Sponsored message
Logged in as
Audience-funded nonprofit news
radio tower icon laist logo
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
Subscribe
  • Listen Now Playing Listen
AirTalk

New study reveals the science of how we change our minds (updated with clarification)

SAN FRANCISCO - AUGUST 04:  Buttons opposing Proposition 8 are displayed during a rally to celebrate the ruling to overturn Proposition 8 August 4, 2010 in San Francisco, California. U.S. District Judge Vaughn Walker announced his ruling to overturn Proposition 8 finding it unconstitutional. The voter approved measure denies same-sex couples the right to marry in the State of California.  (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)
Buttons opposing Proposition 8 are displayed during a rally to celebrate the ruling to overturn Proposition 8 August 4, 2010 in San Francisco, California. U.S. District Judge Vaughn Walker announced his ruling to overturn Proposition 8 finding it unconstitutional. The voter approved measure denies same-sex couples the right to marry in the State of California.
(
Justin Sullivan/Getty Images
)
Listen 14:36
New study reveals the science of how we change our minds (updated with clarification)

Update, May 28, 2015: Since this AirTalk segment was published on Dec. 11, 2014, Science has retracted the journal article that is the source of the segment. Donald P. Green, who co-authored the study with AirTalk guest Michael LeCour, on May 19, 2015, asked Science to retract the paper, according to Science Editor in Chief Marcia McNutt:



Science, with the concurrence of author Donald P. Green, is retracting the 12 December 2014 Report “When contact changes minds: An experiment on transmission of support for gay equality” by LaCour and Green ( 1 ).



The reasons for retracting the paper are as follows: (i) Survey incentives were misrepresented. To encourage participation in the survey, respondents were claimed to have been given cash payments to enroll, to refer family and friends, and to complete multiple surveys. In correspondence received from Michael J. LaCour’s attorney, he confirmed that no such payments were made. (ii) The statement on sponsorship was false. In the Report, LaCour acknowledged funding from the Williams Institute, the Ford Foundation, and the Evelyn and Walter Haas Jr. Fund. Per correspondence from LaCour’s attorney, this statement was not true.



In addition to these known problems, independent researchers have noted certain statistical irregularities in the responses ( 2 ). LaCour has not produced the original survey data from which someone else could independently confirm the validity of the reported findings.



Michael J. LaCour does not agree to this Retraction.

Other media organizations that reported on the study — including the This American Life and The New York Times — have chosen to add notes like this to their coverage as well.

In light of these developments, KPCC is adding this note advising listeners that the study is not what it purports to be and that the data at its source is falsified. 

Previous segment: Most political strategists will tell you that changing voters’ opinions on divisive issues is difficult if not impossible — and that when it does occur, it is almost always fleeting. But a new study published today in the journal Science finds that a single conversation with the right messenger can go a long way toward building lasting support for a controversial social issue. The study took place in 2013 just a month before the Supreme Court effectively overturned California’s Prop 8, which outlawed same-sex marriage in 2008.

The project followed a long-standing door-to-door campaign in support of gay marriage and found that, while by the end of the year support for gay marriage was slightly up among voters in the study, the increase in support for gay marriage among those who had been contacted by gay canvassers was five times higher than that of the other participants. In addition, and perhaps even more noteworthy, that effect tends to spill over to friends and family members. The study looked specifically at the issues of Americans’ support for gay marriage, but the same researchers are beginning to apply their findings to other contentious issues, starting with abortion rights, and they hope to eventually test whether a similar approach could shift people’s attitudes on immigration.

Have you had similar experiences? When was the last time your mind was changed on a political issue? Was it because you came into contact with someone who was personally affected by the issue? Have you changed someone’s mind?

Guest:

Michael LaCour, Ph. D. candidate in the Department of Political Science and Statistics, University of California at Los Angeles; he co-authored the study in Science