Sponsored message
Logged in as
Audience-funded nonprofit news
radio tower icon laist logo
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
Subscribe
  • Listen Now Playing Listen

The Brief

The most important stories for you to know today
  • Company says all 5 passengers are dead
    A boat near the U.S. Coast Guard base in Boston, Mass., on Wednesday, where rescue teams are racing to find a missing submersible with five people on board.
    A boat near the U.S. Coast Guard base in Boston, Mass., on Wednesday, where rescue teams are racing to find a missing submersible with five people on board.

    Topline:

    All five passengers aboard the missing Titan submersible are believed to have died, according to OceanGate, the company that developed the submersible. U.S. Coast Guard officials said the debris found indicates a "catastrophic implosion of the vessel."

    Why now: Remote-operated vehicles were searching for the sub, called Titan, near the site where a surveillance aircraft first detected "underwater noises" late Tuesday.

    The backstory: Various underwater search efforts were moved to the location of the noise to discover its source, but the Coast Guard said efforts "yielded negative results" up until news of the debris field.

    All five passengers aboard the missing Titan submersible are believed to have died, according to OceanGate, the company that developed the submersible.

    U.S. Coast Guard officials said the debris found indicates a "catastrophic implosion of the vessel."

    "We now believe that our CEO Stockton Rush, Shahzada Dawood and his son Suleman Dawood, Hamish Harding, and Paul-Henri Nargeolet, have sadly been lost," the company said in a statement on Thursday.

    A remote operating vehicle operating on the seafloor near the wreck of the Titanic identified debris that is confirmed to be the remains of the Titan submersible.

    Officials said they will begin to demobilize vessels from the scene over the course of the next 24 hours but added that remote operations will continue on the sea floor.

    Earlier in the day rescue teams hunting for the missing Titanic-touring submersible uncovered a field of debris near the site of the wrecked ocean liner, the Coast Guard said.

    Remote-operated vehicles searched for the sub, called Titan, near the site where a surveillance aircraft first detected "underwater noises" late Tuesday.
    Here's a guide to what we know.

    What do we know about the debris field?

    The U.S. Coast Guard said that the debris field was uncovered by an ROV deployed by the Canadian ship Horizon Arctic, which had reached the sea floor early Thursday.

    Other than that, there's not much known about the U.S. Coast Guard's findings. Experts say the seabed around the Titanic is littered with bits of the wreck, which shows tell-tale signs of its age, including the effects of an iron-eating bacteria.

    The U.S. Coast Guard said that maritime surveillance planes operated by Canada detected underwater sounds late Tuesday, then again on Wednesday.

    Various underwater search efforts were moved to the location of the noise to discover its source, but the Coast Guard said efforts "yielded negative results" up until news of the debris field.

    As of Wednesday, underwater acoustic experts from the Navy were still analyzing the sounds, which one expert described as "banging noises."

    The U.S. Coast Guard and other experts with knowledge of the search warned that the sounds may not necessarily be proof of life.

    "You have to remember that it's the wreck site of the Titanic, so there is a lot of metal and different objects in the water around the site," Rear Adm. John Mauger said in an interview with CBS News on Wednesday morning.

    What kind of equipment is being used in the search?

    A red ship is seen through fog, sailing on blue ocean water.
    A photo provided by the U.S. Coast Guard on Wednesday shows a ship searching for the lost submersible near the wreck site of the Titanic.
    (
    U.S. Coast Guard
    )

    The U.S. Coast Guard says that the data from the Canadian aircraft, known as a P-3 Orion, is nevertheless serving as a focus point for its unified search efforts.

    The remoteness of the location and the size of the search area — extending 10,000 miles on the surface and 2.4 miles down to the ocean floor — has complicated efforts to locate the vessel and its passengers. Thursday's weather, at least, may prove more favorable to search crews, with winds slowing to 14 mph and wave swells dropping around 4 to 5 feet.

    In addition to the ROV deployed by Horizon Arctic, a second deep-diving ROV, deployed by the French vessel L'Atalante, was searching for the Titan as of Thursday morning.

    Multiple maritime surveillance planes from U.S. and Canadian armed forces have flown over the site and dropped sonar buoys in the area.

    Also en route is the U.S. Navy's Flyaway Deep Ocean Salvage System (FADOSS), a motion-compensated lift system which can lift heavy undersea objects.

    The design of the Titan means that only those outside the vessel can unseal it, so regardless of whether it rises to the surface or not, the passengers will require outside help to escape.

    The Canadian ship Glace Bay, which contains a mobile decompression chamber and is staffed with medical personnel, is also expected to arrive Thursday morning.

    The unified search command led by the U.S. Coast Guard has been criticized by industry experts and U.S. lawmakers who say the teams didn't send equipment to the site early enough.

    Richard Garriott de Cayeux, president of the Explorers Club, tweeted that members of the research group continually offered their expertise and equipment — including a deep-diving ROV with the ability to attach a lift cable to the Titan — but were not approved to send the equipment until Wednesday, putting the estimated arrival time hours behind when the Titan's emergency oxygen supply is due to expire.

    When will the sub's oxygen supply run out?

    At the beginning of the search on Sunday, officials estimated the submersible, if still fully functional, contained about 96 hours of reserve oxygen. At a 1 p.m. ET press conference on Wednesday, the Coast Guard estimated that supply was down to about 20 hours.

    That means the the oxygen on board the Titan could run out early Thursday morning.

    But U.S. Coast Guard Capt. Jamie Frederick said that's only "one factor" in what is still "a search-and-rescue operation, 100 percent."

    "We need to have hope," he said in a Wednesday media briefing. He added that he wasn't ready to speculate about when the search efforts might end.

    On Thursday morning, U.S. Coast Guard Rear Adm. John Mauger said that crews would continue their efforts throughout the day on the assumption that the people on board are still alive.

    "In all of our search and rescue efforts that the Coast Guard does every day, we use all available data and information to prosecute those searches," Mauger said in an interview with NBC. "But we continue to find, especially in complex cases, that people's will to live needs to be accounted for as well."

    When and where did the sub go missing?


    Titan lost contact with its support ship — a Canadian research vessel called Polar Prince — an hour and 45 minutes after it first entered the water on Sunday, around 8 a.m. ET.

    At that point, it was already more than halfway down to the Titanic's wreck on the Atlantic's ocean bed, roughly 900 miles east of Cape Cod in Massachusetts.

    The Coast Guard said it was first notified of the missing vessel at 5:40 p.m. ET, nearly three hours after the Titan was expected to resurface at 3 p.m. ET.

    Who was on board?


    The people on board Titan include pilot Stockton Rush, the head of OceanGate, the company that developed the submersible; Paul-Henri Nargeolet, a French underwater wreck expert who has written about the Titanic and visited the wreck dozens of times; a British entrepreneur Hamish Harding; and father-son Pakistani nationals Shahzada and Suleman Dawood.

    A former passenger of the Titan described the vessel as like being in a "minivan without seats" and says its interior design relies on "off-the-shelf parts," including a video game controller for steering.

    What was the sub's mission?

    The OceanGate logo is seen on a vehicle stored near the company's offices on Wednesday in Everett, Wash. The company owns the submersible that has been missing since Sunday.
    The OceanGate logo is seen on a vehicle stored near the company's offices on Wednesday in Everett, Wash. The company owns the submersible that has been missing since Sunday.
    (
    David Ryder
    /
    Getty Images
    )

    The missing vessel is owned by OceanGate, a company based in Washington that's become a major chronicler of the Titanic's decay.

    In May, OceanGate shared the first-ever full-size digital scan of the wreck site, which is slowly succumbing to a metal-eating bacteria and at risk of disintegrating in a matter of decades.

    For $250,000 a person, the company promises tourists an underwater voyage to explore the remains of the Titanic from the seafloor. From St. John's in Newfoundland, Canada, explorers travel 380 miles offshore and 2.4 miles below the surface. A full trip can take eight days and include multiple dives.

    If successful, the dives offer a glimpse of what's left of the 1912 crash into an iceberg, which took the lives of all but 700 of the Titanic's 2,200 passengers and crew.

    Did anyone warn OceanGate that the Titan wasn't safe?


    Years before the Titan went missing, OceanGate faced several complaints and warnings about the safety of its submersible vessels.

    Records from a 2018 lawsuit show that the company's former director of marine operations, David Lochridge, flagged potential safety issues with the Titan as it was under development in 2015.

    Lochridge was particularly concerned about the company's lack of testing on the Titan's 5-inch-thick carbon fiber hull, which employed an experimental design developed in collaboration with NASA. He also said that the Titan's port window was only designed to withstand depths of about 4,200 feet — far shallower than the 13,000-foot depth of the Titanic.

    OceanGate responded in legal filings by saying it relied on acoustic testing "better suited" to detect safety issues. The company fired and sued Lochridge, accusing him of breaching his contract.

    Separately, but in the same year the lawsuit was settled, the chairman of the Marine Technology Society's Submarine Group wrote a letter to OceanGate saying 38 industry experts had "unanimous concern" about the Titan's lack of adherence to industry standards.

    "We have submarines all over the world diving at 12,000 to 20,000 feet every day of the year, for research. We know very well how to design these machines and operate them safely," the chairman, Will Kohnen, told NPR's Morning Edition on Wednesday.

    How did OceanGate respond to warnings about Titan's safety?

    OceanGate has seen at least two documented safety incidents with the Titan after these warnings.

    During a 2022 expedition, OceanGate reported that its sub had experienced a battery issue during a dive and had to be manually reattached to its lifting platform, court filings show.

    In the same year, the vessel lost contact with its surface crew for nearly five hours during a dive, according to CBS correspondent David Pogue, who was observing the mission for a journalistic report on the company.

    Pogue reported that a waiver for passengers of the Titan clearly states the vessel has not been approved or certified by any regulatory body.

    OceanGate's founder, who is reportedly on board the missing Titan, said in a 2019 interview that the commercial submarine industry's regulations stood in the way of progress.

    "It's obscenely safe because they have all these regulations," Rush told The Smithsonian Magazine. "But it also hasn't innovated or grown."

    NPR's Willem Marx, Ayana Archie and Juliana Kim contributed reporting.

    Copyright 2024 NPR. To see more, visit npr.org.

  • International tourists get their kicks

    Topline:

    One hundred years after its founding, the nearly 2,500-mile highway from Chicago to Santa Monica, Calif., continues to capture imaginations far beyond U.S. borders.

    Why it matters: According to a 2024 study conducted by the tourism research firm SMARInsights and shared with NPR by the New Mexico Tourism Department, international travelers are more likely to travel the entire length of Route 66 than those from within the United States.

    There isn't much to see in Amboy, Calif. But if you're traveling on Route 66, the dusty stop in the Mojave Desert is a must for its famous 50-foot-tall neon Roy's Motel and Cafe sign. Photographing the sign can wait: Alan Jacob gets out of his rented GMC truck and heads straight for the gift shop.

    Others in Jacob's tour group driving the length of Route 66 have bought T-shirts, hats and socks along the way. One even got a Route 66 tattoo. For the sinewy, retired plumber from a small town about an hour North of New Zealand's capital, Wellington, it's all about the fridge magnets along the nearly month-long journey.

    A photo montage of a man in a hat standing in front of his truck. A road with the Route 66 sign. And a table of Route 66 memorabilia.
    New Zealander Alan Jacob picked up Route 66 magnets during a stop along the tour in Amboy, Calif.
    (
    Krystal Ramirez
    /
    NPR
    )

    "I've been buying magnets everywhere I go," Jacob said. "When I get home, I'm going to get an 8-by-4 sheet, powder-coat it white, put the road on it and put all the magnets where I got them from."

    Celebrating the road's centennial

    A neon Wigwam Motel sign stands near cone-shaped teepee rooms and palm trees at dusk along Route 66.
    The Wigwam Hotel is a popular stop on the highway in San Bernardino, Calif.
    (
    Krystal Ramirez
    /
    NPR
    )

    One hundred years after its founding, the nearly 2,500-mile highway from Chicago to Santa Monica, Calif., continues to capture imaginations far beyond U.S. borders.

    According to a 2024 study conducted by the tourism research firm SMARInsights and shared with NPR by the New Mexico Tourism Department, international travelers are more likely to travel the entire length of Route 66 than those from within the United States.

    "60 to 70% of the people who come here are international travelers," said Samir Patel, the manager of The Wigwam Motel, a popular stop on the highway in San Bernardino, Calif. "And a good chunk of them are Australians and New Zealanders." The highway has been popular for decades with Europeans, he added, and, in more recent years, with South American and Asian tourists.

    A person in a blue WigWam Motel shirt stands at a check-in counter below a wigwam-shaped sign spelling 'WigWam Motel'.
    Samir Patel stands inside The Wigwam Motel.
    (
    Krystal Ramirez
    /
    NPR
    )

    Driven by a passion for cars

    Sam Murray, the New Zealand-based owner of Gilligans Tours — loosely named after the 1960s American TV show Gilligan's Island — has been leading Route 66 trips in the spring and fall for more than a decade. His clientele are mostly tourists from New Zealand and Australia.

    Murray said he was drawn to Route 66 through his passion for car racing. The 48-year-old first came to the U.S. as an adult in 2005 for an auto race in Laughlin, Nev. When the event was done, Murray drove down a nearby part of Route 66 for the first time. It made him want to do the whole thing.

    A man smiling at the camera.
    Sam Murray is the New Zealand-based owner of Gilligans Tours, which has been leading tour groups along Route 66 for over 10 years.
    (
    Krystal Ramirez
    /
    NPR
    )

    "So in 2011, I bought an old motor home in Pennsylvania, drove down to St. Louis, followed Route 66 back to LA," he said. "And then I realized when I got home, people that I talked to had an interest as well in doing Route 66."

    Of course, "doing Route 66" these days isn't what it once was. The construction of the modern interstate highway system made older sections of the road obsolete. It was officially removed from the system in 1985. Route 66 now exists as an incomplete patchwork of roads, some of them unpaved.

    A building with a map of the historic Route 66 route.
    A mural depicting the map of Route 66 painted on the side of a building in Oro Grande, Calif.
    (
    Krystal Ramirez
    /
    NPR
    )

    "We've done quite a bit of gravel driving, which is something I didn't expect to do over here," said retired apple grower Pete Volkers. He opted to ride with Murray rather than drive himself in a rented car.

    Volkers was looking to venture out on his own for the first time since losing his wife last year to breast cancer, and Route 66 had long been on his bucket list.

    He was steeped in mid-20th century American pop culture growing up in New Zealand — "The American diner thing and TV shows like Happy Days," he recalled.

    A man in sunglasses sitting on a bench at a boardwalk facing a beach.
    New Zealander Pete Volkers enjoyed seeing kitschy Americana at stops along the tour.
    (
    Krystal Ramirez
    /
    NPR
    )

    "On this trip, we've been to so many little towns which have all this stuff that we've seen on TV, and all of these iconic neon signs," said Volkers. "And you just don't get a chance to see that anywhere else in the world."

    Volkers said he enjoys wide-open roads sprinkled with opportunities to revel in American kitsch and nostalgia. ("At least I can go home and say I slept in a teepee," he said after spending a night in a concrete, teepee-shaped guestroom at the Wigwam Motel.) But Volkers also acknowledges there's a certain bleakness to traveling Route 66 in 2026.

    "These little towns that not a lot of people come through. No one stops there," Volkers said. "They're just zooming on to the next big place."

    Thriving pit stops along the way

    People and vehicles fill a dirt street in Oatman lined with wooden shops, with jagged mountains rising behind the town.
    Tourists walk through Oatman, Ariz., which is along Route 66.
    (
    Krystal Ramirez
    /
    NPR
    )

    Even if Route 66 isn't what it once was, many stops along the way look like they are thriving — at least for tourists. Oatman, Ariz., is among them.

    The windswept former gold mining town is packed with people on a Monday afternoon. To Australian insurance broker Peter Johnson, the rickety clapboard storefronts and local population of roaming donkeys bring classic Westerns to mind. "You should be walking along here with a six gun," Johnson said.

    Inside the Oatman Hotel on Main Street, Carrie Eagan is packing bottles of ketchup and mayo instead of a Colt revolver. The restaurant manager at the bustling Route 66 landmark, built in 1902, said she's noticed one main difference between foreign visitors and American ones: "The Americans, they know a lot about the history. But the foreigners are very excited," Eagan said. "They come dressed to impress; ready to go."

    A photo montage: A man looking off-camera. A donkey roaming in front of a store. A couple inside a room decorated with dollar bills.
    Australian insurance broker Peter Johnson (left) enjoyed stopping in Oatman, Ariz., which features roaming donkeys in a old Western-style town. New Zealand couple Keiron and Wendy Guinness sit at the Oatman Hotel bar, which is covered in dollar bills.
    (
    Krystal Ramirez
    /
    NPR
    )

    This is certainly true of tour participants Kieron and Wendy Guinness. He's sporting a handlebar mustache and white cowboy hat; she's petite and put together in a scarlet sweater. The New Zealand couple are wowed by the thick wads of greenbacks plastering every inch of ceiling and wall space in the Oatman Hotel. "This hotel would be worth a fortune!" Wendy said.

    She's been a fan of the United States ever since she spent a year in California as a high school student. "I put on 20 pounds that year because especially when you're young, you come and you're like, 'Oh my God, there's so much good food,'" said Guinness, who managed a women's clothing store before retiring. "We ate out all the time."

    Kieron Guinness is nuts about American cars, like many in the group. "I've been around hot rodding all my life, mucking around with old V8s, Chevrolets and Fords and Dodges," he said.

    The wiry retired bartender said he has a side hustle importing U.S. cars into New Zealand — despite the fact that steering wheels on American cars are on the left-hand side. "And our country's a right-hand drive country," Guinness said.

    A person photographs a blue Jeep parked outside a wooden Western-style building with an old wagon on its roof and a sign reading "The Legendary Red Ridge Marauders Wild West Shows."
    Steve Gray photographs a building next to a Gilligans Tour car in Oatman.
    (
    Krystal Ramirez
    /
    NPR
    )

    Relief at the end of the trail

    Waiting in line near the famous "The End of Trail" sign in Santa Monica for a final group photograph, Sam Murray was relieved about making it to the end of Route 66 with no major mishaps.

    The tour operator said arriving at the final destination is usually a relief for his guests, too.

    "It's not easy," Murray said. "Driving a two-lane highway from downtown Chicago to here is a big expectation for anyone — let alone somebody that's from a country where you drive on the other side of the road."
    Copyright 2026 NPR

    A man poses for a photo next to Santa Monica's Route 66 "End of the Trail" sign.
    Peter Johnson poses for a photo at the end of Route 66 trail in Santa Monica, Calif.
    (
    Krystal Ramirez
    /
    NPR
    )

  • Sponsored message
  • Mixed-status families in CA could lose housing
    A housing construction going up.
    Accumulated dirt at the Urban Town House Project in Long Beach, on July 22, 2021. The affordable housing project will be for low-income families.

    Topline:

    Housing authorities across the state are scrambling to prevent their clients from ending up homeless as they brace for a new Trump administration rule that could pull federal subsidies from 7,000 California households.

    Why now: Starting next month, the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development plans to bar all families with a “mixed” immigration status from federally funded housing.

    Why it matters: The upheaval is expected to hit California, with its large immigrant population, harder than any other state. The Trump administration has framed this as a way to remove subsidies from undocumented immigrants and give them to homeless veterans and disabled or elderly citizens.

    What's next: The agencies that administer housing vouchers are trying to make emergency plans for their mixed-status families, attempting to move them from federally funded programs into ones that are paid for with city, county, state or philanthropic dollars. But how successful that effort will be will vary greatly county by county, depending on what resources each has available.

    Housing authorities across the state are scrambling to prevent their clients from ending up homeless as they brace for a new Trump administration rule that could pull federal subsidies from 7,000 California households.

    Starting next month, the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development plans to bar all families with a “mixed” immigration status from federally funded housing. The upheaval is expected to hit California, with its large immigrant population, harder than any other state.

    “This is a very big deal,” said Sanford Riggs, director of operations for the Santa Barbara County Housing Authority. “This is a huge change.”

    The agencies that administer housing vouchers are trying to make emergency plans for their mixed-status families, attempting to move them from federally funded programs into ones that are paid for with city, county, state or philanthropic dollars. But how successful that effort will be will vary greatly county by county, depending on what resources each has available.

    The Trump administration has framed this as a way to remove subsidies from undocumented immigrants and give them to homeless veterans and disabled or elderly citizens. “President Trump warned that the days of illegal aliens and ineligible noncitizens exploiting government-funded welfare programs would be over,” HUD Secretary Scott Turner said in a statement.

    But the change could hurt even U.S. citizens who don’t live in mixed-status households. That’s because in some counties, due to a technicality, the vouchers freed up when mixed-status families leave for any reason go away entirely rather than be reissued to other applicants.

    Other counties say they’ll be able to serve fewer people overall because mixed-status families pay more in rent and receive a lower subsidy than U.S. citizens. If HUD forces them out and replaces them with citizen households, there will be less funding to go around, and fewer families will get housed.

    How does HUD’s new rule change things?

    Federal housing funds have always been reserved only for U.S. citizens, or people with an eligible immigration status, such as a green card. But historically, mixed-status families could receive prorated aid – meaning a family of four with two members who are eligible citizens, and two members who are undocumented immigrants, would be paid the same rate as a family of two.

    Under the new rule, set to go into effect Dec. 14, those families would receive nothing. U.S. citizens living with undocumented family members would have to separate from those family members or lose their housing, too.

    An analysis of 2024 data by the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities found 7,190 mixed-status households receiving federal housing aid in California. The only other state that comes close is Texas, with 4,500.

    HUD proposed this rule change once before during President Donald Trump’s first term in 2019, but rolled it back after a public outcry. This time, lawsuits attempting to block the rule from taking effect have already started, including one from a group of Los Angeles-based families and tenant rights advocates.

    The Santa Clara County Housing Authority has 157 mixed-status households in its program, including 290 children, who will be affected by the new rule. In many cases, the children are the only members of a family who are eligible for federal aid – so there’s no option for the family to separate in order for eligible members to remain housed, said Angie Garcia-Nguyen, deputy executive director of the county’s housing authority.

    The county saw this change coming, and prepared for the cutoff. The community has a contingency plan to help families at risk of being displaced, Garcia-Nguyen said. She wouldn’t disclose how much money has been raised, or where the funds came from, to avoid putting a “target on anyone’s back.” But, she said, whatever nonfederal aid they can provide is only temporary, meaning those families still need a long-term plan.

    “I think families are going to have to make some pretty tough choices,” Garcia-Nguyen said. “Santa Clara County is not the most affordable place to live without a subsidy. Some households will need to make decisions about whether or not they’re going to stay.”

    After the rule takes effect, it could be more than a year before people are evicted. Housing authorities have the option to grant deferrals for up to 18 months.

    Seniors asked to verify immigration status

    In Santa Clara County, the ripple effect of the new rule could extend beyond even the 157 mixed-status families.

    HUD also will require some people who were previously exempt to submit documentation that proves their citizenship or immigration status. The housing authority is assisting 12,000 seniors and almost 9,000 children who have not verified their immigration status. Now, those people will be required to do so or lose their housing subsidies. It’s not clear how many of them will be able to, Garcia-Nguyen said.

    In Santa Barbara County, Riggs said he’s not aware of any city, county or state funds that can help the 131 mixed-status families who receive federal subsidies through his agency.

    “It’s quite possible that some could end up homeless,” he said. “There’s no question about it.”

    Many of the vouchers freed up when mixed-status families move out won’t be re-issued to U.S. citizens, or anyone at all, Riggs said. The cost of housing in Santa Barbara County, for example, is so expensive that HUD provides extra funding, on top of the regular housing vouchers, to cover people’s cost of rent. But there’s a catch. In exchange, once someone gives up a voucher (whether they die, are evicted or something else) HUD doesn’t let the housing authority re-issue it to someone else.

    The Housing Authority of the City of Los Angeles serves 1,709 mixed-status families who would be affected by the new rule. Those families pay more out of pocket and receive smaller subsidies than households where every member has an eligible immigration status.

    The housing authority said that removing all mixed-status families from the program would force it to cut at least 800 Section 8 housing vouchers in order to cover the increased costs – meaning 800 fewer families would benefit.

  • No audit, says city council
    Inglewood City Councilmember Gloria Gray’s proposal to audit the city’s multimillion dollar deals with billboard company WOW Media died without a vote on Tuesday afternoon after all four of her colleagues on the City Council refused to support it.

    Topline:

    Inglewood City Councilmember Gloria Gray’s proposal to audit the city’s multimillion dollar deals with billboard company WOW Media died without a vote on Tuesday afternoon after all four of her colleagues on the City Council refused to support it.

    Why now: Gray first floated the audit back in October while the City Council was launching a separate audit of the city’s financial relationship with SoFi Stadium. She said she fielded questions from multiple residents concerning whether the city is getting everything it’s owed from WOW.

    The backstory: Inglewood’s city budget relies on as much as $8 million a year from its billboard deals, city staff estimate. If an audit found WOW owed more than that, the extra money could boost the fund that pays for basic city services from police to parks.

    The post Gloria Gray’s effort to audit Inglewood’s billboard revenue dies in City Council appeared first on LA Local.

    Inglewood City Councilmember Gloria Gray’s proposal to audit the city’s multimillion dollar deals with billboard company WOW Media died without a vote on Tuesday afternoon after all four of her colleagues on the City Council refused to support it.

    Gray first floated the audit back in October while the City Council was launching a separate audit of the city’s financial relationship with SoFi Stadium. She said she fielded questions from multiple residents concerning whether the city is getting everything it’s owed from WOW.

    “I do think it’s absolutely necessary for transparency,” she said. “The public needs to know.” 

    Inglewood’s city budget relies on as much as $8 million a year from its billboard deals, city staff estimate. If an audit found WOW owed more than that, the extra money could boost the fund that pays for basic city services from police to parks.

    WOW’s billboards have split opinion in Inglewood despite the revenue they bring. Some locals call them an eyesore, while a financial conflict between the city and its stadiums has dragged the WOW deals into the spotlight. 

    Gray’s proposal called for an independent reviewer to dig into how much WOW has pulled in over recent years and whether it has paid the city everything it contractually owes. The audit could have cost up to $150,000, according to a report prepared by Gray.

    The billboard audit got a flicker of support from Councilmember Eloy Morales in October, but Gray said she couldn’t say why he and others didn’t back the audit on Tuesday. The LA Local has reached out to Morales.

    The lone comment on Gray’s proposal during Tuesday’s meeting came from Butts, who confirmed with city staff that an audit procedure is built into WOW’s deals with the city. 

    The terms of those deals could limit how deep any auditor could go. Two WOW contracts reviewed by The LA Local allow the city 30 days after WOW submits its annual revenue report to request an audit. Butts did not respond to an inquiry to determine if the city has ever requested such an audit.

    Gray voted along with the rest of the City Council in April 2025 to approve one of those contracts, saying at the time that it would provide a needed revenue stream. She told The LA Local on Friday that a 30-day review window is bad policy and that she isn’t giving up on a billboard audit in the future. 

    Gray’s failed motion is a rarity for a city council that typically votes in lockstep and came against the backdrop of a bruising mayoral election. The council member is challenging Butts for his seat and, with just over a week until county election officials certify results, looks set to take him to a runoff in March. 

    The election also sucked in Inglewood’s big business interests. Hollywood Park, the development that houses SoFi Stadium, set its financial muscle against Butts’ bid for reelection and in support of Gray’s challenge. Butts, for his own part, has received a chunk of his campaign funds from billboard companies and developers. Both candidates have said they aren’t influenced by who supports their campaign. 

    The billboards were the subject of this fall’s ballot Measure BB, which would have restricted commercial ads along city roads and sidewalks. Voters appear to be rejecting the measure, as of Tuesday’s ballot count.

    Inglewood officials and their stadium counterparts have been brawling since last summer over billboards, stadium taxes and infrastructure payments. 

    A judge voided Inglewood’s contract with SoFi Stadium earlier this year — siding with the city’s argument that it wasn’t legally valid — and stadium and billboard companies clashed this fall over ballot measure attempts to change city rules around advertising rules and ticket taxes. 

  • Mexican Latin Grammy winner to join LA Phil
    A young woman with medium skinned and long dark hair sings into a microphone while playing a small guitar, one foot resting on a stool, in an empty theater.
    Silvana Estrada, the Grammy-winning musician who has been named the Creative Chair of Latin Music at the LA Phil.

    Topline:

    Months after departure of legendary music director Gustavo Dudamel, LA Phil taps Grammy winning Mexican musician Silvana Estrada to new post as Creative Chair for Latin Music.

    Why it matters: Silvana Estrada’s been recognized for her musicianship and songwriting as she’s performed across the U.S. and Latin America, including key performances with the LA Phil. She won a Latin Grammy for Best New Artist in 2022 and another Latin Grammy this month for Best Singer Songwriter Song.

    Why now: For 17 years, Venezuela-born Dudamel built collaborations with Mexican and Latin American composers and performers for the LA Phil stages His departure in August left a gap.

    The backstory: Estrada was born and raised in the state of Veracruz, Mexico with a long music tradition that blends indigenous, African, and European sounds, not unlike that of New Orleans.

    What's next: Estrada is set to program three performances in the 2027-2028 season, she said, choosing from among the LA Phil’s three venues – Disney Hall, the Hollywood Bowl, and the Ford Amphitheater and one of the shows will include her in performance.

    Read on… to hear what some music educators in L.A. are saying about Estrada’s appointment.

    There was a moment of uncertainty after the host at this year’s Latin Grammys read Silvana Estrada’s name as the winner of the award for Best Singer-Songwriter Song.

    The TV camera couldn’t find her. Then, from the rear of the hall, running out of the darkness, wavy hair tossing from side to side, Estrada appeared.

    “I was like, ’Oh my God, what is this? This is a dream,’” Estrada told LAist.

    Female presenting woman with long, wavy hair holds a microphone on a stage. Half a dozen musicians play instruments behind her.
    Silvana Estrada performs at the Ford Amphitheater in L.A. with members of Youth Orchestra Los Angeles.
    (
    Courtesy LA Phil
    )

    “My team and I, we've been working so, so, so hard this year and for the last 10 years we've been really … building this beautiful project,” she said.

    That beautiful project is centered around her melodic voice, solid musicianship and poetic songwriting that explores the shades of love and loss.

    About a week before the Latin Grammys, she'd also been recognized by the Los Angeles Philharmonic, which appointed her to a post it had just created creative chair for Latin music.

    “It's such a dream. … I feel just absolutely honored, and I want to do my best. Every day I'm writing in my notes all sorts of ideas, who I want to bring, how I want to do it,” she said.

    Sanctuary for Latin culture

    The appointment of the Mexico-based singer-songwriter comes on the heels of years of creative work in the U.S. She first gained public attention in 2022, when she won Best New Artist at the Latin Grammys for her album Marchita. That was followed by several high-profile appearances, including NPR’s Tiny Desk and Jimmy Kimmel Live! with members of the LA Phil.

    A woman with medium skin and long brown hair wears a tan colored dress. She sings into a microphone in front of an orchestra.
    Silvana Estrada performing at Disney Hall
    (
    Courtesy LA Phil
    )

    Her new role stands to establish Estrada as a cultural tastemaker in Southern California as she programs several concerts next year. It's a door opened after LA Phil music director Gustavo Dudamel, who was born and raised in Venezuela, invited her to perform in L.A. over the years. Dudamel left the LA Phil in August to become music director of the New York Philharmonic.

    “The LA Phil is that sort of sanctuary for the Latino culture and many, many communities who find a … space to be seen,” Estrada said.

    "This is big"

    The appointment of a Mexican singer-songwriter by such an established L.A. cultural institution is not going unnoticed.

    “It's great to see that an organization like LA Phil is thinking outside the box,” said Pilar Diaz, a longtime music educator in L.A. schools and the lead singer of the L.A. rock band Los Abandoned.

    It's great to see that an organization like LA Phil is thinking outside the box.
    — Pilar Diaz, L.A. music educator

    Diaz, who was born in Chile but grew up in the San Fernando Valley, credits Dudamel’s 17-year tenure with opening the doors to make Estrada’s appointment happen.

    “This feels like … for me as an Angeleno and as a Chilena woman and a musician … this is big,” she said.

    Selecting Estrada, she said, feels like what happens in Chile, where cultural organizations are more inclined to tap artists to curate and program events.

    Estrada was born and raised in Veracruz, Mexico. The state capital, a port city with a long musical tradition that blends Indigenous, African and European sounds, is not unlike that of New Orleans. Some people with ties to both Mexico and Veracruz hail the appointment.

    “We feel pride, we feel proud of Latinos in general … so now imagine being Mexican, and then being from Veracruz,” said Cesar Castro, who’s from Veracruz and teaches son jarocho, a regional style, at UCLA and Occidental College.

    He admires Estrada, he said, for being firmly rooted in her home region and country, but he’s expecting the shows she programs to look beyond.

    “I don't appreciate the Mexican centrism that some people have. So it would be a good chance to have that platform to represent other regions of the continent of Latino culture,” he said, like music from Central America and Peru.

    Next season's performances

    Estrada is set to program three performances in the 2027-2028 season, she said, choosing from among the LA Phil’s three venues — Disney Hall, the Hollywood Bowl and the Ford Amphitheater. One of the shows will include her in performance. For now, she’s not naming specific performers she plans to invite. Whoever it is, she said, she wants Southern California audiences to see the richness of what Latin American performing arts have to offer, the United States included.

    “It's very important to especially embrace the richness of our culture and the dialogue between our culture with other cultures and also between our countries,” she said.

    It's very important to especially embrace the dialogue between our culture with other cultures and also between our countries.
    — Silvana Estrada

    Estrada has performed throughout the U.S. and Latin America in recent years. Her 2025 album, Vendrán Suaves Lluvias (Soft Rains Will Come) is centered around the death and feeling of loss of her best friend four years ago.

    “A broken heart can heal, but to heal we have to be alive … let’s live life and rejoice,” she told the audience at the Latin Grammy ceremony earlier this month.