One year ago, Congress defunded public media. Now that we're 100% community funded, please become a sustaining member or increase your existing membership today.
Cole’s gets its glow-up. Will downtown come back for it?
Walking into the new Cole’s feels like seeing a friend after they’ve taken a much-needed holiday.
The restaurant reopened Wednesday, Nov. 18, under new owners Sean Maloney and Jeremy Fall, who took over after Cedd Moses closed it in March.
You feel a sense of familiarity, even with updated fixtures, including new banquettes and more dining-room seating.
Think of it as a Hillstone that moved downtown, except this one’s been here since 1908 and just got a glow-up.
“It has that kind of New York bustling brasserie feel,” Maloney said. “It’s warm, but you don’t feel overwhelmed. I think that’s really hard to re-create.”
Maloney, formerly chief hospitality officer of Mozza Restaurant Group, said saving Cole’s felt like a personal responsibility. “It’s part of L.A.’s fabric,” he said. “It was kind of necessary, and if no one else is doing it, I felt inclined to.”
Jus first, then mustard
The question on everyone’s mind: What about the French dips? Fall said the team kept the original recipe but upgraded every component, dry-brining the prime rib overnight and simmering the jus for 24 hours from the beef’s own trimmings.
It's now $26 (previously $20), with an option to upgrade to Flannery prime rib for an additional $8. There’s also a pastrami dip from RC Provisions — the same supplier as Langer’s — and a new veggie-friendly mushroom-and-onion version with red wine jus ($27). Each comes on a French loaf from Clark Street Bread, layered with Swiss cheese and served with a side of jus, atomic pickles and hot mustard.
The sandwich holds its own, channeling the energy of a quality French dip — especially from a place that claims to have invented it (a title Philippe the Original in Chinatown has long disputed). Both the sliced beef and the pastrami stay moist and flavorful, and the custom loaf soaks up jus and mustard without ever getting soggy.
That mustard may surprise longtime regulars. It’s now made with fresh horseradish, which the owners pitch as an upgrade. Maloney said it has “a brightening effect” that’s “very much a palate-cleansing effect,” unlike a typical grocery-store mustard. His preferred eating method? “I like to start jus first, and then go mustard and then go back to jus,” he said. How about going straight to mustard? “I think that’s crazy.”
I found the new iteration definitely fresh-tasting, though personally speaking it could have used more kick. (I like to feel mustard's effect in my olfactory system, but I realize not everyone might want that!)
Beyond the dip
Other new items on the menu: a series of appetizers that includes spinach dip with caramelized onions, made with Comté, and rosemary crackers ($18), along with fried ravioli ($20) filled with wild mushroom and fontina, served with pomodoro dipping sauce for those who love a good finger food option; there's plenty to share with a small group of people.
For larger entree-style dishes, the Cole’s Caesar salad features stacked romaine with Calabrian croutons, white anchovies and a generous showering of Parmigiano-Reggiano.
Rounding out the menu is a chicken cordon bleu stuffed with mortadella and Comté ($38) that oozes American comfort — a good option if you’re looking for something cozy. The baked gnocchi Parisienne ($25) arrives as soft pillows submerged in a creamy pomodoro sauce with a kick of Calabrian chili.
The Mozza influence feels intentional on the latter half of the menu, from the mortadella to the Calabrian chili, and it fits snugly alongside the classic sandwiches.
At the bar
The cocktail menu offers a tasteful modern take on classic recipes priced from $15 to $17, with notable options including an Accidental Vesper made with agave, and the Beef Dip Old Fashioned, featuring an au jus–washed Buffalo Trace. The Beef Dip was rich and full-bodied, with a coating mouthfeel. Both are good complements to the menu.
The Varnish space, the old speakeasy inside Cole's, isn't open to the public yet but can be reserved for private parties; Maloney and Fall hope to unveil a new concept once the restaurant is up and running.
Can it bring people back downtown?
Downtown Los Angeles is on an upswing. The Original Pantry Cafe is reopening, an incoming mayor has called downtown a priority, and, as the Los Angeles Times recently reported, the office exodus has finally leveled off. With it comes a new sense of hope.
Still, the pressures that led Moses to close Cole’s haven’t gone away: lingering pandemic fallout, rising rents and operating costs, and the perception that downtown isn’t safe.
Then there’s the price. A $26 dip plus a $15 to $17 cocktail comes to about $41 to $43 before tax and tip. That may be more than many Angelenos are used to paying for a sandwich and a drink, but plenty of people have fond memories of Cole’s and downtown and will likely want to see the new version for themselves.
Maloney is betting on value. “I think people are really craving affordable luxuries right now,” he said. He also hopes Cole’s gives the rest of the city a reason to come to the area, which he acknowledged “can also be a little bit intimidating to people who are from outside downtown.”
For longtime regulars wary of the changes, he offered a simple case.
“Obviously we want to change as little as possible, but we have to change a lot of things,” Maloney said.
“We’re really just doing what we have to do to ensure that it’s here longer, because otherwise it wouldn’t be.”
Location: 118 E. 6th St., DTLA.
Hours: 6–9:45 p.m., Wednesday through Sunday. Starting Dec. 2, noon to midnight, Wednesday through Sunday.