February 21, 2008
The Black Circle Has Stopped Spinning
In 1995, Pearl Jam toured in support of their third full length, Vitalogy. Though the album wasn't the traditional send up to the band's unparalleled Ten, it was to be an otherwise ordinary tour of the best that grunge rock had to offer, save for one looming message: Ticketmaster is the devil.
Thirteen years later, that well-intentioned boycott is deader than a mummy as lead singer Eddie Vedder and Ticketmaster prepare for an upcoming Wiltern show where a single ticket price could dent your wallet to the tune of $90.
If pop is dead, so is any hope of circumventing the world-wide ticket broker.
Citing Ticketmaster's obscene service charges that had been added to ticket prices in Chicago, Pearl Jam dedicated the Vitalogy tour to spreading the gospel truth about the fiendish ticket broker that proffered on the backs of service charges and facility fees that have been known to equal the amount of the original ticket price.
They fought a losing battle for the better part of three years, ultimately yielding to fan's complaints that finding tickets to Pearl Jam shows and going to out of the way venues was too much work. It was a basic battle between the forces of practicality and idealism, which is never a fair fight.
It wasn't fair then and it is not fair now to say Pearl Jam gave up. They fought more than anyone else did and was forced to cede to their fan's wishes and Ticketmaster was the only game in town. Without the Internet and viral marketing opportunities, it wasn't as easy to showcase your message nationwide in 1995 as it is today.
Meanwhile, Ticketmaster got richer. On Feb. 8, the ticket broker announced a robust increase in revenue. From the fourth quarter 2006 to the fourth quarter of 2007, sales increased 27% from $279.1 million to $354.7 million based on "record worldwide ticket volume."
Evidence of Vedder's idealistic demise arrived in the form of an email announcing the show. In my inbox Thursday, KROQ told me about Thursday's 10 a.m. pre-sale (password: "hardsun") for a show he is playing on April 12 and 13 with New Zealand Australian crooner Liam Finn at The Wiltern. Each ticket costs $68.50. With a facility and handling charge, that price could shoot to nearly $90. For a concert. For Eddie Vedder. For a man who once wore flannel that looked like it was from the Salvation Army and dedicated an entire tour to fighting the ticket behemoth.
The boycott isn't just dead, its mangled body has been stabbed almost 100 times with a shiv in its falsetto heart. Vedder hasn't just lost the battle. The concert has given a whole new meaning to the term sell-out.
But I don't begrudge him. I don't have to pay $68.50+arm+leg. In fact, if you are able to afford $40 an hour for a concert, I am severely jealous. While I liked, not loved, the movie Into the Wild, the soundtrack was one of last year's best. No small feat in a crowded field of greatness that included music from Juno and Once.
Pearl Jam still holds a special place in my poetic memory (not to mention the band's appearance in Singles). Ten was a seminal work, but Vs. was poetry and every album since has showcased their transition from angry grunge rock to full tilt folk with at least one brilliant opus on each full length.
That said, I will not shed a tear when Vedder and others charging astronomical prices for concerts complain that people steal their music.
Some artists and labels might contend that the reason they have to charge so much is because people steal their songs. Bullshit. The Wiltern's capacity is roughly 2,300. If both shows sell out, all interested parties will split $315,500 (not counting fees, which could push that total past $400,000). If Vedder sells out all seven shows on his mini West Coast tour, well over $1.5 million dollars will be raked in by all involved. If you illegally downloaded the Into the Wild soundtrack, your soul should be at ease.
Of course, Vedder has dedicated himself to more important causes than people who can afford to pay high prices but are annoyed by the financial inconvenience. Still, it is interesting to note how far Vedder has strayed from his No on Tickemaster days. No more evidence than the $86.50 Wiltern show is needed to see that the Black Circle has stopped spinning.



i had the same thought when i saw the prices for the Wiltern shown. MAYBE he could justify charging this much if he was playing one night at a small club. But all seats costing that much for a 2-night stand in a theatre? that's insane.
Exactly, if there isn't a 2,300 cap venue that's controlled by the more reasonable TicketWeb or Groove Tickets or otherwise, perhaps it's time to find/open/convert one.
FYI, TicketWeb is owned by TicketMaster/IAC
Whoa - Liam Finn is from New Zealand. Saying he's from Australia is like saying Obama comes from Canada!
PJ drew a line in the sand that they wanted a $20 ticket price inclusive of parking, fees & everything. The piece they were fighting over was a reduction in the service charge of around $2 a ticket.
Their crusade was undermined when Green Day started touring arenas with a $12 ticket price that same year. Ticketmaster fees included, it was around $15. to get in. Of course they were still travelling in a van with a very small crew, with about the same expenses they had when touring clubs to 300 people a night.
The amount of money the band needs to walk out of town with a profit is largely determined by the band's expenses. Are they still willing to stay at Motel 6, or do they want Four Seasons now that they're selling out the Forum? How about a bus and a crew and a light show? They afford it now, if they just bump up their revenues a bit.
Even so, Pearl Jam's tickets have been consistently the lowest of major touring acts, about half the price of seeing Neil Young or Springsteen. And they do assure the best seats go to their fan club members in a much more intense way than any other major band. They have been admirable in so many ways.
Hearing that he's now asking almost $70 for a solo gig is indeed disappointing.
PJ drew a line in the sand that they wanted a $20 ticket price inclusive of parking, fees & everything. The piece they were fighting over was a reduction in the service charge of around $2 a ticket.
Their crusade was undermined when Green Day started touring arenas with a $12 ticket price that same year. Ticketmaster fees included, it was around $15. to get in. Of course they were still travelling in a van with a very small crew, with about the same expenses they had when touring clubs to 300 people a night.
The amount of money the band needs to walk out of town with a profit is largely determined by the band's expenses. Are they still willing to stay at Motel 6, or do they want Four Seasons now that they're selling out the Forum? How about a bus and a crew and a light show? They afford it now, if they just bump up their revenues a bit.
Even so, Pearl Jam's tickets have been consistently the lowest of major touring acts, about half the price of seeing Neil Young or Springsteen. And they do assure the best seats go to their fan club members in a much more intense way than any other major band. They have been admirable in so many ways.
Hearing that he's now asking almost $70 for a solo gig is indeed disappointing.
True bzilla, but this isn't Pearl Jam proper. This is just Vedder. How much does one man need to wail away for 2 hours and, more interestingly, how much would someone pay to hear one man play?
This show is a BENEFIT fundraiser for the legal defense of the West Memphis 3, thus the ticket prices are higher than say a regular Pearl Jam show.
So, the basic research is lacking from this reporter. Instead, we get a glorified blog pretending to be news... puhleeez.
Pearl Jam's regular concerts are some the most reasonabley priced tickets compared to other bands playing the same venues.
Pearl Jam still go out of their way to give their fans great value for their money. They treat their fans great, including low fan membership, the best seats in the house for shows, and a vinyl single every year. Their merchandise is not horrendously overpriced either. They've been a leader in offsetting their carbon emissions related to touring, and their most recent tour featured products made from recycled products or other low-carbon emissions methods. And the band donates money from every show in every city they tour to local charities.
In the relative scale, Pearl Jam is very low in the pecking order of greedy organizations that take more than they give.
See instead: Every major league sports franchise and professional athlete in the US.
Rosewood,
Vedder's west coast concerts are, by and large, not benefit fundraisers. I believe all eight of his shows are sold out, but some tickets might still be left via a Tickemtaster auction where people can bid on tickets for all west coast dates. This might be what you are referring to. The proceeds do support the West Memphis 3, but that does not make the entire tour a benefit, per se.
It's great that he is doing that. It's a worthy cause and such, but that does not give him a pass for still charging fans $70 a ticket, in my opinion.
I can't stand Ticketmaster. I've always said its legalized scalping. Eddy, what happened?