Here's to Your Health: Beneveda

Aura reading.jpg
Photo provided by Beneveda Medical Group | Dr. Thom Lobe administers his aura-reading machine

You heard it here first: fitness and health is big in L.A. Knowing that you would not want to be uninformed of the recent trends, we bring you Here's to Your Health, in which we explore new local offerings in health and wellness. Consider trying them, consider mocking the Hollywood fools who try them, or consider staying on the couch and watching reruns of The Bachelor. Whatever floats your boat. This week, we start with...

Beneveda Medical Group

In a bright office on a Wilshire Blvd. in Beverly Hills, Dr. Thom Lobe, the founder of Beneveda Medical Group, explains the importance of energy flow in my body. "Energy affects everything," he says, as I sit amidst Star Wars-y computer screens and lights. "What's the difference between being alive and dead? Chi. Prana. Life force. Energy."

I was in a reclining chair in Beneveda Medical Group, a spa-style health center that combines Eastern and Western medicine, of which Lobe is the founder and medical director. After practicing pediatric medicine for 30 years and teaching alternative medicine on the side, he wanted to capture the potential of new technology that combines his two areas of expertise. From there, Beneveda was born.

Lobe began my late-afternoon session by leading me down a short hallway and into a room with a single computer. Linked to the computer was a small box with a glass plate that I was told would “read my aura.” I placed each fingertip of my left hand on the surface, and up on the screen popped a picture of each tip with what appeared to be an electrical field around it.

Interesting enough. But I didn’t want him (or you, gentle readers) to think that I would be taken in quite so easily. If there wasn’t a scientific explanation for my little finger pictures, I was out the door. Lobe humored my skepticism, and patiently explained that the machine tracks something called the galvanic skin response (GSR). GSR - which has been studied since the late 1800’s, and was a technique touted by Carl Jung - is the level of resistance the skin has to electrical currents, which can predict emotional arousal.

In other words, the ability of your skin to resist or conduct electrical currents can demonstrate your state of emotion - whether you’re stressed, anxious, nervous, fearful, and yes - even sexually aroused. The correlation of the currents to various parts of the body has been compared to acupuncture: the same way that acupuncture points correspond to the body, electrical currents run through the body, starting with the skin.

Looking at my results, Lobe took the tip of a pen and gestured to the computer screen, which now featured a read-out of my aura in the form of a female figure with a border of different colors seeming to shoot off her body. "See right here?" he said. "Your energy is a little off around your head."

Perfect. But alas - not surprising. To remedy my domal imbalance, Lobe led me into a room with a lounge chair and several large stacks of A/V machinery where I would receive something called neuroacoustic therapy.

By producing sound frequencies that cause brainwaves to essentially self-adjust in time, neuroacoustic therapy has been compared to Chinese gongs and chanting. The practice is used to achieve a desired state of mind - in this case, relaxation - and ideally, the brain relaxes so deeply that it, as the body’s governing organ, relaxes the rest of the body.

I was given a blanket, headphones and Florida senior citizen sunglasses (read: covering the whole face), and told that for the next 20 minutes, I'd experience something akin to a "trip."

For the first time since arriving, I panicked. Had I unwittingly signed up for some sort of electric kool-aid acid test? Was I going to have a seizure? I could imagine the headline: Intrepid Reporter Found Dead in Neuroacoustic Therapy Room, Victim of New Age Medicine Gone Wrong.

But, journalistic duty beckoned me forward, and Dr. Lobe stepped out of the room and closed the door. Music began to play and lights began to flash in front of my eyes. At first I felt terror. But slowly, as I became calmer, my fears of death gave way to tranquility. I did not hallucinate, I did not jump out a window, I did not combust. In fact, before I knew it, Lobe was back at the door and I was as relaxed as Ice Cube on a Friday.

He immediately read my aura again, and this time, my head energy was visibly evened out. Barring a significant technological hat trick, it would appear as though the procedure had worked.

The final stop of my tour found me in another lounge chair (I'm starting to like this kind of medicine) surrounded this time by Beneveda’s piece de resistance, The Energy Enhancement System (EES). EES uses scalar fields generated by computer screens to rejuvenate the body’s cells, which can make a person look younger, have more energy and feel happier overall.

“There’s nothing in here that’s a magic switch,” said Lobe, as I sat on a recliner amidst the screens. But “energy has to flow, and if it doesn’t,” the body won’t work properly.

So, did it work for me? Well, I do have that youthful glow, but I have it so often anyway it’s really difficult to say what causes it. Either way, Dr. Lobe’s practice is a classic case of science vs. faith, and questions whether the effects of Eastern medicine -- which have up until now been based on first-hand experience, hope and testimonials -- can be tracked. If the skeptics among us can see it, will they believe it?

I suppose you'll just have to decide for yourself.

Email This Entry


Comments (4) [rss]

You say "If there wasn’t a scientific explanation for my little finger pictures, I was out the door," but you settled for a three letter acronym (GSR). Follow that up with some Eastern buzzwords, and some pseudoscientific baloney (scalar fields), and the credulous can be sold a nap with a blanket and soothing music for quite a pretty penny.

I note that the website for neuroacoustic research (http://www.neuroacoustic.com/) provides an important disclaimer at the bottom of the page:

"Disclaimer: Nothing on this website is intended to diagnose, treat, or cure any medical condition of whatever nature, and shall not be construed as medical advice, implied or otherwise. "

The appearance of that message is a warning sign. What it means is that, not only has the FDA not evaluated this therapy, but the purveyor is trying to avoid the scrutiny of the FDA. They are not promising to cure or heal anything... only to 'adjust your auras'. Adjusting metaphysical nonentities is not what doctors do, it's what witchdoctors do.

Signed,

Crankypants Skeptic

PS It's cheap and pleasant to take a nap with a blanket and soothing music, and/or to stare at a trippy screensaver on your computer. This is my recession-busting suggestion for the devotees of these treatments.

ah, crankypants skeptic, i was expecting you. you're right -- he gave me three little letters, and then i wrote this entire article! but seriously -- GSR has been studied and used for over a century. it's not actually even up for debate as to whether it's legit or not anymore.

as far as the nueroacoustic disclaimer, what that means is that the you can't diagnose yourself by reading the WEBSITE. and funny enough, it only took me about three seconds to find the following disclaimer on the mayo clinic website, too:

"Nothing contained in this site is or should be considered, or used as a substitute for, medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. The services provided on this site are here to educate consumers on health care and medical issues that may affect their daily lives. This site and its services do not constitute the practice of any medical, nursing or other professional health care advice, diagnosis or treatment."

http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/terms-of-use/AM00006

i guess that crazy mayo clinic must be trying to avoid scrutiny by the FDA too! thanks for setting me straight. now, why don't you go take a nice little nap with a blanket.

Yes, GSR exists, and it can indicate emotional arousal, but it does not indicate the kind of emotion. Being frightened looks the same as being aroused to GSR. GSR can't tell the difference, much less provide insight into the offness of the 'energy' around your head. It's like saying that fluctuations in the temperature of your fingers tells you about the qi imbalance of your spleen. GSR may be 'legit' as a phenomenon, but it is not a legit diagnostic tool.

Yes, GSR has been used for 100 years, but it has largely been supplanted by newer techniques like MRI that actually can discriminate between different emotions. The only advantage of GSR is that it's cheap, and so easy to build, a Scientologist can do it (that's what an e-meter is).

I'll backpedal a little on the website disclaimer. Good job. Still, consumers should not be fooled by the appearance of scientific-like words into thinking that a therapy has been scientifically validated. The FDA offers a great public resource for evaluating health claims. The many treatments one can find on the Mayo Clinic's site have been evaluated by the FDA. Has neuroacoustic therapy, or the Energy Enhancement System?

Forget FDA clearance, I'm surprised the EES people haven't won a Nobel Prize in Physics for discovering and manipulating the scalar field, which is "a fith-dimensional [sic] non-linear field ... [that is] unbounded and capable of passing through solid matter." And it is all accomplished via images on a computer monitor! Ain't science grand?

Crankypants Skeptic

user-pic

It's obvious you are not aware of the fact that just because the FDA approves something does not mean that it is safe. They approve products that contain known carcinogens and they approve pharmaceutical "medicines" because lobbyists pay them off while these "medicines" are actually harming more people than doing good. They do not approve natural approaches because lobbyists from pharmaceutical and big business know that these actually work and they'd be out of business. It's all about the bottom line--so please do us and yourself a favor and do some research on these issues before making claims that are irrelevant.

Hope the FDA treats you and this cancer-ridden society well.

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

About LAist

LAist is a website about Los Angeles. More

Editor: Zach Behrens Co-Editor: Lindsay William-Ross Publisher: Gothamist

Contribute

Latest Tip:

Any ideas why the 110 off/on ramps will be shut down for 1 year starting tomorrow from the hours of
[more]

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from LAist.

All Our RSS

Links