Sponsored message
Logged in as
Audience-funded nonprofit news
radio tower icon laist logo
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
Subscribe
  • Listen Now Playing Listen

This archival content was originally written for and published on KPCC.org. Keep in mind that links and images may no longer work — and references may be outdated.

KPCC Archive

Lawsuit claims California fails to correct nursing home misconduct

QUINCY, IL - FEBRUARY 16: A veteran sits in a wheelchair at the Quincy Veterans Home February 16, 2005 in Quincy, Illinois. The home, with its 683 beds, is the largest and oldest of four veteran's nursing homes in Illinois. The federal budget, as currently proposed by the Bush Administration, seeks to reduce the number of residents nationwide in these facilities from 38,000 to 33,000. (Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images)
QUINCY, IL - FEBRUARY 16: A veteran sits in a wheelchair at the Quincy Veterans Home February 16, 2005 in Quincy, Illinois. The home, with its 683 beds, is the largest and oldest of four veteran's nursing homes in Illinois. The federal budget, as currently proposed by the Bush Administration, seeks to reduce the number of residents nationwide in these facilities from 38,000 to 33,000. (Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images)
(
Scott Olson/Getty Images
)

One year ago, Congress defunded public media. Now that we're 100% community funded, please become a sustaining member or increase your existing membership today.

Listen 0:48
Lawsuit claims California fails to correct nursing home misconduct

A consumer advocacy group has sued California’s Health and Human Services Agency for its alleged failure to prevent nursing homes from illegally refusing to readmit Medi-Cal residents who were sent away to receive hospital care.

The California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform, which this week filed the lawsuit along with three nursing home residents, alleges that as many as half of the state's nursing facilities are engaged in this practice.

The plaintiffs claim that nursing homes refuse readmission to some Medi-Cal residents who need temporary care in a hospital as a way to open up beds for higher paying private-pay or Medicare residents. The plaintiffs characterize this practice as "patient dumping." They claim it's cost California taxpayers more than $70 million during the past ten years because many people are forced to stay in hospitals, which charge Medi-Cal many times more than do nursing facilities. 

When a Medi-Cal enrollee who lives in a nursing home is transferred to a hospital for temporary care and then refused readmission to his nursing facility, federal law requires the opportunity for an appeal hearing, according to the lawsuit, which adds that states are also required to enforce the hearing decisions. The complaint cites a 2012 letter from the federal Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services that explains those legal obligations to California's Department of Public Health.

While California's Department of Health Care Services does conduct hearings in such cases, plaintiffs say, they contends the state does not provide residents with "their right to an administrative procedure for prompt readmission if they are successful." 

Public records indicate there have been about 500 appeals of nursing homes' refusals to readmit residents over the past decade, says Tony Chicotel, staff attorney for California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform. About 90 percent are decided "in favor of the appellant," he says.

Chicotel believes many other Medi-Cal enrollees who could request a hearing don't take that step, based on his organization's conversations with hospital discharge personnel and family members.

Sponsored message

"One of the problems is they don't even know they have a right to a hearing," Chicotel says. "We have a lot of reason to think this is just the tip of the iceberg."

A spokeperson for California's Health and Human Services Agency says the department is unable to comment on pending litigation.

The California Association of Health Facilities - the trade association that represents nursing homes statewide -  denies that nursing homes and assisted-living facilities are illegally refusing to readmit residents who receive hospital care.   

"No one has been 'dumped,'"  Deborah Pacyna, the organizations director of public affairs writes in an email to KPCC. "We strongly reject any notion that patient admissions or discharges are tied to payment sources. Most of our patients – 66 percent – are already on Medi-Cal which barely covers the cost of 24 hour care."

The three nursing home plaintiffs named in the lawsuit filed in federal court in San Francisco are all Medi-Cal enrollees.  Each was refused readmission to a nursing facility after receiving temporary hospital care; each won a readmission order after a hearing but has not been allowed to return, the suit says. Two of the three have been forced to remain in hospitals since June and July, respectively. One has moved to a new nursing facility "hundreds of miles away from his family," according to the complaint.

One year ago, Congress voted to defund public media, eliminating a critical $1.7 million from our budget every year going forward. But they couldn’t silence us, and we’re not going anywhere. LAist is now 100% community funded and that means we’re taking our future into our own hands and turning to you to keep local reporting strong.

You come to LAist because you want independent reporting and trustworthy local information. Our nonprofit newsroom doesn’t answer to shareholders looking to turn a profit. Instead, we answer to you and our communities. We are free to follow facts wherever they lead and to hold power to account without fear or favor. Our only loyalty is to our readers and listeners and our mission: to inform, engage, and strengthen Southern California’s communities.

If this story helped you, please become a monthly member today to help sustain this mission. It just takes 1 minute to donate below.
Senior Vice President News, Editor in Chief

Make your tax-deductible donation today