Cato Hernández
covers important issues that affect the everyday lives of Southern Californians.
Published December 10, 2025 4:16 PM
A file photo of an ink-based printer.
(
Neilson Barnard
/
Getty Images
)
Topline:
The L.A. City Council has voted to create a new ordinance that bans the sale of certain single-use ink cartridges from online and local retailers.
Why now? L.A. is recommending that a ban target single-use cartridges that don’t have a take-back program or can’t be refilled. That's because they’re winding up in the landfill, where, L.A. Sanitation says, they can leach harmful substances into the ground.
What’s next? The City Attorney’s Office is drafting the ordinance. It will go before the council’s energy and environment committee before reaching a full vote.
Read on ... to see how the ban could work.
Los Angeles could become the first city in the U.S. to ban ink cartridges that can be used only once.
The L.A. City Council unanimously voted Wednesday to approve the creation of an ordinance that prohibits their sale. The move comes after more than a year of debate over the terms.
Why the potential ban
This builds upon the city’s effort to reach zero waste, including phasing out single-use plastics. You’re likely familiar with some of those efforts — such as only getting plastic foodware by request and banning single-use carryout bags at stores. Multiple plastic bans have been suggested, like for single-use vapes and bag clips, but now it’s ink’s turn.
The cartridges are tough to dispose of because of the plastic, metal and chemicals inside, according to the city. They’re also classified as regulated waste in the state because they can leach toxic substances into the environment, such as volatile organic compounds and heavy metals.
That poses a problem. L.A.’s curbside recycling program can’t recycle the cartridges, and while its hazardous waste program can take them, a significant portion end up in landfills.
Major printer manufacturers and some ink retailers have take-back programs for used cartridges so they can get refilled. However, L.A. Sanitation says there are certain single-use cartridges that don’t have recovery programs. These are usually cartridges that work with a printer but aren’t name brand.
How outlawing them could work
LASAN has spent months figuring out what a ban would cover — and it hasn’t been without pushback. The city’s energy and environment committee pressed the department back in September on how effective a ban would be.
Ultimately, the committee moved it forward with a promise that LASAN would come back with more details, including environmental groups’ stance, concrete data to back up the need and a public education plan.
The department’s current recommendation is that the ordinance should prohibit retail and online establishments from selling any single-use ink cartridge, whether sold separately or with a printer, to people in the city. Retailers that don’t follow the rules would get fined.
So what does single-use mean here? The ban would affect a printer cartridge that:
is not collected or recovered through a take-back program
cannot be remanufactured, refilled or reused
infringes upon intellectual property rights or violates any applicable local, state or federal law
Any cartridges that meet one of these points would fall under the ban, though you still could get them outside L.A.
The proposed ordinance will go to the committee first while LASAN works on a public education plan.
If it ends up getting approved by the full council, the ban likely would go into full effect 12 months later.
Dentist Don Call checks the teeth of a kindergartner at De Vargas Elementary School in San Jose.
(
Karl Mondon
/
Bay Area News Group
)
Topline:
A 20-year-old initiative requiring California’s youngest students be screened for cavities and untreated tooth decay before they enter public school is falling short.
Why now: The state created the Kindergarten Oral Health Assessment in 2006 to ensure families connect with dentists, and to identify students’ dental needs and reveal roadblocks to care. But the effort has been dogged by challenges, according to a new California State Auditor report that focused on six school districts and the California Department of Public Health.
Why it matters: Tooth decay is largely preventable, yet it’s the most common chronic disease in kids nationwide. About 61% of third grade students had tooth decay during the 2018-19 school year, according to a 2021 state report, and experts find that children’s oral health has declined further since the start of the pandemic.
Read on... for more on the report.
This story was originally published by CalMatters. Sign up for their newsletters.
A 20-year-old initiative requiring California’s youngest students be screened for cavities and untreated tooth decay before they enter public school is falling short.
The state created the Kindergarten Oral Health Assessment in 2006 to ensure families connect with dentists, and to identify students’ dental needs and reveal roadblocks to care. But the effort has been dogged by challenges, according to a new California State Auditor report that focused on six school districts and the California Department of Public Health.
Tooth decay is largely preventable, yet it’s the most common chronic disease in kids nationwide. About 61% of third grade students had tooth decay during the 2018-19 school year, according to a 2021 state report, and experts find that children’s oral health has declined further since the start of the pandemic.
Untreated dental problems can lead to missed school days. The California Health Interview Survey from the UCLA Center for Health Policy Research found nearly 7% of children 5 and older who attend school missed class due to dental problems in 2025.
The review of the districts found that they did not maintain reliable data about all aspects of the program and reported incorrect information to the state. The audited districts are Los Angeles Unified School District, Merced City School District, Milpitas Unified School District, Oakland Unified School District, San Luis Coastal Unified School District, and Woodland Joint Unified School District.
No state agency is assigned oversight of the kindergarten oral health program, the audit found, and neither the California Department of Education nor the Department of Public Health oversees program activities. The state health department, which is responsible for the state’s efforts to improve dental health, hasn’t verified the data reported by districts, the audit said, and isn’t using the data to measure the state’s progress in improving kids’ oral health.
The department doesn’t publish annual analyses of the data on its website; the most recent program data available online, from the 2020-21 school year, is on the California Dental Association website. The audit also revealed that the program’s source of funding — a 2016 tax on tobacco products — is dwindling.
“We determined that unreliable data reported by districts and insufficient statewide oversight of the [Kindergarten Oral Health Assessment] program’s requirements threaten the goals of the program,” State Auditor Grant Parks wrote in a Nov. 5 report.
Department of Public Health spokesperson Kristine Tuzon, citing state education code, said the agency isn’t responsible for tracking kindergarten oral health program submissions or notifying county offices of education when districts don’t report data. Tuzon said the statute doesn’t give the health department authority to require districts and county offices to comply with the program’s data reporting mandate.
One method of reducing barriers to kids’ obtaining dental assessments, the audit found, is to conduct more on school campuses, as is done for state-required vision and hearing screenings. That solution, too, has had data-reporting challenges.
Esther Yepez is the associate director of wellness programs and oral health at The Los Angeles Trust for Children’s Health, which coordinated oral health screenings at L.A. Unified schools for five years. After completing the assessments, her team left the completed forms with the schools. But oftentimes, she said, schools didn't enter those screenings in the district’s system, resulting in a mismatch between the number of students screened and the number reported to the state. It was unclear, she said, who at each school was responsible for compiling the data.
“It was frustrating,” Yepez said, “because we had information that the screenings had happened, but the schools didn’t have that data.”
L.A. Unified did not answer CalMatters’ questions regarding data accuracy in the kindergarten oral health program. In a response to the audit published as part of the report, Joel Cisneros, executive director of L.A. Unified’s student mental health and wellness services, said the district plans to train school staff on data-entry procedures and program documentation requirements and establish a standardized process for recording all returned forms and waivers.
Rotten teeth and huge pain
The American Academy of Pediatric Dentists recommends that children see a dentist when their first tooth appears, or no later than their first birthday.
Early childhood dental visits are “extremely important,” said Dr. Francisco Ramos-Gomez, UCLA School of Dentistry’s pediatric dentistry chair and director of the UCLA Center for Children’s Oral Health. But he said many families don’t access care due to transportation challenges, language barriers and few providers treating low-income kids.
“If we start seeing these children by age 3 or 4,” he said, “they already come with rotten teeth, abscesses and huge pain.”
The kindergarten program directs school districts to notify families enrolling in public school for the first time in transitional kindergarten, kindergarten or first grade that they need to present proof of an oral health assessment. State law allows parents to waive the assessment requirement due to a financial burden, lack of access to a dental provider or nonconsent.
The program mandates that districts submit specific data to their county education offices or a system designated by the state’s dental director, which since at least 2021 has been the System for California Oral Health Reporting. It directs the health department to periodically evaluate the kindergarten program requirements.
But the audit found none of the districts provided families with all required information regarding the assessment requirement. The six audited districts also lacked formalized procedures for following up with families that didn’t return assessment forms, the audit said, or that returned waivers indicating a barrier to obtaining an assessment.
The audit found that five districts reported data to the state system that was “significantly different” from their local data. For example, L.A. Unified, the state’s largest school district, for the 2024-25 school year incorrectly included all first-graders in its count of students subject to the program requirements, instead of only those who had not previously enrolled in kindergarten in the district, the audit said. The district also overreported the number of students who presented proof of the assessment, the audit said.
“The magnitude of the reporting errors by Los Angeles Unified School District alone,” Parks wrote, “skews any statewide analysis of the collective data.”
The audit recommended that the districts provide parents with all required program information and report complete and accurate data to the state system. In responses submitted to the state, the Milpitas and Oakland districts said they would implement the audit’s recommendations, while the L.A. and San Luis Coastal districts shared action plans to address some of the report’s findings. The Merced and Woodland districts did not provide a response.
‘Where is the money coming from?’
Funding for the oral health program is also declining, the audit found.
The state public health department grants Proposition 56 funds – which are generated by a tax on tobacco products – to county health departments, and requires them to support oral health initiatives, including the kindergarten program. But revenue from the tax is plummeting, according to the audit, and starting next year the health department will no longer require counties receiving grant funds to support the kindergarten program.
Tuzon said the health department is assessing strategies to maintain and improve compliance with the program, given declining funding from tobacco taxes.
Despite the data issues, Eileen Espejo, senior managing director for health at Children Now, said policymakers should consider how to fund the kindergarten oral health program moving forward.
“Local health programs are going to have less capacity to do some of the work,” she said. “There needs to be that conversation of, ‘Where is the money coming from to help increase compliance?’”
Efforts to address racial profiling by the LAPD have fallen short, despite a state law intended to curb it.
The backstory: In 2020, as protests over the murder of George Floyd swept the country, Angelenos called for an end to racial disparities in policing. The Los Angeles Police Commission responded with a promise to reduce racial disparities in traffic stops. Six years later, that promise has fallen short. So far this year, Black Angelenos accounted for 24% of all traffic stops made by the Los Angeles Police Department, despite being only 8.4% of the city’s population. In 2020, they accounted for 27% of stops.
An analysis: A Crosstown analysis of eight years of LAPD stops, from July 2018 to July 2026, shows a stubborn trend of Black people being stopped, and not charged with any crime, at far higher rates. During that time frame, the demographic made up 38% of stops in which officers took no enforcement action.
Read on... for more from the data analysis.
This was produced in collaboration with our partner at Crosstown.
In 2020, as protests over the murder of George Floyd swept the country, Angelenos called for an end to racial disparities in policing. The Los Angeles Police Commission responded with a promise to reduce racial disparities in traffic stops.
Six years later, that promise has fallen short.
So far this year, Black Angelenos accounted for 24% of all traffic stops made by the Los Angeles Police Department, despite being only 8.4% of the city’s population. In 2020, they accounted for 27% of stops.
For decades, research has shown that Black and Hispanic or Latino drivers are pulled over by police at higher rates. In Los Angeles, the 1992 civil unrest following the acquittal of officers who beat motorist Rodney King brought renewed attention to longstanding racial disparities in policing.
A Crosstown analysis of eight years of LAPD stops, from July 2018 to July 2026, shows a stubborn trend of Black people being stopped, and not charged with any crime, at far higher rates. During that time frame, the demographic made up 38% of stops in which officers took no enforcement action.
How California tracks police stops
California’s Racial and Identity Profiling Act of 2015 prohibits law enforcement from using characteristics such as race or ethnicity as a pretext for a stop, and requires officers to report the perceived race and gender of any pedestrian or driver they stop. Officers must also report the reason for the stop and the outcome.
The law was intended to address the longstanding issue of racial profiling by law enforcement. But despite numerous pledges, legislation and increased disclosures, racial disparities persist.
Stopped more than 40 times
LiQuan Hunt has been stopped by police more than 40 times in Southern California since 2009, and received a citation only twice. Four of those stops were by the LAPD, and none resulted in a ticket.
Hunt, who is Black, said the frequency of the stops, the lack of evidence and the repeated outcome of no action being taken led him to think he was being racially profiled. He also said the stops quickly de-escalated when he told officers his father was an LAPD watch commander.
“I’m a Black guy. I had a firearm. The chance of me walking away from that [stop] free of harm wasn’t necessarily the highest,” Hunt said.
The total number of stops involving escalated outcomes has declined since 2020. However, Black drivers still faced aggressive measures at a much higher rate. So far in 2026, they accounted for about a third of people that had firearms pointed at them by LAPD.
Hispanic and Latino drivers make up the majority of stops in each of those categories. They also make up 47% of the city of LA’s population.
LAPD said in a statement that although the data shows disparities for Black drivers, those figures alone “do not establish racial profiling or explain the many factors that contribute to police contacts.”
“We continuously review stop data, training, policies, and oversight measures to ensure officers are policing fairly and constitutionally,” the LAPD said.
LAPD stops Black Angelenos at more than 7 times the rate of white people — and more often for nothing
In May, the Los Angeles City Council unanimously voted to ban pretextual traffic stops.
Racial justice advocacy group Catalyst California published a report this year on racial profiling in LAPD stops. Elycia Mulholland Graves, the group’s director of research and data analysis, said the racial disparities in police stops extend beyond Los Angeles.
“We’ve done similar reports for the Fresno area as well that show stops of people of color are more likely to result in no action.”
Catalyst California, in partnership with advocacy group PUSH LA, found that Latino and Black residents are also much more likely to be profiled during pretextual stops. These stops involve pulling someone over for a minor offense, such as a broken taillight, to investigate a more serious suspected crime, such as drug or weapons offenses.
Black Angelenos were stopped for “reasonable suspicion of criminal activity” at even higher rates. Last year, 28,871 Black people were stopped on that basis, accounting for 30% of stops.
The disparity is even greater when adjusted for population. For every 10,000 people, 895 Black people were stopped on reasonable suspicion of criminal activity, compared with 275 Hispanic or Latino, 125 white and 32 Asian.
Put into context: Black people are stopped for this reason at more than seven times the rate of white people. Stops of Black drivers on this basis also resulted in no action at higher rates.
Beyond the stops
Hunt, now a 35-year-old brand strategy manager at a social justice advocacy organization, said racial profiling has eroded trust in law enforcement and fueled animosity between police and communities of color.
“The perception changes from creating a safe environment that’s inclusive of people to one where people are feeling blatantly discriminated against,” Hunt said.
Hunt said officers have searched his vehicle four times during traffic stops, but he was never told why.
Racial profiling causes physical and emotional trauma in marginalized communities even when officers take no action, said Shelby Richardson of the Social Justice Learning Institute, a group that advocates for youth and communities of color.
She said the constant police presence and surveillance in Black and Brown neighborhoods can condition residents to fit a criminal mold.
“Black and Brown folks are in constant survival mode and on constant guard,” Richardson said. “That does something to our own views of ourselves. Racial profiling makes or manifests the racial profile.”
Drivers can also reach out to civil rights groups such as PUSH-LA and the ACLU Foundation of Southern California, which have filed formal complaints against the Office of Traffic and Safety to stop police funding and are actively campaigning against racial profiling in stops.
Keep up with LAist.
If you're enjoying this article, you'll love our daily newsletter, The LA Report. Each weekday, catch up on the 5 most pressing stories to start your morning in 3 minutes or less.
An inspired synthesis of violent satire and contemplative storytelling, Grand Theft Auto VI is more mature and ambitious than any prior game in the record-breaking franchise.
The backstory: For anyone who has somehow missed the shrieking, neon-and-swamp-water marketing onslaught over the past several days, weeks, months and years, Grand Theft Auto VI is the newest release from Rockstar Games. It is a Bonnie and Clyde love story, a knife-edged satire of modern American culture and politics, an unapologetic murder simulator, a love letter to 50 years of crime movies, and a thoughtful, emotional meditation on the sacrifices, small and large, that we make for family.
About the game: A massive open world game set in the fictional state of Leonida (based on the very real state of Florida), it represents a return to a location that Rockstar hasn't visited in-depth since its 2002 release of GTA: Vice City, and is the first new game in the franchise since GTA5 launched in 2013. According to estimates, it already earned over $1.5 billion in pre-sales and will likely make a total of $3 to $5 billion in its first week, which could make it the largest single entertainment product launch ever.
Read on... for more on the game.
I want to tell you about the time I saw Bigfoot. I want to tell you about sitting in the rain on a city street in a muscle car and prepping to rob a bank while lightning split the sky between high-rise condo towers in the distance and the drum fill from In The Air Tonight played on the radio. I want to tell you about gunfights and fistfights, the perfect satire of radio commercials and how the sunrise looks over Ocean Beach. But more than any of that, I want to tell you about the time an alligator bit my mom.
It happened in the backyard of an abandoned house with a rotting inground pool. My mom, Mia Caminos (mother of Lucia Caminos, one of the two leads in Rockstar Games' Grand Theft Auto VI, probably the most highly anticipated video game sequel of all time), was thrilled by the pool. Standing there, amid the artfully rendered weeds and trash, she spread her arms and told me to use my imagination, to see her vision for this ruin of a house with its upmarket water feature, in a scabby neighborhood on the outskirts of Vice City. She speaks in tones of increasingly frantic desperation because she has already put money down on this house, sight unseen. All of her money, actually, in hopes of flipping it and selling it fast to keep her startup real estate business afloat.
Lucia begins her epic as a petty criminal.
(
Rockstar Games
)
The pool is still half full of water. There's a dirty, sodden mattress floating in it. And as if this is the main thing standing between her and success, Mia is fixated on getting it out of the pool.
Help me, Lucia, she says.
And, dutifully, I do. Playing as Lucia, I grab hold, mash buttons, help my mom drag away the wet, heavy, stinking mattress. And just as we get it up and over the lip of the pool that's going to be the thing that makes this wreck of a house suddenly desirable – that's when the alligator lunges out of the murky water, grabs my mom by the arm and tries to drag her back in.
This is a story about folly, fixation, unrealistic expectations of success at the ass-end of late capitalism, and the vicious, whip-crack cruelty of predators who lie in wait for anyone trying to improve a terrible situation.
But then I shoot the alligator in the head before it can eat my mom. Because this is also a story about violence, and how sometimes (maybe all the times), the loud, cathartic rip of gunfire is the only solution left for people who have already lost so much and can't bear to see one more thing taken from them.
It's a story about my mom and an alligator, sure.
It is also the story of GTA6
Grand Theft Auto VI returns to Vice City and its Florida-inspired environs.
(
Rockstar Games
)
But let's back up a little. For anyone who has somehow missed the shrieking, neon-and-swamp-water marketing onslaught over the past several days, weeks, months and years, Grand Theft Auto VI is the newest release from Rockstar Games. It is a Bonnie and Clyde love story, a knife-edged satire of modern American culture and politics, an unapologetic murder simulator, a love letter to 50 years of crime movies, and a thoughtful, emotional meditation on the sacrifices, small and large, that we make for family. A massive open world game set in the fictional state of Leonida (based on the very real state of Florida), it represents a return to a location that Rockstar hasn't visited in-depth since its 2002 release of GTA: Vice City, and is the first new game in the franchise since GTA5 launched in 2013. According to estimates, it already earned over $1.5 billion in pre-sales and will likely make a total of $3 to $5 billion in its first week, which could make it the largest single entertainment product launch ever.
Fans have been waiting yearsfor it. They have created libraries worth of lore and theories and dissected trailers frame-by-frame. To discount the overheated environment into which this singular work of art is being released would be doing a disservice both to it and the legions of salivating prognosticators who have made guessing the number of bird species included in-game, or speculating on the square mileage of its map, their entire personalities.
While Vice City remains the game's hub, most of its map is actually rural or wild.
(
Rockstar Games
)
Now, though, they know it all. We all do. We know that GTA6 is expansive, covering everything from the Keys (where the game starts) to the hilly, forested north, with Vice City in all its grimy, pastel-colored splendor at the beating heart of it. It is a playground, equal parts gorgeous and maniacal, and in all that space the developers have given us a thousand different things to do. You can rob a bank or take a bike ride, go fishing, hunt trophy animals, visit strip clubs, rob random civilians, street race, fly drones, eat a sandwich, work out, manage your family savings account, jump a sports car off the top of a building, steal a plane, punch out a convenience store clerk, fight a bear or, yes, just wander out toward the horizon and study the birds. And while some of that is fun and all of it is diverting (at least for a little while), none of it is the ostensible point. The game-y part of the game — the hundred extras and time-wasters that players have come to expect from open-world projects in general, and GTA specifically — is not what makes it matter.
What matters is Mia and the alligator, Lucia and the gun. It's the multi-pronged, exquisitely balanced narrative about poverty and rigged systems that makes it hard to turn away from GTA while you're playing and impossible not to think about when you're away.
Jason and his pal, Cal, shoot pool.
(
Rockstar Games
)
Lucia is an ex-con, a car thief and a small-time criminal who got caught trying to rob a payday loan joint and starts the game in jail. Her partner, Jason Duval, is a veteran, dishonorably discharged, now making a living flying loads for a local coke dealer down in the Keys and living rent-free in one of his properties. Jason skims a little on the coke deals, wears flip-flops and drinks beer in the sun, and goes fishing with his best friend Cal. And every plan Jason and Lucia have is about getting right by the law, making a few bucks, and grabbing whatever chance they can at finally being a family.
Only there are complications — surprisingly banal ones at first (like not being able to open a checking account because of their bad credit) — that slowly ramp up into huge ones across 60-odd hours of main story gameplay that see Jason and Lucia (both of whom are playable characters) graduate from knocking over liquor stores in a beat-up El Camino, to pulling off elaborate heists in the middle of Vice City which will have you dangling from a net suspended from a cargo helicopter hauling 200 tons of cocaine. It goes from Badlands to Die Hard with the speed of a muscle car, all bright chrome and barking straight pipes. From True Romance to Heat like that's just the natural arc of any American love story.
And what's remarkable about the whole bloody delight is that it remains, until its final operatic moments, so surprisingly grounded. This is a somewhat more mature GTA than its predecessors, trading aliens, cannibal cultists and whacked-out drug trips for wellness influencers, local politics and the music industry. Jason and Lucia's relationship is the superstructure around which the entire narrative is built, and it's a dynamic thing that must be maintained in a dozen little ways — making coffee in the morning, opening doors for each other, date nights (even if that means robbing a jewelry store together), or holding hands as you walk toward yet another betrayal by someone you thought you could trust. You can switch freely between them, or just call the other one to come drive the getaway car. Let their relationship dwindle and the narrative shifts, flattens. But when they're together, the two of them talk and talk: In bed, in the car, by the pool. They reveal pieces of themselves in quiet moments, joke, tease, flirt, make plans for a future that always seems right around the next corner. And you love them for it. You can't help but love them for it, and root for them, and want good things for them, because they're just two hard-luck kids trying to do right in a world where "right" sometimes means petting a dog or helping a farmer spray manure all over his boss's house, and sometimes means stealing $10 million from South American drug lords.
The couple that robs together, stays together. That's the hope, anyway.
(
Rockstar Games
)
In so many ways GTA6 is an example of inspired synthesis. Rockstar made a killing with the sunlit beauty and craziness of GTA5 more than a decade ago, a game built on deconstructing Hollywood myths and male friendships. Then it made art with a slow-burn meditation on loyalty, death and obsolescence in Red Dead Redemption 2. And this? It is the middle path charted between those two bright stars. It has seriousness and weight and something to say. And also, you accidentally end up starring in a porno movie. Through mechanical tweaks and narrative railroading, the game trades abject chaos for consequences that force you to actually live in its world rather than just murder your way through it, but then makes the dullest, most quotidian chores (like going grocery shopping or answering your mom's texts) feel like a long, slow breath taken between gasping moments of panic.
Yes, you have to sleep. Yes, you have to eat. Yes, you have to work out and put gas in the (stolen) car. But after a while, I found myself actually wanting to do those things because doing them felt like roleplaying; like added opportunities to fully exist within the fiction of Jason or Lucia's world. And in what will no doubt enrage a million over-testosteroned 15-year-olds who want nothing more out of GTA6 than a shinier, brighter, higher-resolution playground in which to jack a Lambo and mow down pedestrians, certain mechanical adjustments in the game (like cars that exist without the tools immediately available to steal them, or how you no longer carry every gun you've ever touched, but store them in the trunk of your ride) have made it harder to jump right in and create mayhem from hour one.
Plus, the police response has been overhauled. Commit brazen crimes and cameras will capture your appearance. Witnesses will describe your clothes or getaway car. Wanted levels now measure not just the size of the armed response, but its sophistication, so speed and stealth become vital. Do a job cleanly, destroy the evidence, get out fast without tripping alarms or blowing stuff up and you're golden. Go loud and cops will search whole regions for you, using helicopters and canine units. They'll hunt you until you change your appearance, swap cars, or simply flee.
Do your best to evade or overcome the police in GTA6.
(
Rockstar Games
)
To call the game a masterpiece seems like a cheap, throwaway declaration because after years of development and hundreds of millions of dollars spent, a masterpiece feels… expected, right? Like if it wasn't a masterpiece, that would feel somehow personally insulting. Like they just didn't try hard enough. But the truth is, these things can go wrong so easily. They are enormous, unwieldy, lumbering projects that can fall apart for any number of reasons — and do all the time.
But this one didn't. There is a gloss on it that feels like love. A polish so fine that if you're not looking for it, you might not even notice the way the palm fronds move in the wind when there's weather coming in, or the light on the edge of a storm; how Lucia hangs her head out of a convertible when Jason is driving, or the way the sound of your tires changes depending on whether you're cruising on macadam or blacktop. Does it drag a little in the third act? Sure. Are there NPC glitches, targeting hang-ups and moments where you have to stop to puzzle out exactly who is betraying whom and how they're all connected? Absolutely. But at almost any point, you can walk away from the narrative for a while, call your better half, hop in your car and just drive. Everywhere you go, Leonida is alive around you in a way that no game has ever been before. There are a million stories here just waiting to be discovered or created. Pick one. See where it leads you.
But remember Mia and the alligator. Because at its core, GTA6 will always be a story about predators and prey. And no matter where you go or how powerful you think you are, you can never, ever be sure which one you are.
Jason Sheehan knows stuff about food, video games, books and Star Blazers. He's the restaurant critic at Philadelphia magazine, but when no one is looking, he spends his time writing books about giant robots and ray guns. Children of the Flying City is his latest book. Copyright 2026 NPR
Yusra Farzan
covered the encampments in 2024 and has been keeping tabs on the movement since.
Published November 19, 2026 5:00 AM
Royce Hall at UCLA in 2024, when students set up encampments to protest Israel's war in Gaza.
(
Ted Soqui
)
Topline:
In 2024, a wave of student encampments took over universities. Organizers protested Israel’s war in Gaza and called on their schools to divest from companies making money off the conflict. Those protests became a significant talking point in the run up to the 2024 presidential election. But now, two years later, the encampments have disappeared.
Two nights in April 2024 changed Catherine Hamilton’s life.
At the time, she was a student at the University of California, Los Angeles and a journalist at the student newspaper, Daily Bruin. Hamilton was tasked with covering the encampment students set up to protest Israel’s war in Gaza when it was attacked by a mob. The attackers set off fireworks and used bear spray and mace on student protesters while security hired by UCLA and campus police stood watching. The Los Angeles Police Department and California Highway Patrol were called in, but the violence did not stop.
The attackers also assaulted Hamilton, sending her to the ER. She later tweeted that UCLA’s then-Chancellor Gene Block was responsible for the attack; she said Daily Bruin editors asked her to take down the tweet, which she did.
Soon after, Hamilton quit the Daily Bruin and started her own publication, Poppy Press.
A November 2024 report faulted UCLA for how it involved police in breaking up student protests.
(
Brian Feinzimer
/
LAist
)
“Watching those two nights, I could not stay silent anymore, and I knew that there was also a need for students who were able to write well and express the opinions of our whole movement,” Hamilton, now a law student in San Diego, told LAist. “I had to speak out against the university and their actions.”
It’s been two years since an audit found UCLA had a series of “shortcomings, performance failures, systems breakdown, and campus safety issues” that led to that fateful police intervention months prior. And in the intervening months, the students on the other end of that treatment — like Hamilton — have been injured, doxxed, suspended and some tried for misdemeanors.
LAist spoke to a cross section of those students, who nevertheless maintained that while the encampments are gone, the protests and advocacy for Palestinian rights continues in other ways.
Why students built encampments, and why they stopped
In 2024, a wave of activism overtook college campuses in protest of Israel’s war in Gaza, which started after the October 7, 2023 attack on Israel by Hamas. Students and faculty called on their universities to divest from companies doing business with Israel. They pitched tents, erected barriers around the encampments, flew the Palestinian flag and spent their days with healing circles and teach-ins related to the cause.
But soon after, college campuses came down hard on the protesters. Dozens of people were arrested at the University of Southern California and UC Irvine — and over 200 people were arrested at UCLA.
A recent report from the ACLU and Amnesty International USA alleges UCLA was among a handful of universities where administrators came down particularly hard on protesters, violating free speech laws and imposing severe punishments on students, faculty and staff who expressed support for Palestinian rights. The universities’ responses “made it easier for the Trump administration to crack down on student activism, causing long-term damage to higher education,” the report’s authors said.
In an emailed statement, a spokesperson for UCLA told LAist, “UCLA supports the right of students to express their views, including through peaceful protest and advocacy on issues they care deeply about. Our responsibility is to protect free expression while ensuring a safe and welcoming environment for everyone on campus. UCLA’s policies apply equally to all members of our community, regardless of the views they express.”
The universities and the Trump administration’s actions, the report said, have “profoundly chilled student speech and advocacy, resulting in a steep decline in protests and a less visible protest movement on campuses across the country.”
Students from MIT, Harvard University and others rally at a protest encampment at MIT's Kresge Lawn in Cambridge, Massachusetts.
(
Scott Eisen
/
Getty Images
)
Uma Jayakumar, a professor of higher education and policy at the University of California, Riverside, said that while the report can quantify a decline in protests, what it doesn’t capture is how movements go underground, as students build community with like-minded people.
“That work that was initiated doesn't go away because the encampments were shut down. It has a life of its own, and it continues,” Jayakumar said.
She drew parallels with the student organizers today and Black teachers during segregation who took their movement underground because they were policed by white administrators.
“The people that choose to be a part of that space are having a liberatory experience within a largely oppressive institutional space, and [these] spaces coexist,” Jayakumar said.
New iteration of Palestinian activism
For Raeva Mv, a current student at UCLA who was involved in the encampment protest, the work has not stopped. Students are frightened to protest, she said, but the activism has taken another form.
It is not just “big explosions of energy and of pressure that happen in things like a rally or an encampment or a funeral march, like the ones that we've done at UCLA,” she said.
Instead, she said, students are building a strategic movement, bringing in people who watched the encampments in 2024 and realized there was “something wrong” in the university’s response, people who watched videos out of Gaza and wanted to do more. That work has looked like documentary screenings and bringing people who volunteered in Gaza to speak at events.
“We have seen absolutely no deviation or bend from the university in the favor of the Palestinian people because it's so deeply entrenched with Zionism. What we have seen change is in student opinion,” Mv said.
Mv has one quarter left at UCLA. She has spent most of her time at the university with a hold on her student account because of pending student code of conduct charges; she was also banned from campus. All that time she couldn’t be in classrooms, she spent organizing around Palestinian rights. The university’s punishments, she said, “emboldened her.”
During UCLA’s 2026 Welcome Week, Mv said, she recruited for multiple organizations that touch on Palestinian rights.
“We've seen more interest than ever,” she said. “There are dozens and dozens of people filling [out] our interest forms, talking to us about how they're excited to mobilize and to organize around Palestine.”
Organizing around Palestinian rights has shifted her life trajectory, Mv said. Now she wants to work at a place more clearly aligned with her values.
“The university, by threatening things like my education, threatening things like my career, or threatening things like my physical health and physical safety, it made me realize how fickle those things are and how contingent those things are on enacting violence on other people,” Mv told LAist.
UCLA declined to provide further comment.
Hamilton said her experiences have made her appreciate the value of journalism more.
“There's a lot of news organizations where that doesn't fly, and you're not allowed to do that, and we saw so many reporters getting fired or let go from their papers because they were speaking out against the genocide in Gaza,” Hamilton said. “But that's ultimately not a place that I would want to work anyway.”
Building bridges through other struggles
For Malik Alrefai, it was a “burning need for justice” that led him to get involved in UC Irvine’s encampment.
When UC Irvine’s encampment went up, Alrefai called his parents in Jordan. They cautioned him not to get involved, not to get into trouble. He listened to them — but not for long.
Alrefai’s grandmother was forced out of the West Bank in 1947 and 1948, during what Palestinians call Nakba or catastrophe. An Israeli soldier shot his grandmother in the knee, and with no access to hospitals or medical care, she grew up with what he calls a “deformed knee.” Those stories are part of who he is.
On the day the students were commemorating the Nakba on campus, Alrefai was lifting weights in the gym when a university-wide alert went out about a “violent” protest.
Protestors gathered at the UC Irvine campus.
(
Courtesy Amir Mertaban
)
”Given I have read a history book on how violently student movements have been suppressed in the United States … It wasn't difficult to put two and two together and figure out where it would go from there,” Alrefai said.
He said he made peace with his parents “in his head” and headed over to where the encampment was set up. “There is finally a global conversation that recognized the existence of something named Palestine,” Alrefai noted.
He was eventually detained and charged with a misdemeanor. His next trial date is set for January. Alrefai has no regrets about joining the protesters.
“I think the regret would have been if I walked away that day,” he said.
Alrefai’s advocacy has not stopped. On his Substack, he writes about the connections between ramped-up immigration raids in the United States and the policing of Palestinians. It’s easy for people to empathize with someone when they are able to make connections to other struggles, he said.
University values inspire activism
Hasan Mirza was president of UCLA’s Muslim Student Association during the encampment. He is a third-generation Bruin.
He's now a medical school student,
”We were there to be a part of an education that instilled these core values of ethics, of empathy, of excellence,” he said. “When you really try to internalize those, it was just plain as day that something as significant as ethnic cleansing and genocide is just not something that you can really feel comfortable being silent about.”
He said he’s disillusioned with the institution he once held in so much regard. Mirza was present at the encampment the night the mob attacked it and felt let down by university officials and law enforcement.
When he applied to med school, he said, he grappled with feeling ”thrown under the bus and stigmatized for speaking for a cause that I found very important.” He wanted to talk about what drives his empathy and compassion but felt institutions didn’t value that.
Mirza said he wanted his “convictions and values” to come through in his graduate school application. He said he tweaked his messaging and “just tried to portray myself in the most honest light and I'm very glad that it worked out and I am where I am.”
Mirza wouldn’t change anything about his advocacy for Palestinian rights.
“I think that the only thing I would do differently is I would invest a lot more resources in the community around us instead of trying to prove that the university was what we thought it was,” he said.
Driven by moral convictions
If anyone understands how student protesters move forward, it is Asaad Traina. Traina, now an internal medicine and addiction medicine physician, was part of the group infamously dubbed the Irvine 11. Traina and his fellow students were arrested and charged when they disrupted a speech by Michael Oren, then-Israeli ambassador to the United States, to accuse him of war crimes.
”The district attorney, who was Tony Rackauckas at the time, charged all of us with two misdemeanors,” Traina told LAist. “It completely changed a lot of things about my life, changed the trajectory.”
At the time, Traina was applying to medical school. Of the 16 schools he applied to, he only got into one, despite having a “competitive application.”
Students now have it much harder, he said. While he had a criminal record, plus the case made national headlines, it was before the era of social media and websites that track protesters, like Canary Mission. Traina said he spoke to some students at Harvard University who had a billboard with their names and faces on it.
“I never had to deal with anything like that, like the very aggressive kind of sinister level of doxxing that they're facing now,” he said.
Despite the arrest and charges changing his life, Traina — who has since had his record expunged — says he has no regrets and that he learned a lot from that experience.
”As I get older, I have three kids now, I have a family, I don't wanna be arrested for protests,” Traina said. “But at the same time, I hope I don't give up that kind of courage and willingness to stand up for what's right, which is why I am very inspired by the students and all of their activism now that I think is having a much bigger impact than we ever imagined possible.”