Quantcast

Did Chevy Steal Creative Concept from Popular Blog?

Have you seen Chevy's new "Then & Now: 100 Years of Chevrolet" commercial? Set to the comforting vocals of Ray Charles belting out "America the Beautiful," the ad is quite creative, elicits a heavy wave of nostalgia and is all-American. And its concept might have "borrowed" from the popular blog Dear Photograph.

The blog popularized the "picture in a picture" concept starting in May but is not mentioned anywhere in the ad. Now, Chevy does not use any of the blog's content in the piece, but the concept is note-for-note, says Mashable.

Taylor Jones, Dear Photograph's founder and operator, told Mashable:

When you look at it, there appears to be a lot of creative similarity, so I was hoping they would a least acknowledge that they were inspired by my site. I didn’t invent the technique of taking a picture of a picture — but I did popularize it by creating a unique site that brings together the physical technique with deeply emotional reflections that are expressed as captions. My site receives submissions from around the world and has been seen by more than 10 million visitors [since launch].

Comments on the commercial's YouTube page note the creative similarities between the video and the blog and remind Chevy to properly credit the ad.

Anovakowich wrote, "Cool! I loved it the first time I saw it on DEAR PHOTOGRAPH. Nice. Really should have something like 'inspired by....' Credit clearly should be given."

Another user, akapunishment, commented, "Popularized by 'Dear Photograph' ... maybe not created by 'Dear Photograph' but, definitely played up because of the popularity of 'Dear Photograph' ... guess the guys in the advertising department just couldn't come up with an original idea of their own. And yes, they ripped off 'Dear Photograph' because it's so well known."

Alchemysnap posted, "So you steal this idea from Dear Photograph and not give credit. Pretty disappointing behavior, Chevy."

Perhaps Chevy needed a little Don Draper "Mad Men" action to help bone up their advertising chops to produce the company's centennial.

Contact the author of this article or email tips@laist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • Questionin

    Yeah.... and the Museum of London released an Iphone App that does the exact same thing for history one year before Taylor Jones had his "brilliant" idea... 

    http://www.creativereview.co.u...

  • Jesse Lemos

    Its no big surprise that the people that did this make the crappy cars of the future... i will never buy another chevy after my 2004 tahoe.. now it just proves my point.

  • What's the big deal?  Stealing a little idea?  You wanna talk stealing?  How about the billions that Chevy(GM) stole from the taxpayers?  Oh, right, that wasn't stealing, it was a "bail out".  My bad.

  • slowmodem

    I find it amazing anyone would think advertising creatives were original- ever.

  • blah blah blah. blibbidy blahbbidy blahbbidy blibbidy. blahn blahnnnn.

  • I feel like this is probably almost as old as photography? I've seen books of these kinds of photographs from the 70s at least, I have to imagine at that point it'd been a pretty popular technique.

    Though to give him credit, he's not saying he invented taking photos of photos, he's saying he popularized giving them emotional weight. (?)

  • Good artists copy.  Great artists steal.

  • smushmoth

    As far as I can tell DP started in Mid May.  Do they really think that GSP and Chevy got a world series ad conceptualized, written, directed, produced and OKed by fox, in 4 1/2 months?  Just getting the Song would have taken these legal teams more time than that.

  • It would be more proper to claim the ad agency Chevy hired stole the idea....but seriously you are whining about this? 

    If he saw my photo collage from grade school, maybe DEAR PHOTOGRAPH stole it from me and I should have credit on his site. 

  • eflash

    and ray charles DIDN'T EVEN WRITE THAT SONG!

  • stolo

    unreal. a blatant ripoff.

  • RJ

    Dear Photograph stole it from someone else, who stole it from someone else, who stole it from someon else....

  • remyngtin

    wow

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@laist.com