coastal districts shared action plans to address some of the report’s findings. The Merced and Woodland districts did not provide a response.

    ‘Where is the money coming from?’

    Funding for the oral health program is also declining, the audit found.

    The state public health department grants Proposition 56 funds – which are generated by a tax on tobacco products – to county health departments, and requires them to support oral health initiatives, including the kindergarten program. But revenue from the tax is plummeting, according to the audit, and starting next year the health department will no longer require counties receiving grant funds to support the kindergarten program.

    Tuzon said the health department is assessing strategies to maintain and improve compliance with the program, given declining funding from tobacco taxes.

    Despite the data issues, Eileen Espejo, senior managing director for health at Children Now, said policymakers should consider how to fund the kindergarten oral health program moving forward.

    “Local health programs are going to have less capacity to do some of the work,” she said. “There needs to be that conversation of, ‘Where is the money coming from to help increase compliance?’”

    This article was originally published on CalMatters and was republished under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives license.