Is it safe out there? This has been a key question since the pandemic blew into Los Angeles. You'd be forgiven for not knowing how to respond — it's been extremely confusing.
So, here's the simplified answer: No. There's a deadly virus running amok. COVID-19 is out of control in Los Angeles County. It is not safe.
December started with a record-setting number of new cases of coronavirus. Two days later, that record was broken. It was broken again the day after that. By December 10, another broken record: 12,819 cases reported in a single day.
Meanwhile, the City of L.A issued its own bewildering "targeted" order.
It essentially orders Angelenos to stay home and do nothing, except for the things on the nine pages of exceptions, which is everything you were already allowed to do, because the rules exactly mirror the county order.
A regional stay-at-home order has also been announced, but not yet triggered.
If Southern California's ICU capacity falls below 15% we will be placed into a Stay-at-Home order for three weeks. That could happen as soon as tomorrow, and likely within a week, according to Governor Gavin Newsom.
Below is a not-so-brief history of mixed signals and confusing messages. The real ambiguity was the friends we made along the way.
How We Got Here
- Shutdowns started in March.
- Reopenings ballooned in May.
- And in July there was a frightening increase in hospitalizations and fatalities.
The testing positivity rate at the time had spiked, the number of cases began to surge and break records, and community spread went up with an estimated one in every 230 people in the county infected and contagious — with many actively infecting others.
On a state level, all Californians were required to wear face masks in public.
Then came the update from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention on October 5 about how the virus spreads:
COVID-19 can sometimes be spread "by airborne transmission."
That means that in certain conditions, it is possible for the virus to:
- Spread more than 6 feet via particles and droplets
- Linger in the air for minutes to hours
- Infect even after an infectious person has left a space
According to the CDC, person-to-person close contact transmission is still the most common way COVID-19 is spread. Transmission by touching contaminated surfaces is also possible, but not thought to be as common.
Getting a straight answer about how to safely exist in this new world has not been easy.
Mixed Signals And Metrics
On the West Coast, there have been mixed signals that vacillated between enjoy-L.A.-at-your-own-risk and "hunker down."
There's also still leftover chaos from the first round of reopenings. When restrictions were initially lifted the messaging more or less stayed the same. People were told they should continue staying at home as much as possible.
But the inherent disconnect — ie: why are things reopening if we're not supposed to go there? — was never adequately resolved or clarified. It continues to create cognitive dissonance as sectors reopen and re-close (and people respond with varying levels of compliance).
What does this mean in practical terms? How can people evaluate possible health hazards when engaging with the reopened parts of Los Angeles?
That's a great question!
Spoiler: You sort of can't in a robust way?
Georgia Tech researchers created a Risk Assessment Planning Tool.
And you can choose outside activities over inside activities (provided you maintain distance and wear a mask).
But, just because something is open doesn't mean it's free of risk. There are plenty of new rules, but human error is real.
Plus, there's a lot we still don't know about this virus, about transmission, and about what it does to infected people and survivors.
If you're looking to officials to spell out actionable steps for decision-making in your daily life, prepare for inconsistencies and contradictions.
The narrative is fluid. The situation is fluid. And, after all the back-and-forth, you may want to take a very long nap inside an exasperated facepalm.
For example, during the inital rounds of reopening, here's what was said when asked about how people should judge possible dangers:
- L.A. Mayor Eric Garcetti initially said that people should make their own risk assessments about going out, then act accordingly. That hands-off tone changed by the end of June when he was urging Angelenos to behave as though everyone is sick.
- County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer at first went the subjective route, advising people to just avoid any activity that was "beyond your comfort zone." Within weeks, that message changed to "hunker down, back in your home, whenever you can."
- And Gov. Gavin Newsom took a you-do-you approach with comments like: "If a county doesn't want to reopen, they don't have to." Days after that remark he paused further reopening plans and re-closed our bars. He then re-closed additional sectors.
A Rainbow Of Threats
BUT, we do have a color chart now.
Two of them.
According to L.A.'s rainbow we're at level "ORANGE," meaning the risk of infection is high, and it's recommended people stay home except for essential needs and essential work.
According to the state, we are PURPLE. That means the pandemic is "Widespread," based on case rates and positivity rates. PURPLE is the top tier.
There is no GREEN.
"We don't believe that there is a green light, which says go back to the way things were," was Newsom's messaging in late August.
Confluence Of Crises
Reopening Los Angeles during a rising pandemic is a tricky thing. But reopening Los Angeles during a rising pandemic when the nation is also — as civil rights lawyer Connie Rice put it — "fighting the last battles of the American Civil War," is another thing entirely.
And that's where we are right now.
As a society, we are standing inside a Venn diagram of pandemic and brutality, staring down centuries of racial inequity and a historic contagion with a death toll that screams "racism is a public health issue."
The coronavirus has taken a disproportionate toll on Black and Latino Angelenos, and the aggressive law enforcement tactics seen at some L.A. protests — like tear gas, not distancing protesters in custody, corralling arrests, crowded buses — can create conditions that can increase spread.
The surges in cases, however, were traced in July to parties and gatherings over Memorial Day weekend. The surging cases in November were blamed on "COVID fatigue," a false sense of security, and people not following public health guidelines about spending time with family and friends they don't live with.
For now, the ground keeps moving, the rules keep shifting, and it's not entirely clear what comes next.
This special edition of our How To L.A. handbook series was created with this in mind, for this moment in time, with guides to help Angelenos navigate the day-to-day, as it changes, seemingly, minute-by-minute.
With contributions from Ryan Fonseca, Jackie Fortier, Brian Frank, Mike Roe, Jessica Ogilvie, Gina Pollack, Elly Yu, Elina Shatkin, and the entire KPCC/LAist newsroom.
This story has been updated. It was originally published on July 29, 2020.
Image Credit (top): Illustration by Chava Sanchez/LAist | Image by Morning Brew/Unsplash