Sponsored message
Logged in as
Audience-funded nonprofit news
radio tower icon laist logo
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
Subscribe
  • Listen Now Playing Listen

The Brief

The most important stories for you to know today
  • Investigation finds dangerous restraint still used
    Men, some in masks, carry a white coffin in a cemetery
    Shayne Sutherland’s brothers, brothers-in-law and best friend carry his casket at his funeral on Oct. 17, 2020 — the day before his 30th birthday.

    Topline:

    Since the 1990s, law enforcement officials and medical experts have cautioned about the dangers of police-prone restraint, especially when people are high on stimulants or experiencing a mental health crisis. Some California police officers haven’t been getting the message

    Why it matters: A new review of law enforcement data shows that, despite growing awareness of the dangers of prone restraint, in California, the problem is pervasive.

    How we know: After the passage of AB 71 in 2015, California began tracking data about when people died after police use of force. Between 2016 and 2022, at least 22 people have died in the state after being restrained stomach-down by law enforcement officers, according to a new analysis of currently available state use-of-force data by the California Reporting Project, The California Newsroom, and the Guardian.

    Keep reading... for more the full investigation and details about cases in Southern California.

    On a Thursday morning in October 2020, less than five months after George Floyd was held on his stomach by Minneapolis police until he died, Shayne Sutherland called 911 from a convenience store in Stockton, California, and asked for a taxi.

    This story was published in partnership with the Guardian.

    LAist is a member of the California Newsroom, which is a collaboration between major public media newsrooms in the state.

    When the operator told Sutherland he’d dialed 911, he said someone was trying to rob him.

    Stockton Police Officers Ronald Zalunardo and John Afanasiev arrived at the store about 15 minutes later. In the meantime, a store employee had called 911, saying Sutherland was threatening him with a wine bottle.

    In body camera footage that captured the officers’ response, Sutherland seems fidgety, and his speech is difficult to understand at times, but he doesn’t appear violent, and he isn’t armed. He cooperates with police, addressing Zalunardo as “sir” and sitting against a wall outside the store as instructed.

    The officers question Sutherland. When he tells them he can’t remember why he’s under court supervision, Afanasiev says, “The drugs probably have something to do with it.”

    “How long you been using meth,” Zalnunardo asks. Sutherland stutters and says he's been using cocaine.

    Sutherland briefly stands, then sits when ordered to do so. A minute later, he stands up again. This time, the officers tackle him to the ground and hold him belly-down — a position known as prone restraint. Thirty seconds later, his hands are cuffed behind his back.

    That could have been the end of the encounter. Experts say prone restraint can be a safe, effective way to subdue someone and get them into handcuffs — so long as they’re quickly placed in a “recovery position” on their side or in a seated position to allow them to breathe more easily.

    But Zalunardo and Afanasiev didn’t do that. The body camera footage shows them holding Sutherland belly-down for more than eight minutes. For nearly half that time, Afanasiev lays across Sutherland’s back. Sutherland panics, alternating between moaning and screaming for help as Zalunardo, who uses his baton and body weight to help keep Sutherland’s shoulder down, repeatedly tells him, “Relax!”

    “Please let me breathe,” Sutherland begs, his voice barely decipherable. In between shrieks and gasps, he calls out, “Mom!” He begs for help. “Please let me live.”

    Before the officers notice that he’s turning colors and losing consciousness, Sutherland, his mouth bloody from being slammed and scraped against the ground, sputters: “I’m f—ing dead.”

    Another five-and-half minutes pass before officers roll Sutherland onto his side and begin to render aid.

    Sutherland was declared dead 47 minutes later at a hospital.

    'Deeply concerning’ findings

    As far back as the 1990s, medical experts and law enforcement officials have been aware of the dangers of prone restraint. A number of organizations and law enforcement agencies, including the U.S. Department of Justice, the Chicago Police Department and the New Orleans Police Department, warned officers of these dangers and advised them on how to minimize risks.

    We really shouldn't have any of these deaths. Any time there's prolonged prone restraint, something's going wrong. It should not happen.
    — Seth W. Stoughton, former police officer

    Many training manuals have since been updated to address the risks of prone restraint and the importance of using the recovery position. Ohio State Police officers are forbidden from using prone restraint. A Nevada law forbids the practice. In California, a law that became effective in 2022, AB 490, bans any maneuvers that put people at risk of being unable to breathe due to the position of their body, or positional asphyxia, a common cause of death in prone restraint cases.

    But a new review of law enforcement data shows that, despite growing awareness of the dangers of prone restraint, in California, the problem is pervasive. After the passage of AB 71 in 2015, California began tracking data about when people died after police use of force. Between 2016 and 2022, at least 22 people have died in the state after being restrained stomach-down by law enforcement officers, according to a new analysis of currently available state use-of-force data by the California Reporting Project, The California Newsroom, and the Guardian. Our examination also included police reports, death investigations, district attorney reviews, body-worn camera footage, 911 calls and lawsuits.

    Other key findings:

    • Nineteen of the 22 people who died following prone restraint tested positive for meth.
    • Five died after May 2020, when Minneapolis police killed George Floyd.
    • Two of those people died after AB 490 went into effect.
    • All 22 cases involved people in crisis — either struggling with addiction, mental illness or otherwise behaving erratically.
    • Almost half of those who died were Latino, followed by white people — a trend that reflects larger use-of-force data in California. 
    • Two of those who died were armed, but not with guns.

    “We really shouldn't have any of these deaths,” said Seth W. Stoughton, a former police officer in Tallahassee, Florida, who teaches criminal law and procedure at the University of South Carolina’s Joseph F. Rice School of Law. “Any time there's prolonged prone restraint, something's going wrong. It should not happen.”

    “My general disgust [is] that we're still having to talk about this,” he said. ”It's a little depressing that we're coming up on 30 years of making the same mistake over and over again. That's really frustrating.”

    “It's deeply concerning to learn about the deaths of individuals in California due to positional asphyxia, even after it was banned by AB 490,” wrote California Assemblymember Mike Gipson, who was the primary author of the bill, in an emailed response to the findings. “These incidents underscore the urgent need for comprehensive training and accountability measures within law enforcement agencies.”

    Others who have died following prone restraint by California police officers between 2016 and 2022 include:

    ● Isabel De La Torre, died on March 26, 2022, after her partner, who was five months pregnant, called 911 in Clovis, California, because she believed De La Torre was unconscious, according to official records and court documents. When De La Torre awoke, her partner hung up the phone, but Clovis police officers responded anyway. De La Torre tried to turn the officers away, hiding in a bathroom, writhing and screaming, allegedly holding a knife. When she came out of the room, officers ordered a police dog to bite her, bringing her to the ground, where officers handcuffed her and held her in the prone position for more than three minutes. She died of positional and compressional asphyxia due to prone restraint, according to the Fresno County Sheriff-Coroner. Her family sued the department for wrongful death and is set to receive a $1.9 million settlement.

    ● Mario Gonzalez, who died on April 19, 2021, in Alameda, California. When police responded to a call about a man sitting in a park and talking to himself, officials said they found Gonzalez so intoxicated he couldn’t speak in full sentences. He refused to take his hands out of his pockets, according to official reports, leading two officers to hold him down on his stomach while another held his legs. Body camera footage of the incident shows officers repeatedly telling each other not to put too much force on him, but they continued to hold him prone after he was handcuffed. He died of the “toxic effects of methamphetamine” after suffering a cardiopulmonary arrest, according to the Alameda County Coroner's Bureau. His family sued the city of Alameda, the officers involved in Gonzalez’s death and the police chief at the time and won a settlement of $11 million. In 2023, the Alameda County district attorney reopened her office’s investigation into whether the officers acted criminally.

    ● Edward Bronstein, who died on March 31, 2020, in Altadena, near Los Angeles. California Highway Patrol officers had detained Bronstein in an L.A. County station on suspicion of driving under the influence. When Bronstein declined to give a blood sample, officers forced him face down onto a mat, at which point he said, “I’ll do it willingly,” a video of the incident shows. An officer can be heard saying, “It’s too late.” Five officers continued to pin Bronstein to the ground. As they drew blood, Bronstein screamed, “I can’t breathe” and "Let me breathe" multiple times before his breathing and pulse stopped. Officers performed CPR to no avail. In 2023, the Los Angeles County district attorney charged a CHP sergeant, six officers and a nurse with involuntary manslaughter and assault under the color of authority. His family was awarded a $24 million settlement in a civil wrongful death suit.

    And there may be more deaths beyond the 22 we found. While the state receives data from law enforcement agencies for deaths that occur after police use of force, it isn't necessarily complete. That’s because agencies don't always submit data to the state as they're required to do, or data is otherwise excluded from the state’s use-of-force database. For example, Angelo Quinto died in 2020 after Antioch police officers held him prone, but his case is not in the database. Gipson, the assemblymember, said Quinto's death was the impetus for the new legislation.

    Despite the passage of AB 490, training manuals for the Antioch Police Department, Stanislaus County Sheriff’s Department and the Sonoma County Sheriff’s Department say that positional asphyxia is "the subject of debate among experts and medical professionals.”

    A woman with light-tone skin and long hair sits in front of a tombstone with flowers flanking both sides
    Karen Sutherland sits by her son Shayne's gravesite at the Park View Cemetery in Manteca, Calif., on Feb. 24, 2024.
    (
    Beth LaBerge
    /
    KQED
    )

    The science of prone restraint

    When a person is lying prone on a hard surface, their chest cavity is compressed and breathing becomes difficult, especially when their hands are cuffed behind their backs. Add the body weight of one or more police officers, and compression increases, restricting the movement of the ribcage and diaphragm, which are vital for the inhalation of oxygen and exhalation of carbon dioxide. The lack of proper ventilation puts stress on many parts of the body, including the heart, as noted in a 2002 study by Disability Rights California.

    The warnings go even further back. In a 1995 bulletin, the U.S. Department of Justice cautioned law enforcement officers about the deadliness of positional asphyxia. “As soon as the suspect is handcuffed, get him off his stomach,” it reads.

    The bulletin outlines how subjects on drugs are at higher risk of death in the position, noting that “cocaine-induced bizarre or frenzied behavior… may increase a subject’s susceptibility to sudden death by effecting an increase of the heart rate to a critical level.” It also said that “drugs and/or alcohol” pose a “major risk factor” because “subjects may not realize they are suffocating.”

    The bulletin explains that suspects restrained in a prone position often appear to be resisting officers when, in fact, they’re fighting, perhaps involuntarily, to get oxygen and carbon dioxide in and out of their bodies as their chest is squeezed. As the memo reads: “The individual experiences increased difficulty breathing. The natural reaction to oxygen deficiency occurs — the person struggles more violently. The officer applies more compression to subdue the individual.”

    “It's horrible because you're just watching a preventable death, and you know the person's suffering,” said Dr. Alon Steinberg, a California cardiologist who studies prone restraint and has viewed hours of footage of people being held stomach-down by police.

    Steinberg, who serves as an expert witness, believes that cardiac arrests following prone restraint might be caused by more than just a lack of oxygen in the heart muscle. When someone can adequately breathe, the expulsion of carbon dioxide regulates the level of acid in the blood. But when breathing and blood flow are restricted, acid can build and cause cardiac arrest, as Steinberg and forensic pathologists Dr. Victor Weedn and Dr. Peter Speth proposed in a 2022 study.

    Dr. Daniel Wohlgelernter, a cardiologist who has also testified in a number of prone-restraint cases, agrees. He pointed out that putting someone in prone restraint when they are in a hyperactive state — as people often are when on stimulants or in crisis — can exacerbate acidosis and cause a “double whammy.”

    “We have carbon dioxide accumulation, development of lethal or potentially lethal metabolic acidosis at the same time that we have deprivation of oxygen,” he said.

    Despite widespread agreement about the dangers of positional asphyxia caused by prone restraint, some studies have argued that the restriction of airflow caused by prone restraint is not, in most cases, enough to kill.

    Medical and legal experts have pointed out flaws in the studies, which have been done on healthy, sober individuals in police-free environments and don’t duplicate a real-life prone-restraint scenario.

    “Studies like that, if they actually had the potential to kill anyone, would never be approved by an institutional review board,” said Joanna Naples-Mitchell, an attorney with Physicians for Human Rights. “So it's not something that's actually possible to model in the real world in a safe way.”

    A collage of photos shows a man from childhood through early adulthood,
    Karen Sutherland holds a photo collage of her son Shayne at Park View Cemetery, where he is buried.
    (
    Beth LaBerge
    /
    KQED
    )

    Sorting out causes of death

    Of the 22 deaths we found where people died after being held stomach-down, coroners and medical examiners attributed acute methamphetamine toxicity to 10 deaths. Coroners are usually elected, and few places require them to have a medical background.

    Wohlgelernter and Steinberg are skeptical of those determinations. Both were adamant that in the prone restraint cases they’ve reviewed, methamphetamine, on its own, was not to blame for deaths.

    “In no cases did I see that the individuals were destined to die on that day, if not for the interaction with law enforcement and the prone restraint compressive asphyxia,” Wohlgelernter said.

    Steinberg pointed out that while people can overdose on meth, those who wind up dead after being restrained face down were “alive and fine” before they had a run-in with police.

    “They're alive beforehand. They're alive for a few minutes in the prone position, and then after a prolonged episode of restraint, people die,” he said.

    Dr. Odey Ukpo, chief medical examiner-coroner for Los Angeles County, where seven deaths following prone restraint were attributed to meth use or toxicity, said it’s more complicated.

    “What some people don’t realize is that a cause-of-death [determination] is a medical opinion,” he said. “It’s based on deductive reasoning.”

    I think they fundamentally don't respect people they view as addicts or tweakers or whatever the pejorative might be, and treat them accordingly without respect for their lives.
    — Justin M. Feldman, Center for Policing Equity, speaking about police officers

    For instance, Ukpo said he looks for signs of petechiae, a dot-like pattern of blood in the eyes or on the gums, before ruling whether someone died of asphyxia.

    To Seth Stoughton, the University of South Carolina law professor and former police officer, who wrote an amicus brief about the dangers of positional asphyxia that was submitted to the U.S. Supreme Court in 2022, causes of death are beside the point. Prone restraint, he argues, is so easy to perform safely that it should never lead to deaths in the first place, no matter who’s being restrained.

    “Whether they're dying of oxygen deprivation or metabolic acidosis is irrelevant,” he said. “People are still dying! And if you flip them over to their side, they don’t!”

    Stoughton served as an expert witness in the case against Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin for the murder of George Floyd. He says that if officers take the proper precautions to manage the scene and protect themselves, someone in handcuffs on their side is not a great danger.

    “We're talking about literally the difference between taking someone from their stomach and rolling them 90 degrees onto their side,” he said. “If there is any increase in risk at all [to officers], it is so marginal that it is vastly outweighed by the potential of saving that person's life.”

    In addition to training officers to use the recovery position as a matter of routine, experts say officers can keep an eye out for warning signs when restraining people prone.

    Wohlgelernter says officers should watch for changes in alertness, speech or physical movements.

    Steinberg argues that the use of prone restraint should be limited.

    Justin M. Feldman, principal research scientist at the Center for Policing Equity, said that some incidents escalate because of officers’ bias against people who abuse drugs.

    “I think they fundamentally don't respect people they view as addicts or tweakers or whatever the pejorative might be, and treat them accordingly without respect for their lives,” Feldman said.

    For Peter Moskos, a criminologist with John Jay College of Criminal Justice and former Baltimore police officer, there should be a greater focus on preventing the events that lead people into the hands of police by getting them the help they need, such as jobs, housing, drug treatment and mental health care.

    “At some point, it would have been nice if someone could have pulled a switch track and diverted that person, whether it's community, family, other government agencies, anything,” he said. “But once you get to that point [of a police encounter], it's kind of too late to offer an ideal solution.”

    A grave marker has an image of a man with light-tone skin. A built-in urn holds lilies.
    Shayne Sutherland's tombstone.
    (
    Beth LaBerge
    /
    KQED
    )

    $41 million in civil suits 

                                                                                                             
    The San Joaquin County medical examiner’s office determined that Shayne Sutherland’s cause of death was cardiac arrest due to “acute methamphetamine toxicity” with a contributing factor of “physical restraint by law enforcement.” In other words, meth, not police, was primarily responsible for Sutherland’s death.

    Sutherland’s family wasn’t satisfied with the medical examiner’s findings or with the Stockton Police Department’s response to his death. In October 2021, they filed a federal civil rights lawsuit against the city of Stockton, Officers Zalunardo and Afanasiev and former Stockton Police Chief Eric Jones. The suit alleges wrongful death, excessive force and interfering with Sutherland’s constitutional rights by force.

    “They did not have that right to judge him that morning,” his mother, Karen Sutherland, said. “They did not have that right to do what they did.”

    Families of people in California who have died following prone restraint have won at least $41 million in civil suits across the state, according to court documents and press reports.

    In the year leading up to her son’s death, Karen managed to get Shayne into rehab for a stint, but finding mental health care and ongoing treatment was a struggle. When people like Shayne reach out for help, she said, “They're turned away, or they're told they have to wait.”

    “[But] when you have a mental health problem, you can't wait,” she said.

    Last December, Karen pulled into Park View Cemetery in Manteca — about 20 minutes south of Stockton — and walked to her son’s grave. Sitting on a blanket, she talked about Shayne’s life: his “teddy bear” lovability; the fishing and camping trips with his two kids, Shayne Jr., 8, and Demi, 7; coaching the Manteca Chargers youth football team.

    She talked about the hard times, too: the cocaine and meth addiction; the split with the mother of his children; the “little, petty, stupid, whatever crimes” that, she said, “are in no way in any comparison of any type of magnitude of the crime that those two police officers committed that day when they killed my son.”

    “I've always been able to handle things,” she said. “I'm a very strong person, but not when this happened. This broke me — completely shattered me.”

    After Shayne’s death, Stockton PD determined that Zalunardo and Afanasiev acted within policy. The only issue the investigation raised was that Zalunardo left his baton “unsecured on the ground near the suspect” when administering aid.

    The Stockton Police Department did not respond to our requests for comments and interviews with the officers.

    Karen has watched the footage of Shayne's final encounter with police. But she says she’ll never turn on the sound, because others have told her what she’d have to hear.

    “He knew he was dying,” she said. “He was being tortured. And knowing that tortures me every second, man. Every second.”

    Karen chose this particular grave site because of the morning sun that hits it each day. She’s come to believe that God reached down to stop Shayne’s suffering — not just at the hands of police, but in life.

    In the winter sunshine, the top of Shayne’s headstone reads: “God reached down and rescued me.”

    How we reported this story

    Since the 1990s, experts have warned that restraining someone prone, or on their stomach, can kill them. When someone is agitated, on stimulants or acting erratically, they are also more likely to die if officers use prone restraint, according to medical experts. Former police officers and criminologists say that putting someone on their side or seated after they’re handcuffed saves lives. In 2020, Antioch police officers held Angelo Quinto down on his stomach after responding to a call from his family. His death inspired California legislation, which went into effect in 2022, that prohibits officers from using techniques such as prone restraint that “involve a substantial risk of positional asphyxia.”

    The California Newsroom and The California Reporting Project wanted to better understand how many people were dying after officers used prone restraint in the Golden State.

    Since the passage of state law AB 71, California law enforcement agencies submit anonymized data to the state Department of Justice’s Use of Force Incident Reporting database when officers seriously injure or kill people. That data contains information listing the types of force officers used and whether someone died. Currently, the data includes incidents that occurred from 2016 to 2022. Although people can die from prone restraint after being otherwise injured, we wanted to focus on cases where the cause of death was more clear. We filtered the data to incidents where someone died and officers used a control hold but did not use a gun, Taser or carotid restraint. Outside of carotid holds, the data does not distinguish between specific types of restraint. To better identify the decedents, reporters then combined the use-of-force data with data from California’s Death In-Custody database. To ascertain whether officers specifically used prone restraint on those decedents, we used public record requests to obtain records and body camera footage from law enforcement agencies, district attorneys, medical examiner/coroners and oversight agencies about the incidents. We also obtained lawsuits in cases where loved ones sued local authorities. Two people reviewed those records, and an editor checked that work. We were unable to obtain enough records on four people’s deaths and excluded them from our analysis. Through our reporting, we determined five were incorrectly marked as not having been tased and removed them from our analysis. We also found that two people did not clearly die after a prone restraint and cut them from our analysis.However, we know that this data was incomplete because it did not include Angelo Quinto. We had records showing that officers used prone restraint, so we included him in our analysis despite his not appearing in the state’s use-of-force data.

    Justin Feldman, principal research scientist at the Center for Policing Equity, says that it’s not uncommon for prone restraint deaths to go unreported. In a study, he found that in more than half the cases when police kill someone, it’s not documented on the death certificate and so may not be properly recorded.

    Feldman said the “number one predictor” of misreported deaths was when officers didn’t shoot someone, such as when they used prone restraint or a Taser.

    Two police departments would not release police reports to the California Reporting Project because the death investigations found the men died of other causes, such as methamphetamine toxicity.

    Credits

    Additional reporting by Bella Arnold, Hanisha Harjani, Simmerdeep Kaur, Grace Marion, Adam Solorzano and Krissy Waite of Berkeley Journalism’s Investigative Reporting Program; Leila Barghouty, Jacqueline Munis and Camryn Pak of Stanford University's Big Local News; and Brian Krans of The California Newsroom.  

    The California Newsroom is a collaboration of public media outlets throughout the state, with NPR as its national partner. The California Reporting Project collected police records. 

    This project was completed with the support of a grant from Columbia University's Ira A. Lipman Center for Journalism and Civil and Human Rights in conjunction with Arnold Ventures.  

  • Return to Vice City
    Crowd of people holding umbrellas and wearing rain ponchos lines up in the rain outside an arena, beneath a large black-and-pink banner that reads “Welcome to Vice City” in white and pink script.
    People wait outside Kaseya Center to buy Vice City-themed Miami Heat merchandise, in Miami, Wednesday, Nov. 18, 2026, ahead of the “Grand Theft Auto VI” video game release.

    Topline:

    After a 13-year wait, “Grand Theft Auto VI” has begun its global rollout, sending players back to Vice City and kicking off one of the most anticipated entertainment launches in years. Players in New Zealand were among the first to enter Rockstar Games’ sprawling Florida-inspired world as midnight Thursday arrived, hours before the game becomes available across the United States.

    The backstory: The “Grand Theft Auto” franchise has sold more than 470 million units worldwide. “Grand Theft Auto V,” released in 2013, accounts for more than 230 million of those sales and generated $1 billion in retail sales in just three days.

    After a 13-year wait, “Grand Theft Auto VI” has begun its global rollout, sending players back to Vice City and kicking off one of the most anticipated entertainment launches in years.

    Players in New Zealand were among the first to enter Rockstar Games’ sprawling Florida-inspired world as midnight Thursday arrived, hours before the game becomes available across the United States.

    Internet providers there had prepared for a massive surge in downloads. Chorus New Zealand expected about 35 petabytes — 35 million gigabytes — of additional traffic across its network as players downloaded the massive game.

    “The game file size at 212 gigabytes is unprecedented,” said Kurt Rodgers, the company’s network strategy manager. “That’s more than a quarter of the average household’s data usage in an entire month, all in one go.”

    In Wellington, Adam Simmons launched the game from his living room as soon as it unlocked, keeping the volume low so he wouldn’t wake his wife and daughters.

    “The gameplay dynamics are just amazing and the graphics are great and you can tell that the storytelling is really deep,” he said after about half an hour of play.

    Shares of Take-Two Interactive, Rockstar’s parent company, rose more than 8% Wednesday as the rollout continued.

    In the Dallas area, Bryan Banuelos, a mobile auto detailer, told customers he wouldn’t be taking calls Thursday so he could focus on “GTA VI.” His social media post actually drove some business beforehand, with customers trying to get their cars detailed before he disappeared into Vice City.

    “Tomorrow will be the beginning of a new era for the gamers that like GTA,” Banuelos said.

    Game returns to Vice City after 13 years

    The “Grand Theft Auto” franchise has sold more than 470 million units worldwide. “Grand Theft Auto V,” released in 2013, accounts for more than 230 million of those sales and generated $1 billion in retail sales in just three days.

    Rockstar returns to Vice City, its fictionalized version of Miami, with two new protagonists, a sprawling Florida-inspired world and the pressure of following one of the most successful entertainment products ever released.

    At the center of “GTA VI” are Lucia Caminos and Jason Duval, a couple whose attempts to improve their lives pull them deeper into the criminal underworld of Leonida, Rockstar’s fictionalized version of Florida.

    Lucia has recently been released from prison, while Jason is a former soldier who became involved with drug runners in the Leonida Keys. When a criminal job goes wrong, the pair become entangled in a wider conspiracy.

    The focus on their relationship marks a major departure from “Grand Theft Auto V,” which followed three playable protagonists.

    Rockstar has promoted Leonida as its largest and most detailed open world yet, extending beyond Vice City to beaches, highways, wetlands, nightlife districts and smaller communities inspired by South Florida.

    Developers immersed themselves in the region while building the game, driving through Miami, the Florida Keys and surrounding communities, flying over the Everglades and researching the area’s history and architecture.

    Miami embraces its fictional alter ego

    Miami and surrounding communities have leaned into their connection to Vice City ahead of the release, with businesses, sports teams and local governments using the game’s arrival as a marketing opportunity.

    Miami-Dade County entered into a $3.9 million promotional deal with Rockstar that includes a giant “Welcome to Vice City” display atop the Miami Heat’s Kaseya Center. The NBA team is also scheduled to wear black-and-pink Vice City uniforms on the eve of the game’s release.

    The campaign has not been universally welcomed. Some South Florida officials have questioned whether public resources should be used to promote a franchise known for car theft, gunplay and other criminal activity.

    Supporters have argued that the enormous attention surrounding “GTA VI” gives the region an opportunity to capitalize on a global spotlight.

    In Seoul, a giant advertisement draped the side of a building, while Warner Music will host a party at a bar Thursday themed around the game’s soundtrack.

    Years of hype arrive at launch day

    Few entertainment releases arrive with this much anticipation.

    The first “GTA VI” trailer drew more than 93 million YouTube views in its first 24 hours, while Take-Two Interactive, Rockstar’s parent company, has said the second trailer generated more than 475 million views across platforms in a day.

    The game also has attracted awards attention before most players have had a chance to explore it.

    “GTA VI” received eight nominations Tuesday for the Game Awards, including game of the year, game direction, narrative, art direction, score and music, audio design, action/adventure and performance. The awards will be presented Dec. 10.

    The long wait is partly a product of the extraordinary staying power of its predecessor. “Grand Theft Auto Online,” the multiplayer component of “GTA V,” has kept players engaged for years through updates, activities and in-game purchases.

    Music has long been woven into the “Grand Theft Auto” experience, with fictional radio stations and carefully curated soundtracks accompanying players as they drive through the series’ cities.

    “Grand Theft Auto VI: The Album,” a 34-track collection of original songs tied to the game, is scheduled for release Friday.

    A separate 30-track “Grand Theft Auto VI: Original Score” by Grammy-winning French electronic duo Justice is scheduled for release Dec. 11. The adaptive score is designed to shift depending on where players are and what they are doing and includes collaborations involving Tame Impala, SZA, King Gizzard & The Lizard Wizard and Gesaffelstein.

    What players will find next

    Despite years of trailers and promotional material, Rockstar has kept significant portions of “GTA VI” under wraps.

    The full voice cast has not been revealed, including the performers behind Lucia and Jason. Actor Stephen Root has confirmed to The Associated Press that he appears in the game, though Rockstar has not publicly identified his role.

    Questions also remain about the full range of characters, locations, activities and gameplay systems waiting inside Leonida.

    ___

    Associated Press journalists Charlotte Graham-McLay in Wellington, New Zealand, and Tong-hyung Kim in Seoul contributed to this report.

  • Sponsored message
  • Luna says 2028 Games policing will cost $3B
    New Los Angeles County Sheriff Robert Luna speaking after being sworn in as the 34th Los Angeles Sheriff.

    Topline:

    L.A. County Sheriff Robert Luna said Wednesday that he anticipates that security for the 2028 Olympic and Paralympic Games will cost close to three times the $1 billion the federal government has allocated for law enforcement for the Games. That would mean a price tag of nearly $3 billion.

    What Luna said: “I don't believe a billion dollars is enough,” Luna told LAist Wednesday, ahead of a meeting at the U.S. Secret Service’s Los Angeles office, where law enforcement leaders gathered to plan for the summer of 2028.

    Influx of officers expected: At its peak, up to 30,000 additional law enforcement officers could be deployed across L.A. and Orange counties for the Games, Luna said. Together, the Olympics and Paralympics will span more than a month and take place across the whole region, with a few events in Oklahoma City, too.

    What the growing security price tag means: Luna’s estimate indicates that organizers will appeal to U.S. lawmakers to set aside more funding for Olympics policing. It also raises a question L.A. officials have asked repeatedly over the past year: Who will cover security costs if expenses exceed what the federal government is willing to pay for?

    Read on...for LAPD's estimated Olympics spending and more on plans for policing the summer Games in Los Angeles.

    Los Angeles County Sheriff Robert Luna said Wednesday that he anticipates that security for the 2028 Olympic and Paralympic Games will cost close to three times the $1 billion the federal government has allocated for law enforcement for the Games.

    That would mean a price tag of nearly $3 billion.

    “I don't believe a billion dollars is enough,” Luna told LAist Wednesday, ahead of a meeting at the U.S. Secret Service’s Los Angeles office, where law enforcement leaders gathered to plan for the summer of 2028.

    At its peak, up to 30,000 additional law enforcement officers could be deployed across L.A. and Orange counties for the Games, Luna said. Together, the Olympics and Paralympics will span more than a month and take place across the whole region, with a few events in Oklahoma City, too.

    Luna’s estimate indicates that organizers will appeal to U.S. lawmakers to set aside more funding for Olympic policing. It also raises a question L.A. officials have asked repeatedly over the past year: Who will cover security costs if expenses exceed what the federal government is willing to pay for?

    “Our local taxpayers shouldn't be footing the bill for this,” Luna said Wednesday.

    LA28, the private organizing committee putting on the Games, has not included law enforcement costs in its $7.2 billion budget — although it has promised the city of L.A. that it can tap a limited contingency fund to recoup security costs if the federal government doesn't cover those expenses.

    On Wednesday, other law enforcement officials agreed about the rising cost of deploying thousands of additional officers during the summer of 2028. LAPD Chief Jim McDonnell told the L.A. Times he expected costs could go as high as $4 billion.

    The Los Angeles Police Department has estimated its costs for staffing venues within the city alone during the Games will exceed $730 million.

    “I am concerned about funding, definitely,” Chief McDonnell said, adding that he expects the federal government to contribute more.

    Sean Duryee, commissioner of the California Highway Patrol, said he expects to more than double the number of CHP officers in L.A. County from about 700 and 800 to 2,000 during the summer of 2028. He didn’t put a number on what the influx of staff would cost but said it would be “hundreds of millions.”

    Deploying so many additional officers in Los Angeles and the surrounding region will require bringing in officers from across the state and country. According to LAPD projections released earlier this year, all outside law enforcement working the Games will make overtime rates at an estimated $131.94 an hour.

    Earlier this year, Gov. Gavin Newsom signed a bill directing the state’s Office of Emergency Services to negotiate agreements with outside law enforcement agencies to temporarily deploy in the L.A. area during the Games.

    The state of California is also relying on the federal government to cover those costs. If it doesn’t, the Office of Emergency Services estimates that contracting costs could be more than $1 billion.

  • Downtown’s French dip palace is back for seconds
    The exterior of Cole’s in downtown L.A., a tan brick building with tall arched windows. A blue vintage neon sign reads “Cole’s, Originators French Dipped Sandwiches Since 1908, Cocktails,” with a white arrow pointing down toward a bright red scalloped awning and red curtained entrance along the sidewalk.
    A fresh red awning signals the next chapter for Cole’s, the nearly 120-year-old restaurant that closed in March and has reopened under new owners.

    Topline:

    One of L.A.’s oldest restaurants, which closed earlier this year, is back under new ownership with a new menu. The owners tried to change as little as possible, but the glow-up is real. The question remains: Will it be enough to lure crowds back downtown?

    Why it matters: Cole’s, which opened in 1908 and claims to have invented the French dip, closed in March, and its closing became a symbol of downtown’s struggles.

    Why now: Cole’s reopens this week, the same month as the Original Pantry Cafe, as downtown shows early signs of a comeback after years of pandemic-era losses.

    Walking into the new Cole’s feels like seeing a friend after they’ve taken a much-needed holiday.

    The restaurant reopened Wednesday, Nov. 18, under new owners Sean Maloney and Jeremy Fall, who took over after Cedd Moses closed it in March.

    You feel a sense of familiarity, even with updated fixtures, including new banquettes and more dining-room seating.

    Think of it as a Hillstone that moved downtown, except this one’s been here since 1908 and just got a glow-up.

    “It has that kind of New York bustling brasserie feel,” Maloney said. “It’s warm, but you don’t feel overwhelmed. I think that’s really hard to re-create.”

    Maloney, formerly chief hospitality officer of Mozza Restaurant Group, said saving Cole’s felt like a personal responsibility. “It’s part of L.A.’s fabric,” he said. “It was kind of necessary, and if no one else is doing it, I felt inclined to.”

    A sliced baguette sandwich with meat sits on a metal tray, secured with toothpicks, next to a bowl of pickles.
    Cole's French dip sandwich, arguably the oldest in the city
    (
    Gab Chabran
    /
    LAist
    )

    Jus first, then mustard

    The question on everyone’s mind: What about the French dips? Fall said the team kept the original recipe but upgraded every component, dry-brining the prime rib overnight and simmering the jus for 24 hours from the beef’s own trimmings.

    It's now $26 (previously $20), with an option to upgrade to Flannery prime rib for an additional $8. There’s also a pastrami dip from RC Provisions — the same supplier as Langer’s — and a new veggie-friendly mushroom-and-onion version with red wine jus ($27). Each comes on a French loaf from Clark Street Bread, layered with Swiss cheese and served with a side of jus, atomic pickles and hot mustard.

    The sandwich holds its own, channeling the energy of a quality French dip — especially from a place that claims to have invented it (a title Philippe the Original in Chinatown has long disputed). Both the sliced beef and the pastrami stay moist and flavorful, and the custom loaf soaks up jus and mustard without ever getting soggy.

    That mustard may surprise longtime regulars. It’s now made with fresh horseradish, which the owners pitch as an upgrade. Maloney said it has “a brightening effect” that’s “very much a palate-cleansing effect,” unlike a typical grocery-store mustard. His preferred eating method? “I like to start jus first, and then go mustard and then go back to jus,” he said. How about going straight to mustard? “I think that’s crazy.”

    I found the new iteration definitely fresh-tasting, though personally speaking it could have used more kick. (I like to feel mustard's effect in my olfactory system, but I realize not everyone might want that!)

    Beyond the dip

    Other new items on the menu: a series of appetizers that includes spinach dip with caramelized onions, made with Comté, and rosemary crackers ($18), along with fried ravioli ($20) filled with wild mushroom and fontina, served with pomodoro dipping sauce for those who love a good finger food option; there's plenty to share with a small group of people.

    A restaurant table set with a Caesar salad, fried appetizers on a tiered stand, and glasses of red and white wine.
    Old is made new again.
    (
    Courtesy Cole's
    )

    For larger entree-style dishes, the Cole’s Caesar salad features stacked romaine with Calabrian croutons, white anchovies and a generous showering of Parmigiano-Reggiano.

    Rounding out the menu is a chicken cordon bleu stuffed with mortadella and Comté ($38) that oozes American comfort — a good option if you’re looking for something cozy. The baked gnocchi Parisienne ($25) arrives as soft pillows submerged in a creamy pomodoro sauce with a kick of Calabrian chili.

    The Mozza influence feels intentional on the latter half of the menu, from the mortadella to the Calabrian chili, and it fits snugly alongside the classic sandwiches.

    At the bar

    The cocktail menu offers a tasteful modern take on classic recipes priced from $15 to $17, with notable options including an Accidental Vesper made with agave, and the Beef Dip Old Fashioned, featuring an au jus–washed Buffalo Trace. The Beef Dip was rich and full-bodied, with a coating mouthfeel. Both are good complements to the menu.

    The Varnish space, the old speakeasy inside Cole's, isn't open to the public yet but can be reserved for private parties; Maloney and Fall hope to unveil a new concept once the restaurant is up and running.

    A long wooden bar lined with leather stools sits beneath globe lights and a tin ceiling, with shelves of liquor bottles behind it.
    The interior of Cole's and its famous bar.
    (
    Gab Chabran
    /
    LAist
    )

    Can it bring people back downtown?

    Downtown Los Angeles is on an upswing. The Original Pantry Cafe is reopening, an incoming mayor has called downtown a priority, and, as the Los Angeles Times recently reported, the office exodus has finally leveled off. With it comes a new sense of hope.

    Still, the pressures that led Moses to close Cole’s haven’t gone away: lingering pandemic fallout, rising rents and operating costs, and the perception that downtown isn’t safe.

    Then there’s the price. A $26 dip plus a $15 to $17 cocktail comes to about $41 to $43 before tax and tip. That may be more than many Angelenos are used to paying for a sandwich and a drink, but plenty of people have fond memories of Cole’s and downtown and will likely want to see the new version for themselves.

    Maloney is betting on value. “I think people are really craving affordable luxuries right now,” he said. He also hopes Cole’s gives the rest of the city a reason to come to the area, which he acknowledged “can also be a little bit intimidating to people who are from outside downtown.”

    For longtime regulars wary of the changes, he offered a simple case.

    “Obviously we want to change as little as possible, but we have to change a lot of things,” Maloney said.

    “We’re really just doing what we have to do to ensure that it’s here longer, because otherwise it wouldn’t be.”

    Location: 118 E. 6th St., DTLA.
    Hours: 6–9:45 p.m., Wednesday through Sunday. Starting Dec. 2, noon to midnight, Wednesday through Sunday.
  • What patients should know what ICE can do there
    A slightly low angle view and close up of a building with signage near the top that reads "White Memorial." A street sign is out of focus in the foreground.
    Adventist Health White Memorial Hospital in Boyle Heights.

    Topline:

    After federal agents blocked the ambulance entrance and detained two protesters, families are questioning whether it’s safe to seek care at Adventist Health White Memorial Hospital. Here is what patients and visitors should know about what ICE can legally do there.

    Why now: Protests this month began after U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents brought someone in their custody to the emergency department. But the agency has been at the hospital before. Detainees in ICE custody have been taken to hospitals across Los Angeles, including White Memorial, for urgent medical care, either because they were injured while being detained, had a preexisting illness, or because they became ill while being held at the downtown immigration facility.

    The backstory: As immigration raids surged across L.A. last year, a report from LAist found that ICE agents were violating the privacy rights of detained patients at White Memorial and prohibiting contact with patients’ family members. The reporting alarmed many in the community and raised questions about what agents can legally do at the hospital, prompting White Memorial to release guidelines reinforcing privacy rules and staff protections.

    Read on... for more on what patients and visits to the hospital should know.

    This story first appeared on The LA Local.

    After federal immigration agents blocked the ambulance entrance to Adventist Health White Memorial earlier this month and detained two protesters, families are grappling with whether it’s safe to visit the Boyle Heights hospital for care.

    Protests this month began after U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents brought someone in their custody to the emergency department. But the agency has been at the hospital before.

    Detainees in ICE custody have been taken to hospitals across Los Angeles, including White Memorial, for urgent medical care, either because they were injured while being detained, had a preexisting illness, or because they became ill while being held at the downtown immigration facility.

    As immigration raids surged across L.A. last year, a report from LAist found that ICE agents were violating the privacy rights of detained patients at White Memorial and prohibiting contact with patients’ family members. The reporting alarmed many in the community and raised questions about what agents can legally do at the hospital, prompting White Memorial to release guidelines reinforcing privacy rules and staff protections.

    White Memorial maintains that the hospital remains a safe place for residents and advises patients not to delay their care. “Every patient who comes to White Memorial receives timely, respectful and culturally sensitive care. We do not ask patients for their immigration status. That is not a function of hospital care,” a hospital representative said in a statement to Boyle Heights Beat. 

    Here is what patients and visitors should know about what ICE can legally do at White Memorial:

    Why have ICE agents been at White Memorial?

    ICE agents have been seen at cafeterias, lobbies and parking lots at White Memorial, according to Centro CSO, a social justice group that has been organizing around patient rights at hospitals in the area.

    In an emailed statement, White Memorial said that people in the custody of a government agency are brought to the nearest appropriate hospital when they need medical care. “We care for that patient, just as we do when the sheriff, LAPD or any other agency brings someone to us,” the hospital said.

    Does White Memorial ask about immigration status, and what are patients’ rights?

    White Memorial said it does not ask patients for their immigration status, adding that it “does not participate in immigration enforcement and does not have, nor would it ever agree to, any arrangement to do so.”

    Under a law known as SB 81, California hospitals, including private facilities like White Memorial, must protect patients’ immigration status as private medical information. There are basic constitutional safeguards protecting people from unreasonable searches, the right to remain silent, and the right to counsel, said Andrés Dae Keun Kwon, a senior policy counsel and organizer with the American Civil Liberties Union.

    Beyond that, Kwon said, federal and state privacy protections like HIPAA and the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act in California, “provides some protection against ICE being able to access sensitive information like patients’ protected health information.”

    What areas can ICE access at White Memorial and other health centers?

    In the past, “sensitive locations” like schools, hospitals and churches were spared from immigration enforcement, but President Donald Trump ended that policy. 

    That means health centers must allow ICE agents into areas open to the public, according to the “Know Your Rights: Immigrant Safety in Hospitals and Clinics” fact sheet from the ACLU. They can restrict agents from private areas if those spaces are clearly designated and enforced for patients and families.

    A 2025 bulletin from State Attorney General Rob Bonta also outlines rules under SB 81 limiting immigration agents’ access to nonpublic areas. White Memorial said it follows the law by denying agents access to nonpublic areas, such as patient rooms and treatment areas.

    However, one doctor said they have personally witnessed ICE agents or guards contracted by the agency roam around the hospital “with guns and without identification and refusing to identify themselves when asked,” which creates fear among staff and patients.

    Which areas of hospitals are considered public, and when can ICE enter private areas?

    Public areas include lobbies, waiting areas and any other places open to the public, the ACLU said. Treatment rooms, inpatient units and offices are considered nonpublic areas.

    For ICE to access a nonpublic area, a judicial warrant must be signed by a judge, naming the patient and the location where the agent is allowed to enter, the ACLU said. Kwon said it’s crucial for hospitals to “clearly designate private areas where ICE would have to have a judicial warrant.”

    It’s also important to note that a deportation order or arrest order is not the same as a judicial warrant and does not permit an agent to enter. The ACLU advises the health center’s legal counsel to review and validate the warrant before decisions about access are made. 

    Can ICE conduct immigration enforcement in a public area of the hospital without a judicial warrant?

    Yes, but federal agents would need a valid administrative warrant or probable cause. Judicial warrants allow ICE officers to go into private areas. More on the difference between administrative and judicial warrants here. 

    Whether that is common sense or whether they should be doing so is a different question, Kwon said. “Doing that obviously is tremendously detrimental to the community and the community’s health … But can they do it? Yes.”

    Still, ICE needs reasonable suspicion to stop somebody, said Kwon, reminding the public they have the right to remain silent and not consent to searches.

    What happens when a patient is in law enforcement custody? Does ICE handle that or another company?

    At White Memorial, “a patient in custody remains in the custody of the agency that brought them,” the hospital said.

    Federal immigration agents accompany patients they bring to the hospital’s emergency department. “If the patient is admitted, a contracted security company, typically Spectrum Security Services, takes over and stays with the patient during their hospital stay,” according to White Memorial.

    When the patient is ready for discharge, agents typically return to take them back to the detention facility. “For patients in LAPD custody, that contracted role is typically filled by InterCon. These companies work for the agencies, not for White Memorial,” the hospital said.

    What is White Memorial doing to protect the rights of detained patients?

    Last November, White Memorial released guidelines stating that staff can speak up without facing retaliation if patient rights are violated.

    The hospital said its physicians ask agents to step away when patients need to discuss sensitive medical information privately. Doctors have said that doesn’t always happen, citing overcrowding, intimidation from ICE agents or the hospital’s failure to educate staff on protocols, raising concerns about whether those privacy practices are enough.

    Raquel Roman with the Boyle Heights Immigrant Rights Network, a coalition of community organizations that documents ICE activity in the neighborhood, said recent events have left her feeling uneasy.

    “I wanted to trust that White Memorial would do the right thing,” Roman said of the guidelines. But she said doctors have told her that ICE activity in the hospital has gotten worse. 

    Roman said she wants more transparency from White Memorial about how it enforces its guidelines when ICE agents show up there.

    On Nov. 7, Sen. María Elena Durazo hand-delivered a letter to the hospital’s president, calling for a written account by Nov. 21 that explains why agents were allowed to block the ambulance entrance and what steps hospital leadership took to address their presence. 

    Centro CSO will protest ICE at White Memorial at 3 p.m. Saturday at Mariachi Plaza. 

    The Department of Homeland Security, which oversees ICE, did not answer specific questions about immigration enforcement at White Memorial.