Judge orders city to pay $1 million over censoring
Jill Replogle
covers public corruption, debates over our voting system, culture war battles — and more.
Published April 28, 2026 12:04 PM
Librarians at the Huntington Beach Central Library review books in the children's section on Feb. 7, 2024.
(
Jill Replogle
/
LAist
)
Topline:
Huntington Beach suffered another courtroom loss in its culture war battles this week when a judge ordered the city to pay $1 million in legal fees for restricting minors’ access to library books.
The backstory: The City Council passed a resolution in 2023 restricting minors from accessing books deemed to contain sexual content in the public libraries. Critics said the policy amounted to illegal censorship, and that it was actually an excuse to restrict books with LGBTQ characters and themes. In September 2025, Orange County Judge Lindsey Martinez found the policy violated California’s newly passed Freedom to Read Act. The city has appealed.
Huntington Beach ballot initiative: The city had also established a citizen review board with the power to censor children’s books at the library. Voters repealed that review board in a special city election in June 2025.
Read on... for more details on the judges order to Huntington Beach.
Huntington Beach suffered another courtroom loss in its culture war battles this week when a judge ordered the city to pay $1 million in legal fees for restricting minors’ access to library books.
The City Council passed a resolution in 2023 prohibiting children from accessing books deemed to contain sexual content in the city's public libraries. Critics said the policy amounted to illegal censorship, and that it was actually an excuse to restrict books with LGBTQ characters and themes.
The city had also established a citizen review board with the power to censor children’s books at the library. Voters repealed that review board in a special city election in June 2025.
Since the start of last year, the city has lost court battles over state housing mandates, voter ID requirements and California’s immigrant sanctuary law, racking up millions in legal fees.
“The City Council continues to burn through taxpayer dollars to pursue their own personal grievances,” said Erin Spivey, the named plaintiff in the library lawsuit who is now running for City Council.
The city has received some pro bono legal counsel from the conservative law firm America First Legal, co-founded by Trump advisor Stephen Miller, including a recent appeal over the sanctuary law.
The city has appealed Martinez’s decision and, in the meantime, has not taken many of the steps required in the judge’s order, according to library advocates. Those include returning a handful of censored books on puberty and the human body to the children’s section, and restoring the central library’s once-popular teen section.
In a statement to LAist, Mike Vigliotta, the city attorney, said officials were “evaluating next steps.” He also noted that the judge’s award of $1 million was reduced from the $1.5 million initially requested by plaintiffs.
Kavish Harjai
writes about how people get around L.A.
Published August 12, 2026 9:53 AM
L.A. Mayor Karen Bass has long stated her interest in a fare-free Metro. As she runs for reelection and begins her second tenure as chair of the agency's board, she said she wants to develop a long-term plan to make that a reality.
(
Patrick T. Fallon
/
AFP via Getty Images
)
Topline:
Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass surprised some transit advocates during a speech at Union Station last month when she proclaimed she wants a "long-term financial strategy and plan" to make public transit on L.A. Metro free for everyone.
Light on details: How Bass plans to achieve this and what exactly the timeline is remains unclear. In a follow up statement, the mayor’s office told LAist that Bass “plans to introduce a motion to explore what further steps are needed to go fare-free.”
Read on … to learn what Metro executives have said on free transit in the past and how rider advocacy groups feel about a fareless system.
Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass surprised some transit advocates during a speech at Union Station last month when she proclaimed she wants to develop a "long-term financial strategy and plan" to make public transit on L.A. Metro free for everyone.
The announcement was met with hesitant applause.
In a follow-up statement, the mayor’s office told LAist, “Going fare-free is important to reducing the financial burden on working Angelenos and making Los Angeles a more accessible, affordable city.”
The mayor’s office said Bass plans to introduce a motion to explore what further steps are needed to eliminate Metro fares. Her office did not provide answers to follow-up questions asking whether that motion would go before the Metro Board before or after the election in November, when Bass is running for reelection.
Bass’ announcement comes just a few years after Metro executives said free transit would cost more than $1 billion annually for the region. At the same time, the agency, which is facing mounting political pressure to strengthen fare enforcement, is pouring tens of millions of dollars into taller fare gates that are designed to make it harder for riders to skip out on paying.
Bass’ history on a fare-free Metro
Bass’ July speech, which she made to outline her priorities for her second tenure as Metro Board chair, isn’t the first time the mayor has signaled support for a fare-free transportation system.
When she campaigned for mayor in 2022, Bass told StreetsblogLA that she believes fareless transit “will give people the freedom of mobility with no barriers to entry.” She reiterated that she supports a move to a fareless Metro in a 2023 interview with the L.A. Times.
Mariana Luna leads the fareless transit campaign for Strategic Actions for a Just Economy, or SAJE, which has long advocated for a fare-free Metro. Luna said Bass’ speech in July reaffirming support for fareless transit was unexpected, but exciting nonetheless.
“We would really love to see some sort of action and not just leave it as a promise during her campaign season,” Luna said.
On the other side is the rider advocacy group Enforce the Fares. Alex Davis, a Metro rider and member of the group, said going fare-free is the opposite direction the agency should be heading.
“It will distract and even set Metro back from tackling the stuff that will actually improve the lives of transit riders,” Davis said, adding that ensuring fares are collected can lead to improved service reliability and system safety.
Bass’ opponent in this year’s mayoral race, former ally and current L.A. City Councilmember Nithya Raman, does not include fareless transit as part of her publicly available transportation platform, which calls for Metro system expansion and service reliability improvements. Raman’s campaign did not respond to requests for comment about her thoughts on fareless transit.
Metro says fareless transit would cost region $1 billion
Though not a novel concept, support for free transit in L.A. County gained momentum during the pandemic, said Brian Taylor, a research professor of urban planning and public policy at UCLA.
“There was concern with contact between operators and passengers,” Taylor said. “So there was a public health aspect to it that led not to go fare-free, but actually to stop enforcing fare payment. That sort of revived the fare-free movement.”
Days after stay-at-home orders began in March 2020, Metro temporarily suspended bus fare collection and permitted rear-door entry to minimize contact between drivers and passengers.
In response to the financial challenges imposed by the pandemic, former Metro CEO Phil Washington assembled a task force that studied the possibility of a universally fareless transportation system.
A few months later, the idea didn’t seem so possible.
According to a September 2021 staff report, a fully fareless rail and bus network was estimated at the time to cost $1.1 billion annually for Metro and local transportation agencies that rely on the same TAP payment system.
Revenue from fares has decreased since the report was published. Last fiscal year, Metro brought in $175 million in fares, and the agency is projecting $25 million less in fare revenue this fiscal year. That’s compared to the $250 million Metro was, on average, collecting annually in pre-pandemic years, which the agency used to come up with its 2021 estimate.
The 2021 Metro report also detailed that a fareless system would require changes to how the state allocates transit funding, since state funding is dependent on local fare revenue.
In 2024, the Metro executive who oversaw the push toward fareless transit said the agency’s analysis was verified by an outside auditor.
It also resulted in making it easier for people to enroll in Metro’s assistance program for low-income riders, which offers 90 days of free rides after sign-up followed by 20 free rides per month.
Metro riders load their tap cards at Union Station in Los Angeles.
(
Samanta Helou Hernandez
/
LAist
)
Metro invests in stopping fare evasion
As Bass is pushing for a free system, Metro officials have been moving in the opposite direction by making it physically more difficult to catch a free train ride.
In response to customer feedback about improving fare compliance, Metro began installing taller faregates in 2025. The 7-foot-tall plexiglass, paddle-door gates are designed to be more difficult to jump over or duck under and are equipped with motion sensors. So far, they’ve been installed in 26 rail stations across the Metro system.
Metro spent more than $14.7 million installing the faregates in the last fiscal year and has budgeted $15.5 million to continue installing additional faregates throughout the system.
The faregates were highlighted several times during Metro’s State of the Agency event in July, where the mayor announced her fare-free initiative.
Before Bass spoke, L.A. County Supervisor Kathryn Barger said the gates support a safer system.
“Our new faregates have significantly increased paid ridership while reducing reported issues,” said Barger, who is also first vice chair of the Metro Board. “There is a correlation.”
In a written follow-up statement to LAist, Barger said that any potential changes to Metro’s fare policy need to be weighed against the “important reality” that “fare enforcement and access control measures are associated with reductions in crime across the Metro system.”
According to Taylor, the UCLA professor, there’s a good economic case to be made for transit systems to go fareless when a large share of its riders are low-income and when the percentage of operating costs covered by fares falls below roughly 10%.
Both conditions are there for L.A. Metro, he said.
Luna, the assistant director of organizing and advocacy for SAJE’s fareless transit campaign, said she hopes Bass will push to offer a pilot program that would make transit free for those who already qualify for the agency’s low-income assistance.
How to reach me
If you have a tip, you can reach me on Signal. My username is kharjai.61.
You can follow this link to reach me there or type my username in the search bar after starting a new chat.
And if you're comfortable just reaching out by email I'm at kharjai@scpr.org
Making Metro free will negatively impact customer experience, group says
Last year, the rider advocacy group Enforce the Fares launched a campaign to push Metro to restore the number of fare checks transit security officers perform on trains and buses, saying that the physical fare infrastructure investments cannot scale to all parts of the system.
Fare enforcement is tied directly to safety, the group says. Following a surge in violent crime on the system in 2024, Metro reported to its board that 96% of those apprehended for committing a violent crime on the system between April 2023 and March 2024 did not pay fares.
According to the group’s accounting of Metro data, the agency's contracted law enforcement and security officers verified riders paid their fares hundreds of thousands of times per month between 2014 and 2018. That number plummeted to an average of 5,000 verifications per month in 2025.
There’s also been a drop in the amount of fares that pay for the day-to-day operations of the system. In fiscal year 2016, Metro could reinvest the fares it collected to pay for 22% of its operational expenses. In the latest fiscal year, that figure dropped to 6%, according to agency financial reports.
In a report to its board, Metro staff attributed this drop to the “expanding rail system and the declining fare revenues.”
Scott, with Metro’s Department of Public Safety, said Metro’s security officers conducted 20,000 fare checks in July and that “it’s trending that way in August.”
In a statement, Bass’ office said she does not support transit security officers performing fare checks and wants them focused on ensuring public safety.
Students and families arrive at Eastman Avenue Elementary School in East L.A. on Wednesday, Aug. 12, 2026.
(
Jacqueline Ramirez
/
Boyle Heights Beat
)
Topline:
It’s the first day of school across the Los Angeles Unified School District, and students on the Eastside are returning to their classrooms after an unusual summer break dealing with the aftermath of the Lineage cold storage warehouse fire in June.
More details: LAUSD has assured that campuses near the site have been thoroughly cleaned and deemed safe for students to return. With schools now open, the cleanup at the warehouse continues as Lineage rushes to meet L.A. Mayor Karen Bass’ Friday deadline to remove the rotted food waste from inside.
Parents' and teachers' worries linger: For weeks, parents and teachers across the Eastside have been calling on LAUSD to have stronger protections for students and to be more transparent about environmental testing results. The groups, including Eastside Padres and United Teachers Los Angeles, have also called on Lineage to leave the community permanently.
Read on... for more on how Eastside students are returning to their classrooms.
It’s the first day of school across the Los Angeles Unified School District, and students on the Eastside are returning to their classrooms after an unusual summer break dealing with the aftermath of the Lineage cold storage warehouse fire in June.
Summer school sites were relocated, baseball games were canceled, and instead of spending time outside, some children spent the past two months behind closed doors to avoid the unhealthy air, mounting stench of rotting food, and hordes of flies and rats in their community.
“[This summer] was horrible, like living through another pandemic,” said Lizandra Jimenez, who lives in East L.A. two blocks from the Lineage warehouse with her 11- and 14-year-old sons. “It was hell where we were isolated from information, where we had to endure a smell, where we had to endure the heat.
"My sons were anxious because they wanted to go outside but we couldn’t, and there was no information about air quality,” she said.
Students and families arrive at Eastman Avenue Elementary School in East L.A. on Wednesday, Aug. 12, 2026.
(
Jacqueline Ramirez
/
Boyle Heights Beat
)
That worry about air quality lingers for Jimenez, whose children attend Griffith STEAM Magnet Middle School and Roosevelt High School less than 3 miles away from Lineage. She said she also worries about the safety of the students who attend Eastman Avenue Elementary, the LAUSD school closest to the warehouse, where she works as a school supervision aide.
LAUSD has assured that campuses near the site have been thoroughly cleaned and deemed safe for students to return. With schools now open, the cleanup at the warehouse continues as Lineage rushes to meet L.A. Mayor Karen Bass’ Friday deadline to remove the rotted food waste from inside.
LAUSD says campuses are safe to return
Over the past few weeks, LAUSD has provided updates and hosted webinars to inform parents on the cleaning and environmental testing efforts it conducted for the more than 50 schools within a 3-mile radius of the Lineage warehouse.
Those efforts included:
Deep-cleaning school campuses including floors, walls, furniture, drinking fountains, lunch pavilions, playgrounds and walkways.
Replacing all MERV-13 HVAC filters and placing air purifiers in all classrooms and offices, and;
Independently testing air quality, water, dust and soil samples.
A white van with South Coast AQMD branding sits on the playground at Eastman Elementary in East Los Angeles.
(
Steve Saldivar
/
The LA Local
)
The district said air monitoring will continue at Eastman Elementary School and Stevenson Middle School for the duration of the cleanup.
A 561-page environmental assessment report released Tuesday by the LAUSD Office of Environmental Safety concluded that the Lineage fire did not result in widespread contamination at nearby schools and thus, were safe for students and staff.
The report did, however, find lead levels in the soil at City Terrace Elementary School and Christopher Dena Elementary School that exceeded California’s acceptable threshold. The district said it does not believe the findings are tied to the warehouse fire.
As students return to campus, LAUSD said there will be masks available for students and staff upon request, school principals will decide whether students should remain indoors based on odors and outdoor conditions, and psychiatric social workers will be available on-site to support students.
Lineage says cleanup is 90% complete
Meanwhile, Lineage said it is on track to meet the mayor’s 45-day deadline to remove all the food waste from the site by Friday. As of Monday, the company said they had removed 90% of the food waste.
“At ninety percent, we are in the final stretch, and we will continue to tirelessly work until the work is done,” Jeff Rivera, chief operating officer of Lineage, said in a statement.
The company said it expects to spend $80 million to $100 million on the cleanup.
Last week, the South Coast Air Quality Management District’s Hearing Board unanimously approved an abatement order requiring Lineage to strengthen odor-control measures, expand air monitoring and improve communication with residents.
Parents’ and teachers’ worries linger
For weeks, parents and teachers across the Eastside have been calling on LAUSD to have stronger protections for students and to be more transparent about environmental testing results. The groups, including Eastside Padres and United Teachers Los Angeles, have also called on Lineage to leave the community permanently.
Alma Lagunas speaks on a megaphone along with members of Eastside Padres at a town hall regarding the fire at the Lineage warehouse at Stevenson College and Career Preparatory in Boyle Heights in Los Angeles, Calif. on July 9, 2026.
(
Isaac Ceja
/
Boyle Heights Beat
)
On Aug. 6, UTLA, the union representing LAUSD teachers, sent a letter to the district demanding that it expand resources and share the data before the first day. (LAUSD ended up posting its report on testing efforts on Tuesday.)
Following the fire, Jimenez said her family endured headaches, sore throats, congestion and irritated eyes for days. Now, she said she hopes LAUSD has taken the necessary steps to ensure that doesn’t happen again.
“Who’s going to solve this for us? Or why?” Jimenez asked. “We’re not to blame.”
Need extra support?
LAUSD has two main hotlines available for students and families.
Parent Hotline: (213) 443-1300
The hotline is open weekdays from 7:30 a.m. to 5 p.m., excluding holidays.
Student & Family Wellness Resource Line: (213) 241-3840
The wellness line is open weekdays from 8 a.m. to 4:30 p.m., excluding holidays.
Keep up with LAist.
If you're enjoying this article, you'll love our daily newsletter, The LA Report. Each weekday, catch up on the 5 most pressing stories to start your morning in 3 minutes or less.
Aaron Schrank
has been on the ground, reporting on homelessness and other issues in L.A. for more than a decade.
Published August 12, 2026 9:00 AM
Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. and Housing and Urban Development Secretary Scott Turner held a news conference at the Dream Center amid tensions with local officials.
(
Aaron Schrank
/
LAist
)
Topline:
Two of the Trump Administration’s top cabinet officials visited a faith-based homelessness program in Los Angeles Tuesday to call for a shift in the region’s approach to the unhoused crisis. Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. and Housing and Urban Development Secretary Scott Turner held a news conference at the Dream Center amid tensions with local officials.
Why now: The L.A. region’s lead homelessness agency, known as LAHSA, is currently suing the federal housing department after HUD suspended it from federal grant activity in June.
The backstory: The Trump Administration suspended the Los Angeles Homeless Services Authority for alleged mismanagement in June, pending a federal investigation. That effectively cut off the agency that administers federal homelessness dollars from performing many of its roles. For example, HUD says that suspension means LAHSA cannot apply for up to $240 million in funding in a grant competition this year.
Read on... for more on the Trump Administration's visit to L.A.
Two of the Trump Administration’s top cabinet officials visited a faith-based homelessness program in Los Angeles Tuesday to call for a shift in the region’s approach to the unhoused crisis.
Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. and Housing and Urban Development Secretary Scott Turner held a news conference at the Dream Center amid tensions with local officials.
The L.A. region’s lead homelessness agency, known as LAHSA, is currently suing the federal housing department after HUD suspended it from federal grant activity in June.
Turner said Tuesday the federal government wasn’t backing down on that.
“LAHSA does not receive another dollar until there’s accountability and transparency, and the right partners have come around for us to work with,” Turner said.
HUD has formally invited homeless service providers to apply directly for the federal homelessness funding, bypassing LAHSA entirely.
The federal government is pushing to partner more with faith-based homeless service providers like the Dream Center, which have not historically relied on much funding from the federal government, or from the state, county or city.
Turner and Kennedy toured the Echo Park facility, a 14-story converted hospital building, and spoke with several residents in transitional housing or recovery, LAist observed.
“I saw the success upstairs with their clients,” Kennedy said Tuesday. “They're doing it better than us, and we need to start recognizing it.”
Kennedy and Turner presented the suspension of LAHSA as part of the Trump Administration’s broader push against fraud in public benefits spending, mostly involving Medicare.
Funding battle
The Trump Administration suspended the Los Angeles Homeless Services Authority for alleged mismanagement in June, pending a federal investigation.
That effectively cut off the agency that administers federal homelessness dollars from performing many of its roles. For example, HUD says that suspension means LAHSA cannot apply for up to $240 million in funding in a grant competition this year.
LAHSA is suing to overturn the suspension and to pause it in the meantime to prevent funding losses the agency said could cause 11,000 people to lose publicly-funded housing.
In a court hearing last Thursday, U.S. District Judge David O. Carter acknowledged legitimate concerns about LAHSA’s history of dysfunction and said he wanted to avoid catastrophic funding disruptions.
LAHSA says letting providers apply directly to HUD, without relying on LAHSA or some other agency to coordinate and prioritize the funding request would be unfair and disastrous.
Carter has not issued an injunction order, as of Tuesday evening.
HUD Secretary Scott Turner at the Dream Center Tuesday
(
Aaron Schrank
/
LAist
)
Why the Dream Center?
Dream Center in Echo Park is a large Pentecostal Christian nonprofit that does residential recovery and housing for families. The center, associated with the Assemblies of God denomination, has been operating for more than three decades.
Pastor Matthew Barnett is the co-founder and CEO. He said in the news conference that the facility in Echo Park provides recovery treatment and transitional housing to about 600 people.
“I feel that sadly, over the last few years, there's just been a prevailing overall theme in LA that people can't change,” Barnett said. “Let’s just get them out of sight. Let's put them in housing somewhere, but can they really change? Well, 70% of the people that live at the Dream Center are graduates of the recovery program,” Barnett claimed.
Unlike many local service providers, the Dream Center does not rely on taxpayer funding to serve unhoused Angelenos, but private donations.
“ Places like the Dream Center that have not asked for money, that have just done the work, it's made it very, very difficult for us to function in this city of expenses that are rising,” Barnett said.
Local officials respond
There were no local elected officials present at the event.
L.A. County voted last year to divert $300 million in county homelessness funds away from the city-county homelessness agency LAHSA and administer those dollars itself with a new county homelessness department.
After Tuesday’s news conference, L.A. County Supervisor Lindsey Horvath said the county government has been working to fix the problem, while the federal government has not.
“Publicity stunts are no substitute for the hard work the County has already done to move away from the broken LAHSA system, establish new and accountable oversight of taxpayer dollars and change how we measure success from dollars spent to outcomes achieved,” Horvath said, in a statement.
A view of Los Angeles Lakers themed T-shirts prior to Game Four against the Oklahoma City Thunder in the Second Round of the NBA Western Conference Playoffs at Crypto.com Arena on May 11, 2026 in Los Angeles.
(
Luke Hales
/
Getty Images
)
Topline:
The Los Angeles Lakers are being sold to businessmen Josh Kushner and Bob Iger for a record-breaking price, the second such sale in a year.
Record setting price tag: ESPN first reported that Kushner and Iger are buying the NBA’s most valuable franchise, which was valued last year at $10 billion when Mark Walter purchased a controlling stake from the Buss family. The $12.5 billion price tag is not only record-setting for U.S. pro sports but it continues a trend of NBA franchise values skyrocketing. Only three years ago, Michael Jordan sold his majority stake in the Charlotte Hornets for a $3 billion valuation, and the Boston Celtics were sold last year at a valuation of just over $6 billion, then a record.
What's next: The sale still will need approval from the NBA’s board of governors, and that process can take several weeks. The next board meeting is set for next month in New York.
LOS ANGELES (AP) — The Los Angeles Lakers are being sold to businessmen Josh Kushner and Bob Iger for a record-breaking price, the second such sale in a year.
This sale agreement is $12.5 billion, according to a person familiar with the terms who spoke to The Associated Press on condition of anonymity Wednesday because neither side revealed specific details.
ESPN first reported that Kushner and Iger are buying the NBA’s most valuable franchise, which was valued last year at $10 billion when Mark Walter purchased a controlling stake from the Buss family. The two businessmen had been involved in trying to get an expansion team for Las Vegas.
By buying the Lakers, Iger and Kushner simply don’t have to wait for that decision. Expansion, if it happens, could take place in the 2028-29 season.
The sale still will need approval from the NBA’s board of governors, and that process can take several weeks. The next board meeting is set for next month in New York.
The $12.5 billion price tag is not only record-setting for U.S. pro sports but it continues a trend of NBA franchise values skyrocketing. Only three years ago, Michael Jordan sold his majority stake in the Charlotte Hornets for a $3 billion valuation, and the Boston Celtics were sold last year at a valuation of just over $6 billion, then a record.
Walter’s purchase of a controlling stake in the Lakers in June 2025 blew that away, and now Iger and Kushner have pushed the bar even higher.
Walter’s purchase was approved by NBA owners last October. He originally bought a 27% minority stake in the Lakers in 2021 before the 2025 sale. That was part of a franchise valuation of $10 billion — the highest ever set for a pro sports team.
The Lakers have won 17 championships going back to the franchise’s early years in Minneapolis, the second-most in NBA history behind Boston’s 18. It is a global brand, always at or near the top of the league’s merchandise-sales rankings.
This record sale price comes just weeks after LeBron James, the league’s all-time leading scorer, left the Lakers after eight seasons to become a free agent. James ultimately decided to sign with the Philadelphia 76ers.
AP Basketball Writer Tim Reynolds contributed to this report.