I’m Fine, But Mad, After Right Wing Extremists Attacked Me Outside City Hall
Something happened to me last Saturday that’s never happened to me in 30 years of news reporting in Los Angeles: I was attacked. I’m fine. But I’m mad as hell.
It happened on the South Lawn of City Hall, where I’ve gone hundreds of times to cover everything from immigration marches to Occupy L.A. to Chamber of Commerce events to mayoral inaugurations.
The South Lawn is truly one of the great civic gathering places in L.A. It’s also beautiful, expanding from a wide, sweeping set of stairs at the base of the majestic granite centerpiece of city government. There are tons of trees, lots of green grass, and a monument to former U.S. Senator Frank Putnam Flint in the middle.
Saturday’s event was billed as a “Stop Socialism, Choose Freedom March Against Medical Tyranny.” It was mostly an anti-vaccination rally, but included lots of big blue and red Trump flags, Recall Gavin Newsom signs, and “Don’t Tread on Me” flags — the American revolutionary-era symbol adopted years ago by the Tea Party that also was flown by some of the people who stormed the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6.
Several hundred people gathered around a loudspeaker at the base of the steps, listening to speakers denounce mask and vaccine mandates, and warn against what they see as looming tyranny in America.
The Man With The Bloody Bandage
Just a few steps into the park, I noticed a man with a bloody bandage on his head. I asked what had happened and he said he’d gotten into a fight with “antifa.” At that point, I identified myself as a reporter. He asked who I was with.
I said KPCC radio and LAist. He laughed and said he was familiar with the station. He said he likes the BBC.
Perfect, I thought. He’ll give me an interview. Instead, he declined. He said he didn’t trust the media, that it twists things, even though I seemed like a nice guy.
His was the only visible face in a crowd of about a half dozen guys around him. They all had face coverings and dark glasses on. Some wore fatigues, others shorts. They looked to range in age from their late 20's to early 40's. All, as I found out an instant later, were very angry.
I walked a few feet away, then came back and started to ask the guy I had been talking to whether he wanted to talk anonymously. The men with him immediately started cursing at me and telling me to “get the f*** out of here.”
Initially, I was confused. What set them off? Was it just that I was a “mainstream” journalist wanting to ask questions?
When I told them that it was a public park, they exploded.
One shoved me in the chest. Another came from behind, grabbed my hat, and ripped my prescription sunglasses off my head. As I turned to leave, I told them I was going to find a cop. They called me an anti-gay slur and “little bitch.”
It's On Video
There is a video of the attack. It starts just after I’m shoved in the chest. I’m the guy in the light-colored shirt and dark pants with my back to the camera just after it passes a group of women.
Cue the conspiracy theories: You can hear on the tape a woman warn that my presence is some sort of provocation by opponents. “It’s a false flag. Don’t give them what they want,” she yells.
Later, others would call me antifa, an atheist, and a communist. Some threatened violence.
As I walked away, some of the guys followed me. I was scared. But I was not going to run.
As I reached the sidewalk, you can see a man running up to me from behind and kicking me.
Here's the video: Note that it has offensive language
Going through my livestream footage now. I believe this is KPCC reporter Frank Stoltze getting harassed, shoved, & kicked by Proud Boys who call him a "faggot" and a "bitch". The person who kicked him at the end started another fight shortly after w/ someone sitting in the park. pic.twitter.com/HbTC1xlAhf— Andrew Kimmel (@andrewkimmel) August 16, 2021
The man who kicked me later knocked my phone out of my hand as I was trying (from a distance) to record him harassing some other people.
That happens at the end of this video:
Journalism is a tightknit profession. That’s especially true for those of us who work the streets of L.A. A Los Angeles Times reporter and an AP photographer came to my aid as I escaped the violence.
There were police nearby but none indicated they’d witnessed what took place. LAPD officers were all stationed along the sidewalk on First Street in front of LAPD headquarters. If they had been stationed along Spring and Main Streets too, they might have had a better view.
While the vast majority of those at the rally were peaceful, two people were stabbed that day as protesters and counter-protesters clashed. Both are in stable condition. Neither has been identified. Both sides blame the other. No arrests have been made.
Other people were punched, sprayed with Mace and knocked to the ground.
Political violence is on the rise in L.A.
A Black woman was attacked in almost the same place as I was during a pro-Trump rally on Jan. 6, as the U.S. Capitol was under siege. Two people were stabbed earlier this summer during an anti-transgender protest outside Wi Spa in Koreatown. There were no arrests in those attacks, either.
A leftist “activist journalist” we profiled earlier this year — Vishal Singh — was beat up in the alley behind Harlowe Restaurant in West Hollywood as he was trying to videotape another anti-vaccination protest. The next day, another videographer who documents right-wing movements was forced to seek refuge in a Trader Joe’s as anti-vaccination protesters chased him.
'We Ask...The Public To Police Themselves'
Many critics of law enforcement say officers have taken a laissez faire approach to confrontations at protests organized by the right, compared with their aggressive posture during last year’s protests over the murder of George Floyd. On Saturday I witnessed police officers stand idly by as protestors carried long poles that were among the items prohibited at protests last year because they could be used as weapons.
An LAPD spokesman vehemently denied any bias. He told me that they treat all protests equally.
He also said police are stretched thin.
“At some point, we ask the members of the public to police themselves,” said Lt. Raul Jovel. “We just can’t be on every corner” — even though the protest happened across the street from LAPD headquarters.
Bonus video: This shows a rally organizer trying to get the man who kicked me to leave.
Anthony Lowe was shot and killed by Huntington Park police on Jan. 26. 'Thank goodness that we’re in the era of videos,' said the family attorney as they file a federal civil rights lawsuit
In a memo, Chief Michel Moore said “extremist groups have hijacked the use of the ‘Thin Blue Line Flag’ to symbolize their undemocratic, racist, and bigoted views.”
LAPD Chief Moore also questioned officers' actions in the fatal shooting of Takar Smith, although not in two other fatal incidents.
In a conversation with LAist, the new sheriff acknowledges that, as an outsider, "I have my work cut out for me" in winning the support of the department's rank-and-file.
He was elected in 2018 after running as a progressive Democrat who would reform the department. He ended up fiercely resisting oversight and clashing with watchdogs and the rest of the county’s political establishment.