Sponsored message
Logged in as
Audience-funded nonprofit news
radio tower icon laist logo
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
Subscribe
  • Listen Now Playing Listen

The Brief

The most important stories for you to know today
  • City has only 4 working restrooms on sidewalks
    A photo of a multi-colored structure with red, orange, yellow and black paint on the walls. There's a door on the left side with a blue and grey sign. There's a stainless steel sink on a side wall.
    A standalone restroom run by the city of L.A. is one of four working sidewalk toilets in the Skid Row area.

    Topline:

    Los Angeles has 14 permanent public toilets on its sidewalks. Only four work, and all of them are located on Skid Row. The other 10, scattered from the San Fernando Valley to South L.A., are closed.

    Why now: Last month, Councilmembers Ysabel Jurado and Nithya Raman, now the city’s mayor-elect, introduced a motion calling on the city to fix the problem. It asks the city administrative officer to report within 60 days on a plan to keep the four Skid Row toilets funded and add more public toilets, handwashing stations and permanent water spigots across the city.

    The backstory: The city’s toilet shortage goes back decades. A 2001 deal with advertising company Outfront/JCDecaux could have put up to 150 self-cleaning toilets on city sidewalks, but permit delays left the city with just 14, LAist reported in 2023.

    The city's Bureau of Street Services absorbed the cost of running all 14 toilets in fiscal year 2023-24, and the following year, the costs were covered largely by discretionary funds from Council District 14, which includes Skid Row.

    What's next: Jurado and Raman’s motion was referred to L.A.’s Homelessness and Health Committee for consideration. The committee approved the motion Nov. 10. It will now go to the full City Council.

    The city of Los Angeles has a public bathroom problem.

    Three years ago, LAist reported that in a city of nearly 4 million residents, there were only 14 permanent public toilets on the streets. Today, four of them work, according to city documents.

    All four are on Skid Row.

    The other 10, scattered from the San Fernando Valley to South L.A., are closed. Most shut down in July 2025, when the city’s 2025-26 budget included no money to operate them, according to the City Controller’s office.

    Last month, Councilmembers Ysabel Jurado and Nithya Raman, now the city’s mayor-elect, introduced a motion calling on the city to fix the problem. It asks the city administrative officer to report within 60 days on a plan to keep the four Skid Row toilets funded and add more public toilets, handwashing stations and permanent water spigots across the city.

    “This woefully inadequate scale of public hygiene infrastructure has left the streets of Los Angeles, especially in underinvested areas such as Skid Row, without consistent access to sanitation and water,” they wrote.

    Photo shows the inside of a public restroom in Skid Row. There is a metal toilet with a black seat, lifted up, that is attached to a far wall. There graffiti scrawled on all of the interior walls. There is a small blue sign with white text on an exterior wall that reads, "All gender restroom."
    An interior view of a public restroom in downtown L.A.'s Skid Row.
    (
    Dana Littlefield
    /
    LAist
    )

    City sanitation crews collected more than 70 tons of human waste from the public right-of-way in 2025, according to the motion. LAist reached out to the city for information on how much waste was cleaned up in previous years, but did not get a response in time for publication.

    Jurado’s office used more than $200,000 in discretionary funds to help keep the Skid Row toilets open.

    “Our office committed discretionary funding and advocated during the budget process to keep four public restrooms open in Skid Row,” Jurado said in a statement. “But keeping essential facilities open cannot depend on individual council offices filling funding gaps year after year.”

    How we got here

    The four working toilets are the city’s standalone sidewalk toilets, run by the Bureau of Street Services, also known as StreetsLA. They are separate from restrooms inside city parks and libraries and from the app-operated Throne restrooms L.A. Metro has installed at more than 60 transit stations.

    The city’s toilet shortage goes back decades. A 2001 deal with advertising company Outfront/JCDecaux could have put up to 150 self-cleaning toilets on city sidewalks, but permit delays left the city with just 14, LAist reported in 2023.

    When that contract ended in 2022, the city replaced the toilets with its own, and StreetsLA said at the time that all 14 would be open by mid-April the following year.

    StreetsLA absorbed the cost of running all 14 toilets in fiscal year 2023-24, the Controller’s Office said, citing the bureau. The next year, the costs were covered largely by discretionary funds from Council District 14, which includes Skid Row. The 2025-26 budget left the program out.

    This year, the City Council’s budget committee asked City Administrative Officer Matthew Szabo for ways to fund the toilets. StreetsLA estimated it would cost $1 million to operate the 10 closed toilets, but Szabo recommended against adding the money, according to a May budget memo the Controller’s office shared with LAist.

    StreetsLA declined an interview request. In a statement, the bureau confirmed the four Skid Row toilets are open and said the city “is committed to identifying additional funding.”

    It did not say when the others might reopen.

    Inside the working bathrooms

    According to the City Controller’s Office, the four open toilets are located at:

    • 509 S. San Julian St.
    • 814 E. 6th St.
    • 204 E. 5th St. 
    • 545 S. San Pedro St.

    On San Pedro Street near Sixth, the restroom is a squat cinder-block building painted with a mural of a blue heron in orange and green. Two sinks are set into its outside wall. The paint is chipped, peeling and tagged with graffiti, but the stalls inside were clean and stocked with toilet paper and soap.

    A worker from Five Keys Schools and Programs was stationed outside. The city has paid the nonprofit, which runs reentry programs for people leaving incarceration, to staff the Skid Row toilets since at least 2024, under a contract worth up to about $7.9 million a year that also covers mobile showers and Skid Row street cleaning.

    Image of a public restroom in L.A.'s Skid Row. The standalone restroom door is open and a man is inside, leaning over to clean it. He is wearing dark clothing and a blue apron on his waist.
    A man working for the nonprofit Five Keys cleans the inside of a public restroom in L.A.'s Skid Row community.
    (
    Samhita Krishnan
    )

    Under its Pit Stop program, attendants clean the stalls and nearby sidewalks, pick up used needles and hand out hygiene kits with soap, toothpaste and, for women, menstrual products, according to the nonprofit’s website. Five Keys says its Pit Stops serve about 50,000 visits a month at 15 sites downtown.

    Richard Baker, who does community outreach for Five Keys and works at the Pit Stops in Skid Row, said the job goes beyond cleaning. He carries naloxone, also known by the brand name Narcan, a medication that can rapidly reverse an opioid overdose. And, he said, he helps people find food and shelter.

    A man with dark skin who is wearing a dark gray hooded sweatshirt and white sunglasses stands in front of a painted van.
    Richard Baker, who works with the nonprofit Five Keys, stands near one of the city's available public toilets in the Skid Row area.
    (
    Dana Littlefield
    /
    LAist
    )

    “These restrooms are important for people on the streets. … Sometimes they just need 10 minutes to get their thoughts together,” Baker said. “It’s chaos out here.”

    The San Pedro Street restroom gets about 50 to 100 visitors a day, he said, adding that the city needs many more.

    “There’s feces everywhere,” Baker said. “It’s highly unsanitary.”

    A 26-year-old woman on Skid Row who identified herself as “Seven” told LAist she relies on public restrooms when she’s with her son. Often, she said, it is hard to find a place for her son to use the restroom, and it gets even more difficult when they’re on the move.

    “I have had him pee on the sidewalk before,” she said. “Kids, they need to use the bathroom all the time.”

    It’s about 'human dignity’

    Ricky Bluthenthal, chair of the Department of Population and Public Health Sciences at USC’s Keck School of Medicine, studies harm reduction — a set of strategies aimed at minimizing the negative consequences associated with drug use.

    When people can’t wash, he said, they are more likely to get sick. People who inject drugs face higher risks of skin and bacterial infections. Hepatitis A spreads through contact with feces. In 2017, an outbreak of the virus that largely affected unhoused people and people who use drugs killed 21 Californians, most of them in San Diego. Los Angeles County recorded 12 cases.

    Asked whether an outbreak like that could happen again, he said: “Yeah, of course.”

    “On some level, it’s just about human dignity,” Bluthenthal said. “People should be able to, in this country, have access to restrooms that they can safely use.”

    He said unhoused people often can’t walk far to find a bathroom. Many worry their belongings will be taken if they leave them behind, and some Skid Row streets are dangerous, especially for women.

    That’s why restrooms need to be close by, he said.

    “It’s not like it’s impossible to do,” he said. “It’s more like, do you have the will to set it up and the resources to sort of make sure it’s monitored and clean?”

    The view from the driver’s seat

    For people who work on the road, finding a bathroom is essential.

    Rebecca De La O, 26, started driving for Uber about a month ago. She tracks which Whole Foods, Starbucks and Ralphs restrooms she can use and saves their door codes in her phone.

    Every stop means pausing the app, and drivers aren’t paid for that time, she said. She usually buys something when she goes in, often spending $2 to $14. At night, when most stores close, she limits what she eats and drinks.

    She would like to see more public restrooms, she said, but only if the city keeps them clean.

    “If they’re going to invest in more public restrooms, they also have to invest in constant upkeep and maintenance,” she said.

    Transit riders also have problems finding available restrooms.

    Stacy Mata, who graduated in June from UCLA’s urban planning master’s program, audited transit stations for a policy brief published by the UCLA Lewis Center. She found that L.A. has “one of the lowest rates of public restroom availability among major U.S. cities.”

    “I saw multiple examples of the bathroom infrastructure existing but being completely fenced off,” she said.

    What’s next

    Jurado and Raman’s motion was referred to L.A.’s Homelessness and Health Committee for consideration. The committee approved the motion Nov. 10. It will now go to the full City Council.

    Among the options it asks the city to study are public-private partnerships, such as the Hollywood Partnership’s 40 public bathroom stalls at a city garage on Vine Street, and sites on city and county property, including near Metro stations. The council members also request that the city recommend whether StreetsLA should keep running the program or hand it to another department.

    The motion asks whether state homelessness funds could pay for restrooms. In his May memo, Szabo said they could not.

    With millions of visitors expected to arrive in L.A. for the 2028 Olympics, LA28 said its restroom plans “are still taking shape.”

  • 97% of union vote in favor
    An older feminine presenting person with dark hair and glasses wearing a black puffer jacket holds a sign that reads "CFA/California Faculty Association/On Strike!" behind them are out of focus groups of people in red standing on a wet pavement on a rainy day.
    Chicano and Latino Studies Department lecturer Theresa Yugar stands for a portrait at a California Faculty Association members strike at California State University Los Angeles on Jan. 22, 2024.

    Topline:

    California State University faculty members have voted in favor of giving their bargaining team the authority to call a strike after negotiations with administrators reached an impasse, their union announced Friday.

    What does the faculty want: The California Faculty Association, which represents 29,000 faculty members across the CSU schools, last went on strike in January 2024. While the union is asking for pay raises, they also want provisions to align with all the ways higher education has changed since the last contract. The union wants CSU to guarantee academic freedom in the face of pressure from the Trump administration over DEI cuts and artificial intelligence guardrails.

    What's next: Even though members voted in favor of a strike, negotiations can still continue.

    California State University faculty members have voted in favor of giving their bargaining team the authority to call a strike after negotiations with administrators reached an impasse, their union announced Friday. About 97% of members voted in favor of a strike.

    The California Faculty Association, which represents 29,000 faculty members across the CSU schools, last went on strike in January 2024. While the union is asking for pay raises, they also want provisions to align with all the ways higher education has changed since the last contract. The union wants CSU to guarantee academic freedom in the face of pressure from the Trump administration over DEI cuts and artificial intelligence guardrails.

    Even though members voted in favor of a strike, contract talks can still continue.

    LAist has reached out to CSU for comment and will update the story when we hear back.

    How we got here

    During the union’s last strike in 2024, class was disrupted for roughly 500,000 students. The strike lasted one day — to the disbelief of many union members.

    “The last contract sucked. The union caved after one day. We had all the momentum of faculty here and a lot of support to keep the strike going,” Helen Hood Scheer, a cinematic arts professor at Cal State Long Beach, told LAist earlier this month. “However, I will say that at some of the other CSUs that are not as healthy as we are, I think some other people felt like it was a good contract.”

    After some members voiced disappointment with the last contract and the strike ending after a day, the union made some changes to the bargaining team by including a member from each campus.

    Since the last contract, the union says, the higher-education landscape has also changed.

    Contract negotiations have centered on federal funding cuts to research and to grants that sought to increase representation of historically excluded groups on campus. This time around, CSU faculty members also want strong artificial intelligence guardrails after the CSU system recently renewed a controversial contract with OpenAI that costs $13 million annually. Faculty members say they were not consulted on that decision.

  • Sponsored message
  • Kimchi Day at the Los Angeles County Arboretum
    A person wearing white gloves digs their hands into a pot of Kimchi to mix it up. Flowers and other foliage can be seen below the pot. The person is wearing a white shirt and black pants.
    A person mixes a pot of kimchi while wearing food preparation gloves.

    Topline:

    California Kimchi Fest is taking place Saturday at the L.A. County Arboretum to celebrate California Kimchi Day.

    Why it matters: The thousands-year old practice of making kimchi is important to Korean culture. California was the first state to designate Nov. 22 the official day for the Korean fermented vegetable dish in 2021.

    What will be there: The star of the show is a hands-on kimchi making workshop. The festival also includes Korean food stalls, a Korean marketplace, and performances of K-Pop and traditional dance and drums.

    What'll it cost: Entry is free with Arboretum admission — $18 for adults and $8 for children under 12.

    Go deeper: {if you have stories you want to link add them here}

    Los Angeles has designated Nov. 22 as Kimchi Day to recognize the importance of the dish to Korean culture. Just in time for California Kimchi Fest, happening Saturday at the Los Angeles County Arboretum in Arcadia.

    In 2021, California became the first state to honor kimchi with an annual day of recognition.

    Kimchi festival

    California Kimchi Fest
    Where: Los Angeles County Arboretum and Botanic Gardens, 301 N. Baldwin Ave, Arcadia
    When: Saturday, Nov. 21, 11 a.m. to 3 p.m.
    Cost: Free with Arboretum admission; $18 for adults and $8 for children under 12

    A communal activity

    There are varieties of Kimchi, but the most common type found in Southern California restaurants is likely poggi, made from cabbage.

    “Probably the first time anyone eats kimchi, it's usually poggi,” said Su Oh, the Arboretum’s CEO.

    A highlight of the festival is a kimjang workshop, the late autumn tradition of making and sharing kimchi communally that’s been practiced in Korea for over 2,000 years.

    “ In the beginning, it was a preservation method, to preserve harvest through the harsh winters,” Oh said. “But now it is such a unique part of our heritage.”

    Celebrating the “K-Wave”

    A wide shot of shoppers inside a Korean grocery store looking through the aisles for their produce. A crowd can be seen around the fruits and vegetables stacked in piles. Two men on the left side of the picture have carts. One man in the center of the picture has a backpack on.
    Shoppers inside the Korean grocery store, California Market, one of the featured vendors at California Kimchi Fest.
    (
    California Market
    /
    California Market
    )

    The festival includes a Korean marketplace with more than 20 vendors, Korean food stands, traditional dance and drums, and a K-Pop performance.

    “There’s a big, as they say, ‘K-Wave’ happening right now,” Oh said. ”We’re just wanting to share that all here at this location.”

  • Budget analyst warns of stock market risk
    People walking outdoors with the state capitol in the background.
    The California State Capitol in Sacramento on May 6, 2025.

    Topline:

    Despite raking in near-record revenues, California faces a possible budget shortfall for the fifth year in a row and remains vulnerable to a downturn in the stock market, according to an annual budget report the Legislative Analyst’s Office released on Wednesday.

    Facing billions in deficit: While the LAO projects the state could face a $2 billion deficit for the 2027-28 budget year — modest in comparison to projections in recent years — it warns the shortfall could exceed $15 billion the following year. That’s because the state is consistently spending more than it earns, largely on the back of personal income and corporate tax revenue.

    Stock market effect: But the bigger concern, Petek said, is the looming threat of a stock market crash, which could push California’s annual deficits past $30 billion given the state budget’s reliance on volatile revenue streams. For years, the LAO has warned the Legislature to be wary of a possibly overheated stock market and a speculative bubble from the booming artificial intelligence industry. The warning comes amid turmoil in Silicon Valley, even as AI lab Anthropic prepares to make a massive debut on the stock market this week.

    Despite raking in near-record revenues, California faces a possible budget shortfall for the fifth year in a row and remains vulnerable to a downturn in the stock market, according to an annual budget report the Legislative Analyst’s Office released on Wednesday.

    The report, which serves as a starting point for state budget proposals and negotiations, comes as Democratic Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra prepares to take office and work with lawmakers on his first spending plan.

    While the LAO projects the state could face a $2 billion deficit for the 2027-28 budget year — modest in comparison to projections in recent years — it warns the shortfall could exceed $15 billion the following year.

    That’s because the state is consistently spending more than it earns, largely on the back of personal income and corporate tax revenue.

    “Our central message here is that the state budget is overextended at this point,” California Legislative Analyst Gabriel Petek told reporters on Wednesday.

    But the bigger concern, Petek said, is the looming threat of a stock market crash, which could push California’s annual deficits past $30 billion given the state budget’s reliance on volatile revenue streams.

    For years, the LAO has warned the Legislature to be wary of a possibly overheated stock market and a speculative bubble from the booming artificial intelligence industry.

    On Wednesday, Petek again encouraged careful spending and for the state to grow its reserves to prepare for a possible downturn.

    “While the stock market’s recent run has been great for many investors and the state budget, it now appears to have advanced to a dangerous stage,” Petek said in the report. “The risk now facing state revenues is that this boom, like many in the past, will abruptly end in a bust.”

    The warning comes amid turmoil in Silicon Valley, even as AI lab Anthropic prepared for its debut on the stock market this week.

    California-based chip manufacturer Nvidia saw its stock price go into a tailspin last week after CEO Jensen Huang admitted to an extramarital affair with an alleged Chinese spy and resigned.

    Petek and other experts say it remains to be seen how the company’s recent fall will affect California’s projected revenues. The state’s progressive tax structure means it relies heavily on tax revenue from corporations and high-income residents.

    However, experts are steadfast in the message that Nvidia’s plummeting stock price alone won’t drastically harm the state’s fiscal position.

    “I don’t think that we’re likely to see any immediate impact on the state budget from their stock price falling,” said Chris Hoene, executive director of the California Budget and Policy Center. “The taxes that they pay to the state aren’t necessarily based on the stock price; they’re based on the sales of their chips.”

    California has long navigated the ups and downs of individual technology companies, which haven’t moved the needle significantly for the state’s fiscal outlook.

    The state’s booming, homegrown AI industry has brought an unexpected budget windfall to the tune of billions of dollars. Revenues started to soar in 2024-25 due to investor enthusiasm and a subsequent stock market rally.

    The pressing question, some experts and lawmakers say, is whether Nvidia’s recent decline signals the start of a broader economic downturn, one triggered by an overvaluation of AI companies in general.

    “Where it would be a concern is if it were a precursor to a broader selloff in the market,” said Petek.

    If that’s the case, California could see a dramatic drop in revenue.

    “Obviously there are financial consequences to what has happened with Nvidia, but those are more modest compared to what we might see if there is a broader market downturn or a broader bubble that’s burst with AI,” said Assemblymember Jesse Gabriel, D-Los Angeles, who chairs the Assembly Budget Committee.

    At the same time, California could get an unexpected bump in income tax revenue from Anthropic’s initial public offering on Thursday, as many of its employees and investors are expected to suddenly become very wealthy. But the size of that bump is hard to know.

    “Obviously, when some of these companies go public, when they do well, it can have important consequences for our state budget.

    But again, I think it’s looking at the sector more broadly that is going to tell us the real story about where we’re headed,” Gabriel said.

    Becerra is expected to release his first budget blueprint in early January. The governor’s annual budget forecast typically differs from LAO projections in terms of a possible budget deficit.

  • It shows how LBPD responded to ICE call for help
    A screenshot from body camera footage showing an ICE agent with a face mask standing next to a black SUV as other agents stand on the other side in a residential street.
    A screenshot from body camera footage shows how Long Beach police interacted with federal immigration agents in North Long Beach on Oct. 17, 2026.

    Topline:

    When neighbors surrounded ICE agents who’d injured a man in North Long Beach last month, local police cleared the roadway to help them leave, newly released body camera video shows. It was the quickest way to safely diffuse the tense situation, according to the Long Beach Police Department, even as some neighbors accused officers of helping immigration officials, something they are banned from doing in most cases.

    About the video: The 17-minute video shows LBPD officers at a chaotic scene where neighbors are yelling angrily at ICE agents and blocking agents’ cars, including one vehicle holding a person they said was wrongfully detained. Police begin clearing cars and people out of the streets so ICE agents can leave before an LBPD officer says a supervisor has ordered officers to leave the scene.

    A fight over body camera footage: The video’s release comes more than a month after the incident, which grabbed national headlines and sparked calls for a federal investigation from Long Beach’s mayor and congressional representatives. LBPD initially completely denied the Post’s request for a release of all relevant body camera footage and 911 audio, claiming the department was not required to release them because the video and audio were collected as part of an investigation.

    Read on... for more on the video.

    This story first appeared on Long Beach Post.

    When neighbors surrounded ICE agents who’d injured a man in North Long Beach last month, local police cleared the roadway to help them leave, newly released body camera video shows. It was the quickest way to safely diffuse the tense situation, according to the Long Beach Police Department, even as some neighbors accused officers of helping immigration officials, something they are banned from doing in most cases.

    The 17-minute video shows LBPD officers at a chaotic scene where neighbors are yelling angrily at ICE agents and blocking agents’ cars, including one vehicle holding a person they said was wrongfully detained.

    Police begin clearing cars and people out of the streets so ICE agents can leave before an LBPD officer says a supervisor has ordered officers to leave the scene.

    “We’re being ordered to pull out, so you guys are going to be on your own,” the LBPD officer wearing the body camera tells an ICE agent. “I’m sure you’re used to it. Good luck.”

    When asked about why officers were ordered to leave, LBPD spokesperson Allison Gallagher said they departed “once there was no longer a public safety need.”

    The footage shows only a portion of what happened and from a single perspective.

    The Long Beach Post has repeatedly requested all relevant body camera footage and 911 audio from that Oct. 17 confrontation, but the LBPD has refused to release most of it.

    Neighbors who spoke to the Post gave a broader perspective. They said several ICE vehicles had been parked in the neighborhood since the early morning.

    That afternoon, a U.S. citizen named Ricardo Gonzalez was riding an e-bike near Elm Avenue and 56th Street when an agent jumped out of an unmarked car and took him to the ground, according to four residents who spoke to the Post.

    Surveillance video showed the agents’ vehicle veering toward Gonzalez, but it’s unclear if they hit him. Neighbors said agents tased Gonzalez twice, and one agent knelt on his back while Gonzalez yelled in pain and said his arm was broken.

    Neighbors said agents also detained two women during the ensuing confrontation, but they were ultimately freed before agents left.

    An ICE spokesperson said Gonzalez was among a group of “anti-ICE agitators” who tried to “impede operations, threaten officers, and damage government vehicles.”

    The spokesperson said agents took Gonzalez into custody after he “smashed the mirror of a government vehicle.” They said agents did not hit him with their vehicle.

    Residents began confronting federal agents while Gonzalez was handcuffed on the ground. Cell phone video of that confrontation quickly went viral.

    The body camera footage released by Long Beach police Thursday provides a fuller view of the aftermath but does not show officers’ initial arrival on scene.

    The officer wearing the body camera even says in the footage he was delayed in activating it.

    In a statement, police said officers showed up because ICE agents made an emergency call for help to the city’s communications center “due to vehicle vandalism taking place and a subject in need of medical attention.”

    Gonzalez was bleeding on the ground when police arrived, according to the LBPD, and officers drove him to a nearby fire station so he could be taken to the hospital.

    Officers also tried “to de-escalate the situation and keep the peace by directing everyone to clear the area.”

    In the body camera footage, one LBPD officer walks up and down the street ordering drivers to move their cars to clear an exit for the unmarked federal vehicles.

    He tells drivers, “We’re trying to de-escalate” and asks one driver to “help me help out.”

    While he’s doing this, one driver asks him, “What about you cooperating with ICE? Because that’s what you’re doing.”

    The officer responds by saying she can move her car or have it towed.

    Near the end of the video, another neighbor yells at the officer while he’s walking by.

    “This is our neighborhood. Our kids live here. What are you going to do to protect that?” she asks.

    The Long Beach Police Department emphasized that officers did not participate in any immigration enforcement and quickly got medical help for Gonzalez.

    “The officers prioritized de-escalating the situation and keeping the peace, which included clearing the street so that ICE agents could leave the area,” Gallagher said.

    When some of the ICE agents followed police to a private parking lot at the police station, they were told to leave, LBPD said.

    A fight over body camera footage

    The video’s release comes more than a month after the incident, which grabbed national headlines and sparked calls for a federal investigation from Long Beach’s mayor and congressional representatives.

    LBPD initially completely denied the Post’s request for a release of all relevant body camera footage and 911 audio, claiming the department was not required to release them because the video and audio were collected as part of an investigation.

    In a statement, LBPD Chief Wally Hebeish said he decided to authorize the release of footage from this one body camera. He said it showed officers “complied with local and state law and acted in accordance with department policy.”

    A public records expert disagrees with police’s justification for keeping secret other evidence of what happened that day.

    David Loy, a lawyer for the First Amendment Coalition, said the LBPD was not legally justified in withholding any footage or audio.

    The investigatory exemption of the California Public Records Act does not apply because LBPD was not investigating a crime that day, Loy said.

    “Police departments do many things that are not about investigating crimes,” Loy said. “It’s not enough to simply say police officers responded and therefore they were automatically investigating a crime.”

    Earlier this year, the First Amendment Coalition sued the City of San Diego over their withholding of body-worn camera footage from two separate incidents involving federal immigration agents last year.