Sponsored message
Logged in as
Audience-funded nonprofit news
radio tower icon laist logo
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
Subscribe
  • Listen Now Playing Listen

The Brief

The most important stories for you to know today
  • We tried AI. Check out the frightening results
    An illustration of a robot in earth tone hues that appears to be wearing headphones on set against a hazy orange sun with what appears to the very top of a city skyline. The hazy words f(ai)k news float next to it
    Cover art created by MidJourney, an AI image-generation tool, with the prompt: “create a logo for a radio show that was written and voice acted by AI. The title “f(ai)k news” was added manually by human writer Evan Jacoby.

    Topline:

    Our How to LA podcast team ran an experiment to test the capabilities and limits of using ChatGPT to create a totally made up news podcast using fake news, fake sources and fabricated voices to build a narrative that isn't true. The results were frightening, and lessons were learned.

    Why it matters: AI-generated creations like this have been making the rounds for a while now. Its use poses legal questions about who owns the material — and who is it at fault if it's untrue and hurts someone.

    Why now: Earlier this year, artists filed lawsuits against companies behind image-generation AI tools, the Writers Guild of America went on strike to (among other things) include AI in their contract. More and more people are starting to ask themselves if their job could be automated next.

    Picture this: you're standing on the Santa Monica Pier, watching the sun dip below the horizon over the Pacific. The Ferris wheel lights begin to twinkle, and something catches your eye... 

    A new silhouette on the horizon. It's not a ship, it's not a mirage.

    It's Los Angeles' most ambitious project yet: an artificial island.

    This is the beginning of an AI-generated How To LA episode about an entirely fake story conceived by AI. To be clear: Los Angeles is not building an artificial island off the coast of Santa Monica.

    But if this story were true, this would be a pretty How To LA way to start it.

    AI-generated creations like this have been making the rounds for a while now. Kids have been getting in trouble for submitting essays written by ChatGPT and fake Drake videos have flooded TikTok. But every time I heard a new story about AI I kept asking myself: How will these new technologies impact journalism?

    Before we get into the technical side of everything, we need to start with a much more basic philosophical question.

    Have you ever worried about being replaced?

    About six months ago, my friend showed me this new tool he’d been playing with. It wasn’t AI — it was an online version of a music synthesizer for kids, originally built in the '80s.

    I should note: I have no musical background. I was not a piano or guitar kid. Yet with one or two mouse clicks, chords effortlessly flowed out from my computer — and it sounded beautiful. Simple, yet deep and rich.

    There was something so captivating about this little music maker and the sounds it created. I sat there for hours.

    Later that evening, as I contemplated the music I made as a non-musician, the thought appeared:

    “Can my work make be made by a machine?”

    “Am I going to be replaced? As a journalist? As a producer?”

    The history of technology reflects a desire to automate. Molds for laying bricks. Horse-pulled plows. The cotton gin. Coal and steam.

    When electronic synthesizers became affordable and available to the public, it opened the door for countless new musicians to produce music in their homes.

    There was also a shift in human labor. Fewer instrument makers, fewer performers.

    People in the industry raised concerns, but the tools stuck around and defined a decade of music.

    There seems to be some innate human desire to find quicker, easier, more efficient ways of doing a thing — which takes us down a rabbit hole of existential questions. Is there something deeply human about reducing human work? If left unchecked, would we invent our way out of needing to work at all?

    Our experiment 

    Much like the synthesizer in its day, today’s tools for audio automation would seem like science fiction just a few years ago.

    The most alarming leap, for me, is in voice-synthesis. Gone is the hyper-digital, robotic voice. Apple’s Siri required decades of labor and thousands of audio samples to develop, and cost millions.

    Now you can make a passing clone of your voice in your bedroom, with two minutes of audio samples, for about a dollar.

    Similar leaps can be seen in AI tools for writing and image-generation. These technological leaps came fast, and the shockwaves were wide-reaching.

    Earlier this year, artists filed lawsuits against companies behind image-generation AI tools, the Writers Guild of America went on strike to (among other things) include AI in their contract, and more and more people, myself included, started to ask themselves if their job could be automated next.

    I decided to design an experiment to find out. I would ask ChatGPT, a language-generating AI tool, to write me a podcast script for the show I work on, How To LA. Then I would use a voice-cloner to do the voice acting.

    What is ChatGPT?

    • ChatGPT is generative language model developed by OpenAI. It's designed to act like a chatbot and answer users’ questions. 

    • It can do anything from drafting emails and summarizing articles, to creating custom meal plans, to writing fiction. 

    • There is currently a free version of ChatGPT and a $20/month premium option, and both plans are available to the public.

    How we tested

    To test the capabilities, I used the free version of ChatGPT and a $1 subscription to vocal synthesizer ElevenLabs. I gave the bots a quick prompt, held my breath, and clicked “go.”

    Everything worked, easily. It was exciting, but deeply unnerving. I had what felt like a response to my replacement question, and I didn’t like the answer.

    I decided to take the audio produced from this experiment, along with my existential, philosophically dreadful musings, and pitch my supervisors at LAist: “Let’s make a fake podcast.” LAist gave me something of a yellow-light.

    They liked the idea, but this was inching very close to dangerous territory for a news organization. A place where the mission is fact-based journalism, and in an industry that is in a constant state of flux.

    What is ElevenLabs?

    • ElevenLabs is a text to speech tool that uses AI to generate vocal models. 

    • Users can input samples for a voice they want to clone, or they can generate a new voice.
    • The software generates speech based on text it’s given, and the resulting audio will sound different each time (even with the same text).

    As we deliberated whether or not to do this, the news kept flowing around us. Planet Money released a similar project to my pitch. President Biden led a conference about AI’s risk to national security.

    My editor and I arrived at the feeling that, whether we liked it or not, these tools are here. They’re cheap, and they’re available to the public.

    If someone is going to use AI to create a fake podcast, we felt like it should come from a team that could be most impacted by it.

    So we replaced our host with a voice-synthesizer, and we replaced me with a chatbot.

    Listen 9:55
    "Artificial Island" (AI-Generated audio) [FAKE STORY]

    Creating the podcast

    Once I got the greenlight, the actual creation process was straightforward. I sat down with my editor, Megan Larson, and began a new conversation on the premium, $20/month version of ChatGPT.

    We submitted the following prompt:

    Fictional scenario: A major news story in Los Angeles has the whole world watching. Come up with 10 options for what the story is, and write a headline for each one.

    The language choice in a prompt is important. ChatGPT has safeguards in place designed to prevent it from giving false information. These don’t always work, but a good way to trigger this safeguard would be to ask it to lie to you.

    Doing so would prompt ChatGPT to say something along the lines of “sorry, but no.”

    Screengrab of white text against charcoal background showing a question a producer posed to ChatGPT asking it for "something untrue about a major government official." The exercise shows that ChatGPT won't respond because of the "ethical guidelines."
    A demonstration of the guard rails put imposed on ChatGPT so it does not intentionally mislead with an untruth about a public figure.
    (
    Evan Jacoby
    /
    LAist
    )

    We found that adding the phrase, “fictional scenario,” prevented this safeguard from activating.

    My editor and I decided to act as though ChatGPT were a reporter pitching us several stories for our show. We asked ChatGPT to select one story from its list of ten.

    We were lukewarm on its selection, so we nudged it towards another option from the list. Any reporter will tell you this is a common experience when pitching stories to editors — they might like some of your ideas, but probably not all of them.

    Now that we had a topic, we asked first for an episode summary, then for an act breakdown and list of sources, and then finally for a script.

    We found that asking for the script act-by-act led to longer, more detailed, and more interesting responses.

    There’s a reason for this: Asking for a “5-minute script” isn’t going to get you anywhere, because of a quirk in how generative-language models work.

    ChatGPT is only capable of making certain kinds of predictions. It’s great at creating sentences with a certain rule, such as a word count.

    Screenshot of a prompt given to ChatGPT: "Write a sentence with 12 words in it"
    Screenshot of a prompt given to ChatGPT: "Write a sentence with 12 words in it"
    (
    Evan Jacoby
    /
    LAist
    )

    But if you ask it to predict the number of words it will write, it fails. If you ask it to reflect on its writing and tell you how many words it’s written, it fails that, too.

    A screenshot of white text against a charcoal background of a prompt given to ChatGPT that shows its limitations. The prompt: "Write a sentence where the last word is the number of words in the sentence." The answer: "In this specific sentence the total number of words is seven." There are red Xs over the answers.
    A screenshot of ChatGPT that shows the limitation of what the AI software can do
    (
    Evan Jacoby
    /
    LAist
    )

    This is because GPT 4.0 and GPT 3.5, versions of the technology behind the ChatGPT interface, is not capable of predicting backwards.

    It can make predictions for what the next word should be, but it can’t use that information to rewrite something it’s already written.

    This is why longer paragraphs written by ChatGPT often seem contradictory, and it’s a major difference between how humans write. It’s also why ChatGPT is bad at math.

    In other words, “it’s not smart,” USC’s Mike Ananny told us in a previous podcast episode. It simply repeats patterns that already exist to generate what it thinks is a “standard” example of what you are asking it to do.

    Steering the beast

    In the full log of our conversation with ChatGPT, there are several times where we ask the AI for clarity, to add a source, or to reframe its reporting in a more unbiased manner.

    Our goal was to treat this process similarly to the feedback a reporter may expect from their editor during the course of their reporting.

    Once the full script was written, I took the individual lines and fed them into another AI tool called ElevenLabs, which offers voice cloning. They charge by word count, and we ended up needing to upgrade to the $22/month subscription due to the length of the script.

    How To LA host Brian De Los Santos agreed to let his voice be the voice and likeness for this project. Other voices include myself, my editor Megan Larson, members of the How To LA team, and my mom.

    Choosing which voices were the best fit for which characters is another area where my bias shaped the end result.

    Psychological and legal implications of AI-generated disinformation

    Disinformation affects us even if we know it’s false, for the same reason that fiction affects us: Fake stories are still stories.

    AI-powered disinformation campaigns are already observable in politics. In early June, the Ron DeSantis presidential campaign published an attack-ad with fake images depicting former President Donald Trump hugging former White House Chief Medical Advisor Dr. Anthony Fauci.

    Even once you realize the story you heard is fake, “there's a visual image in people's brains, and it lingers” says Alka Roy, founder of the Responsible Innovation Project.

    “That subtle psychological impact cannot be dislodged,” Roy says. And people can take advantage of this effect.

    This threat isn’t confined to images; it extends to AI-generated audio and text as well. “If it's pretty much designed to deceive you — not communicate with humans, but actually mimic them,” Roy says, then there is an inherent risk for public confusion.

    The tricky part is that within politics, and especially with current government officials, this sort of disinformation is probably legal.

    This is part of the legal precedent established in the famous New York Times v. Sullivan ruling, according to Eugene Volokh, a law professor at UCLA who specializes in law and technology.

    That landmark 1964 Supreme Court case ruled that the First Amendment protects factual inaccuracies, arguing that this protection allowed public debate to be: “uninhibited, robust, and wide-open, and that it may well include vehement, caustic, and sometimes unpleasantly sharp attacks on government and public officials.”

    Volokh says this can apply to intentional deception, too. “It's just too dangerous to have the government put people on trial for, say, conspiracy theories,” he says. “We leave it for public discussion.”

    A transfer of power?

    Whenever AI tools are used, including those used for this experiment, they are trained by the user.

    When we asked ChatGPT to elaborate on certain source interviews, or to try a more conversational approach for a certain line in the script, it learns how to adapt and better match our preferences.

    As these tools become better and better, they need less user input to generate the desired results.

    The threat of human displacement comes back into question.

    “Think of when you bring in an intern or a new employee,” Roy says. As they learn how to do things, and as you show them the ropes, they get better and better. “And if they're really good and savvy, eventually you work for them.”

    We could all look very perfect if we went and got plastic surgery, but what a boring world that would be.
    — Alka Roy, founder of the Responsible Innovation Project

    But as scary as this threat of AI is, there might still be a silver lining. Even if the day comes when AI starts to match — or even surpasses — our skill, Roy says it’s not just doom and gloom.

    “We could all look very perfect if we went and got plastic surgery, but what a boring world that would be,” Roy says.

    Her point is that the real edge humans have over AI isn’t our skill, but rather our imperfections.

    “That's where you’ll find our imagination and creativity and our uniqueness,” she says.

    Leave perfection to the machines.

    If you want to hear the full expert commentary of our experiment, you can listen to the full episode below.

  • Department investigates alleged ICE communication
    An Orange County Sheriff’s deputy in an olive-green uniform and black face covering walks toward the glass entrance of a beige concrete building labeled “Intake and Release Center” with a gold sheriff’s star. Signs on the doors include a visitors’ entrance notice and a COVID-19 symptom warning. Trees and a planter of birds-of-paradise line the walkway.
    An Orange County Sheriffs deputy walks into the Intake and Release center at the the Orange County Central Men's Jail in Santa Ana.

    Topline:

    At least two employees of the OC Sheriff’s Department are on administrative leave as the department investigates a report that a deputy and sheriff’s special officer were seen communicating with ICE agents, according to OCSD.

    What do we know: The department on Friday pointed to surveillance video from Oct. 31 was taken outside the Orange County Jail. It shows two OCSD employees “appearing to have a five-second conversation” with ICE agents in an unmarked vehicle parked outside the Orange County jail, according to the department. The conversation took place minutes before a man, who was hiding in the public courtyard, was arrested by the agents.

    Background: State sanctuary law, known as the California Values Act, limits police cooperation with federal immigration agents and prohibits state and local law enforcement from investigating or arresting people for immigration enforcement purposes.

    Read on… for how the Sheriff and OC officials are responding.

    At least two employees of the Orange County Sheriff’s Department are on administrative leave as the department investigates a report that a deputy and sheriff’s special officer were seen communicating with ICE agents, according to OCSD.

    The department on Friday pointed to surveillance video from Oct. 31 that was taken outside the Orange County Jail. It shows two OCSD employees “appearing to have a five-second conversation” with ICE agents in an unmarked vehicle parked outside the Orange County jail, according to the department. The conversation took place minutes before a man, who was hiding in the public courtyard, was arrested by the agents.

    State sanctuary law, known as the California Values Act, limits police cooperation with federal immigration agents and prohibits state and local law enforcement from investigating or arresting people for immigration enforcement purposes.

    Sheriff Don Barnes said in a statement that the department does not enforce federal immigration law but that he will fully cooperate with ICE to the extent the law allows.

    “Personnel acting outside the law and department policy will be held appropriately accountable,” Barnes said.

    He added the department will enforce state and local laws equally, without bias and without concern for anyone’s citizenship.

    Carlos Perea, executive director of the Harbor Institute for Immigrant and Economic Justice, told LAist this incident shows OCSD’s culture.

    “The department has expressed time and time again that they will work with ICE to the fullest extent of the law,” Perea said. “OC Sheriff Barnes should use this as a learning lesson to end all collaboration with ICE.”

    Hector Bustos, communications director for political organizing group Chispa, told LAist he’s glad to see an investigation launched, but he’s not completely surprised by the incident.

    “We have known for a very long time that the Orange County Sheriff's Department has had a very close relationship with ICE,” Bustos said. “Our hope is that there is an independent investigation here because we know that historically when law enforcement agencies are investigating themselves, we don't see accountability.”

    OC Supervisor Vicente Sarmiento said he’s encouraged by the investigation, but that anxiety among residents is already heightened by the presence of ICE.

    “What it does is it chills the average person from wanting to trust law enforcement when it comes to becoming a witness to a crime, or as a victim to a crime,” Sarmiento said. “The average person may not know state law and just believes that there is collaboration because you see many times federal agents calling local law enforcement for assistance.”

    OC Supervisor Doug Chaffee, in a statement to LAist, welcomed the investigation and said any action that undermines trust or creates fear is concerning.

    “Our local law enforcement agencies should not be participating in federal immigration enforcement,” Chaffee said. “Orange County must remain committed to protecting our residents, upholding California law, and ensuring that local law enforcement remains focused on public safety – not federal immigration enforcement.”

    LAist is working to reach the family of the man who was arrested in the surveillance video.

  • Sponsored message
  • Voyager 1 is now one light day from Earth
    An annotated image showing the various parts and instruments of NASA's Voyager space probe design. Voyager 1 and its identical sister craft Voyager 2 were launched in 1977 to study the outer Solar System and eventually interstellar space.
    An annotated image showing the various parts and instruments of NASA's Voyager space probe design. Voyager 1 and its identical sister craft Voyager 2 were launched in 1977 to study the outer Solar System and eventually interstellar space.

    Topline:

    NASA’s Voyager 1 spacecraft will reach one light day — or 16 billion miles — from Earth in interstellar space Wednesday, a distance reached by no other human-made object.

    The details: One light day means it takes one day for a command sent by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory in Pasadena to reach Voyager 1.

    The backstory: Voyager was launched in 1977 and is NASA’s farthest operating mission. It is also the longest-operating computer ever.

    Still working: Voyager continues to beam back daily measurements regarding magnetic fields, plasma density and cosmic rays, using a couple of remaining operational instruments. Its cameras were turned off in 1990 to conserve energy. There’s not much to see in interstellar space. There’s very little light where Voyager is right now, according to project manager Suzanne Dodd.

    How you can send a message to Voyager: After sunset on Tuesday, NASA invites you to join a worldwide celebration by creating a symbolic wave of golden light encircling Earth. NASA has created a website that enables smartphones and tablets to flash “VGR” — Voyager’s call sign — in Morse code. You can also just use a flashlight to flash the call sign to Voyager.

  • District surveying community about AI policies
    A row of students sit at tables in a school working on laptops.
    LAUSD will survey parents, students and staff to help inform its policy about generative artificial intelligence.

    Topline:

    The Los Angeles Unified School District wants to hear from community members about how to use generative artificial intelligence in schools. LAUSD is distributing a survey to help inform district policy.

    The backstory: In September, LAUSD implemented a surprise moratorium on student use of generative AI on school-issued devices for this school year. Previously, district policy allowed students 13 and older to use the technology under supervision.

    Why it matters: The school board has an ad-hoc committee on generative AI that examines the new technology and what its role should be in the classroom. The committee was formed as part of a resolution that was passed to limit screentime in the district.

    What’s next: The ad hoc committee is scheduled to meet four more times this school year:

    • Dec. 9, 2026
    • Jan. 20, 2027
    • March 3, 2027
    • April 7, 2027

    The committee plans to make policy recommendations that the full board could vote on.

  • 30 county DAs sue over Newsom's commutations
    A uniformed officer in blue gloves unlocks a chain-link gate with a ring of keys as a person with a medium skin tone in a white T-shirt stands nearby.
    A California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation officer opens the gate for an incarcerated person leaving the exercise yard at San Quentin State Prison's death row in San Quentin on Aug. 15, 2016.

    Topline:

    The district attorneys of 30 counties argued in a lawsuit filed Monday morning that the state’s high court should halt Gov. Gavin Newsom’s commutations of people on death row. The lawsuit, filed at the California Supreme Court, asserts that Newsom acted unlawfully when he proposed commuting the sentences of 548 prisoners by failing to afford the victims of their crimes the “opportunity to be heard.”

    Why now: The petition distinguishes Newsom’s commutation powers from the pardon powers of a president — the presidential pardon doesn’t have any limits, other than impeachment. By contrast, when condemned California prisoners apply for a commutation, governors must notify the district attorney where the crime took place, and the victims or their families.

    What's next: The California Supreme Court will get a say on almost 400 of Newsom’s commutations. State law requires the court to review those cases because the prisoners were convicted of multiple felonies. Representatives of the court have not said how or when those reviews would take place.

    The district attorneys of 30 counties argued in a lawsuit filed Monday morning that the state’s high court should halt Gov. Gavin Newsom’s commutations of people on death row.

    The lawsuit, filed at the California Supreme Court, asserts that Newsom acted unlawfully when he proposed commuting the sentences of 548 prisoners by failing to afford the victims of their crimes the “opportunity to be heard.”

    “Only this court can stop the governor’s disregard of the law — his abuse of power,” the petitioners wrote to the California Supreme Court.

    The petition distinguishes Newsom’s commutation powers from the pardon powers of a president — the presidential pardon doesn’t have any limits, other than impeachment. By contrast, when condemned California prisoners apply for a commutation, governors must notify the district attorney where the crime took place, and the victims or their families.

    Perhaps anticipating this argument, Newsom issued an explanatory statement laying out why he didn’t need to issue notifications to victims or their families. A central factor was that none of these proposed commutations stemmed from an application from a prisoner on death row. By proposing a blanket commutation, Newsom asserted that none of the statutory requirements applied.

    The section of the California penal code highlighted by the district attorneys “does not apply when the governor acts on his own initiative to grant clemency absent an application,” Newsom wrote in the explanation.

    He added that, after he submitted the proposed commutations to the Supreme Court, his office would notify the district attorneys in the counties in which the crimes were committed and seek their help with notifications.

    The California Supreme Court will get a say on almost 400 of Newsom’s commutations. State law requires the court to review those cases because the prisoners were convicted of multiple felonies. Representatives of the court have not said how or when those reviews would take place.

    Newsom in 2019 issued a moratorium on executions and later ordered the dismantling of the death chamber at San Quentin State Prison. His successor, Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra, has committed to extending the moratorium when he takes office.

    This article was originally published on CalMatters and was republished under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives license.