Sponsored message
Logged in as
Audience-funded nonprofit news
radio tower icon laist logo
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
Subscribe
  • Listen Now Playing Listen

The Brief

The most important stories for you to know today
  • Fatal shooting won’t stop inclusivity efforts
    A rainbow flag hands in the foreground. In the background there are bouquets of colorful flowers stacked outside of a clothing store called mag.pi.
    A makeshift memorial is seen outside the Mag.Pi clothing store in Cedar Glen, near Lake Arrowhead, California, on August 21, 2023.

    Topline: 

    The rainbow pride flag at the center of a fatal Lake Arrowhead shooting was one sign of an increasingly visible LGBTQ+ community in the San Bernardino mountains. “We've made great strides in building a community and creating safe spots,” said Crestline resident Daniel Bittner. “We just never would have thought such violence would come of it all.”

    The backstory: Laura Ann Carleton, 66, was shot and killed at her Lake Arrowhead clothing store Friday around 5 p.m. The San Bernardino County Sheriff’s Department reported the suspect, who deputies shot and killed, had made disparaging remarks about a rainbow Pride flag hanging outside her shop.

    Increasing LGBTQ+ violence: In the last year there were more than 350 anti-LGBTQ+ incidents ranging from vandalism to assault to the deadly mass shooting at a Colorado gay bar that killed five people.

    Creating a more inclusive community: Carleton’s family created a memorial fund to “develop and amplify resources that promote LGBTQ+ awareness, equality, and inclusion,” and support other community initiatives she believed in. Local non-profit Lake Arrowhead LGBTQ+ was previously raising money to open a LGBTQ+ center on the mountain with recreational activities, health care, counseling, and other resources.

    The rainbow pride flag Laura Ann Carleton flew outside her Lake Arrowhead clothing store was one marker of an increasingly visible LGBTQ+ community in the San Bernardino mountains.

    Though Carleton, who went by Lauri, was not LGTBQ+, members of the community and her family said she was an ally.

    “You definitely know you feel welcome in a store like Lauri’s,'' local realtor and financial professional Daniel Bittner said. “You don't have to worry about prejudice or acting 'too gay.'”

    Last Friday, a 27-year-old man tore down the brightly colored flag, hurled homophobic slurs, and shot Carleton when she confronted him, according to the San Bernardino County Sheriff’s Department. Deputies later shot and killed the suspect when he fired and struck their vehicles.

    Piles of bouquets, candles, and rainbow flags now fill the Mag.Pi storefront. The community is processing a loss that is singular but reflects growing threats against LGBTQ+ people and those who support them.

    “We've made great strides in building a community and creating safe spots,” Bittner said. “We just never would have thought such violence would come of it all.”

    LGBTQ+ communities put down roots

    The Rim of the World highway links more than a half-dozen San Bernardino Mountain communities where locals mix with summer and winter vacationers.

    Daniel Bittner moved to Running Springs part-time in the late ‘90s and early 2000s.

    “Being openly gay in the mountains, there was no community there,” Bittner said. “You could wander all day and not run into another gay person.”

    Bittner said while he was walking down the street once, a group of four guys jumped him and shouted anti-gay slurs. When he was younger, he often sported a mohawk and bright clothing.

    “They knew that I was different,” Bittner said.

    Still, after Bittner met his partner, a Lake Arrowhead salon owner, eight years ago, he put down roots and moved to neighboring Crestline full-time. About 20,000 people live between the two communities.

    Up to 5% of America’s rural population is LGBTQ+, about the same proportion of the general population, according to research from the think tank Movement Advancement Project.

    “Who doesn't want to like step out and see a bunch of beautiful trees and animals and birds and nature,” Bittner said. "I never got that down the hill anywhere.”

    A man with light skin tone and a salt-and-pepper beard with sunglasses  drives a boat festooned with rainbow flags. There is a pontoon boat in the background that also has rainbow flags. Pine trees ring the lake.
    Matthew Clevenger pilots a boat in the 2021 Lake Arrowhead Pride boat parade.
    (
    Courtesy Matthew Clevenger
    )

    During last winter’s punishing winter storms, people checked on their elderly neighbors and organized food and supply runs.

    “There was a lot of solidarity in the community and putting forth efforts to make sure everybody was okay or taken care of,” Bittner said.

    Growing visibility and followship

    The LGBTQ+ community has become more visible in recent years.

    Matthew Clevenger followed his cousin’s footsteps and moved to the area in 2016 with his husband. Within a few years, they’d met and become friends with Bittner and his partner.

    On a typical “Big Gay Sunday,” they take the boat out, barbecue, and hit a local pub.

    “We're not constantly watching our backs up there,” Clevenger said. “We hold hands. We're affectionate in public.”

    In early 2020, the informal meet-ups grew into monthly gatherings with the larger Lake Arrowhead LGBTQ+ community.

    Pandemic social distancing prompted the first Pride boat parade that summer. Now rainbow flags fly on the water throughout the season.

    The events evolved into Lake Arrowhead LGBTQ+, a non-profit with a larger mission of creating a safe and inclusive community.

    More than two dozen businesses including restaurants, coffee roasters, vacation rentals, and fitness centers support the organization as “business allies.”

    One of them was Carleton’s Cedar Glen clothing store, Mag.Pi.

    A stake with a rainbow-colored arch over it. Dozens of people in the audience hold rainbow flags and wear bright colors. A drag queen with a long red, yellow and white dress and medium-dark skin tone performs on stage.
    The main stage at San Bernardino Mountain Pride 2023.
    (
    Courtesy Matthew Clevenger
    )

    The organization’s events have also attracted families like Cheryl Kol’s.

    She moved to Crestline in 2020 with her husband and three kids. Kol, who is Filipino, said her middle son is 17 and came out as gay several years ago.

    There have been a few “looks” but “for the most part, though, everybody has been welcoming and very kind,” Kol said.

    She attended this summer’s Pride with her 9-year-old daughter and her friends.

    The weekend included the boat parade, a concert with “Bass Down Low” singer Dev and performances from Long Beach drag queen Jewels, Delta Work and Mayhem Million of “RuPaul’s Drag Race” fame.

    “We’re just happy to celebrate the uniqueness and the individuality of people. Hopefully, people see that we’re not a threat while supporting this community.”
    — Cheryl Kol, Crestline resident

    “We’re just happy to celebrate the uniqueness and the individuality of people,” Kol said. “Hopefully people see that we’re not a threat while supporting this community.”

    'I wanted to find a community'

    Kimber Christie saw posts about the festivities on Instagram.

    “I still honestly can’t believe that the gays have made it up to Arrowhead,” Christie wrote in response to a video of the main stage.

    Christie grew up in the mountain communities and said she was one one of few LGBTQ+ people in high school. She found a small group of friends, but left soon after graduating in 2014.

    “There really wasn't much room for growth up there. I wanted to travel, see the world,” Christie said. “I wanted to find a community for myself.”

    Christie is now a Navy sonar technician and lives in Hillcrest, the heart of San Diego’s LGBTQ+ community.

    Now, she visits to see old friends showing the sometimes halting growth of LGBTQ+ acceptance in her hometown. Once, someone ripped a rainbow bear sticker from her car’s bumper. Another time, Christie made a special trip to buy Lake Arrowhead Brewery’s now-annual summer Pride beer.

    “I think it’s fantastic,” Christie said. “You're showing little kids, ‘Hey, it's OK to be gay.’ Whereas, you know, I didn't have that growing up whatsoever.”

    Violence against LGBTQ+ people grows

    Authorities continue to investigate the shooting. Sheriff Shannon Dicus said in a press conference Monday that the suspected shooter maintained several social media accounts that posted anti-LGBTQ+ sentiments.

    Listen 0:56
    Shop Owner Killed in Lake Arrowhead

    An image of a burning pride flag is pinned to the top of an X account that shares his name.

    “There have not been any other reported hate crimes in the mountain communities in recent times,” Dicus said at the same conference and noted that there were four seemingly unrelated hate crimes in 2022.

    Bittner, Clevenger and residents in online forums say there are more subtle signs of intolerance.

    Lake Arrowhead Brewing announced a rainbow sherbert sour as the third annual “Pride Brew” in June. The majority of the 400 plus comments on Instagram were positive, but several people expressed disgust, accused the brewery of pushing an agenda and said they wouldn’t be returning.

    Other businesses and homes have had their pride flags tampered with. Clevenger said people have called the local lake association with unfounded complaints about the boat parade.

    There is an increasing threat of violence against LGBTQ+ people and their allies. In the last year, there were more than 350 anti-LGBTQ+ incidents, ranging from vandalism to assault, to the deadly mass shooting at a Colorado gay bar that killed five people.

    “Discrimination and harassment against LGBTQ people happens everywhere,” said Logan Casey, senior policy researcher at the Movement Advancement Project. “That's not a uniquely rural problem.”

    California being one of the best states in the country when it comes to LGBTQ policies on the books doesn't mean that people living in California aren't affected by the rhetoric that's happening in other states.
    — Logan Casey, Movement Advancement Project

    Not all people are targeted equally.

    LGBTQ+ people of color are more likely to experience discrimination than their white counterparts. Transgender people are four times more likely than cisgender people to experience violence including rape and sexual assault.

    Movement Advancement Project tracks legislation and has counted more than 700 “anti-LGBTQ+” bills introduced across the country this year. The legislation ranges from restrictions on drag performances to bans on gender-affirming health care.

    “California being one of the best states in the country when it comes to LGBTQ policies on the books doesn't mean that people living in California aren't affected by the rhetoric that's happening in other states,” Casey said.

    At least three Southern California school districts recently adopted a policy requiring staff to inform parents and caregivers if a child identifies as a gender other than their biological sex.

    Demonstrators who want to limit discussion of LGBTQ+ issues in schools clashed with counter-protestors outside of a Los Angeles Unified School District board meeting Tuesday.

    Creating a more inclusive mountain community

    “[Carleton’s death] highlights how much more work there is for us to do all across the country no matter where we live,” Casey said. “Because everybody deserves the chance to live in the place that they call home and be free from fear.”

    He said one step that anyone can take, no matter where they live, is to talk openly about their support for the LGBTQ+ community. That’s just what Carleton did, according to friends and statements from her family on social media.

    “Her [Pride] flags had been torn down before and she always responded by putting up a bigger one,” daughters Ari and Kelsey Carleton wrote in an Instagram post. “We find peace in knowing she passed quickly in a place she cherished, doing what she loved while fiercely defending something she believed in.”

    Carleton’s family created a memorial fund and plans to to work with Lake Arrowhead LGBTQ+ to “develop and amplify resources that promote LGBTQ+ awareness, equality, and inclusion,” and support other community initiatives she believed in, the website reads.

    The Los Angeles LGBT Center and Flags For Good are selling a Lauri Carleton commemorative Pride flag with proceeds to benefit the organization

    Clevenger said one of the organization’s existing goals was to open an LGBTQ+ community center on the mountain with recreational activities, health care, counseling and other resources

    The closest option for young people is the Rainbow Pride Youth Alliance 20 miles away in San Bernardino. Adults have to travel more than 50 miles to Pomona to find in-person support, according to a national directory of LGBTQ+ centers.

    “We are going to turn this into a positive experience of finding wonderful ways to support the community,” Clevenger said.

  • Long Beach aquarium has plan
    About a dozen small, green frogs with dark spots crowd together on and between smooth gray and tan rocks. Most face different directions, with their dark, gold-rimmed eyes visible.
    A group of frogs piles on top of one another in a tank at the Aquarium of the Pacific in Long Beach, where they are being raised before being released into the local mountains, Tuesday, Sept. 15, 2026.

    Topline:

    A program at Aquarium of the Pacific has nearly closed out its fifth year with a major milestone: more than 1,000 frogs raised and released into the wild.

    The backstory: By the time the mountain yellow-legged frogs was listed under the federal Endangered Species Act in 2002, fewer than 100 adults remained in Southern California. A count in 2020 put the number at about 188 in the wild, though biologists say that figure has almost certainly shifted since.

    Why that matters: That’s more than five times as many mountain yellow-legged frogs — named for the lemon-hued streak along their hind legs — believed to be in the wild when last recorded in 2019, reduced to small pockets of wild streams in the San Gabriel, San Bernardino and San Jacinto Mountains.

    This story first appeared on Long Beach Post.

    Inside three water tanks in a tucked-away room at the Aquarium of the Pacific, biologists are tasked with bringing back a population of frogs that once thrived across the state’s mountainous streams but has since reached the brink of extinction.

    It’s a program that’s nearly closed out its fifth year with a major milestone: more than 1,000 frogs raised and released into the wild.

    That’s more than five times as many mountain yellow-legged frogs — named for the lemon-hued streak along their hind legs — believed to be in the wild when last recorded in 2019, reduced to small pockets of wild streams in the San Gabriel, San Bernardino and San Jacinto Mountains. By the time the frog was listed under the federal Endangered Species Act in 2002, fewer than 100 adults remained in Southern California. A count in 2020 put the number at about 188 in the wild, though biologists say that figure has almost certainly shifted since.

    The species’ collapse is tied to a compounding list of threats: wildfire, mudslides, pesticides, fungal disease, habitat loss and the appetites of non-native trout, bullfrogs and crayfish. It’s a decline so severe that biologists consider the species among the rarest vertebrates on Earth.

    Staff at the Aquarium of the Pacific in Long Beach are working to change that math, one tadpole at a time.

    In the latest release, about 653 of the endangered frogs were returned to their native mountain habitat by staff from the Aquarium of the Pacific, the Los Angeles Zoo and the U.S. Geological Survey. Of those, 394 had been head-started at the aquarium — its largest release of the species yet, bringing its total to 1,032.

    The frogs were bred at the Los Angeles Zoo’s breeding program, then transferred to Long Beach as tadpoles, where aquarium staff reared them through metamorphosis into froglets and frogs. The process typically takes one to two years, though the species can remain in its tadpole stage for up to five years, making a given frog’s age something of a mystery even to the people who raised it.

    A large speckled brown tadpole rests on a bed of multicolored pebbles at the bottom of a green-tinted glass tank. A second tadpole, blurred by motion, swims near the surface above it. A clear glass divider separates the water from a pebbly section on the right.
    A tadpole chills by the rocks in a tank at the Aquarium of the Pacific, where it is being raised before being released into the local mountains, Tuesday, Sept., 15, 2026
    (
    Thomas R. Cordova.
    /
    Long Beach Post
    )

    Inside the aquarium, the water is engineered to mimic the mountains it’s standing in — kept near 60 degrees in summer, the temperature currently found in the streams the frogs call home, and cooled to around 52 degrees in winter, with reduced UV exposure to simulate the season’s shorter, dimmer days.

    The aquarium’s involvement began in 2021, in the aftermath of the 2020 Bobcat Fire, which tore through the central San Gabriel Mountains and destroyed an estimated 95% of the frog’s remaining usable habitat.

    “They had salvaged some tadpoles from the fire-impacted areas, and they ended up bringing a handful of them here,” said Erin Lundy, with the aquarium’s conservation team. “And then we also had some captive-bred ones from the L.A. Zoo that year, and that was our first group.”

    Since then, the team has expanded to include the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, the U.S. Forest Service and the California Department of Fish and Wildlife, which help monitor populations and oversee releases.

    A person with long dark brown hair and a light-medium skin tone smiles as they lean toward an open, shallow tank with pebbles, mossy rocks, and a curved ceramic shelter. They wear a navy polo with a partial wave-shaped logo, a red bracelet, and a black fitness tracker.
    Erin Lundy from the Aquarium of the Pacific looks into a tank at frogs as she gets them ready to be released into the local mountains Tuesday, Sept. 15, 2026
    (
    Thomas R. Cordova
    /
    Long Beach Post
    )

    As the aquarium’s tadpole numbers have grown, some are now sent to the Santa Ana Zoo each October to continue growing until they’re ready for reintroduction. Frogs are carefully separated by genetics and population of origin, so each can be released back into its native range and preserve healthy genetic lines.

    “I think that we have some responsibility to give the animals the best chance that they could possibly have,” Lundy said, “but this is certainly a species that without a good amount of human intervention would not exist to this day.”

    Much of the aquarium’s work is now focused on an even more elusive threat than fire: chytrid fungus, a microscopic pathogen that attacks the keratin in amphibian skin, blocking the salt absorption frogs rely on and eventually causing cardiac arrest. It has driven amphibian populations to collapse worldwide, and mountain yellow-legged frogs appear especially vulnerable to it.

    “Some amphibian species over time have developed a resistance to chytrid, and so part of the intention of growing so many animals is hoping to find what gene that is that introduces some chytrid resistance,” Lundy said. Researchers are testing whether frogs can be inoculated before release, or whether introducing different microbes to their skin might help them fend off the fungus on their own.

    Six or seven brown, speckled tadpoles swim at different angles in a glass tank with a pale blue background.
    Tadpoles swim in a tank at the Aquarium of the Pacific as they are raised before being released into the local mountains, Tuesday, Sept., 15, 2026
    (
    Thomas R. Cordova
    /
    Long Beach Post
    )

    Lundy has now been on three of the aquarium’s release trips, watching frogs she has cared for — some for years — carried up into the mountains and set loose into the streams they were bred to repopulate. It is, she says, a strange kind of joy.

    “It’s a little bittersweet because, oh no, I’ve been taking care of you for so long, but that is the point, so it feels a little bit like Christmas Day,” Lundy said.

    Not every frog leaves the same way. Some, she said, shoot off into the current without so much as a pause. Others linger at the water’s edge beside her for a few minutes before finally disappearing beneath the surface.

    “Almost feels like they’re saying goodbye,” she said.

  • Sponsored message
  • Where to find it in Anaheim Hills
    Photo of a restaurant's logo titled "Keno's Restaurant and Lounge."
    The Keno's Anaheim Hills location opened in 1980, but wouldn't become an established fixture locally until 1983.

    Top line:

    Keno's Restaurant in Anaheim Hills blends classic steakhouse vibes with a cafe twist — and it's a place you can find a 15-pound burrito on the menu. That's right, 15 pounds.

    The vibes: You can experience the cafe, with a bustling diner feel, or you can step into their steakhouse, which has a fireplace inspired by the Peppermill in Las Vegas.

    Live event programming: Along with the Rat Pack-era interior, they also have plenty of live music to check out in the evenings. Your dinner and a show could include artists like a Frank Sinatra cover artist or a more general acoustic set.

    15-pound burrito: Keno's serves up lots of traditional menu items like a Monte Cristo or chicken sandwich, but you can also find a 15-pound burrito and a 32-ounce Tomahawk steak.

    Listen:

    Listen 10:20
    Keno’s in Anaheim Hills — lively steakhouse meets cafe

    Keno’s Restaurant in Anaheim Hills is a family-run business with a vintage feel — and a 15-pound burrito on the menu.

    General Manager Shauna Reyes joined Austin Cross on AirTalk, LAist 89.3's daily news show, to talk about what customers can expect at the decades-old steakhouse that has a cafe twist.

    About the owners

    An old, developed photo of a restaurant sign
    Vintage photos of Keno's, back when it first opened, and was a 24-hour restaurant.
    (
    Courtesy Greg Rogers
    )

    Keno's originally opened in 1972, gaining enough popularity to expand into a small chain of restaurants. Gus Cooper helped build and operate the Anaheim Hills location since its opening in 1980. The Anaheim Hills location eventually changed hands to Gus' nephew, Steve Cooper, in 1993. Steve Cooper and his family have been running Keno's ever since.

    What it's like being a Keno's customer

    A dimly lit lounge, with diners eating at booths in the background.
    Photo of Keno's lounge and steakhouse section.
    (
    Courtesy Greg Rogers
    )

    According to Reyes, the ambiance and customer connections are what set Keno's apart.

    You can experience the cafe, with a bustling diner feel, or step into their steakhouse, which has a fireplace Reyes says was inspired by the Peppermill in Las Vegas.

    Restaurant details

    • Keno’s has a live event schedule that includes solo acoustic sets and a Frank Sinatra cover artist.
    • In addition to the 15-pound burrito, you can also find a 32-ounce Tomahawk steak on the menu.

    Menu items we tried

    • The Lumberjack Breakfast
    • Monte Cristo
    • California Chicken Sandwich
    • Tomahawk Steak

    How to visit

    • Address: 5750 E La Palma Ave, Anaheim Hills, CA 92807
    • Hours: Sunday – Thursday, open 7 a.m. to 9 p.m.; Friday and Saturday open from 7 a.m. to 10 p.m.
    • Cost: The Lumberjack breakfast costs $23; the Monte Cristo costs $17.79; the California Chicken Sandwich costs $17.49; the 32-ounce Tomahawk steak costs $80.

    What should we try next?

    What should we try next?

    Have a question or comment about a segment? Want to pitch us a story?

    Fill out the form below, and please include an email address so we're able to follow up if necessary! We're not able to respond to every inquiry, but all submissions are read and reviewed by our production team.

  • Uber must pay family of woman left on OC freeway
    A uber sign is pictured on the windshield of a car.  Above the logo is a black box within a white circle.
    An Uber logo on a car
    Topline:
    Uber must pay $40 million to the parents of a woman who was struck and killed after an Uber driver left her on an Orange County freeway in 2023, an arbitrator has ruled.

    About the case: On Aug. 12, 2023, Uber driver Vu Tran picked up Emily Normandin-Parker and her friend, Luna Moore, from a bar. When Moore started throwing up in the car, Tran stopped at a gore point — the small, triangular area at the off-ramp — on State Route 73. As Tran and Moore argued, Normandin-Parker, 23, was struck and killed after wandering into traffic because she was inebriated, according to the ruling. Normandin-Parker’s parents and Moore sued Tran and Uber in Orange County Superior Court in September 2023, and the parties agreed to arbitration. Richard Stone, a retired judge who served as the arbitrator, wrote that it was hard to determine exactly what happened because the testimony of both Moore and Tran were not entirely credible. Stone awarded Normandin-Parker’s parents, Carol Normandin and Ken Parker, $20 million each, and Moore $300,000.

    Uber's response: The arbitrator rejected Uber’s arguments that California’s Proposition 22 — a voter-approved law written by Uber and other gig companies that cemented drivers’ status as independent contractors, not employees — shields it from liability for a driver’s actions. Stone wrote that when California voters passed Prop. 22 in 2020, they could not have intended to do away with Uber’s liability for its drivers’ actions. He noted that the language in the ballot proposition urging voters to approve it referred to classifying drivers as independent contractors, meaning they would not get standard benefits and protections like employees would. Uber spokesperson Gabriela Condarco-Quesada told CalMatters that the company disagrees with the decision.

    Uber must pay $40 million to the parents of a woman who was struck and killed after an Uber driver left her on an Orange County freeway in 2023, an arbitrator has ruled.

    The arbitrator rejected Uber’s arguments that California’s Proposition 22 — a voter-approved law written by Uber and other gig companies that cemented drivers’ status as independent contractors, not employees — shields it from liability for a driver’s actions.

    “Prop. 22 does not immunize Uber from vicarious liability” for the wrongdoing of its drivers, Richard Stone, a retired judge who served as the arbitrator, wrote in his July arbitration award. Vicarious liability is indirect liability for the actions of another, such as in instances where the parties have a legal relationship.

    In his earlier ruling in March, Stone wrote that when California voters passed Prop. 22 in 2020, they could not have intended to do away with Uber’s liability for its drivers’ actions. He noted that the language in the ballot proposition urging voters to approve it referred to classifying drivers as independent contractors, meaning they would not get standard benefits and protections like employees would.

    “There is no reference in key voter materials to the liability of app-based transportation companies,” Stone wrote. “Not a word.”

    On Aug. 12, 2023, Uber driver Vu Tran picked up Emily Normandin-Parker and her friend, Luna Moore, from a bar. When Moore started throwing up in the car, Tran stopped at a gore point — the small, triangular area at the off-ramp — on State Route 73. As Tran and Moore argued, Normandin-Parker, 23, was struck and killed after wandering into traffic because she was inebriated, according to the ruling. Stone wrote that it was hard to determine exactly what happened because the testimony of both Moore and Tran were not entirely credible.

    Normandin-Parker’s parents and Moore sued Tran and Uber in Orange County Superior Court in September 2023, and the parties agreed to arbitration. Stone awarded Normandin-Parker’s parents, Carol Normandin and Ken Parker, $20 million each, and Moore $300,000.

    Uber reported revenue of more than $14 billion and net income of more than $2 billion in its second quarter that ended in June.

    Uber spokesperson Gabriela Condarco-Quesada told CalMatters that the company disagrees with the decision.

    “We believe the arbitrator was wrong in holding Uber legally responsible for the tragic events of that night,” she said, citing Prop. 22. Uber, along with companies such as DoorDash, Lyft and Instacart, spent more than $200 million on the ballot initiative.

    She also said the company’s “thoughts continue to be with the Normandin-Parker family.”

    Parker pushed back on what he called a spin campaign by Uber, noting that the company tried to keep them from talking about the arbitrator’s award.

    “Their thoughts have never been with us,” he told CalMatters on Thursday, the day he and Normandin appeared on Good Morning America to discuss the case and the death of their daughter, a UCLA graduate.

    Parker said Uber has never apologized or acknowledged responsibility, and that throughout the arbitration process the company was “at best aloof and at worst distastefully crass.”

    In a November filing, the company argued the incident “was the result of Moore and Normandin-Parker’s extreme intoxication, which was existent because of Moore’s and Normandin-Parker’s intentional conduct — not Tran’s driving.”

    The award will help fund the Emily Normandin-Parker Foundation, which her parents created last year. Part of the foundation’s mission will be to hold corporations accountable, particularly in the ride-hailing industry, Parker said. He said that might come through advocacy in legislation, regulations or the “court of public opinion.”

    The arbitrator also rejected Uber’s argument that it is not a common carrier that transports people or goods, but a transportation network company because it’s licensed as such by the Public Utilities Code. Stone wrote that Uber could be subject to both public utility rules and a non-transferable legal duty for safety as a common carrier at the same time, citing other cases in which the company was deemed to be a common carrier. Further, he said another California law, Proposition 51, does not apply in this case. Prop. 51 limits liability for non-economic damages to a defendant’s proportionate share of fault. Stone said Uber is 100% responsible for the driver’s actions.

    Lawyers for Normandin-Parker’s parents said evidence presented during the arbitration showed Uber had received previous complaints about Tran's driving.

    Uber said in a filing that Tran had a valid driver’s license and passed its background check, and that the company had no duty to train Tran beyond that because he was an independent contractor. The company spokesperson said this week that Tran, who can no longer drive for Uber, had completed thousands of trips without any unsafe drop-offs, freeway stops or rider injury.

    CalMatters contacted the law firm that represented Tran but did not immediately receive a response.

    Stone wrote that he hopes Uber “will learn from this tragic incident … and change the pertinent policies and procedures accordingly. Should it fail to do so, it no doubt engages in that approach at its own substantial risk.”

    This article was originally published on CalMatters and was republished under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives license.

  • Groups are being forced to cover millions
    Makeshift tents line with both sides of a city street with tall skyscrapers visible in the background.
    Makeshift tents line 6th Street in downtown Los Angeles.

    Topline:

    Several L.A.-area organizations who serve survivors of domestic violence and people experiencing homelessness say a legal dispute over federal homelessness funding is holding critical dollars hostage.

    What’s happening: Groups, now forced to cover up to millions of dollars in annual grant agreements, are running out of reserves, cutting staffing and relying on private donations to keep people housed and services running.

    Why it matters: “If these contracts don't get executed, if HUD doesn't start to reimburse agencies quickly … we're going to see more suffering on the street,” said Myong Kim, chief program officer at the Downtown Women’s Center. “It's going to be more tangible and more visible.”

    Why the delay? The organizations have had contracts stalled for months in a legal back-and-forth between the Trump administration and the region’s top homeless services agency, which has some programs starving for money.

    Read on… for details about the ongoing legal battle and how local providers are faring.

    Several Los Angeles-area organizations that serve survivors of domestic violence and people experiencing homelessness say a legal dispute over federal homelessness funding is holding critical dollars hostage.

    Groups, now forced to cover up to millions of dollars in annual grant agreements, are running out of reserves, cutting staffing and relying on private donations to keep people housed and services running.

    The organizations have had contracts stalled for months in a legal back-and-forth between the Trump administration and the region’s top homeless services agency, which has some programs starving for money.

    “If these contracts don't get executed, if HUD doesn't start to reimburse agencies quickly … we're going to see more suffering on the street,” said Myong Kim, chief program officer at the Downtown Women’s Center. “It's going to be more tangible and more visible.”

    The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development told LAist it's not currently required to execute grant agreements after the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals issued an emergency stay while it decides on HUD’s appeal in the coming weeks.

    “HUD stands by its commitment and legal right not to continue supporting LAHSA, which even Judge [David O.] Carter and Mayor Karen Bass have acknowledged is an abject failure and riddled with fraud, waste, and abuse,” a spokesperson said in a statement.

    The region's top homeless services agency, the Los Angeles Homeless Services Authority, told LAist that it’s not backing down and is actively pursuing legal remedies to force the federal government to honor its commitments.

    “Frontline providers have kept lifesaving programs running for months without compensation,” spokesperson Chris Yee said in an email. “Releasing these federal funds is essential to maintaining their operations and protecting services for people who rely on these critical programs.”

    Overall, HUD delays are expected to affect more than 50 local service providers, with the bulk of their renewal grants expiring in the next three months, according to LAHSA. Dozens of grants could be affected by the end of this year, totaling nearly $65 million.

    A fight over who controls funding

    The situation facing these providers is part of a broader delay with HUD's execution of FY2025 Continuum of Care grants, which has affected groups in other parts of the country, such as Ohio.

    More than 1,300 of the FY2025 Continuum of Care renewal grant agreements — about one in five — had not been fully executed as of Monday, according to court documents reviewed by LAist. That includes more than 400 agreements that had not been issued by HUD.

    But the L.A. grants are not just facing bureaucratic delays — they’ve become entangled in a fight over who controls the region’s federal homelessness funding.

    HUD suspended LAHSA from federal grant activity this summer, and LAHSA sued. Some of the organizations’ leaders were hopeful a federal judge could clear the path for their contracts to be paid in August.

    That’s when U.S. District Judge David O. Carter issued an order that, among other things, named a dozen service providers for which HUD has failed to execute grant agreements after getting award letters earlier this year. He wrote that the delays leave them without the funds they need to continue operating.

    Carter ordered HUD to execute those signed agreements immediately. But about a month later, the order was paused by the Ninth Circuit.

    “We expected HUD to immediately execute our grant agreements in compliance with Judge Carter's order,” said Jessica Reed, LAHSA’s director of Continuum of Care, during a LAHSA Commission committee meeting Wednesday. “Obviously, the appeal [by HUD] has continued to hold that up.”

    LAist reached out to all 12 organizations named in the order, and several said they’re getting stuck in the middle of the legal dispute.

    Groups in limbo for months

    House of Ruth in Pomona, a roughly 50-year-old domestic violence agency that offers crisis, outreach, housing and legal services, has a roughly $286,000 grant tied up in the litigation, according to Pat Bell, CEO. The grant, which hasn’t been executed since April, pays for the organization’s transitional housing shelter.

    Bell said LAHSA has told her an executed contract was unlikely to come anytime soon, forcing House of Ruth to float the funds in the meantime. The organization is now reducing staffing for its transitional shelter, including layoffs and cutting hours, according to Bell.

    “We have six months of paychecks going out to the staff that are providing the transitional shelter services without any reimbursement,” Bell said.

    “It[‘s] causing us to fall behind. … We've drained our cash reserves. I'm talking right now to banks about securing a line of credit. It's just enormously stressful for us on a frontline level.”
    — Pat Bell, CEO of House of Ruth

    House of Ruth is not an isolated example.

    The Downtown Women’s Center based in Skid Row, which provides housing, employment and mental health services to survivors of violence experiencing homelessness, has been waiting on a $3.5 million annual contract since July, according to Kim, the chief program officer. The renewal contract supports rent payments for survivors of domestic violence, she said.

    The Downtown Women’s Center has been covering about $150,000 a month in costs with private donations since then, but Kim noted that’s “not going to last forever.”

    “In the midst of all the politics, and in the midst of all the back and forth, we really need to remember that these are individual lives — women, their children, their dependents — that are at risk and that are counting on us to move things forward,” Kim said.

    ‘Wreaking havoc’

    The People Concern, an L.A. County nonprofit that provides housing and services to people experiencing homelessness and survivors of domestic violence, has two outstanding contracts for a little more than $2.2 million combined, according to John Maceri, CEO. He said a few other contracts that are set to end in the coming months could also be affected, bringing the total to about $3.3 million.

    The People Concern is relying on donations and reserves, but Maceri said cash flow is a particularly big challenge, and it’s “really wreaking havoc in the system.”

    He said they’re approaching an untenable situation.

    “Ultimately, the people who are hurt are the people that we're serving. Because at some point, organizations cannot continue to finance debt."
    — John Maceri, CEO of The People Concern

    “Ultimately, the people who are hurt are the people that we're serving,” Maceri said. “Because at some point, organizations cannot continue to finance debt.”

    Jewish Family Service L.A. has been waiting since April on a contract for its transitional shelter that supports women and children who survived domestic violence.

    Eli Veitzer, CEO, said the organization is tapping into its reserves to cover the roughly $300,000 portion of annual costs to keep the shelter open until at least next summer. But that can’t be a long-term solution, he noted.

    Veitzer said LAHSA has fallen short in critical ways, but blocking funding to the agency without another path for service providers “essentially shuts down the system.”

    “HUD hasn't proposed an alternative method for getting these funds to the providers and the clients who need those services, and that's the part that is the most upsetting,” Veitzer said. “There's a complete disregard for the impact of the people in L.A. County who need these services desperately, and who benefit from these services.”

    Why it matters

    Scott Cummings, a professor of legal ethics at the UCLA School of Law, told LAist it’s not unusual to seek a stay after an order like Carter’s. But litigation takes time, and the programs are effectively put on hold while it’s worked out in court.

    “There are short-term wins for the [Trump] administration in just playing this delay game,” Cummings said. “The delay can actually last a long time, and in the meantime, the programs are suffering, and the people they're serving are suffering.”

    L.A. County Supervisor Lindsey Horvath commented on the contracts in Tuesday’s board of supervisors meeting, saying: “A top concern is the 2025 LAHSA COC contracts that HUD is refusing to execute, although those programs are already operating without funding.”

    Horvath requested an update next Tuesday from the county’s Department of Homeless Services and Housing to go over the remaining contracts at LAHSA.

    The Ninth Circuit is expected to hear arguments next Tuesday, according to court documents, and Carter has scheduled a status conference for the week after.

    LAist’s Aaron Schrank contributed to this story.