One year ago, Congress defunded public media. Now that we're 100% community funded, please become a sustaining member or increase your existing membership today.
This archival content was originally written for and published on KPCC.org. Keep in mind that links and images may no longer work — and references may be outdated.
What we know about the knife found at OJ Simpson's former home
Los Angeles police are investigating a knife that was found at the former estate of O.J. Simpson that was recently acquired by officers.
At some point in the last month, the department became aware of a knife allegedly recovered at Simpson's former property on Rockingham Avenue in Brentwood, possibly during the 1998 demolition of the site, according to LAPD spokesman Capt. Andrew Neiman.
Neiman said investigators are not sure whether the knife is in fact evidence at this point. He said forensic experts were currently testing it to determine whether it would be submitted to the still-open O.J. Simpson murder case.
The former NFL star and actor was acquitted in the 1995 double homicide of his ex-wife Nicole Brown Simpson and Ronald Goldman. That case is now the subject of a TV miniseries.
The item has been submitted to a lab for study, Neiman said, where it will be tested for blood, DNA and hair samples.
Police are still not sure exactly how the knife came into their possession, Neiman said.
The details so far are sketchy and come from a retired LAPD motorcycle officer who told police he obtained the knife from someone who said he was a construction worker while the site was being demolished. The officer said he was off-duty working on a film, which Neiman said is not uncommon for off-duty and retired officers.
What was uncommon, Neiman said, was that an officer would not turn over possible evidence in a murder case.
"I was really surprised. I would think that an LAPD officer — if this story is accurate as we're being told — would know that anytime you come into contact with evidence, that you should and shall submit that to investigators," he said.
He added that the department could not take administrative action against the former officer as he had since retired.
George Williams, police trainer and director at Cutting Edge Training, said not booking evidence is "totally against protocol."
In order for evidence to be filed as part of a case, Williams said a "report is written as to all the facts: where it was found, how it was found, when it was found."
Police are currently looking for the construction worker who reportedly handed over the knife, and Neiman called on that person come forward if they were watching Friday morning's press conference.
Neiman would not describe the knife, saying details about the knife are central to determining whether it should be considered evidence or if it is simply a fake or made-up story.
The Simpson-Goldman murder is still considered an open case, since no one was ever convicted of the crime.
Pulling DNA off a weapon years after the crime is possible, according to Edward Imwinkelried, UC Davis law professor emeritus and author of a book on scientific evidence.
"They've extracted DNA from mummies, hundreds of years after they've died. DNA is incredibly durable," Imwinkelried said.
However, he said there can be challenges when evidence has undergone "environmental assault," which the knife found at Simpson's house may have. For example, if a piece of evidence has faced weather conditions for a number of years, it loses the probability for classic nuclear DNA to be collected and used for random-match probabilities.
Another challenge Imwinkelried mentioned is lifting fingerprints from the knife.
"The criminal isn't stopping to make sure he leaves a perfect palm print impression on the handle of the knife," he said. "If you layer on top of that years of exposure to the elements, then it really diminishes the probability that you can have good fingerprint evidence extracted from that knife."
Plus, even if useable DNA or fingerprints are lifted from the knife, Imwinkelried said there are legal difficulties with long-lost evidence, such as this knife.
"You've got this huge practical legal problem of establishing the chain of custody to prove that at the time of the analysis it was in the same condition as at the time of the crime," he said.
Simpson, a former football star, was acquitted of the murders of his ex-wife and her friend in 1995. The knife used in the stabbings was never found.
Neiman said even if the knife recovered is linked to the murders, Simpson cannot be retried for the homicides because of double jeopardy, experts advised. The legal defense broadly prevents a murder defendant from being retried for the same crime.
This story has been updated.