One year ago, Congress defunded public media. Now that we're 100% community funded, please become a sustaining member or increase your existing membership today.
What Eaton Fire survivors need to know as Edison payout and lawsuit deadlines approach
The window is closing for survivors of the Eaton Fire to apply for direct compensation through Southern California Edison. The deadline is Nov. 30.
Nearly two years since that fire killed 19 people and destroyed more than 9,400 homes and businesses, many survivors remain stuck in the fog of trauma, in battles with their insurance companies or overwhelmed by the day-to-day struggle of rebuilding their lives.
They’re also weighing whether to accept the Edison payouts or hold out for a lawsuit.
“The community is in a state of fatigue at a time where they can't afford to be,” said Elise Preston Mallory, a longtime Altadena volunteer, member of the Pasadena NAACP and community liaison for United Policyholders.
Legal and community experts LAist spoke with emphasized that the decision is deeply personal and unique to each circumstance, but that survivors can no longer wait to take action as it takes time to retain a lawyer for a lawsuit, as well as put together paperwork for the Edison direct compensation program.
“You can be doing both things in parallel until you get an offer that you have decided to accept,” said Amanda Riddle, a court-appointed liaison counsel for the Eaton Fire lawsuits.
Edison faces thousands of lawsuits, with the first of three bellwether trials set to begin March 8. Lawyers representing Eaton Fire survivors say they expect each trial to take up to eight weeks. If Edison doesn't appeal the verdicts, they expect the rest of the cases to be settled relatively quickly, with the goal being under two years.
Upcoming deadlines for Eaton Fire survivors
- Nov. 30, 2026: Deadline to apply for SoCal Edison’s Wildfire Recovery Compensation Program.
- Jan. 7, 2027: Deadline to file a lawsuit against Edison for claims involving wrongful death, personal injury and emotional distress.
- Jan. 7, 2028: Deadline to file a lawsuit for claims solely involving property damage.
Survivors can apply for the SoCal Edison direct compensation program and file a lawsuit at the same time. If you do both, you’ll have to have your lawyer also do the paperwork for Edison’s program. Edison says it will add an additional 20% of net damages to offers submitted through an attorney. If you accept the offer from Edison, you’ll have to drop your lawsuit and waive your right to sue over damages related to the Eaton Fire.
Regarding the expected timing of lawsuits, you can hear directly from court-appointed liaison counsels for Eaton Fire cases Jerry Singleton and Amanda Riddle at this recent webinar hosted by Every Fire Survivors Network.
Taxes and public assistance
Legal experts said it’s important to look closely at any attorney retainer agreement and speak with a tax adviser about how the state may tax these payments in your specific situation.
Settlements through Edison’s programs or lawsuits will be largely exempt from federal taxes, thanks to a new law. At the state level, another new law does something similar.
Experts also emphasized that if someone in your household receives public assistance, it’s important to discuss with Social Security, a benefits administrator or an attorney how any settlement payment may affect eligibility for those services.
Resources for legal help
The following organizations have offered free legal consultations or information for fire survivors.
Neighborhood Legal Services of L.A. County
United Policyholders is hosting an assistance clinic on Nov. 19 to help survivors gather the paperwork they need for the Edison direct pay program, insurance and other aspects of recovery.
Experiences with the Edison program
LAist heard from more than two dozen fire survivors weighing the decision between a lawsuit and Edison’s direct compensation program.
Some rejected the Edison offer, saying it was far too low and didn’t sufficiently compensate for emotional distress, including a homeowner with smoke and ash damage and a renter who had to relocate.
Others accepted, often with mixed feelings, including a homeowner with a total loss who found the offer would be just enough to bridge the gap between what they have and what they need to get back home as soon as possible.
Multiple survivors LAist spoke with worry that permitting, construction delays and rising building costs may mean they still end up in a financial hole.
Survivors LAist spoke with also expressed frustration that the Edison offer deducts the full insurance policy limit, not what a household has actually received.
“The Fast Pay offers are a little formulaic,” said Lloyd Dixon, director of the Feinberg Center for Catastrophic Risk Management and Compensation at RAND and co-author of a recently published review of Edison’s Wildfire Recovery Compensation Program so far. “Some people are going to end up doing well just by luck of the draw.”
Though Dixon cautioned that RAND’s analysis has limits, the report identified some commonalities between survivors who accepted offers, including:
- Households who need the money now for living expenses and cannot wait until claims are resolved through traditional litigation
- Residents who are older or in poor health
- Residents who worry litigation would be too stressful
- Residents in a situation where the Edison compensation protocol happens to generate a more favorable offer than they may expect through other avenues. That may include people without significant noneconomic damages, or those who were severely underinsured compared to the value of their property.
- Residents who do not have disputes with their insurers over certain coverage. For example, a total loss for which insurers have agreed to pay policy limits.
Many say process is lengthy
Most survivors LAist spoke with said the Edison compensation process took months longer than they expected. They also found it convoluted, with repeated asks for paperwork and other holdups, adding frustration to an already difficult recovery.
One of the most common reasons for delay relates to a state law that requires the court to approve settlements involving minors, called the “minor’s compromise.”
Others described to LAist an exasperating back-and-forth with the third-party contractors answering the phones.
“We take all that feedback seriously,” said Edison spokesperson Joel Kennedy when LAist described these issues. Kennedy emphasized that, per the utility’s surveys of participants, 82% “have reported a favorable opinion of the program.”
Kennedy said the utility has, on average, sent offers 36 days “after a claim is considered substantially complete.”
One lawyer representing dozens of clients in the program said the detailed review on average took four to six months, and up to nine months when minors were involved.
Still, legal experts told LAist the process is likely to be shorter than litigation.
“The compensation program is still quite likely to pay people earlier,” said Nicholas Lampros, an attorney with Bet Tzedek Legal Services. “We don't know exactly how much faster.”
How ‘fair’ are the Edison offers?
Jerry Singleton, a court-appointed liaison for the Eaton Fire lawsuits and an attorney who has settled past California wildfire cases, said at a recent webinar hosted by local grassroots group Every Fire Survivors Network that he has about three dozen clients who have chosen to go with the Edison compensation program.
He estimates the payments to those clients were 30 to 50 cents on the dollar, compared to what they may be able to get through litigation. Edison maintains that its goal is “to offer compensation in line with settlement values for similar claims in past wildfire lawsuits, with a more streamlined and faster approach than litigation.”
It’s difficult to truly compare since such settlements are confidential, said Dixon, the RAND researcher.
“We don't have data on what the actual settlements look like from other litigation of other fires, so it's really hard for us to assess whether there really is a gap or not,” he said.
The SoCal Edison Wildfire Recovery Compensation Program by the numbers, so far
SoCal Edison so far has paid out about $680 million through its direct pay program, according to Joel Kennedy, a spokesperson for the utility. Nearly 6,000 claims have been submitted, 42% through an attorney, and more than 3,400 offers extended, totaling more than $1.1 billion.
On average, homeowners with a total loss have been offered $890,000 through the program, and have received $1 million through their insurance.
The highest total paid out to a homeowner so far is $6 million. That household was a total loss with no insurance, Kennedy said.
The lowest payment for a tenant with smoke and ash damage so far is $15,000
The average payment for a tenant with smoke and ash damage is $60,000.
The utility says it takes about two hours on average to submit a claim and 80% of offers so far have been accepted.
Edison will host a final virtual community meeting about the program on Thurs., Nov. 19 at 6 pm. You can sign up to attend here.
You can submit a claim online or call 888-912-8528 for assistance. Find answers to Frequently Asked Questions here.
The ‘minor’s compromise’
Casty Fortich had been attending meetings held by law firms for months before he decided to apply for, and later accept, the direct compensation offer from Southern California Edison.
Fortich, his wife, Tracey, and their two daughters, now 15 and 20, lost their Altadena home of more than two decades in the Eaton Fire. While Fortich doesn’t think the offer reflects the trauma of their evacuation and grief of their loss, he was far enough along in his rebuild process to have a good idea of the costs, and the Edison offer turned out to be what he needed to bridge the gap between what his insurance paid out and what he needs to rebuild. His insurance covered about two-thirds of his expected rebuild costs. About three months ago the family received their offer and decided to accept, given the uncertainty of timing with the lawsuits, he said.
“To be able to continue with my rebuild and know that I have the funds to cover the construction costs, it allows me to sleep at night,” Fortich said.
But the process to receive that money has taken far longer than expected. They applied about a month after the program launched at the end of October 2025. They’re still waiting to receive the offer they accepted because of a state law that requires any settlement involving a minor to be approved by the court, called the “minor’s compromise.”
Despite using an attorney to go through the process, they faced hurdles to get a court date. The process to find a bank that would receive such a settlement was also complicated and frustrating.
“It’s a daunting process,” said Tracey Fortich, Casty Fortich’s spouse. “I hate to think there’s someone out there not getting the funds they need because it’s so hard to navigate this process.”
The Fortiches are not alone. Lawyers representing people who accepted Edison offers said on average it’s taken one to three months to get through the minor’s compromise process.
If all goes to plan, the Fortiches should receive their money before the end of the year.
Meanwhile, Casty Fortich expressed frustration with the struggle survivors continue to face while Edison executives make millions.
For him, the choice to accept was purely practical.
“The main factor in that decision,” he said, “is do we have the funds to rebuild?”
Weighing litigation
For Alphonso Browne, who was dropped from his insurance just months before the Eaton Fire, the Edison compensation program has only recently become more appealing. He and his wife suffered a total loss and are living in a trailer on their lot in Altadena.
Browne said he’s become fed up with lawyers asking for 25% to 30% of a potential settlement through litigation. The nonprofits connecting people to financial support, he said, have been “a disappointment” too.
“I've been hearing from many others who say, ‘Oh, my lawyer says don't take the settlement,’” Browne said. “I say, ‘Yeah, they're going to tell you that because the more money they could get from Edison means the more money for them in their pocket.'"
Meanwhile, unexpected costs have piled up — he recently had to pay a fee of more than $2,000 to connect his trailer to electricity on his lot, for example.
After hearing from others who were happy with their offers from Edison, he decided to take the leap this month and begin the application.
“I'm optimistic,” Browne said. “We’re holding up the best that we can. It’s all we can do.”
For some older residents, Edison program made sense
Diann and Mike Danneker moved to Altadena in 1977, where they raised their kids. Their home of decades burned in the Eaton Fire. But they had good insurance through USAA. They expect it will cover their rebuild.
Because of their age — Diann is 78; Mike is 82 — they wanted to get home as quickly as possible.
“I was feeling that at our age, if we go with attorneys, cases tend to go on forever, and so we'll be very, very old by the time this case is settled,” Mike Danneker said.
With a mortgage still to pay, they hope the Edison funds will assist with unexpected costs they’re facing as part of their rebuild — like building a retaining wall. Still, it’s taken nearly a year to finish the process after back-and-forth on documents and a delay caused by the minor’s compromise for their daughter’s child. Nearly a year after applying, they have yet to receive their payment.
“We’re just kind of waiting,” Diann Danneker said.
Still, the Dannekers said, they’re grateful to be alive and designing a home they love. They expect to move back in the spring or summer.
Their experience was similar to that of Tommy McMullins and his wife, Gwendolyn, both in their early 80s. They moved from Georgia to California in 1968, and bought a house in Altadena in the mid-1970s. It burned in the Eaton Fire. When they heard about the Edison direct pay program, they applied soon after it launched.
“We decided that rather than wait for the attorney lawsuit to go through, we would actually check out Edison and find out what they could offer us,” Tommy McMullins said. They ended up going through the detailed review process with an attorney after receiving the first offer.
They’re still deciding whether to accept it, but Tommy McMullins said they’re likely to. They’re waiting on quotes from contractors first.
Unlike others LAist spoke with, the process was fairly quick for them, Tommy McMullins said. They received an initial offer well within 90 days. The detailed review process then took a bit longer.
The reaction to the final offer?
“Relatively fair,” Tommy McMullins said. “How can you measure it, what's fair, what's unfair? But it was sufficient to cover our basic needs.”