With our free press under threat and federal funding for public media gone, your support matters more than ever. Help keep the LAist newsroom strong, become a monthly member or increase your support today.
We bought, we tried, we sputtered: looking for LA's spiciest Nashville hot chicken
We tried three Nashville-hot chicken shops to crown the king of spice.
(
Courtesy Dave's Hot Chicken
/
LAist
)
Dozens of Nashville-style hot chicken shops dot the streets of L.A., and opinions abound about whose spicy chicken is the best. But the inner spice fiend in me couldn’t help but wonder… whose spicy tender is the most scorching?
I set up a (highly unscientific) LAist experiment to find out.
The experiment
First, I needed to figure out a few variables.
Support for LAist comes from
Style of chicken: I avoided sandwiches or sliders because I didn’t want the heat of the chicken to be masked with bread, pickles or sauces. I also opted for a non-bone option so all attention could be on a clean, spicy bite. That left me with the classic tender — all flavor, no fuss. Just pure heat.
The contenders: There are many excellent Nashville hot chicken places in L.A., but I realized I needed to narrow down the contenders to save the judges' palettes — and LAist’s budget. So I scoured Reddit forums and other social media posts for recommendations from heat lovers, and saw that three names popped up the most: Dave’s Hot Chicken, Howlin’ Rays and Main Chick.
Oh, and another important consideration: proximity to the LAist office in Pasadena.
The participants: I opened the floor to anyone at LAist who’d want to spend a lunch break sweating over chicken with their colleagues. In the end, we got 11 brave souls to take part, including editors, producers and interns.
Now, asking my colleagues to try the spiciest chicken in L.A. without an out would be akin to torture. Plus, any tasting must include a palette cleanser! So one final, and crucial, question remained… what's the best way to cut the spice?
Turns out it’s a one-word answer: fat.
Support for LAist comes from
Capsaicin is the chemical component that makes your mouth burn when you eat something spicy. But it’s fat-soluble, so foods that are high in fat may dissolve capsaicin and help mask some of the heat.
So, armed with two tubs of Thrifty’s ice cream, two gallons of milk and a dream, we began the experiment.
The trials
First up: Dave’s Hot Chicken's Reaper Tender
The reaper tenders from Dave's Hot Chicken.
(
Danika DeLaczay
/
LAist
)
Dave's is infamous for making people sign a liability waiver before ordering their reaper level — and we at LAist quickly found out why.
Our players started eating with the utmost confidence … until the ultra-spicy Carolina Reaper pepper-extract started to kick in. Faces quickly turned red, and people were desperately reaching for milk and ice cream to cool off.
Support for LAist comes from
“I literally just taste death,” said Managing Editor Jason Wells.
Nic Perez, (L) Ross Brenneman, Matt Ballinger and Dana Littlefield go for the burn.
(
Aiko Offner
/
LAist
)
“Yeah, can we tap out?” said Senior Editor Dana Littlefield, slapping the table and pleading for relief.
Even after it seemed like the spice level had peaked, the reaper seemed to keep getting hotter. The actual flavor of the tender was mostly masked by its heat.
The judges were charged with rating each tender out of 10, with 1 being no big deal, and 10 being the fires of hell.
Most gasped out a 9 or a 10. But AirTalk Producer Nicolas Perez gave it an 8, the lowest ranking of the staff.
“It’s not, like, all-enveloping,” Perez said. “I don’t feel like my entire mouth is on fire. It’s really just concentrated on my tongue. I don’t like the air on my tongue right now.”
Support for LAist comes from
The judges consumed a gallon of milk and an entire tub of ice cream recovering from a few bites of that tender alone.
The chicken shop also offers a cauliflower tender option, which is dubbed ‘Dave’s Not Chicken.’ Two vegetarians on our staff tried it out.
The cauliflower tenders dubbed 'Dave's Not Chicken' from Dave's Hot Chicken.
(
Danika DeLaczay
/
LAist
)
“I might finish this actually, this is really good,” All Things Considered Producer Kevin Tidmarsh said. “I’m going in for another bite.”
Reporting intern Vitus Larrieu said the cauliflower patty had a nice flavor and decent texture.
“Sometimes the best chicken is cauliflower,” he said.
Either the cauliflower damped down the spiciness, or our testers had iron constitutions.
Average meat score: 9.18 out of 10
Average vegetarian score: 8 out of 10
Next up: Howlin’ Rays howlin' tender
The howlin' tenders from Howlin' Rays.
(
Danika DeLaczay
/
LAist
)
Dubbed the best-tasting chicken by most online users from my research, I was curious to see if Howlin’ Rays would live up to its reputation.
Our testers took their first bite of the hottest level, the “howlin’ tender,” a blend of the Carolina Reaper, Ghost Pepper and Trinidad Scorpion peppers. Sounds terrifying, but it didn't seem to take our testers down. They even commented on things other than the spice.
"Oh, the skin on that's good, like the outside is actually good," said Senior Editor Ross Brenneman.
Matt Dangelantonio posing with a tender from Main Chick.
(
Aiko Offner
/
LAist
)
“It has so much more flavor than the last one,” said Senior Editor Matt Ballinger. “I could eat this whole thing.”
While the spiciness was very strong, they said it wasn’t overwhelming, allowing the juiciness of the chicken to come through.
It was clear this tender packed more of a flavorful punch.
“Spicy, but I’m not dying,” Littlefield said. “That one’s my favorite [so far].”
Average score: 6.58 out of 10
Finally: Main Chick's spicy tender
The spicy tenders from Main Chick.
(
Danika DeLaczay
/
LAist
)
Now, a disclaimer. We'd selected what we thought was the spiciest level when we ordered the tenders online. But when they arrived at the office, we saw that our chosen "spicy tender" was outranked by another, an even hotter level — the "supreme tender.” Aaagh! So much for scientific rigor. Still, we had mouths to feed, so we continued with the test.
Our testers’ initial response: "It tastes exactly like the XXTRA Flamin' Hot Cheetos," engagement intern Mikaela Perez said. "That's the amount of spice I'm feeling."
The spice level continue to build. "It's hot," said Ballinger.
"Oh, it's growing!" said Littlefield.
“It has a good tongue burn,” Senior Producer Matt Dangelantonio said. “Not too deep in the back of your throat to the point that you start hacking or hiccupping, but good flavor.”
Wells described it as "having a little kick." But no one was reaching for their milk.
“I expected it to peak a little more,” social intern Danika DeLaczay said. “It hit around my tongue, nowhere else.”
OK, so not really a contender in our trials. But I think it can take its place in the spice universe as a great on-ramp to heat heaven.
Average score: 3.72 out of 10
The winner(s)
Since our test became (ahem) scientifically challenged, we decided to expand the judging categories. Trophies all around!
Hottest: Dave’s Hot Chicken
With a sizzling tender that left our tongues burning long after the challenge was complete, the reaper certainly swept the spice competition.
Most flavor and staff favorite: Howlin’ Rays
Howlin’ Rays expertly blends some scary-sounding peppers into a tender that certainly leaves you howling… for more.
Best gateway tender into the spice world: Main Chick
A spice level the non-contestants in the office could still enjoy, Main Chick brings a subtle sizzle to the table that’s a good on-ramp to more heat.
If you’re interested in seeing our faces burn in real time, you can check out our video on the experiment at @laistofficial.
At LAist, we believe in journalism without censorship and the right of a free press to speak truth to those in power. Our hard-hitting watchdog reporting on local government, climate, and the ongoing housing and homelessness crisis is trustworthy, independent and freely accessible to everyone thanks to the support of readers like you.
But the game has changed: Congress voted to eliminate funding for public media across the country. Here at LAist that means a loss of $1.7 million in our budget every year. We want to assure you that despite growing threats to free press and free speech, LAist will remain a voice you know and trust. Speaking frankly, the amount of reader support we receive will help determine how strong of a newsroom we are going forward to cover the important news in our community.
We’re asking you to stand up for independent reporting that will not be silenced. With more individuals like you supporting this public service, we can continue to provide essential coverage for Southern Californians that you can’t find anywhere else. Become a monthly member today to help sustain this mission.
Thank you for your generous support and belief in the value of independent news.
Chip in now to fund your local journalism
(
LAist
)
Trending on LAist
-
The rock legend joins LAist for a lookback on his career — and the next chapter of his music. -
Yes, it's controversial, but let me explain. -
What do stairs have to do with California’s housing crisis? More than you might think, says this Culver City councilmember. -
Doctors say administrator directives allow immigration agents to interfere in medical decisions and compromise medical care. -
The Palisades Fire erupted on Jan. 7 and went on to kill 12 people and destroy more than 6,800 homes and buildings. -
People moving to Los Angeles are regularly baffled by the region’s refrigerator-less apartments. They’ll soon be a thing of the past.
Best of LAist